Legislator Case Law & Legislation
3-07-1943/3 AI generated

3-07-1943/3 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-07-1943/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

                  

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-07-1943/3 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja:                   

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                  

        !""  #$%& #'# ((  #

 '   ## ! 

)#(  $%   #   *     +  $%&,( 

'     - .'  

 ( ( /0!   -1 +



'  

 ( #  (,,+ (# ,

 '   1-   .!       #(  #(,,+"+( 

(+" ( / 0!   1"#(

   + 12   .3 

(+" ( (  ( / 0!   1*+  # 2

 # $%*(   

 (" +   4-0'" + 4-1,  !     " 5

'  * # +   *+ (    # *   +  #(,,+"+(    !   

(

#& (*"    2  +6 "5" (*#"*(((#   +

" +  (,,+ #(#( * # +    +   + (#  +  +  !  + -# 

' + 2(

+    .'  ( /7*"#*"  +

'     (# -"   "   ($%&    

(0(,,+1

    # +((5

!            # (     "+0,( 1 #(,,+*!   " $% 6 (   $%+ 2*( '" +  4-$%  *+     (  " +     +( (#0216

'   2   -.8  

 ('" + 4- *"( #  

 (    /0!   -1" + *  $% 2*( " + *"(+" ""  +!   -"+    , +     

     (0   

1     0   99 ,   1(#0,,( 1(,,+"+(6  " $%&"!   -",(  (#+*+ ( $%   " + *"(" """

  *( 

   (,,+    (6  #( "  $%&     "    (01(,,+0:(1 #( 2  ## ( $%+  *(    (" + *"" " ""6  +     (

 #$%  2*(    (" +  + $%& 

(,,+(" +    $%  

"

 *( $%&   (     

      ( (#  $%+ 2*(    ('" + 4- *""  $%    $%&  (   + 2    !   " # + *+ ($%  *    (   #(,,+"+(0    12   + !#

'  -!   "  *+  #+*(" 

&(  ;&7  , $%+ 2*(  " + 4-   

 ( !# $%+ *(" +(,,+("     + 

+( ( " +  (,,+,#

  '" +  4-"   

 ( ( #+ ##*  $%     *  ,(,,+ ($%&

8  !  + -   #* #

  (  #* ("  "    "  "*# #!   " *+    +

 *   !   "# 2   .3 

(+" ( (  ( / ( *+ "*# ,# #  (5  #  !   "#*+    +( *+   $%&   (  

(0(,,+1

     +   +!     " +  *((6 # #

   

(+" ( !         ((  # +  #      6 " *#*+ *   *  *#0$% 16    " "     (       2     6 '" + " 

  ( "    "

 +     " 6  "# *(" +   +( " (   +(  " + " +( 6

' + 2(

+   .'   ( /7+*       *  

51 +  

 

!   #

(  ("   ( (#  ( " *  (  #, +  *   

  "  "    +     , (+"*# (   !  "+  !   7+       

   !  "*#  #  ;&7-2 * (    (

  +

  #       ((((  *# &( *#( "  2

'  # $% *(   

 (" + ( #,  "*#  # 2" +   +( " + +8  << 0!&17+( * +*  "   , # *=,, 

(    +*        +( # *(  " + +% , (   " +  #      ((  !   +  0! &17+"#-

  #

    (    + &( 7+    ("   

* 

,  *+ +     #  +   + # +

    ! &7+# +     *,   (    #( * (,,+   (,,+"  * (,, >(      

      # ,  (   "

    ( (  , , ((    " + , ;&7  #

(

 +7+"# +  #

%&7+ 0  (  *+  (("   + , 1!&7# + (  ,  ( ( +  " + *((*   &+      (,  * + 2" + ,   " + *+ "   " +(

 +;&7-    * " + " "   #(  + #

 "  

*# #       

*   !&7- *  &+ *   # ++( " + +   

 (+  8 " +      ( +( 0 " +1   

 ( 0*+ " +1 !  + * #   " + +  (   $%&# " #*+    

    + *   -!      

