Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-03-630/8 AI generated

2-03-630/8 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-03-630/8
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-03-630/8 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

     

        !"  #!  !$ !   

            %&'&%'%(()*+$ 

    %,(-,.-( 

   ''  ''  '' $ "  ''''$"      

%-'(-'%((.          

 ''''/!!0        -('&('%(()              /!!1 &2 '' 3" 44444444444  ! 4444444 5,55  $ ! ",  "6  !/!"$!7$8 /!!1 -2 '' 3" 44444444444  ! 4444 55,55  $ ! ",  "6  !/!"$!7$8 /!!1%2''3"44444444444  ! 4444444 5,55  !!6  !/! " $!7$8

1 '' 3" 44444444444  !444444455,55 $! ", "68 !  ' ' 3" 44444444444  44444444455,55 !!6    !"  ##   # # $              %&#'&#%''(  #    &' ''''!"!9!"' %' '' ! !" $9!+ !""' ',! + $9! ''  !"3+0!"6&%:(3; "$;"6',!+$9!

 % ''  !" 3+0!"6  &%:(3;"$;"6'         /! $+0 " 0

! -( /9$ !  ! 9 !  "  /9 $  <<"   $!! $' $!!"36=%&>!-! $+0 !! !   !"  " $!"  ! ; $""$"$"!'

$!  = .)& ! : !0 0 9"    $0   !'

! ! !     +  !" !!'        ) * "   )    &'(.'&&'%((-"''3"/"&6''3"/"%6$ !$!"3 "'!&,-6''3"/"6$ !!/!" "#''(-'&%'&??.!"; ''9$!55$ ";!"'  $!"!(?'(>'%((-'' !";3 @6'! "55'9$!'"''/9"/<<""";  ;!$$! @'/+!'%A'(?'%((-$+"; !''#9"$/""" #''! "9 @, ''55$/9'+"  $/!(-'&%'&??.&A>?A'#9"#''$  &>'(?'&???' @ '  ! &??.' ! ' ;  55 ' 9$! 3" '6 ";!'  "!!#'' @! "!";!!$ '$+";; !!$+/9""'#9$ /"";!55'9$! @,'#9'' @ !+;!-:'  "!"" #'''";!!/$$" "#''/9""'$"#''' ''&?'(%'%((% @,'A%$$$+;!" 0!'  $!" "" " /9" 3#96 = ?A  $!" ;!" "3@6=?%!"" #''!(-'&%'&??."B!!" 0+ "!"/$! "!" $99" !" " /$ !   "  $! 

 - /$"/$$ /$$!" /$$+0/!'  %'!$&%"3 "'!%?,-(6  !"/!9"' 

!/9"$#''! @"/$ '' 553/ @''556'#''"+0$ $(:'(.'&?>. %,-:'/<<"/!$!"/9"'!"! + @''55$!$!3 6'  -'%A'(-'%((:''3"/"-6$!$!"3 "'! &&>,&&?6'' 36$  !!/!"#''(-'&%'&??. ! @, ''9$!55$";!"'!" /!$9!+!'  $!" !  #'' (-'&%'&??. !! +" "  !! /9"!"" @, ''55'&>'(?'&???#'''%((A' /!!!$!"/9"$$+'  !  /9+ #'' $!' %A'(:'%((A   ! $!" /9" $$+'#'' /9"!!!$! !"#'' @ ''55$ ! @' $!""-#9=?A @=?%'  A'!$3 "'!&-&,&-%6-"' 

 !  @ ' 3' 55  " '6  ! ;! %('&&'%((& ;!" ' "  ! !! 9" "  !'  $ #'' ! "/$ ''55'''!'55'$ !'';!#',!'  0/!"!55 /!C'55'55'#!9 ;";" !;!!;;9!!!  +'  "  ' 55 @ ' $! $  $ (:'(.'&?>.!%,-:!";""#''!''' "   "/$ ' $$! !! !//!    #',' #! $   ''  !! !!    ' ''  /""!'  :'$(-'(.'%((:993 "'!'&&-,&&A6!"&% $"+"-$ "+";!'  .' $  &:'(>'%((: 99 3  " '!' &A-6  ! $ +"!"/!!' '3"/"!6'     )' %-'(-'%((.3 "'!'&?A,&?>69& %- $"!"'!& !% !-+!"$9!%:(('

