Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-03-249/7 AI generated

2-03-249/7 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-03-249/7
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

$  (.'(&')//.," ''";;$, '-'',!!)*'(*'%((%", ''40'  $!"!$!"'-''," '' !!$"5!"5 "!4!!"' $  &)')('%((%)%)%05  %&')('%((%$!"!"''"5=!$!"" '' 40"$ $$, "0 40' '' "0 40  40"2#03!;;$,,"'-'' !!!!!#0<)(. ! ,  " 40!'  %*'()'%((&   ).& 0  ! '-'' " 40 !' $!" ! !5 '' (.'(&')//.  =" !!0$!4,!7 )3 ''  ! '' !    ! "'   $ 54"",4''$"8 %3 !0"! "!$!  ! ''  $"  $ $,$,,! !40""8 &3 !0"!"!$!! ''!"$!$!$5 =$$"$$!4$!0" , $!0'40!!! $!" $0!"'   $,  ' '' ! !4!",!!8 .3 ,"!!$"!!"=$"'=$ $"!! !!" ''4!8 ?3 , ! 45 $!   4,,' @    "!!! ;;$,!!'  %'))'(.'%((&002 "'!')%3'-''$!"!!$ 0=!00- ! $!"! $'  &'%>'(/'%((&'-''2"4"300- !$!"2  "'!&(-&?3''2"4"3$ $  4!(.'(&')//. ," ''",=40, , ''40"$! !!!!"! 5"%> $ $0!!4"!?/?% ",!!!$!'  $!" !  )*'(*'%((%  ," ''  !! $"  5 !" 5 "!!!!4!"' $ ' &)')('%((%)%)%05  %&')('%((%!"A-"5=!$!"" '' 40"$$$,"040',"040   ! $ $,40!4'" ''!"4!40$ $!""'!,!!!"  ''"$"   $,,! !' !   '' ! $! $,!    

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-03-249/7 · Viru Ringkonnakohus: $  (.'(&')//.," ''";;$, '-'',!!)*'(*'%((%", ''40'  $!"!$!"'-''," '' !!$"5!"5 "!4!!"' $  &)')('%((%)%)%05  %&')('%((%$!"!"''"5=!$!"" '' 40"$ $$, "0 40' '' "0 40  40"2#03!;;$,,"'-'' !!!!!#0<)(. ! ,  " 40!'  %*'()'%((&   ).& 0  ! '-'' " 40 !' $!" ! !5 '' (.'(&')//.  =" !!0$!4,!7 )3 ''  ! '' !    ! "'   $ 54"",4''$"8 %3 !0"! "!$!  ! ''  $"  $ $,$,,! !40""8 &3 !0"!"!$!! ''!"$!$!$5 =$$"$$!4$!0" , $!0'40!!! $!" $0!"'   $,  ' '' ! !4!",!!8 .3 ,"!!$"!!"=$"'=$ $"!! !!" ''4!8 ?3 , ! 45 $!   4,,' @    "!!! ;;$,!!'  %'))'(.'%((&002 "'!')%3'-''$!"!!$ 0=!00- ! $!"! $'  &'%>'(/'%((&'-''2"4"300- !$!"2  "'!&(-&?3''2"4"3$ $  4!(.'(&')//. ," ''",=40, , ''40"$! !!!!"! 5"%> $ $0!!4"!?/?% ",!!!$!'  $!" !  )*'(*'%((%  ," ''  !! $"  5 !" 5 "!!!!4!"' $ ' &)')('%((%)%)%05  %&')('%((%!"A-"5=!$!"" '' 40"$$$,"040',"040   ! $ $,40!4'" ''!"4!40$ $!""'!,!!!"  ''"$"   $,,! !' !   '' ! $! $,!    

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               

       

     !" #!!$ !   

            %&'()'%((*+,$ 

    %-(&-%./ 

   '-''''$"      00-   )*'(/'%((.  $!  %- &(%1(&2$3          

 '-''4!!5        )*')%'%((6              4!!17 '' 2'-'' ,0!8 " 99999999999  ! 99999 :1:  99999999 !$$!""38

17 '' 2" 99999999999  ! 99999999 ::  $ !  00-  "3    !"  #            ""     $%&'(&)''*    +        "# &    !"04!""'         4! $,5 " 5

! &( 40$ !  ! 0 !  "  40 $  ;;"   $!! $' $!!"23<%)*!&! $,5 !! !   !"  " $!"  ! =

 % $""$"$"!'

$!  < >6) ! ? !5 5 0"    $5   !'

