Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-07-4063/10 AI generated

2-07-4063/10 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-07-4063/10
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-4063/10 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               

     

     !" ! #$   

            %&'()'*((+,-$ 

    *.(/.)(&0 

   '''1'$!"-"     

'(2'*((/          

 ''3!!4        *2'(0'*((+              3!!56' '7!""' ' " 3 '8 " 99999999999  ! ::::::::::99.99 $!  ". ";8

56 '1' 7!""  '1'  "99999999999 !::::3999.99 !!< ! ". ";    !" #        $$"%&"$%%'  (    " $" " ")* +",     (   " -" (  .   "/ "+"   #  0" " )#  11"11"1111, # *        -!"%!"$%%'    !2%% )#       ,       *  (          . 

          .   *        " 3" " ")* +", *       "      3!!!"<<$"3!""'         3! $-4 " 4

! 0( 3<$ !  !

 * < !  "  3< $  =="   $!! $' $!!"7;>*%+!0! $-4 !! !   !"  " $!"  ! ? $""$"$"!'

$!  > &/% ! 2 !4 4 <"    $4   !'

! ! !     -  !" !!'       . 4 (   .    %'0%'(%'*((/''7"3"; !$!"7'!).2;'1' 7"3";$ !!3!$<!-!!? '?!!3" %+((!*((/'  $!"!?"3!!*/'(+'%@@0!3 '1'73!*)'(+'*((2';' $  (2'%('%@@+  - !   ? !" ?!!3" $<! ! 0(( ' ()'(%'*((/  " ! %2(( ' 3!!" !!!!<"3!"! !3$!!*((&''3!"! 0@%(6%2(( $--!"&(( 4?!%&(  -$"!-")2( $"0(( !?$""%((  ?!%2( 3<"%(( *2(  !4"!-""0(('  *'(/'(0'*((/"!$7'!%@.*(;"' 

 !   !!"$-!! !!%2(('!3==' !(0'(%'*((/==4A. $ 3! )*(+   !! <<4 ! $! < */(+ ' ! 3  !  ! ==$-  )(B  - 34  3"$!  !!" $"  " $!'  !"   !3 $""  3!!!-""-"'$3"71;>. !&%!&3% 0'     0' '(2'*((/<!"!!""'  )'  !    !     ()'(%'*((/  40%'(%'*((/ '*/3<$!!!"'  !"   !3 $""  " */ 3<$ !!! "   !  !" !'   ! " !  -""'  3!  -"" */3<$!!$!"!!!"' 

  $-  !" <! $  !   ! << (@'(*'*((/ ! 3  )(B ==$-   ! ! ! $<!-! !!<<'  2'>%&*!<!!""'!> %/)!'%<'  0*   . 4 (    &'3!43!!47'!)+;?4$"'  4!$!"$!'$<!!    3"$"  !!  4 " <$"6 C". D 9999991999999' $-"!'!!!"

!  7 ; " ' 3!! 3!4  !  3<' 3!! !4    $  $-!  !    ! !!!!<< '%+(('  /'  -"! " 4 <" 7'! 2/; 3!4    ! "%+(('  <"!<"!?"! -"4 ! ! $" !!'  <4   ! !  << !!!!!<"'43! %%/('      (    +'  ! $ 7'! &/.&+; 3!4  < 3!!4 !"  ' 

!$1999999A'!$-!$  !!!*0)* 0($-$<'!$-!$ 3"$-!$-'!"!"'        @'<3!!4"3!""!'!  !3$""" ==4!0('(0'*((/ ==2(((  4!0(( ??!!3$'  %('  3! <   '  !    ==4 <==  4==42(((==$-34%((( ? !!?!!3$'     *.    %%'   !"<!!$"$!!"  !" 3!!4!4!"!' 

