Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-06-4353/12 AI generated

2-06-4353/12 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-06-4353/12
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

              

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-4353/12 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:               

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

     

        !"    ! #$   

            %&'()'&((*+,$ 

    &-(.-/)0) 

   - $ !$!"  !

1 2 345$&&60 &0,"     

&&'(.'&((7          

 ! 18!!9         

     %6'(&'&((*              8!!:; ! 1 2 34< " =========== !=====>>-> $! "-

"5<

:;  $ !$!" 2" %()%.6(.$"%7$! "- "5   ! " #$ %        &&$'($&'')                  

         $ &$*  "          $ +$,   -    .       $      !!"??$" -$!$!""'         8! $,9 " 9

! )( 8?$ !  ! ? !  "  8? $  @@"   $!! $' $!!"25A&%*!)! $,9 !! !   !"  " $!"  ! B $""$"$"!'

 &

$!  A .7% ! 0 !9 9 ?"    $9   !'

! ! !     ,  !" !!'  !     / 0    /    %' &*'(&'&((.   $ !$!" 2"8"  5  ! $!"2'!%-&5 !" 32 15$ !!8!$?!, !"

3!$,!$&&60 &0!,$!"&0('  $!"!,!"8!"(*'()'&((%"$-"!!"!8  "! ===== >>->  $ !"' $! !8 8! )'%(  .'*   %0 8?$ ! 8?    " !""!"$$!!8!!'"!"  (%'(&'&((.   $,!$ $$! &&60 &0 '   $,!,"2 C5A-"!7.!% %(%!%8%'  &'(0'(/'&((.!!2'!%.5 !" 3" ! 3  !" 3"' !! !   $!" ! 3 2"8"  5 $ &&60 &0$,!,"2'!%7-%*<!&*'(&'&((."$!"5'  )' !"?9  !" 34%6'(/'&((02'!%05'  /' (0'(&'&((7??2'!'&75" !" 1!

1'"??A&(*!'%'  0'&7'(&'&((7!$2'!)%5! 12"8"5 "' 

!!$,!!"',""!&((0'89 &&60"!'(*'()'&((%!88.'* ??!!"!'!"!8!,8" ' !!"8!?"'  .'&&'(&'&((7$2'!)05? $,!$,"$"! $!" " $ $?!$,  !"!8'   !  &((0'89'!!"8!?"'  !!   7' &&'(.'&((72'!7)-7/5!"!, $?!&&60 &0'!!"??!!"'  *'  " $,!,"  $!" B!" "  $$! , " " " 2 C 5 A &  A %& !'%  !"   "  !"!!9!?" C-?' CA7.!'%!!!9?$$! !8!$,"!'

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

 / %*'$""B!,"! 8,""D"! !!   "$ "' !  ! " ,""    ! " !! D"  !' 8?   99$!  BB!! !!A&)&!%'  %6'$""(%'%('&(()-(%'%('&((0""!"@@" "!'$"" """"?$"&((0'?&((/'       9 '  ?$" !!" " " !!  ,"""D"!' ??A&)(!% ","!  !!!,8,'  !      &('$8!!9!8!"?"'     ./    &%'    $"  !"  !"     !9 B"$,!!?9$'  

         &&' (/'(&'&((* 9 !  "     $,! !  &0/0 &0'!!!" !"8 !!?9 %%'(7'&((7 !&0/0 &02'!'6*-665' 

 ?9 " !" ?!8 2 A .0& !'/5     ""  ?  " $!' !" !   ! %%'(7'&((7     8!!9  !!  $"!9   $,!$ $?!,  " %.'(7'&((7  8?  B!"!' 8!"8!!9!9$!" !9!  !?"  A .)( !'%  A .0%  !!" 8!!     "!8,""8!!98,!'     &/' ! 8!!9$?"8,""   !9 B" !, "   !,  9,!","$??",'  &0'  !" !   !" ! $,! $?!, ! "$-"! !" !8 !!   ! ,!" (*'()'&((%'  !" 1!" -$!$!"    $!2'!'%-/ %/-&( )0 /.-//5'    

 0   ," 8,"    !" ! " ,"  $!" $! *:&((0-&:&((. ' 3  2'!' 0  &%5  (7'%('&((0 

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

$!A%7)!'&,"9"!"$,9 !"   !?9$   "9  $" ! $$! !!"'     ?  !"  !9  !!" ?!!"A%.&!'% &!!"$!" !! "'  )&' !9 A%7/!'%!$,9!!," !""   ! !!" ! "!?? !" !"$!"88!!!)(8?$! !!" "!",' A%7/!'&?B$$"!$!"!" !' $!"!!!!"!","$" """' 

 7 ))' "!!"A-"//& .)% .)6!%  .0% .0&!* .0/ .07!%8& ..* .7(!%'              !#$