! ! !     ,  !" !!'       , + "   ,    )'))'(&'%((&'-''!$!"2 "'!?->3 !!4!="

$  (.'(&')//.," ''";;$, '-'',!!)*'(*'%((%", ''40'  $!"!$!"'-''," '' !!$"5!"5 "!4!!"' $  &)')('%((%)%)%05  %&')('%((%$!"!"''"5=!$!"" '' 40"$ $$, "0 40' '' "0 40  40"2#03!;;$,,"'-'' !!!!!#0<)(. ! ,  " 40!'  %*'()'%((&   ).& 0  ! '-'' " 40 !' $!" ! !5 '' (.'(&')//.  =" !!0$!4,!7 )3 ''  ! '' !    ! "'   $ 54"",4''$"8 %3 !0"! "!$!  ! ''  $"  $ $,$,,! !40""8 &3 !0"!"!$!! ''!"$!$!$5 =$$"$$!4$!0" , $!0'40!!! $!" $0!"'   $,  ' '' ! !4!",!!8 .3 ,"!!$"!!"=$"'=$ $"!! !!" ''4!8 ?3 , ! 45 $!   4,,' @    "!!! ;;$,!!'  %'))'(.'%((&002 "'!')%3'-''$!"!!$ 0=!00- ! $!"! $'  &'%>'(/'%((&'-''2"4"300- !$!"2  "'!&(-&?3''2"4"3$ $  4!(.'(&')//. ," ''",=40, , ''40"$! !!!!"! 5"%> $ $0!!4"!?/?% ",!!!$!'  $!" !  )*'(*'%((%  ," ''  !! $"  5 !" 5 "!!!!4!"' $ ' &)')('%((%)%)%05  %&')('%((%!"A-"5=!$!"" '' 40"$$$,"040',"040   ! $ $,40!4'" ''!"4!40$ $!""'!,!!!"  ''"$"   $,,! !' !   '' ! $! $,!    

 & " 0"  !  "!   0   $ !!'  !! 4"!4!"'40!$,!$ ," $5"0!!" !!$"!!!"!  !!0$$,,!!'  $!"!$"!!$!#0<%), 4! "! $$ 40, ""     ! 4!'  !"   "! !$ !!  ! !!    '   ! !!,"'   , ''  """ $$" !!   $ 4" ! $,  " ,  " 0"' $!"! !" "!""05 ''!4!'  !"     0!  4! 0 " '' $! "'!!"!$!! ''$"!""!$

$54""$,!!'",4$"'! "   B $ !   '' $  !  ", ' !" 5   '' $ "      , $  23$,!!'C!!"$"! "  $!"!!$!!!$' " ''$ $"!"'$$ 40"$  ,"5 !     )//6'! '' ! !!"  ,$!"'$!!""!  $0!$,!" ''!!' !!  #0 %)'()'%((& ,"  ?6&6#  05   " '' , )//%' ! $   "   )//.'!    ! 5 !4!" ='   ="" )/(('!   ;;$,' '' $ 40  ! !!! 4""  $ "! !"  4 !""  !"'  .'$"!!$2 "'!6)-6%3!$' 

!$0" $"!!!,4!!!"  ,"'     ,  !! " 0"  ,'

0"  ''$"!4! , ""   4 !"! !""   !!!  $5' $ ! "!! ''55="' ''"$5!!!!$,"$!"! ! "'"!40  !!!" '',!$!""" !!$"! !" ''4"!'  ! '' " !"  !     ! !! 00"    40 '' "!!$"!!40' !$,"=00""==!,5' 0!4 !""!$ '''"$!$0"  ''$"40""$ !$0!4!!'! ''5$5!!4 40"40""$!! !5"$"4,!$' ","$" ''!"'

 . !" !! $",0"" '  ?' 00-   )>'(&'%((. 00 2  " '!' )*(3 00 !  $! "$    %&'(*'%((. ! $!" 04    $!" 2  " '! )/*-%(%3'      !5" 40"$ ,"  ",  ,' ,4!   0 "  ,'  $!"!(.'(&')//."=$,! ! $$! B <-! 6. ! )  !" '  !"   0!$! !  '' " !! 00! 5"! !   !"  - '' ,!$      !" $"" A ,!'","5!(?')%')//6, $!"  !!!  $!" 0" ''  " !!!  !! " ' !!"$5!!! $! ''$!4"$,! !  $0!""' ! "!$! ! '' ,!  40""  $ !!'  "  ""  =!   '' ! ,!$    !!!'

$$!)/'(*'%((%!"..600 ''!" '''   0!4 !! "!""40$40 '' '!",%)'(*'%((%'

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

 ? /'$!"! ! ''4"$!"5   !     "  !' ! 4! 5 '' -!' #"$ !"  !  "  !! ! ' =!!" $  5 " !!!!!! ''' ''!!$,! $!"" """'  -#   , + "    )('  4!5  (>')('%((. " 4!!5 2  " '! *-)&3 ="        !! !""  "  '  ))'5!"$!!"2()'()'%((> " -)//*3<%&)!.<%%6!)0' -)//* < %&) ! . 0 45   4,"     ,  $, $0"'45,",""!=='," ,"$ 45"4,"'

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

 > 00!!!!"').'(*'%((% '!40$ '' ''$!" !!4!00" ''!"'!$!" ''   " $" !"     !!! ! " '-! !4!  !"' $!"!!!!!" '' "$!" "0 '''!005 !!"!" $"  '-!!!!"00!!).'(*'%((%'+005   " 00 */-  !" *&- '    5"$$""D!! ''!"'  )?'   "  -)//* < )6>  0 4!!" 04 00 ! !"! 0 !  4! $' $,"   0$!! $","!"! (.'(&')//."! !!" ''""!!" 

