Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-21155/14 AI generated

2-05-21155/14 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-05-21155/14
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-21155/14 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               

       

      !"!      #$%#$%$&&'()  

   $*&+*$##++  

  , -.    ! ) #/+#01   ..! #/+#01  2!"),   

!$$%##%$&&0!! $*&+*$##++       

 .!3   

    $$%##%$&&'()          .!4,566666666666 !5 666666666 77*77 !*(89  !" .  ,  ,,! ,   !!  , -. 4,5 66666666666 !5 66666666 666 777*77 9!")! " !%    ! "     ##! !#$$%   

!#&$'&# ''(  ! #! )( *  +  ,   

       #-$../   0   ! .!      ,   !   (

 *  +  , 

       "    1 #'$ 2"     

 "

3

  $ $409  !       ,  0             .$ ,(        ( 

    4     ,( 

  55            !   6 %-   !'         ( 4          !      4    0       

  !  !*    (  

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

"$$%##%$&&0!4!:$*:19, ,-.  ")!! ,-.8 $'&//:% !!!!3$$%##%$&&$) 4!%%'9,!,,!  3! ,!!%! !8,!!!!3)!=!!  !),!,),!"=*!!! 8!,"!%  8,3 ! = !!     )! !,%   ! !  ) =*

  / /409 !! ", !),3 = !!  4!%%+09%     , -. )%   !),!   8!, ! ., .., $$%##%$&&$ ! !8,3! !24 AB#'+%#9  ! )",".4!%%$0';++09%  ,-. = !! !  "! !! , ! $$%##%$&&$ !  .! )", ,,"!,!,!), = !!"),"!2)!"!%!2)!"  !!"!!2)! !!)!"8!3=!!.!),4#/+#01 9 "". !  !   " !  ! ! !  ) =* !! 2!"!!8,!% = !!     !  .! )! "" "!, !  "@  "  !  ,, =* ! 4! $09 "  ! )!! AB/&")!! 8 ! !2)!,4 AB#'+9% ?!  .!  ! "!"  , !),3 !  !, )!!4!'9%=!!.! $&&+,!,!4!$'9" !  !3   !  ,"! 8!!  "!!,     ! 8! !!!, ,%

)!!!3! !, !0&/0;'< ;#&&& !!" !8!  &#%&1%$&&/ "!!!8! !!"   ..!  ), "" 4! '9% !  . !),, ! ) ., )  )..,% ! )!!)!".)!!%!3 ,,%  !*,     ,0         .! 4! 9 " .!3 4! 1/*1;9 ,! !!! !8 !% .!.3!2!,"!! ! !" 8!! ,"!% 3 .) ,! ! !!  3)! ,  ,  ! "!)" ,!"!)"% ! 8,! .,..,$$%##%$&&$! !8,3! !=*   ! )",".% .!3!2,!,!), .!),!, !.!.%

88   ! 8, !   )!! 2 !  !%  .  )"!,  !   !! 2)!" . .,, "   "% .!3"!! !,!!!!),!!!!   ) !,% ? ) !  ! = !! !      !),%  ,"  !  , -. !!% "! 883 .! 8!! 8! , ! !   ! )   8 8,%  , -. " ! .!3 4! #&$*#&09 , ! !!, 3  .) ,"!  !3 8!! ,"!% .! !!  , -.)),!!"!.!,..!. ,!8! !8,!,%=!!!)!!.,, !8!" !  !! ,! ) , !  "  ", , -. !% 8!! . )!, !! ! , -. =* !!   )!   ! 3 ) !8!"!!% ,-.".!!8!,%,! !!  , -. ) !, !)  )  !

