Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-07-48640/4 AI generated

2-07-48640/4 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-07-48640/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-48640/4 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

        

            !    " # $ %%!      &'( %% %)&&*' #"+  ",-  

   ).&/.0*10&  

  2  # +!"3&&&&  4$5!'         

#5-6- "!5%

#5 !"-6   

     -% ,55"%!     $$5!!800.01980*9800)981&.19:8/1 %#98&%#(98;1%#98;/%#981)%#980&0%# 9  !"!!"!6 %$$ # '%-,4 !" 2  ! !3&&&& +

! <,,5$" "'     !        ""!!5 (5%5+4 =5! "$ (5%%"!  5=!5%%  #   "%5&(5+- !% %"5!"!!5(5%%$ %5 ""5" ,5", !5!"9 $, ""5 %-5, +

5 ,>>$, !5%  ""!!5 +% %""5"+ !"5#5, !5!"'  " #      3'&/')&&!4%, ! $ 2 -%5%5( #9, %%5(." ')  !5%"$ ! 2     %5 !,,! 3;3&&&  '!"+%" %5%5( # (.%5 '  !"!   "#!", %5  3'-% ! )&&1'5!,, !", !5 55!"  !"!   "!, %5%5( #(." )'  !5%" "5!! 3?!"!9 !-5! "5!! %!"!, !5%5 #!" &'- !' 5%5( # (.! ' ,# "$ " "- ! !'' 3'-% ! )&&1   # %5!,," 5  "#!"$'-+ 5, !&'&')&&0.'&*')&&1"!! 2.%5   &&&&

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

%-5,%" '#!" ! )&&/' ,5""$ 5""5(5 ! $ ! #5- "5$9 5"  !"-%  ! ! +4%#5+!5  5!5%"" 5!%"!5!"!, !5 !9"4!!4%, ,, !5#@ ' 5%"$$ 5""5(5 %5 +!"! !"-9 5" 5  %5 !"5% 5 "!, +4%#5+!"  5!5%" " 5! %"!5! #"5# 5""5(5 "!$!$5 (&&   !' #5-( $! !"-(%" ( "$ !, !5 !!" 5=,4!"% %" + 5!5 ! # "5#  5""5(5 9 5" !"-, ! ! &&&   !'

#5- 4= !"-%" 5! %#!5%"  " "5#!5%"  "#!"," !!  %5  *)3&    +%-,4 !", !"!,,!3&&&&  '

#5-4! -% ,55"%!5#'     

-% ! +!"!5!  "%5  "% *.; + $%5= !"- # %5 !% !5%" +!"' !"- (%= #5-% 2 ,"( $, !$ ,5" $5#"45$$95"!< #%% !5%% 5!,, !% 9, !%5%5( ##!$ <%5$' !"-5 4!" #5-+4%+5!"!5#' #5-$,5"5-# "!$&'&')&&0. '&*')&&1&&&&  9, %%5!"*;)3&  +5!""$ "5!! $5 ""5 !' !"-%5 !5%% 5+5!"!,"95 %5!5%#59, %% !"5% (5+$5%-, %% !"5!!,,$5! %5"#!"$'5"#!", !5 (5+$5!"-!!"5!"+4 =!4%"$#+5!"!% 

"5!! !!' !"-%5 =95" #5-(5 !5! ","45$  !5%%5  "9, %%%-, %% !"5! !!"5!%5%5 $"#!  2 !!!!5' "   $%&'%()!

#5-+,!!=!  "%5'&')&&* !" 5$+"5"45$ "5#!''+%-+4""5# 2  )&&'!"-% (5,"!"9, %%5%" "=95"3'&/')&&"$+%- %5!,,!3;3&&&  ' ! ! "= ,5""$+%-+4""5%"95" #5-%%$%5,!  % !5$+ 5$ $%5$, !5 !'5!,,+!"+4", !"

"$, %% -#3'&/')&&%5%5( #%5%$ 

"!%5%5( #%4(!'      0'&')&&*  ",!5#"%0&  !"!  !(% 5! ",," 5$+$"45$ $ &'&)')&&*-,!95""55=  ""!!5 -% !,55"%!5!&1'&)')&&*''  5$+!+!"!5!  "%5&'&)')&&*"%0.00"5"= !"-95""5,5 %$"5$%  #5--= !+ 5% !5!"%5%5( #!"' !"-% !=95" #  #5-5! "$ %5%5( ## !5$+$  ,"( $, !5 $ ,5$ $9 5  %5 5! ""$ ,"( $, !5 %#$ ,5"5%5"#! , !5"5  "' !"-!5 !  %95" #5-+!"!5!5! ""$%5"#! , !5"5 (5+$5-# +4 = + "95" #5-+5!"! "5!! +4%  "5="(5'%"5+ 5% !5%5%5( #()'-#  %5-  !"= "!, %5!,, "!, !5 55!" "5!!  3 ? !"!' #5- (%"

"5!! , !5 +5!", 5 ;&&&&   %"!5!9 !55  #  %5!,, 55!"9 5  %5 (4 -5$"$'5 !-  !$ %5 "#!  , !, 55" "5#!5%"9 !55  55 3'-% ")&&1''5%5( #-# 5 %5%555" "5#5"!, 5 55%"$9, !"4""  %5( "$ "5!!   4 #5 +5!"$  %" %5-# %"'5" "5#!5%" %   '- %

 )&&0 "!"$  &&&&  9 , ! " 5$=9 5" 5$!( $ !5$ "5!! , !5$ %5 ! "%$ +5!"$ %5-# %" 013&&&   #

 %5 ! "%$ "5   5$!( $ !5$ "5!!  +5!"!5$  +!"+!5!  %5 55" "5#!5"5 "#! , !5"5 (5+$5%5  %5-#  !!5 %!5%' #5- 5  %5 !5%% !" +5!"!" "5 $9 , !"4"" "5, 45  !5%%5! !! 5=!5%#5' 4""5!+5!!595" #5-453&&&&  9!

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

# "45$"$-#, !"5 -% 5"45$ "5#6%5%5( ##3'&1')&&9, %%5(."  ')'  !5%"!  !"-= !%53;3&&&  9 %-$ "  5!"  %%"5"5#9 5"( -"5<%5!!"$"5,= ! #"5,%5% 5(5# 9 #5-

-%  5""5(5 #   !"-%5  '-% !")&&/  !"!"5+=" "%  !" ", !5 !9 2  (5,"+%-+4""5#%5+%-!", !5  "!,,!3;3&&&  9 2    ,-$!!" $5#  (5 $ *'&')&&).')')&&  = %!! !   $  ,$ ( -% !5$ 4$5$ %% %5!,,  3;3&&&  9  +#$5 5    $ "$ %5$%%A3;3&&&  9% !)"$%5$-%5- !5 !#')')&&3;3&&&  9!5$!-#!5( , !, !4 #!5" !"!5# !""$);'&*')&&/ %-$ "  5!"  %% (%" 9 , %%5  !5%" %  1  +!"+%" %= +

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