 ) %*'  "  1 >."! 2( !'%  )@  &( !'%  &% !'*  0  )   ! */3<$!"!3$""!!!"'3! "  -""   */ 3<$ !  !!!  ! !"'    !   ()'(%'*((/    ! "  0%'(%'*((/' !"<!$-$! (@'(*'*((/<<! ! 3  )( B ==$-    ! ! $<! - <1>&%!')<"!'  %0'  !4     " !-   !"" $<<!!-'  "   ! 3"  ! ! $<!- 3< !$ !'$-"*/3<$3< ?!!"!!1>&( >&%> 0)+ !'%  > 02% !'% < !<" !" $<! !  - !"    $!" $"! !"   3! $! "' !! 3"  3!! >*0(!'* )<3"$$"-""$-" >*0(!'0!!!!'    <    !  !! ! %)'(2'*((/ ! !" $<! !" "$! !3 $" $-  ! !   !!! " !    !" 3!! $" -" $-"-""!!!'

" ()'(%'*((/!<"<!3  "!"$<!-"!3!-"%2((  !!?!3!3!!!"$"!$<!-"!  ! <<' ()'(%'*((/  3-"$  !"4 ?!! ! 6

                                        "!!!<$!"!"-"" <!"' !! 3" ! "  "  !"! $-! $-!" !$! ! $"  !3 $"    $! "   !! -"$$!'  1>&%!'&3'%!!!$-!<!$<!-$-$<""! !!>&%!')"$ !!!!- ==$-' 1>&%!'&3'%!"!3$!==$-7<!$-!; E $""!!4!""-1>&%!'*!??"!! !!"$$!!"!!<4$-! !-"' $$    "" $" ! ==$-  E!   $"!<$<!--"'  %)' !" !<" !4   ?"        !<4$!'

!4 !4!"!' 

 %2' "!  ! !" ?!   3!!  */'(+'%@@0 ?"" ? 7'!' &./;  !! ?!!3"  " $! !   $<! -" !  $

()'(%'*((/%2((7'!'+.%%;'  %&'1>&%!'*!<<!!3!"!! !<" $$!"!3$"'      3$""$!"7'!').2;"!$$" "0@%('

!7'!'%@.*(;<" $!"""!3$"" -""  3! -""'   !! ! <  <  ""!3$"34!!' !0%'(%'*((/$!"-$<!!!%+((  !!!!<<73!0&((.1>&%!');'  3!""$$<"!3$"$<"$-" !-!"71>&%!');3"4$"!" !??" !3 $" 3-"'  " !-  ! 3-"!' A!"!34$!!3?!!3"-$<!!$<!" <"    $-4 " ! $<"" !! 1 > &% !') <"!<<$-<!$<!-"!$$!1>&% !'&3'%< $ !!!!- ==$-7 $!!! %%'()'*((+0.*.%.%).(+;'  !      %/'   0%'(%'*((/ $!" <"     ==    E"  %)'(2'*((/  3!! 7'!' 02;'  ""  $"! """-""'

 ! 7'!' +&;  !    4 ! 0((   ==4 !0('(0'*((/43!2((( ??!!3$'

3!"<!3<$!-"" !"!7'!'@%; 4"$!7'!'%(%;'  %+'!"-"!!4==A. $*((/' ))(( ==!3!-!"<==7'!'.*);'%)'(2'*((/! 7'!'0&;! ! !44'  3! ! -" ! !   4 *((/  43!)*&*7'!'/);'

 3!  " <!3< $ !  ! ! $ $!!  " !!< ! 7'!' @@  %((;     !"4C". D7'!'+@.@(;'

!7'!'+&.+/; ==" ==4 <==34==42((( 4 ==$-3 4 %(((  ' 1! ?    !! ?!!3$' 

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

 / 3! $! "    3 $! ! -"! !" "'  "   *2'>%/0!'*-"4"!"$-4!"   !<4$   "4  $" ! $$! !!" '  ?44!<4$  !4!!"'  >%&)!'%!!<4!!"3!""'  *&' "!!">."))* &0% &2% &2)  &2/!%3* &&+ &/(!%'             !#$