Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-07-49303/23 AI generated

2-07-49303/23 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-07-49303/23
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

- ( 8 ( (* ((+ (* ,-* 5#/.(. (*++ ,((($ (.'))&((,(  ,2 (     (*   ,,  (  (,   :5(   .*   (,   (/   ((,     ,  *  $# *,          (*(  $(*(  ,,,2 ( $   5 ..    (* ($/, / *$(( (+ (* ,577 ./,2($(,(5+ ($( (* ((* ( $## .(/#   (.2* ,,,$(((, :5( .2 -,((,,,,(2((/ ,$# *,   ,.$((( $,* (+ (*(/, (/,.(. , (* ((, $(5,(,,((,,.* (/(/, ,,,))&5+$ .$.*. $(.2 ,*2((/,, (.2(/((,-  (* (2   *( 2 (  (* - #  ((,-  (  (,   :5( .  .* ( ((,,(,(.  ((,3  ,($(/$+ .2 ,  (( $## .* ,  *  (  (  $(  5,(     (*    , . 2 ( / (+ .$(* $/.( .($   (5(   

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-49303/23 · Viru Ringkonnakohus: $(.2 ,*2((/,, (.2(/((,-  (* (2   *( 2 (  (* - #  ((,-  (  (,   :5( .  .* ( ((,,(,(.  ((,3  ,($(/$+ .2 ,  (( $## .* ,  *  (  (  $(  5,(     (*    , . 2 ( / (+ .$(* $/.( .($   (5(   

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

       

     

        !"#$   

  %&% '  

             !"##" $$%              

('))&*++  (* ( (+ (* ,-* (       

  ,*  ,. *++ -   

  /, *(,         ++ -  (/  ,*  ,.    ( .))&1) 2(",3 $, .%

*42 ,5 ,   ./ $..$(  (   5 ((/   3 $   0  ( . )1'&2 ( ,  3 $  ,   .% *42 ,5 ,   ./$..$(6, * &'()*'' 

  +"##" $$%            "               

"      ,-         

       "    3 $   (1))& (,$,.( -.%77(/ 

- ( 8 ())& (* ((+ (*  $,. ,( #.  $,.   (/ (  -.%77(/ 

- ( 8 ( ))&   (*  (  (+ (*  ,-* ( #,  $ ,(*(, .( 9&),2 (*(/+(* $# -(((+ (* $# *(   (*  $/.( 5#/. $,.   (/ /,2 (  ( ,$ '))& (* *++ 2* ,,,-( (+ (

- ( 8 (1))&( 



(*     . (, . :5( . (/   ((, 0  (   (  ( .   ;'!'2 ) '2 ) &'2 ) & '2 )&'2 )&'2 )&'2)& '42/+ (/($(#(((+ (*(++ ,,  ((,:5( . .*    ,. $# *, 2  &))& 0  5+$  (*++  (* (4 - .   (, #    *((.   (( *:: ,5 . ,( );))&   ((* 3 $6(<2(* (,+ .,$,. (/, . 2 ((/$## .  /.25 .  ,*(*(, 5,#,  $ ,(*(,.( 9&!,)52),((/,$## ../$#  2 * ,, (,*, /++ (/ *.  **( $  $+*   ;    ,( 

('))&*++  ,.(  3 $  $,.( -.% 77(/

- ( 8 ())& (* ((+ (* ,-(+ ( ( -.%77(/

- ( 8 ( (* ))&(  )4 ( .  ,*  ,.    $,. $  )))') ' 5 /  $,. $ )!!1' =( < 5;   4  ( . 3 $ 6( < 5,(  ,*  ,.  % , &))&   (( 0  (   (  ( .   ;'!'2 ) '2 ) &'2 ) & '2 )&'2 )&'2 )&'2 )& '4 *:: ,5  /+   (* , ,$ / *::/, :, .*( ( .;   4 ,(  ,*  ,.  % , +(. &))& , *((.   (( *:: ,5 ((,$(#.# (3 $6(<$(;  ,( 4,( ,*  ,. % ,+(.*$ ,, ,(2((**. /++  **($ $+* ;  ,(  #( 

- ( 8 ( ( (.. 5#/.(    , . 2 (  $,. 

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

- ( 8 (  (  (..  5#/.   /  , . 2 (    (*   /  

- ( 8 (  (     (*     (+ (*   ,-*    5#/.(.   )& - *(,  ,*  ,.   $,.2 * ,, (/ ,+(  $ ,(*(, .(  9&)2 9!; +((((   , : ,( ( $  $($  .5 * ( ( 5 $,2   $(  ( ( ( */.($( 



( )&(*++ *++ (  ;  2* ,, ** , ((( ( $, (* *++ (+ (* ,#5((  ;)& - *(  ,*  ,.   ((,   (*  - # (: (.'))&(*++  ,(  5(((.*(*.2(/5,( (+ .(.( )&*++ (..# 

(1)&*++ (: (( *('))&*++  .(.  (* - # $ ,(*(,.( 9!;,,,  ( '))& *++  5,  ( *++ - (/2 $ .,(. ,#  , *((.(*++ ((+ ,(  )&/1)&*++  .2* ,, . '))&*++ (. -  (/ *+  -2 ( 

- ( 8   . ,*.  9))%) ,; / , -2 ( $(,(0* (( ,(# 4 . ( * 

,#./,( (( (   $( *(, * . *  , , $( ( (: (*   $ ,(*(, .(  9&;) ,) 5; /+   .$# . ,,  *(, *  *  

