Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-07-8298/15 AI generated

2-07-8298/15 · Tartu Maakohus Jõgeva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-07-8298/15
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

                              !"#$!    #$ ! "%&''&       ( (

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-8298/15 · Tartu Maakohus Jõgeva kohtumaja:                               !"#$!    #$ ! "%&''&       ( (

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                              !"#$!    #$ ! "%&''&       ( (

()*+&"#$ !',  

  

    

  ---- ------ $+ ----- ------ , ---- ------  ! ! %#./ '&"            +&,0 ---- ------ 1"!"##% -----------2 &!"#$  -----------------------------------3 +&, & %, 1& % &30  %&%#"   +& ''& 14 %#"%56 ##  +& ''&2 &'5 !   ! 7 8 932 & #& ---- ------- & %, &#& "#$ ! "!" '& '&+ ((

(  # ,%0 -----------1& %(------3 1"!"##%-----------2 &!"#$ ------------------------3 ---- ------ 1"!"##% -----------2 &!"#$  ------------------------------- # , & & %,0 %#"  ##' &  1%#"%56 ##  %#  '/&2 &"#, .  :;5%!&. ( 8 !7

83    

    ( (

((2 ((

(      !!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! "



    #      " & & !# &*5 *!%,$& % !%&'&& '&"#$ ! '& & !"!!%& $  " %"'// '  $& % %! "!!%& . #.# # & ,# !& !& :  ./& ,##"!2 &"!!%&,# !&"#$  &$ !%$& %,*! !'& ( 6   !'' " %" &+&'& %! &  "& , '& & & !% &'&&  '& "#$ !&(%!&& "&'& & !"!!%& '&"   +"!!% *& %%%#"!'& %%(       <##&%*%"#$ !# !&&& %.& ## "&5!& ! +"# "#$ !&: ./& ,##"!  & # !& & "!  "/ & #'& '& ( &5! *%"&  $& %% " ,"! '& & !&2"!"&5!&& # & &&$& %'  ! +(<## &# *+!& &# !& & "! "!!! ' ##5!%"&5!&& '& (  #$! ! 0 $ % &%   ---- ------ &  ( :(

((  ! "#$ !& $+ ----- ------ , ---- ------  !   ! %# ./ '&"( +%!& "#$&  #  ---- ------ .== %! !% "#$ ! .##&2 &  ! ! % &' *+!   &' && "!!! !%    ! %# !! !&&# (------------ &' &! ',#% &'#& ==*'& !& * ! .  !% &' *'!&% &   & %( ' ------ ------- ! ' , # $+&, "&"' &.!!&, ==*'& !9 >(--- ------! -----------,&'------ ------! & &./  %# ' '  &' '&&----------(( </  % " #  "  !2

&+ #

 -------2 !"#$+ -------------------------------------------2'# 6&/ !%./ '*+!&!& $+&,&( +&, #  #   ,!! & $  !% ./  %  // !&" 

 " ## 2 "# ,%2  "!,%2 #  ./  %  // !&" $  !% + :



 " ## ( #   #  $  !% ./  % "#&"  !// !&"  "&"'&& ! !$ &: 7

" ## (    & '& %&& #  $+&,  &' & ----- ------- , ------ ------- ./  % & "!!!  " * %& & '* & & #%& 6& / !% "# , && ? .#,.#&+%&&---------------,-------------( ""## &5"# & #' % 2

&+ # (-------2!"#$+--------------------(#  ,!! &# $+&,$  !%  "!// !&": 

" ## 2"# ,%+87 

" ## (#  # $  !% "!" #&"# & #' %// !&"  "&"'&& ! !// !&&7 7

" ## ( +&,&  #  &%!& &' &,/ &! %#./ '&"(#   &+" %"2&  ----- ------- ! ' ./& $+&,& .!!&  '//  !% & # !%( ( (

8( "!  : ((

7(( #  $+&,& '//  !% "&"' & .!!& , ==*'& ! 9  >( #   &%2 &  $+&,*+! ! %#./ '&"&#& *& % !%, "&"!!!! %#$!""!!!  "##&!( +&,   & #   &5*+&  ' ,/& !% ! %# 2 %& #'  &' & &%!"! ./ ,   !  /$&// !"! , &'"*5' ! $## &+ "  ! #' "!"( +&, #  $!  !% ! %# '&   "!" #&  "# & #' % 2 !"#$+ -----------------( +&,   & .&" &'& "!!!' ! %#  :; # "# & #' % ( +&,  &#   &' &&%!,/ +&./ , "/ & !% /"&'// !&2 "! #&" !%! %#./ '&+(+&,$ %5 &'.## ./  !%"  !// !&"



" ## ,"# , &&6&/ !% "!// !&"7



" ## (+&,.!5"#$ !

 : '//  &".& 2&  &$" %" &'.## ./  !%---------------------"6! "  !// !( +&,.!5"#$ ! !  % &%-----------------!"  !9;9#1:;#3 #' "!" && "  ! ! %# ./ ,   + && & " % "  ! ' !  #( '! .!5$+&,"! ! %"  ! ' !# "# , &-----------,----- -------" %&%  +" % &&%!!& &"#' %#' "& "!'5"7;9#( ! %# '& *+!  *& %5 $+&, $+&  !%   "! &".&  # !&+  + 6 ! &+2&  ##'&'-------------&& "# ,( 

8( (

(( &  $+&, "#$ !& # !&2 '& & 2 &  ##5!5 -------------- "# & #' % ! %# # &'& 2 "!  && #  "# , & .##  '66%!%( +&, ##5 & %% &&   *!%& &% "#'.& &&  $& *!%&+( +&, *!5 "# , &  ----------./  % ! %#// !&/,'* ' 2'&"# 97" ## (+&, /& % *!%&!&% ( (