 !5-)//*<)%/!)!0400' !54!!<)//*&(*!)!! ''=!!'  !"!""!'  )>''-''&)'(6'%((?2 "'!'&%3 !42 "'!'&.-&?3' 

 (*'(?'%((> 00 2  " '!' &/-.(3 !  "  !5 !"14!!",0!'-!2"4"3'      "  +    )6'!5!$2'!)>-)63 0,!"' 

 ! 005   ! " ! "'  05    '' !$$!"! !"$' ''!"! $!!$,!="  "' ''!!"!' ''!!"" '-5!=!' ''!4!5 4"!!',!  ''!""$," "40$!5" !""!5$0!4!!' ''" ,5" ""  =! "!""!" ''$ ' !5"! !!'-''4!5,0!" ''"'        )*'!!"'  )/'0$" !"!"'     #,    %('   !"0!!$"$!!"  !" 4!!5$0"=!'  %)'52 "'!'/  "'!')()'!,30" !!==" ","""" '' ''  ''=!!'

   " -)//* < %&) !' . 0    45 0  ,"" !!!"0!""45,",""!==' ,","$ 45"4,"'",""05 4$<..%!'*' !0!"! ,"!!""4!"" !" "     !=="  ",""   0"     ,  ,"' !!   " !,'  %%' !!0$! !!5     0!"  $0" ,"  ! " ," 4! , $,  4,"" 5    5 "" ," !$! 4  !    !5!"!'   !" !    ," ," 0" ,"" A (.'(&')//."42 "'!'&>3 "2 "'!'&* &/3 40

2 "'!'.(3 $0!$, ''5!" !2 "'!'.)-..3 4" '' 4$!"$$"2 "'!'.?-.63  ,"2 "'!'.*3 """2 "'!'./-?%3 " """2 "'!'?&->.3 !!!4!$0!," $$! """!"002 "'!'))/ )%)-)%%3  ''=!"2 " '!')?&-)?.3 ''=!"2 "'!')?>3  ''!!"00"" 4"2 "'!'%(?-%(*3  ''=!"2 "'!'%)%3'     $$0" ," " ! "  $!" 4"2 "'!'66-6/3 (.'(&')//."42 "'!'*(3 !!! 4! $0!," 4 ," 2  " '!' )%(3   '' =!" 2  " '!' )%/3   ''=!"2 "'!')&(3 @''=!"2 "'!')&)3  ' ' =!"2 "'!')&%3 '-''=!"2 "'!')&&3  %&'4!"=!2 "'!')%/-)&&305  ''$ "!""! $$! !!""! !"' 4!" ''=!2 "'!')?&-)?.3!!$ ''$ 0$$,,! $"!! ! '- 040 $ ''! 5!!"$"! ''$! 5$! = ''$! ,!"4!"44' $0!  !$ '' ,  ,  !"' " ! 40 '' ' ''=!!2 "'!')?>34;;" ''4!%(()-%((%  ""!D5$ "- ==!4 )(! '-=40$"!!! ;!"  ''!!"$,'" '0 ''! !!  '''  ''=!2 "'!'%)%3!!"40 ''  ''$,!"$0 $$"  ''0  !!' '-!!45!""$ !"!" 5 !!!"" ' 

 *

 !5   !" ,"   0!""   (.'(&')//.  '' "!",!'  4! "  =!  0 " "  ! " =" $, D  !! $, 0!"" " !" 2 " ,!$  !"$""3'4!"="" 40"  - %(()'-%((%''!D5$! !!! 40  "'!'.&4 ..$,"!%((%''   "$    )//6-%((('' 2  " '!' ?&->.3   ! D , $$"  4"5$" "!! ''! !"B<6.,'  4! " !!  ="" $, =!"! " !0!""$0"""!"" !' ''$0"" ''$40""$!!$!! "!" !!!!"40"!2 "'!').63'  %.'   " $"!! " $0" "! !$ !!" 2 3' =!!"  2 "'!').&-)..3 "! !!'

 !" 4!!5 " ! 04 !05$2 "'!'6*-*(3"!!$!!"'4"$2 "'!' -/)3!$"!""!!!" '' 

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

 / "'!'.)-.. )%($" ''$!"4"$,"0!""  4! $0""  "  !4!  $$ 0   $,'  " '!' .?-.6 $" """ !" !"" $,"!! 04 !05$!  ," "   ," !","'  %*' 0" =!!" 4"5 !   4!!5 !"     !"0  !5 0   $" 04'    %/'$!!"0!"""<& ! !"  0!$ " , 2''  ()'()'%((>3 !" ! 4! !!" !  " "!00!  " $!!"2-)//*30'  &(' 4!!5 !  ! !"  !! ,5!"  $0!,!' 4!!5005!" 00$"!"-)//*<>(!') * !!""'  4!!!!"!" 00$" !"""2-)//*<>(!') *3'   !05$"" 04 !"   !! "  ! ! !"00'  &)' "!!"<-"..% >&) >?) >?.  >?6!)4) >>* >6(!)'         #!   !$!