Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-07-29634/5 AI generated

2-07-29634/5 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-07-29634/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

 + 1 "  "/      5+    1 9"5 5 1" 9" + 8" 91 + ? +  9 +  5   /      9 1  5   11 +5   %*  '+ "  +/  51+ +      /     -  1 +   91   /   '1 '- ,9 9  8    5   9 '5 5     91 /    0  + /  5 1/5   01 /  5 +"    '-0 :  1     9  1 "+   ; +  ;-0 :  1 7 /8 " +   +5+1    "   "   ++1   ++ +9   +  /9"1 +    ;  @@9 /+1 +  @@ 9    59 "+  " /9"+/@@5 1" +9+@@   '+5"   +  + /+1 +   +    5     +  5 +  "+ " 5     '5  + 1 + + 8  ++1 1  8 '-  ;-0:+   " 01+15  ++9  +"  1 " +9     0 8"    '+"  $11  ;-0:   1  1      5+   9  '+ "   " 5   + 1     + /+11   +  1;-0'-0 +1,9+   9  5   9   ' +,,' '91       8     ++1 ++8 5

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-29634/5 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                 

                     

          ! "# $%&'((() #(((*  ! "+"# !' "       ,#   , +"#   '-'%.'((()/#(((*  0'%&'(((*" 1  ! 2 3 + 45 ! 2 (((  "     , #

6  " '  + % 7  +*    ! " #$      %&'&(()    *+   , , -.  /0 +        ,   '

   !$!" "1!23    3 '  4  * ,  '   !13 #3!5! 1     , +          %(, 

    '       

! " $ 8 +( ++  "(((( 6  "( + 7 +     6  " (((  8 5   '5 /9 +  9

   '5++  +5+11                  " $        / 8   ++   5  1"   9   "5 

    55   ,   5 5 115  -   895  / 

5  5    1     / $     9     ! "    "  9  %   9 +* /   5 %/# '-0* :  1   1    '- /9"     9 + '- ' 5   /       / 9  +5+1:  9  / 1  ! " 8  5   5      "  +  5  55   /  +  '5" /1+  "95  /"  ! " " 8        + 9 "  +    +/  /  ! " 8 +1/9"  +1  +1+  !+  "5      $  

      1 '- ' 

5   8 5 +9 

! /9"+ +88  " 1+#  +5+1%;-0*:  85  989    +" 19"  +5+1 /9"  + +9  ' 5      +   9/9"+9 5  919  " 5    9++9   -  +/   9   5   + 5       %;-0:  1 *       '" 8  "/ <  " ( +  ' " 8 +1 +  +  ;0:  1 /     '5+++ "+9++1 " 1+ #  5"   5   / /+ #

"     "   "   $   1  " '- ++      5    9  #  "+  "  5+   "   0 '   8  /++  " / 0 '"

"    '5 +"  1   5    9+ $     "++    '++5  +"5  5 ++  + 1  / " 1 +   "  + ++1 ++    +"   ++    %' +: 7 1/+ "*    ;-0 :  1  /     /9" 5+1     ,9"/+  $   15  1 85   91  09+1"5       +1 +

  '" ;-0: /+  ++85   91 5   19/9"1 1+/   0 = >5  8+" 5 8 "  /++5  $/ 5  0 ' 

-   + "  + 1 9

1     "'0+  091+ "    /   5  / 5+    "+ 1 

'5 +" / 8   "       " 9 '-  / +   " "  

   

7  ! " "   +" "      " ++1      

5   / /+   9# $%(*   9" /++1 0' ?++ "5+  ! " 1  8   5   " 9 

5            + 5   /   '+1 '-+"   5     +1  5 /8   ,  '- +"     "        '5    1      5   1  '5 9  @@9 /+1 A 1    +@     6   '-

5   + 

19 +91@@9 /+1 ;@ 9/+ ;@@9 +  '- /  "+ ;@@+  /+1  @@"   ! "" 8/@@ '- / /++1+ @@ @@  " "5  ! "   5  /5/     " +9  1  /     5    9   ! "" 8+ / 5     5 @@1@@  1 1"+9  5   1"  '5 +1"8 1 "" /++  /   ,  2  %(((*

  9   '- '   @@ 9   "+ + " /     /  9    / " /++ + @@ "   ! "+ 5 /    '-"" 1 ! "   +  '- 5    ' 5  /   /     9  ++% "*  

 '- 5        9    ,     /   1          ' + " " 1  +  +    ++1 +  "      +  9+     + /9"+  ' 98 1 +  " "    5  /  1    +  //1 9 1

   91 

; + ;0 :  9      

   

        

                            

                          

        

           '   $   8  +  ++   " (((% (*   ++++ 1 + ((( ( 9   ++ "     + ( 5 /+ 7   +  + + +  + +   7     1  911 

6  " ( +  7  +  '5 /9 +  9

   '5++  +5+11    '55      9  1" 1+# 

    $ % (*    9   "   /++10' "/ 0 '"

"  +  "+"+ 9/+    /+"0 'B 20 B"3 & " 1  "%     + " 1    5   8 +* ++1  "  "$%(*"2'%(*     ,     5     5   ++ "5 +  1   ;-0:  1 +  98  +5+1  9"        ++   9 /9"1    

