Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-08-4135/4 AI generated

2-08-4135/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-08-4135/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

 46 $#1,,1,"&&5%$!%(,(.,("55&, $,('"-$&"""("1 "& ,(# !( 0+  $#!!(,) - 51,(,&" . 8) " !( #:, $#1,,1,.,(" 55&, $#1,,1,,  $!%""1 $#1,,1,(1  "& ..#%-,  9 55&, %$$ & $#1,,1,"&&)  !( .,(" "..#%-,""#"$8$#!!(,).,("&$.*-&""&,$!%""$!  "& %    $#!!(, .,(" &""&, " -- %  %,(($,#  &$#=,$") "( $!  , ! %  .*# $!$$".. '&,&, .,(" &""&,"$$&,5%,&$"("1+":$!$$"..+51,(,&".)0+ )(,(1""$! -* &',"&.,("&""&,""&&  $#!!(,)  ?1,(,&" .1 8)+ 8)3 > <    $!% !( ("1 "%" .,(" *# -,,-, &#$ .,(" .'%,,(,&" *"1 ,(#,&# %$ +  9 -'(- "&& ) ," 7) ("#  $!  ,('"-$ &"""("1 -,,-,7+0$#!!(,), !"1,,(-#,("#".,/($%,) )-"0+ $#!!(,('"1+&,87$#!!(,!(&$#1,,1,"&&+ 0+  $#!!(, ,('"-$ &"""("1 "& ,(#+ 7+ 0 $#!!(, ,('"-$&"""("1-,,-,+8$#!!(,..#%-  $#!!(,.,("&""&, "3#-1 <80*"-* &',$! 7) ("#,$"(, & $#1,,1,"&& *,,$" "&,(, -,,-, +  9 & $#1,,1,"&&(,(#-1 <8*"-* &',$!   $!%"!" &, $"".*- $"(, ,('"-$ &"""("1 "& ,(#, *,,$""&,(,+9-,,-,&,(#,"&&)   !(%,-1"',",$".'% (1("1%,&*#,"1 !",1+-,,1> <10833.++833+3 303 + + 3    3 8  3  3 8 &,1 $!% ": $!%"" *, -- .,("+ $" ""# $!%"" #,$$"&,( !( -'"% "(- $!%"" *,& *&,( -', &,$!%( *,&,(+ %" *,&, -,,-,&,() ", -'(,$ !( $!%"" #,$$"("1+ -',: -'"1  ('"1 $!%"" *,&,+ $% " %5-,&,  #%, $!%"" *,&, -,,-,&, $!## ('"1 -,,-, (,( .,(" #,$$"("1 .,(".!! !( $!%"" &$ $% ""1 .,(".!! .,(" $!$$".,"1 ..#%-,) > <  $!% !( #:, $#1,,1,.,( $#1,,1,.,(+ &, !& & (1"-', $"-" "- $#1,,1,(1  ((: -', $!%"": (1& #:,  $#1,,, -', (") - > <     , -', #:,  -'(- &$ "&,-,,-,&,('"1><*"1-,,-,&#$'#&-,,-, (,(><8$!%-',:$#1,,1,(1 !&$(-$#1,,1,."%" $#1,,1,.,("#:, &$-,,-,"'"5;15$( "%"+$",#:, !(*,,$" -',!,-,,-,"-*%&$!&5$, *#(-!&$ $#1,,1,(1 !( (1("1 #:,  1"" -*%& $%(*1 *,(1- *%  .""1" - "&& "&,$$!!-1"+5:*%  !!$"!&$"& *&, $!##.,("5 ('":$!"-'"&,)  !(%,%,-1"&*#,"1""  !"1',",$".'% (1"1(,(

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-08-4135/4 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

          

        !"  