(+" (      #(#(,,+ #( "       !   "+ " (" ( $% " ( 3" (   *(

      $%+   

 ('" +  4-   ( (,,+

 ( + 

      >!   " '" +  4-"    ,#

   

(

#& (*"     ($% 

 

 "

 ($%  *  *+ 2 +  + #(,,+"+(     !  (( +  *#

!      " ( + (,,+ " (" (+# *+  * (,,+(,,+" 

  "# ! * $%&   " ( + 

   !   #" +   +?!   -  +$% 

 + "

 

  + +  *(   ($%&+ "(("  (,,+""<<  (    #$% " 

 (     (  ! $%& 

 (" ,   

(

#&  (*"     ( $% 

  

 (( (+"" 

(!    "#'" + 4-"(# +

 *+ ( $%  *    (  #(,,+ "+(0    12  +   

(

#& (*"    &+ + $% 

     (#(,,+"+(     +(,,+( (   (,,+"+(  ( #

  $%  

,+(,,++($%  *   $%&"     "#  +    *+     #"*# (@

+  (# (   + *  *+ "  **+  # ( +(

  ( *+     +   (   (   + ;&72+    ( ( #

"

 !*+     " (    +# *   #  ( #  ##*""   +(   +( (  *+ #*   +( +  #



  #$% *+    !# + (      *+  .   " + *((/+, " "*# +  

 3 # *    "  ""   +    "" "     ;&7+"  ( #  +" "    ( +   #

   (   

(" ( (

   +    (+  (

 "(! 

 " (" (

  " #  *+     (=    (       *##  + + (*  +( +!    ( #(     *# *+     (++(

   +2(,, "*        *  "#    #  (,,+(,,+"  !   "  "  (      + *+ # "  * *+ ( #  " (*+  +(+#(* +#  (

 " ( 8  ##   *+    #( ++( 

 

+(*(*+ *( *+  +     (   *+     *   "

 (    ,,(  (   *( !  "  "" #-  #(  #          

   >





   

  

 (   

(+" ( (* "

 

   "*      '*"  # "" 2   (+  

* "

 

 ("

 +    

  + #"

 + + (*"*#    + (



+( + 

   *  (  #   ( + (

# + 5 #6#6#6- # &(  # * # +

 #$%  2*(   

 ('" +  4-  +   " + + ( " + ( 

  ( + (,,+"+(  ++ ""= *(   , (+ 8#"  << 7+* (  +* "   , # * =,,  (    +*        +( # *(  " + +&+      ( *+  " +  ( " +  *(    , , (=(  !    ((** ! &7"(      ( 

*    *    ,   *( (  *

"(#  * +  ( 2

! &7+    *

    +   ( #

    (,, "# "*       *,  (     #( * (,,+  &

 (      "      (  * ,  (+ (  +    # ( * (,,+  (,,( &#

*(! & 7+       #(#

     #

  *+     # +  ( +   + 3 

  "    ( "

  ,  (=    +,#

 (

  ("  0 "  (1 $( "    "(("   "*  (,,     *(

,  ( # * (,,(     #( *  (,,+   8    

 (" + + +

        #

(



 (  &#

         (

    "

  +* "   ,  ( (*   

 

     (     , ( #   (  +* " 

 #$% *( " +  " + 3+(  *+  " + + #;&7+"   " + , #;&7-  " + *+ "    ! *  # # !   - *+  * #    #* ( "    (   !   -(  +#( $%&  ( (

*+    (

 #$%    

 (" +&(  #*++  !     + #    "#  +( # (,,+ (    

'      + (  ,+( "

  !(   # + (

 +2*( " +   *+     

  " ( (

 " +  #=   " 8" + #" +      *+ ($%  *     "(  "  " ,($%  *   ( "(  #" "  8 $%& #"<<  ( "(   # ($% " " #   # * +  ( 

$%   " +     "(# " $%   , +        (#*+ *+*  *  +(   +  --  ! #    +"""(  +

 "( (, (*+     $%                 #-

'      $%& (.(,,+ (!   0 "  + ( + 1("  + $% /01#$% #   0 1   "  01( , +(,,+ #   +  + # .("  + $% /   + (,,+

'   #    + -    ( $%&(,,+

(" +   4-              #   *#$%  &+(   # *+"

      ( *+    

 $%& (#

   * * " ( +     +   (  02   0-1 -   01   021-    018*(+ (" (,,+   +-       (, #  #

  * " (*$%& -  + *    

(+" (         #(( #0210 1!  "# +"" (*#*(((#   + 

" + (,,+ #(#( * # +    +   + (#  +  + !  + 01      #

  "      #$% #(,,+"+(!     8  

 (" + 4-

 #$%  *(201'" + # + $% *+ 

!   (

  2 +    #  !   " (  +( >   "  " +  4-" +

 ($%  *     (  #(,,+"+( 

0 #      12  +

(

#&  (*"    + #   +        *

 '  2    -(*( $%+  *( " +*"#   #+ ("   

   $%    (*+ (,,+# (

*(  " +  +  &    $%&  +    + #  2  ",0-1!   -"   " +*+   &+# $%&  !    (,,+"    ( "(( #  $% 