5   + " 9   0  /1   91  8    ++    +9 

5   +  1+++"    /1 9 +  ""  9 + 1  '-0 :  1     5    + 91 5 5   8   5  /@@  /     "    /          ' 6   18    8  5   5    ++ 5++   ! "$ 8  9 +++ "  5  

'-0 :  1   8 5   91 5 5   8 5  " / /@@   ;-0:   85 5  +5+  9   

5       8  +5+1 9  "  9     9   9    $+5+   "  ;-0:  1  898  +5+11   ++9/9"1  5   9   1+ 9    +5+1 ++9/9"    91   /    8 5   91  01  8           +   9/9"1++1 "91  '  +9 '- +"  11   "        

5  + " 5     ;-0:  1+9

  /     /  + +1  + + 5    

 +  01/ '-+" 9 +91   '    ' '-0 :  1   8 5 91  +  '5      +  '-0: 0 /1  9 +5  +     +   +5    1+ +  " 5 9  5+ "+ +"5  5+ +   '5 +1 1/ 5 ++  +  9  5+ "+ +"5  5+ +   '5    +   5  + /  "+    9   5+ "+ +  +8 '-0 : 7 " : 7C " 1 + "+1  +   "+    '5  598 +   55    '     +     5 /  9     9  +$  6'        ,  ' '5%'-0*:  1  1  5  +5  +5+1%;-0*   '-01 55    

;-0: 1" 17" 15  8"9/9"1 + " " 5+1+9        /   /9"1     +  /   1  '" /9" /+   " 1 5      8        /  ++       ; 5   8   / 5  "  +A +     ;+ /   

 1   1"++1 / %  *  ,5' %*+      5   / /+      5    + "  9 + #

 "     "   "   $   1   " ' 8      5     9    1    $   5+    5    + +A   /9 9   1 /  /  +  9 $ 5 /   &+A   /9 9 "     1  5   /  / '-    9   + +A +      /  +  /     /+         

5     "  9       1  "  5+       5   ,   / +   

  5    9  , /+  1 + 855       ""   "  

   ,  /+     +9  +8    5          "      9 "  / +   9 9 + 5     "  

 91 / /++    +1  0 9   5 "     5    5     ?$  5+  1+   '- '     5       +   /     /   " 1 5 #  9  5   " " "/+ ++9 ++ "  '+++1 5     5  /      %   *55   / /  ;-0:  1 5  989   + " 19"  +5+1/9" ++9  0 /1 1  85  +/ 9 5  +5    /9"1 +    ;-0:  5  5 91  85  +5+    9    5       8  +5+1 9  "  9     9 

 9       /  /+  1           

5    +   /+ " '-      "

     '- 98    " $   5+   9    0 1+++1 ,9"/+ ";-0:  1  ; + ;-0:  1  +5',9" +   ;0:  1   " +     '-'5   9# $5+  +5+ +5   +  "9  +  +9  +A   1  5       01 / 5  /   9  "  +    %;-0:  1 :  *  '    "   5   +/   9   5   1    "  5+   % 9*" 1  91  '5 +"  +1    "  / 91          '  +9 /  '- ' +" 1   "  /    91 

                                                                       

  ! " ! #$ ' 8 " 98 5   5    %  9 +*/1"91"   51 " 98    " 91 +9 " 5 ""   ! " $   1 +1   "8 5 /  9  % 9*++" 5 //   9++1 1+ 91 + 681 ,9  9 91    +   9    "   " 5 +9 ! " 8"   91+  8 "5 +95  ;  +   :     + 1    91    9   91 9 8  /@@ 1 + 

   ! " / 8    ++     5 5   /  9#  9$ 5  '+     + ;0    +  5 1   1 +    1 +  +++8 .1+ 1# %&                      

   

                     

                       "#"''(      

    ! " !) '(  !(#!###  

  

  ! " * ##$%.' +  *  '  +9 5 +" 1  5 + ;-0 :    /       5+  9   ' 18%;0:  1*    '-5   9 #   5+   $  98 +     9"  " "  9" "5   0"+  ++ 

5  5   ++ 1     "  " 1 9   +  5   " "  +   9  +  8 +1  /9"      "   0 1  +       5    '   5 +"  5         9    1'-+"  ++ +  1 / +1"5,9"/+   $  '+95+"1,9"/+  $ +                             9  8'-5   9  1 5+   5     ' 85   /  $+    +1% 91" "  *+5 91/@@ +  911+ 9   ' +++1  ,9"   /+  1 9          5             ++ +1   5  +     5 5    ' +++1  98   1   91 1  +   " 5  +9    - 91+    + 5 5    1   5 1+ 91

5   %  9"+*  '+++1 5+"/ + ,9"/+  8   "   '-    9     "  8  ++   91  1  '-   " ++  '-    /     /+ ,9"  ++ '- 5    /  '-   /  +  91   ?  + "  8

++ '  + + "

 +     +/8  +  1  "  0 1 "   55  1 / 5,9" 15   ' +++1  98 5 5      +1  /  1     1  !"    +     "  "   5+  9+91"      '5   " 1        %  1  * +  +1

 +%'-0: 1 *  B 18+95+"1'-0: 1  D " 5   5  + + D +       9   0      + 5   5  + +

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

5    ?   5    $     9 " /++10' ?5%;-0:   * 

    )' ;0 :  1       8  " +   "   "++++1//5'+  +   8" /++  " %'-   +*+91 +  '+#