  ; ;409 !8!    )"!, )) .% !!  !  ! !" .!!!!8!"!%!,)!,=!!! !!!)"!,.)),!8!!!"!)!8!"! .!%!!,!),,!,, ,"!8,   $$%##%$&&$ . )""% !!     >,  ,, !!  "8 !  . !8!" 2  ) 8388" .,, ," )" )! !8!"% ., 8, , -. !! !"!,""!%8!.!, !8!"")!! ,-.=*!!%       

!! 8.!3!,,% !! )!!"! $$%##%$&&$ "!! .!   ,"!% ! " "!! =!! ! . C.!.8!  !  .%"!)!!!! "!!,. ."8!,""! 2,,%     ,0   

3!"!!!3!2!,"!)"," !)!!     )"  ! !"   " !" !  83!","!%     , ,,   .!  $$%##%$&&$ )"!, .! 4. % 9 !! !  !! !, .  ,,  ""#/+#01 ..!""#/+#01% 

)!3.!38!!"3)!,, "!)"",3)!!"%   @! .! ! )!!! 4 A B /&9 ! !% ! .) ,! !  !  ! = !! % !  !=*!!!!)24!%%$0.% 9",!3 ,)!! AB/&")!!% 8 ! ! AB#'+ 82)!,%?!.!!"!",!),3!  !,)!!4!%%'9% 

!"!,$$%##%$&&$  !  )"!,.!4.% 9)!!4!%%'9% 

AB/& 8."3!!!8!"!!!3, !)"!!!!")!!%  !!!,!),,!!  ,$$%##%$&&$" !",!$$%##%$&&$!!% ,"!!! .!)"!.4.%  AB/10%#9"!!   !!!!,)!",=!!%.,3 , $$%##%$&&$ "!!,   ,"! 4. %  !%%'9 )!!%

  + +409

!$$%##%$&&$)",.,. AB/10%# 8% 

AB/10%#!!3.24, 9,"! 4 9""),! 49 !3!"" """)!!"" "%  ?!.,3,!!! $$%##%$&&$.4.%% !%%'9 8! ."!!,"",,,%  A  .!3 8, ! "  !,   "! , .)  3) 8,,.,$$%##%$&&$..,! !8,3! ! =!!!   )",!.%!!!, "! ,! ! .!  !%  )!3  .!3 8!!!),"! 8,! !2)!"! AB#'+ 8%

AB#'+%#!)3"), )"!,.2)!! ) !  ! "  !3  ) "%  )!3.!38!!..!)"!,  "!=B''%/ 8!2)!""!"!, "% 

  . = !! #1%&+%$&&0   "   !!, = !! ! " , -.  "22,! !  ) .! 4!%%+09 !!  ,-.!=*!!$&&$%,!"3% )""#/+#01,88!),!!! !!,=!!"$&%&'%$&&+ =!!)3%! $$%##%$&&+ )"!, .! ! ) 40&/0;' <  ;#&&& 9 !"!% 8.88        ! = !! #1%&+%$&&0   ! ! ,-.2%!#/+#01%2 .)) , ! ! 3   , -. .))! "" #/+#01   ..! "" #/+#01   . "!!,  !  8!! ,-.!,..!""#/+#01%  8 ""!, ".)!%!"" ! ,  . !   8 "" ! !8!" , .!%8!,!!.!.,3,2! ,!, $$%##%$&&+ .  4. % 9    !   !  ,  "!!!,!=!! )!!, AB#0;9 !!!,,88,!),,!!  ! !!2)!,4 AB#'+9!3 8!!,"!% 

!!!"!,! !8!"!,!,", B $ %# !3 ! , " "!!8!  "   )!, !"! ,! )!"! &#%&#%$&&0 ,,  !, !"!,!8!!!!%  B*,0&%# :0#%#!3!, 8!!.!3 ," "!!!2!","! 8!" ,% 

  0409 .!3 . .! 4! 9 2!, !" !,% !   " !" ! ,, )3, "" +&&&  4!%%'&9% .!3 !" ! !  ) "" #+&&&  4!%%1+9% ) ,  $ !!)!,!$:&&&&""#;$+&%!  .!3!"!,)'+&)"%   !!3 .! " !"  .!"! !, 2!"! ""$&&&&% 3!.) ,!,  ," ,   .! !  2!"  #1$+& 4+&&&  )3,  #;$+&)!9% !    B #+& %# .%#  %/  ), B #/  ,"! $1%#$%$&&0"88%0:!!!,)!!,)"!!,'+& !!"!%    ,!!"B*,!0+;0+'%#.%#0'&%# 0'#%     

  !"!