Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-07-1906/17 AI generated

2-07-1906/17 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-07-1906/17
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-1906/17 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

     

       !"  ! 

"! # 



          $%&'$&('')*+,      (-'.-%/'0                        

(1&%'&(''.           2 ,3 4        ! %)&'$&('') !         3  56  2 , 5" 7777777777   777777777 8-8 ,  "- !"6&

 56  #,9 5" 77777777777   77777 77777 88-88  -*:,  "- !"6& "# $%&

' () *          !  +,,-    ,  #        *            "   . *)

      )     /     *)    00     

     ,

1   "       

  ! 23 ,.       

      4

  ,                /                 ,    !    

%&2 ,5"3"6%(&'%&(''.  5& %-(6 #,9 5"3" 6 , + +" 5 ;6 <$/0 &% (    %(''''  ,+ ,: !+!&  , "   + !" 3 "  3 !! %''''' &   !('&'$&(''$": ,""  & ;<%') &% ,+ 4!!,+4,+  " +" :!&  (&! ,5& %/6  !!=''''!  !, > "%'&%'&(''$&!"> " 3 , +   3!: "&()&'(&(''$,+     " 3 !  +"!&  $&(1&%'&(''.5& $.-1'6!+ ,: ,+ , %'(''' & ? ::"  & %)'''  +" :   "!&  !  ":)=@ "&!  ":!""& 

; <$/0 &% : 4  3 >  5 "6 "!    

5 6!!,+",5 6 4!! !!,+!! !!, "&  A  ,  3"4 ,"    >    "  , ",  %'&%'&(''$ !!=''''5& $6 ""& 

,  ; <$/. &%  4 !"-  , "   ! &   3  4!>  3"&  3  +""  3 " 33"  3!   " , %'&%'&(''$ !!=''''!!&!   !"-  , "   3"4    ! !"!! &   3    ,:  !+  ,+ , !"   " ()&'(&(''$  5,+ & (1$6& 

;<$' &%:,+  3!  4:!   4" ,,+!  ! &   3  ()&'(&(''$ "     5,+ 6   4   4 ,!"" =''''     !  !  4 ! ('&'$&(''$  ('''   &   ! " , ,+  !  !:  " 4  ! ,   "   ,+ , !!   :4 ,: " ,+  ,+! " ,,:"    " ,+ +"!&  +""! "%'&%'&(''$ 3 > " =''''   !! :     ! !! !  !   " 4 ()&'(&(''$  &  ""  ," !   &&> "!  > !!  5& &$=6& 

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

,  ;<%'% &%3&%0,+ ",+4,+  "+" :! :!,,! +",,&

; <%%$ &%      :! ,,!   ,+4 ,+  " +",+  ,,5,,6,+,!!  :!& , !::  ; <- /1 :" !:: !   "43& ;</1 &%:  4,, "  ,+ 3  "   !:: 3  3 3 3 3+B!3"   ", ,! !::    %& %& ",+ 3 :"&33 3+B!3"   ", ,! !::  '%&'%&('')  1@&    ()&'(&(''$      =''''  !: ('&'$&(''$&   !!1@('''&%(&'%&(''. ('''81C)'''& 

    3> " =''''  !: "!&   !!1@('''&%(&'%&(''. !4)'''&    )''' D )''' C %0'''   3+,+  %'''''    %%0'''&  !!  ".@!! %%0'''!)%(' 81C$(1)'& !! %%0'''"%0'''D$(1)'C1)1)'&  !, "3  %)''',+  !!,+ !&  =&    , 3 4  !::" :    "&  "   *  0& ,   <0=% &%  4  ! !   " 3+">! 3 ","&  : ,    ," " !   !  :  "! +,%)''',: !+!& 

  4 ," " !  "   3+" !"& 

 ,"  ! " 4  ! (1&%'&(''.   ,,  "   3+""  3 4 ,:"     ! (1&%'&(''.  >!      %)'''  ,: !+!&     +! "&  <0=. &% 3&%     4 !:!!& +4!3+"  , <0=1 &0""&  ,+4 !-E,+ :! ,,!   +," E ,,& ; </1 :4  !::,,:,": "," ;<-%%$&

; </1  :       ! & ; </1  4  "! ,"! !5",+ 36 " " 3 3"&  + "" ;<$/. &%!:4!"-, "    4 !  !  3    4  ! >   3"&  : "         ""    ! !"-  ,  +       !  %'&%'&(''$ > "   !! =''''   +    , +"&  3 4,:" "! !"-, ,+!!"-,& " ()&'(&(''$ 5,+ 6!:"" !!('''  5   3" =('''  -  ='''' 6    3  ," "&



3 4,:" , ", 1)1)',, 5,,6!:4:!& 

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

4,, <0$' &%<0=% &%3 ," " !  " +"  " !  " ! "  +"",,5,,6,: !+!&

  4  ,+  " ,+4 ,,  ; <%%$ &% ,+   ,, 5,,6 +" ,  +, !!   :!&

3 4   %'&%'&(''$> "=''''  :5!:6&"  ! !"3 4!:"3" E " 5!6 %(&'%&(''.E, +,,+  " ""++",+  

;<%%$ &%   3",,&

 !:4   ; <%%$ &% : 4 ,,   33 3"!   ,+ 3"  +"  ! ,,  ,!  53  36   ,,!::    , ; /1 &% : !:: !4 3"  &    3 4 "" 3 3 3+B!3"   ", !:: 1@ !    '%&'.&(''.  '%&'%&('') ,+   ,, ,!  ,:", ,+ 3"  (''$&  %(&'%&(''. ," > ,+  ,!  ,+ 3"  '%&'.&(''.  $%&%(&(''.&   3 4 ::4  "!  !  !!  3"4    ,   <%.$  ," ! !  "" !  "& 

4!: 3  ! "3"4,!  $'&'%&(''.  ""    +, !  +"  3  " +,,, !(=&'%&(''.!:: 5& 1-=)6&! ,"3! "3  +,!!!.''' %)&%'&(''1! !, "!! ! " 3HH" "!::", (-%/.$G'15& $(16& 

 "  !   "   <<0=%-0=1 <0=. &% 3&% <00) &%<0.' &%(&         ! "! #