#"$!%"   !!&'((                 )&*#'#"$!%"& +$,# ,$&("              ,(-#,("#".,/($%,))-" 0+ $#!!(, ,(1"--,,-,('"1)          % ,(-#,("#".,/($+#,#,$!!1 22222222 "$!% 222222 22 22222+ ,(1 222222222223 $!  )  ) + ,,$"$!!1 22222222222+ "$!% 222222 2222 2222222 2222 2222 2222222)    #%"11,(-#,("#".,/($%,))-") * &',)),(-#,("#".,/($$"$04(,$5&&(1 $!&"%,1(,$5&&(15$6$#!!(,  (,) * &',)),(-#,("#".,/($$"$7) ("#, $"(,&$#1,,1,"&&+!87$#!!(,*,,$""&,(,-,,-,+ 9&$#1,,1,"&&) * &',)),(-#,("#".,/($$"$$!%"!" '""&,$"(,,('"-$&"""("1"&,(#,+!"&& 0+$#!!(, *,,$""&,(,-,,-,+9&,(#,"&&)

"((,1$!%"!",-,,-,&*,1-$)      ,(-#,("#".,/($&("$""1 *))$(1)  

     ,(-#,("#".,/($-',:,1.,!!($:".*- !!$"+  !" $*!,&&,+ $",1 &, %, & $", -,, $"" &;;1"&, #" $!%" !" -,$" -$ &,+ #" ,($!(($!%"+ $" ""# $:" -',1$ %(11 $,# ,$" &("+ $", $:" , !  %(1&,,"(,)  )  )  -',:  !" . ,1 $  #" $!%" '#" $!%"& 

 46  !" $*!,&&,   .*- !!$"+ ,1 $  $',$   -&,&,'."-,,&,$- ,$)    !""# "$" #% "# &'# &$##%#$(## 

!%" !( $!%"("1 $!  $!%" $,# ,$" -&  .*- !!$"  %, $*!,&&, 4 6+ %!,1 &+  $", $!  $!%" &#"1 *% $ $,# ,$",-+!($!%"',"%, !"#%"11)  ,-1" $!!  ,1  &#" $,# ,$" -" (1&, $!%"" !( $!  $*!,&"1  <    *"1 $!## ) -:#"#,  4 06) !($! 1,$$$,# ,$"-"(1&,$!%"") ! +$$!%"!( &#("1$,# ,$"-&,*% +,!*%$!%"$,# ,$"-("1) !%" ,:+,,($,, <0 &*#,"1 !"&,-*,-,1  !",1)  ,  !"1 %(1: $!%"  <1 0  + +  *,1 #-1    !") 

!%" ,:+  %, !( %,-1" &*#,"1 ""   !"1 ',",$" .'% (1"1(,($""": !"#%"1&,) 

 < 0  +  $!% -',: $!%" %  !" -', !& " %,  !"#%"11%,-1"&*#,"1  !"1',",$".'% (1"1 ""+ $", $! + $ $!%" !( &#("1 -&, *% + , ! *% -("1)  "%" !$ %  ,"1 =$,,1 -*,1 $!  .!! !&$-'"$ (,( !"-',: "%"%$!%","(,.,1&) 

<"-',: !"-*  *$,# 1-!+-* #-"1 "%"+ $", !( " 11+  !" $""": "(("&,  *,&, $ -* .!! , :#,,$,)/'% (1-!&*#,$5$(',",$.'% (1") 

"( !" , $""" *,&, -* .!! , :#,,$,+ *: $!%"  !" -* $,# 1-! &*#,:.'% (1-!5$(',",$".'% (1") 

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

 < 0   $!% $""": %,  !" #%"1&,  $!  ": %  $"$ -*  &', 0+   $#!!(,3 #-1  < 80 *"  7) ("#,$"(,&$#1,,1,"&&+!87$#!!(,*,,$""&,(, -* &',-,,-,+9&$#1,,1,"&&(,(#-1 < 8+3><8*"-* &',$!%"!" '""&,$"(, ,('"-$&"""("1"&,(#,+!"&& 0+$#!!(,*,,$""&,(, -,,-,+9&,(#,"&&) 

 46

 < 8   .  $!% "((,: $!%" !& " , -,,-,& *,1-$ !") 

<8$!%$((:%,&("$""1.!!+$$% "$!"%,)

!%"+#%"11%,+ *: <8"% &("$""1$! $(1)   

!%"(,$@