,    $(   (*  (( (+ (    $ ,(*(, .(  9&) , ,, (, (*++  (: (.   ,; ,( 5-  (* ( ((,. 5, :$ (* $(5,, /2 *   ( .   (* ( $#    (*  - # .*  $+,( *  (. (( (   (* (#((, .(/5(.>:,*((.?* (* .5+$  +,$,/, (/ ,.  (. 5* (,(  * 2; * ,/ (   2 *  ,  (   (,  ( (. ,(,  / (/ * , /(. ,, ,( (/ + ($(  5 (* (: (* (5#/.(25,-- (/ #. /,(  $ ,(*(, .(  9! ,, (+ .$( (( (2 /  ,, ((  5,* /+ $#

 *$+*,()     / ,, , /, /+(- ((  .*(2     (*   $ ,(*(, .( 9!,/9&),,,(: (.  $(  ( * ( 5- -  (/ -5 5 ( ,2  (/ 5,(   $ *:: ( *. 

2* ,,  (* $ (-,+- ++ * (5 .* , $#,,./(/(  - (/((,- (* (: (* (  ,2( ,-+   (* - #.* , (,-((.(((  $,.5 (.

2 (. (* .* 

 $(.2( /$+ .($#..5 * (//-*# (, ,( *$ / # (  ( :,*++ 2 5,- -  (/ *++ - ,.*( /+(* , $+*,(,, ,($+.. (* .* *++ (. ( $($ $+.(.(/,((.2(/,,,/,$# *, $($ . . ( $,( */.($ (.     (*  $. /. , . $+ *. -  (/ 5,- (: (.  ( '))& (*++      (*  (: (* , ((.  ,*  ,.  %,  ( ((   $,(.. 

 ( (*(  )))& *++  $#(  *++ - *(, / .( /,2.(+(/*++ -( $,.*   /*))&$(5,- ('))&*++ /+((*(*( / ,2(-5 .$# *,.$.( ,, .$ . $( ( * (  -/ - (. *(, $ .,(. $ . '))& (*++ (2 * (( 



 )& / 1)& *++   -  (/  (   )& / 1)& *++ ((*( $ ,2(.>(.?'))&*++ (,-/+((,+- $(*( (. *++ -*(,    , *((. *++   ( ,, .  *(2  *++ -  $ .,((  ., *(,,  

 ,+(.  $ ,(*(, .( 911%11 +(((( ( ,( *++  (: (*  5.$. # , . ,.2 /  *++ -  (/ /- *   

- ( 8 (   (*  ( (: (*  / (*++  $ .,(*  ,. (*++  (+ .( $(   (*  ((.*(,$# -$ .,(.(*++ (2( $ .,(.$(  (* ((++ - (/ , *(.*(, *  * (2* .,

  .   (*  (  $ ,(*(, .(  9&) , , (+ (* ,2 *(  $ . ,*.  9 ))%) ,;  /(2  (( .5 ( )     ((. ++ -  (/ .  .  , .2 *  (#    $(  ( *  $+,( *(  $(  (  ((,*  5. $/.2   -  (/   , $## .. #   *   ( . : 5+$ 5, (,  :5( .$ (* ((* ((.(/($( * (* (/ *++ (+ (* $# *( 

 ( &)& *++  /+(   ,*  ,.  %  *++ -

,.*(/.( ,.*   (,  2 (($.  +,$  ( $ ,/  *( /, .2 , . 2 (  *++ - $+ (. ,(*('))&*++ (: (*   +,$/*( /, .(+(-2(*($ .,(($*++ ,-(. (+ (( -.%77(/

- ( 8 ( (* ))&(  ($,(   $ ,(*(,  .(   9&) ,  (-    *++   5, $,.,,/,-- (* ((+ (* (:/,2 *  (* - # ,/-(,(((,(.$# - (* *++ (  (  #(.2 $/,  (* - # .*   <,,(..+((,,(, *(,( ,, .2* (* - #  ,  /-  (,(  ((,(.     .  ( ,, .  /2 ($(.2 (  ,, ( , . ,2# ( ,-.

- ( 8 (((+ (* ( ,*++ ( (  ( #(.  , -2(*(*++ ., /5#/.(. (,-/+(( *(*(++ - ,$ .(.:, *(,#  *  * , *(5,( $ ,(*(,.( 9&),,.* ,2*  ,(*(*++ (: (* 2* (#((*++ -(,-/+(( ,.*(  (*++ -$+ .(,*+  - /+ * (  ++ -  $+ (.2 *   5.($.  ,*.   * (  $(  5,(  / $(  (     05 $(   ( *   ,*  -5 5 ( ,42 /+(-

  (+,5(2     ( ,, -  *(  '))& *++ ., ( $ ,(*(,.( 9&),,.* ,  5.- (,., , ($(((..# ,  5#/. //+ ,. 

 ;  ++ -$+ (.2* 5.($.*( )&/1)&*++  2 /+(-    (+,5(2   .  (,-  $ .,(.   ,.   *(,  $*++ -/,**(*++ ( ,$# *, $ .,(. :   *++ - +,$  /  $(-    ,+-    ,( *++ -*('))&*++ ,  <,,(.,,(,-*(*++ /+((*(*(/*++ - ,.*(  / .*++ (* ,,(.(/ $ ,(*(,.(  9',)29 129 1 ,)%29 1;29111,)2911&        (