((" ,2"! & 2&  *!%&' & *+!"!"!&" # @A :+(      # ,% &% % ( 8(

(( "#$ !& " ,"!  !& $+&( # ,% $+ & !  ( # ,% #  &!"#$2 &  $+%!& & '&+ & #& *'" "# , .##  # & !% &&'/ " ! %( # ,% #  8( :(

(2 (# & & $+%!& "#$ !& & '&  &%'    % !% && "!!! "# & #' %2 &+ #  -------( # &  #  " !%"#' % &"! & '&&(&& * !&#&*'"$+%!& $!%'&"#

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

 8 /& %! %#./ '&&(------------,-------------./  % "#&% "  !%#% & %&6$#' %(</ A 7"#$& # ! %#.##./  %# 2'& ./ , #&" &%!,/ +& ./ '& "#

  !%2 "! ./  % #&"%  ! * !% "*" &%!,/ +&% ./ ,%( +&, #  ./  !% & "!  --------------------- "6 ! "  !2// !&+: 7

" ## ( "!"# !%"# & #' %// !# ./ '*+!& !  !&"#$& 7 7

" ## (+&,# ./  !% !! &'! !&2"!&%#  &%!&  !& &! %#!! !2' * !.!!%!5$+&,"! %#./ '&*+!&"#

 *+!./ % /& %  (# ,%.!%,/ $+/5 ' ,,!$!2"!"#$! &52& $+/5 ' ,/ '&".!!%!%!&%2,/ $+%! $!%' (  !&" $+&, /.!  !% *!%&& 1 &&   *!%& & %' & $& "#'.&  ## +3 & %"# ,% 7((

((2&  /.!  !% *!%& &' &2'&% ,#!% #&5 $+&, #' $+ !&"( && * ! &  "# ,% & % *!%&& "  !/ &%( # ,% .!% "#$ ! "#$! % $+&,  & ' *!%& '!! '&" $+%!& &"  & "! (  <##&% # &%"#$ ! $&# !& &+&' 2&  ! %2"-------------#*+! ./ % ! %#( +&,   & #   *+! ./ % ! %#  + "# , &   & ! %# ./ '&*+!.!!%!5(  #$! &52 &  $+&, *!& & #& .*$,& % !%  + &&5 , *..# !&  A 88 "#$& (  +&, *!%&.*$,& %!&"# 2& #'& ' &-----------,------------- ! ',# &' ==*'& !  +&&+#  *+!./ % &' &./  % ! %#(  ! #      "! .##  ( (

7( /,  !% ./ '*+!& !  !&  ' &5 ,/ + &%,#!%2'&.## &$&&#&%! 0----------(# ! !%----- ------2 &'./  % /"6&---------------2"&! ----------((    ! #    & ! .##  :( 7(

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

7($& %  :  : 82' 5! %! %#,'* & (+"#$!  $& % "#$&  !&5 + 6"",!$! ! % ! %# , ==*'& !( +"#$ ! $& % "#$&  !&5 *'"! ! %# , "#$  ! %2 " "! .!!%!5 ==*'& !& * ! *'! &   & & %2 "  # ./  %, 6.%'& * # 5,'& * !*+!  !%6.%' '  +" ,./  %,5( ----- ------ !  ----------( , ------ -------!  ----------(( ---- ------- .##  &  !% : ((

8((   "! &".&  # !&  ' &52 &  ---- --------#  !  !% ==*'&"# !9 > & 9((

8("! : ((

7(2,5

&+! & "* 5/,.###'&!"#$ /$&' "#

 /%1 9 32'! #  &  !%  "!&".& # !((

7(&&2&  ==*'& !9 ># '//  !%"!  : ((

9(1  3,  "!&".& # ! 7( (

9(&&2&  ==*'& !9 > # '//  !%"! : ((

((-----------&#&&  !%"'!% *& %&%&&2&  

 7 # !" ==*'& !------------! ',(&&+&#& *& % !%------------ ==*'& !---- -------! ',----------(( /$ ! &  !%  "!&".& # !& : ((

8(# ------------& & !% # & ==*'& ! (# ==*'& ! 9 > ------ ------- ! ' , ----------(( & ==*'& !&'// ' & *& %52& $+&,#8 >! !& ==*'& &  +&&+ *'& && %&&6.%'  && '(,#!2& ----------&# !% ==*'& ! *& %5 "  ! "#$ ! ( (

8( # ! &&2 &  ---- ------ #  '//  !% ------ ------- && "# ,"  + ---- ------- / & "#$&  /  && "# , "#$! ! ?  .%&  B$&'&  *5& .*%&  &'2 $## & &' && ( #$ ! $  +! ==*'& ! " & #&" !! !% &# % B$&'&  *5& .*%& &&  +./& $##%! ( ---- ------- / & "#$&  &'-------------6.%'&#&'  *& %% %#"!'& %%.&  /,'"& &"#$ 2'& ' &52& -------------.& # #  # !%#!& !! &'"!-----------#'( $ & & ' &52& . ,'

7(# ------------'*&'"!!/,'" !%.& #  " ## 1  93(  & & ' & #-------------& !&"'.& ##%'*&'"!!.& #  9 " ##  , #  #& ! 98  " ## ( #$ !   &  !6" ,#!2 &  ------ -------+"! && !&"#!! &'"!------------2& *& %----------- ------------6.%'&#&' (  A9 +"#$& " 5$+'& & !&"!!%.##2"&&"$,!"# ! &$ (#$! ,/ $+ $!%' 2&&+ !&5'& & !"!!%,/ $+&," %(  #$!# !& &+&'&,!$ %!5A %& 8:828:728:9+2 2:28,28:28:288 +288 (    %&''& "#$ ! "