Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-04-1569/7 AI generated

2-04-1569/7 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-04-1569/7
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-04-1569/7 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               

       

     !"#  "      $%&%$&$''()*   

   $+',+%-./  

    # 

" *0   1"*#2 $$3-/  /.3. """ * " *#  " *0     #   2   *#   

%,&'.&$''. $+',+%-./       

  #45   

    $/&%%&$''()*           46   # 7# %''3/8/-!   8- %'%$,   9  " 4 #     " *0  7#8(3%$'.8(%/!:::::::;;+;;!$'$'8  9    ! "     #!$%!&$$%   

  &'$#' (%)    * +   "    ! &! * +  ,'       +-    &&./%0 %$ 1"

      "

    %$  2 ! /! 3  0 !! ,      

  $ $7%'9   *    ,'       +-    

   

 )%.%         

 #. $   * +     *

 

 !   4*5 ,  5  

   5   !  "      !       5  +             /$ 5*        * 

    0     5* 

  66            !   7 %8   !(         * 0          !      0    +       

  !  !,    *   %&# '$&%%&$'',5(+%<',<%%$7&%8+%(9#

"*0 5!"* + # &*0  16 & 2 7*#"$%/-/4/'' 9$$3-/& &  #2 %-& =&  #/.3.& $&   %$&%%&$'', #  # 7& %+,9 4    ## + #*"2 # &*0 # 4 1"*#""$$3-/  #""/.3.&  #  " '/&'.&$'',   "   1   *! " # &*0  *#  =! ""1 ::::::! & &*# >!""1'%/ &$3&'(&$'',  #!"#!4"#*4*"   5%''? & +&8'&'.&$'', &*  + # 2 " *# "" /- '%- &   # 4 @+ AB#  *#"##&%/&'(&$'',*# + # 4" 5    "*# "#  @+ AB# "".($'%&@ AB#  + #4" ! #"1!## ##141"# C  & )!  5 !  *"  #  #! " 

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

  , ,7%'9 *#   "#!       !  ## * # " 2 !  +  &  *#""*4"#"4!# 1##!#### "2 #*# 11# *#11"" *"22*#11& "*#  #!###2 "  # 4 #&   #   2 # *# !#5!4#4#"* &  4   #!  *#  11 11! " 4# #"# #5 "  #4#4& *##4"" *"@ AB# *"!##2"4##&)! !452 "!4" 1! *  " 4 #      ## 4#  " "*   4  #  ## 4*#"# &   #  *      *# *# ""!    # * # 41$3&'(&$'',# 1"1#&  8& &*0  #" $'&%$&$'',7$(+$/9 41  ##"&

"'/&'.&$'',%(&%' ""   " *# >+$%'%%!  ""1 ::: :::! 

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

  - -7%'9 *"4#*4 + #424&%%&'3&$'',   +  # 141" *# 1#  "# #"!# ## 1# 1###E,.+8&141#! #F#"# + # " 5# & *2 "-8',%""& " "#5## * 5  #!   4" #     #  #&   # !    *" *   5 *& "  & "!*#""4"#" 1!"#  "4  *44"!  1 # ##  *# "   1# 11& # ## 1 " "# #       #& C 15!    *" # 4#  ## " "  ! # "      *#  4#  ##  # &  GG 5 ##!    #""" 1#"# "!" "# #"!&!"#" *"# #"##  ##E,(8!" ##$%&'(&$'',4&

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

  . .7%'9  -&  #   7& -%9   "  # 14 "4**#!"# !"  #" %'&%%&$'',   #5&   # 4 1  1  #"&  #1"###&" # ###"  #44# 44  "'-<($!" *##!*# *""#-8'''   @ AB#" & #" ##  *&  # !4**#"!#"  *&   "1  #  #&  !   5+    .& 1"%,&'.&$''(7&%',+%%89  #4*

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

  ( (7%'9 1 !""4 *"#4*##& # " @ 4#444# 7%%9!""253'?" ""&  4 15 "  4*##     "" /''   1"*"*&"  &*0 #* 4""2 "&

&*0 #*# 11 #"/-''' &"  # ""%- # 1!    ! "# &*0  45 "  1 "*! "#5 /-'%- &   &*0  -8',% !  1 

7 9"",%/(,& ! &*0 "22"  *#%3'''!" *4"2 ""$8/(, &

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

"*# #"#"   "  &  3& "*0  45#&  !     

  37%'9 /& 145##&  &*0  4#54*# #""$$&3'" "*#& @11# # &* 45 &  !   5+    %'&  # 1 "#   #   "#! #!  45 1#   4*## &*0  1"*#  2   # "" $$!3'  "  " 1" & @11#5"1""&  ##79E$#" #    #  # # E+ $( "# # *"#&   E ( &%   ##  2 # # # &  E$.&,2 ##4   #    *"  " *! &##E$(##&  E8,&%1 !""4 * "#4*##&E8,&$151 "   11 7*1 "229   #"!  *1""11"4*###&  C    #!  & &!   "    ## +  #! 22 " '/&'.&$'',   *! "  # 

&*0 #*# =&4*"  5%'' ? & +& #     2!  &*0  # *#  11 #"/-'''&  C# # #  2!  &*0  # *#  = """#4*##&  #5! ""#4*### *"-8',%  45#  #*"2 # &*0  # 4 1"*#""$$3-/  ""/.3. &  &*0   !   "   "# 4*##!    #   # *  5  #!   4"# ##& #!  *"* 5 *&  "  7E8,&%9& &*0 5!   # "   2  "" /-'%-   45 1"*(8('.!8,7,%/(,"2  8%(8$!8,  9& 

*5"! 1 # #""$$!3' 1"*" !  &*0  *#  = ""   "# 4*##!   "" 25 3'?   

  / /7%'9 ""  ##"1" &*0   #"4*##! 1 # #""$$!3' 1"*"&   4 +  # 1 "*#  2  5 "  #   # 4 #  # "" $$!3' &   4# &*0 454*#& # *#7&&%$.9  ##$8&%%&$'', &*0  # ""$$!3'& 1##  ..(,.!8$8/(,   1   "## 2  1""  "    ...(/!-'!5"  1""&  E.-,&. 4"""" 1""4*#"& 

45 1#"151"& 

*4# 1!"## *## 2  1    "  2  4* 1#"#2#*##& 

  !  "   "1#  # #  ##1##*##!"#1##!"##! "##&    *   "1#!   44  "    *# " "# 4*## "" -'''' &     " "1#!  *# "     "# 4*## -8'''  &  5!  "# "  # 5*  "!  "   4*##! "  4  "# & L#M "  *# " @ AB#  4* 4*#&  C#   #  2!     " *"& #  2 "# "# 5  "#   2 @ AB#  4*&  *5 " !  @ AB#  7&&%'9 "1!  ""# "" *5 "# "#1!"#5" &  %%&     E 8  #  '%&'%&$''. *#  # " 4 "# "  # #"11"  # "#1&  1# !  45 #  2 +  # 1"*#2  #""$$!3'" "!5@  # 4" # 1  E+# .' &%  %%  .% &% "##& 

4"#2 "#& 

  %' %'7%'9 %$& #"E+#.-,!.-(&%4&%!.('&% .(%&     

  "