      +  "*        #" + 4-  +    -  +(" "+*+   "  '  +   $% *+  + !      " =  #(,,+ #

(  *

(

#& (*"  (,,+ $%  *   #    -(*# $%&  (#  *+ (

+" (*#    *+ "   A+  "( # ( +(",   (+'  "(,,+#+( ( !;&7+# +**+ (

+(   ( ,*(

! ++    -0# 1*+ #*  "

   

+   "#" + =    (  (,,+"+( ($%  *  & *  $% +$%& ( +   01 @    $%& (# (# *+   *(    (&( #  (( +    *  *  #( + (*+ =(,( * (# (( (<<

> #   "#   *+    +(  +" +  4-,  (!# #

    ( *+   +  #      -( *+   +, ,,#   (*(  (#    ( !   *( ( ((  

 (#     #(( (   #  

*+   #  (+(

    +( (   "" ("(@ +  (   # " #  +*((+*+ " +$%&

(       ++  , +  

( (   (  " ((  * " ("*# ((  (   +  (  ++ # (#  3    (  ##     +(

 " #(*(" +  !     (# (    " +  *(((<<(  *(* *+  ( (*#  (*+  #

  #  *+  ",(     #  * +((  0 -1 B*    (# "(

   +#

  (  (    *+ *+  +01!#"  B+   "   "  " (

"  *+ *+    # +(  ! *+    + "*(*# +# +  #,( * 7  (  &*    # (  ""*#  

   "#*    *+  

(!  *+   +( (

(+   #" +  #+   $%&(,,+  

*(  (  + (!    *+   #+#

 + ( "

 (, ( ('   +*+    *+    #  +  ( . " + / *((!  *  #  +&( (

    *+   (  +    " "

#    (+*+    (#(,,+   ( #     +#   #"*#  

    + (    *  "*#   #* # #  + #   .* #

  * /01  *+   +(  #    

  # * (  ! "*#  ""    (#" (  #*+    +(&* B+

 +# +* *+   *(  #*+ + +*+    

 *  # ,( #  *( + *(* ( 7#2  *+ (* (+&+  (*+   *(  # *+ + + 

 *+"(*+    + ",,#  ** ,(# ( + 3"#  $%&  *(         (+ (

 # + *"   #" +  A+   ( *  (  

 +# # *( # ,( (*  "

 *(   + (     #"*#   (    " #       +   *+  

( ! * #"*#   (" (  #   *+   +("

   *   (# (  (* "#  ,,,# (   " #       +        (   +  *+*#  

(+

 (     #((,(   # +" (" (  *+  (     ( (

   "   "- +(#  



+(  " #" (  (( +(+ " "  ("    ( " 3*  ( *  (* 

, + (*+ +"     (+* 

  # 

 *#+! *   +    

(+" ( ( #(,,+"+(# (

(,,+ "# +,(+(,,+  (((   +#"  "*+ (       

 (  +( !    *+   +  (  "

 #,   + ( ( (  $% * " ( ##+   " ("

 #  (    #  (# ( $%&       ( + (



 #$% *(   

 (" +   4-, & # " +  " +   + ,   # "

 !&7# +#+  #     ,  (, ( *+  #   &+= (" +  " + "(  ,  (, ($%   ,   , (   + "   +*  *   " (*+   (   * (  ,  =   (    (72+  /( , ,    *  #     <<( # (( (#    #     "  ( * ,  "   +#    #



 ,  + + /&(" + * # + ( , ,   *  

"*+,(  (#  ( +  (#(

 ("  #  

  

  +

,"(#

    ( , (  '*( ,  (    

 *( " #(&#

++(  +"   ,  (+ '   (  + ! &7+  

   "(("  5 * (,,   "   *(

,  (#  * (,,+( (    #( *  (,,+  8  " + + 4- +

        ($% 

 #

  "

   0 !$!&72+#+1*   *+   

 +   * +  (+(* +( *+  ,  ( *+   , (+! " +  (*+   (     ( "+(  " + +  +  (,  &  # +(  *+   (   " + + (  " + + (     (,(" *+  ((   ( #*# (   (  , +  + ""(*+ #  +  " +*"(*# *3 #

( +(  " + +

(

+# + "(

  ,#"C #"

  # *+  *   (   

 !;&7+ (    "#    &* $%&  # (     #(*( (( -   +*#*+   -     3  ##   !;&72+"27+            @ $%&   (# (     #(*( $ *"   B +  " #    +(   !""