 A  >'  !  ! $"!   #'' ! "     ! @

D3;;" @'6!!!! @,' "!! " @,  !" " #'' /!  "     !' #''  /9"""""""; ''55 55 !   !    /! /9"$" "  "  " '  ?'#!$!$"! #''/9""$ !";!'  !"   "   !!  "   #'' /"  " !!!$ @, '!!!$+/9"!' !$+/9"!/"#''$!" !!!0 ";!$!+!! @,!" !$+!'   $ 36 $ (:'(.'&?>.  90   #'' /" "  " "/$ '     /$ ' !    "/$"99"' 

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

 : 9!$;"$+"!(&'&&'&??A ';-:;/! '"!"'  &A' 9" ;-:#''! /!+""'#9;" ;"''"+"$""""'!&> %(,%% &:A,&:. &>:'  &:'$#''&?'&%'&??)$!"! "" ;-A  "&??)'!!"'9!" !!" !! @ ''9$55 $!!!"!'  &.'#''/9"$ !"'"!#''! !"   ! ;  55 !!  !!   ! !  " !;!55$$$'!"$!@#9'  &)'&-+9!" /"0$"!9$!" 2 &6"!!'!! (.'(>'%((A&$" @, '' %6  #'' /9" $  /9$!' "  "   #'' /9$! $/9";-A$+'  &>' +" "! $+  $ @ ' &%'&%'&??) $$+,;!"' !!"!'"$$$$+,;!" A%' %!!0C'!&> .)'9" 0$ $+'             &?'%03 "'!%>6'  %('   ! $ 3  " '! -(,-&6 /! 9 0 !"  ' 

!!!+"+""" "!0"/9"' $36 $(:'(.'&?>.-''$"!"'9!$! !!"";!" $'"$!+/ #''/9'  %&'!!/!!0"'        %%'&-""9"0"'"/!  ! $9! + !"  " '!' &)) $ !"   !! "!"!""!! /!!0!"!+$ -+0!"-(((/!!'  %-'%""/!!0$9"' 

 . %A'  9 $ "" "!  /! ! &  ! - $9! + /!!+0!"%:(('  %:'!!!"'     $)    %.'



  $" $! !"  !" 9 !!"  !0   /!!0 $9"   !   ;'  %)' 90 /= .:A!'.!$!/+"'

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

 ) -%'  " '!' &:. +" !!    #',! ! $+!$ 3!! 6 !"/"0#''! @, $/"' @/!"+" !!"!""!3'!'%( .- &:.6  90  " ! ;!"+!  +"  $!  " +"39 "'!'&:.$/'%$9" !!" $$$+,;!"! !!!"C "'!' )(6 !""";! @3"/$6!'  --'$ $(:'(.'&?>.3 "'!'-&6$";+" !!!  "   9  + "   !"'"$!;!!9"; " #'' "!!90#''!!"/$ '  "!'  -A' /!!0$"!" !! 9" /"0$"!2 ' "!!'   !  ! $"!   " !!  !     @, ' 0""$9"!9/'

 !0       /""  "+  ;0$9"#''"$"!9'  0' #''/9"$/9$!'    + 9"   $"!  ! !!   #'' /9" $ #'' /9$! '&>'(?'&???' #9"$$!"#9=-!'% !!!/9"$ /9"/9$'/9"$/9$+9" #''/9$ $0!"+"!3'!'&&69  !!!#''/9$/""" 9"' /!!0$9"!"!/+"!!! "'  -:'0""!!! +""!$$+" @ ' >((%&>)> &%'&%'&??)$$+,;!" "!!" !' $9"! "0 "'!')( !!%('&&'%((& !!/!" !"""!"$"!!"$;!!' 0$""!!! ";!!$$$+,;!"' A% "9" !! !!0' 90 9"9',"$$+,;!" ' A%  !! /!   !""      ! "  '  -.'  /!!0 990 !"   /  $! $+ $""$9&%+"+/" /9"!0'

 $9""  /! " +" $"! $+! $!  !"9'  

 >  -)'$!!"9!"""=- ! !"  9!$ " + 3''  (&'(&'%((.6 !" ! /! !!" !  " "!99!  " $!!"3,&??>69'  ->' /!!0 /!"  &   - $9! + ! !!" A&:.&(((/!!0!"!+$& %&->-'

!&-"$!"!  " '!' &)) $! !" !  !!  !$! !""!' -/!!+0!""-(((3  "'!'>>6'  /!!0990!" 99$"&-!",&??> =.(!'& >!!"""'  -?'/!$!3 "'!'-& >&69!"  %:((   &   - "' 0! ! !" $ $ %:((3 "'!'-%6' ,&??> = .( !'&  >  = .& !'& /'% !! !0  ! !"!   !0!&!-$9!+!" !!&%:( '  A('%!!"!"3 "'!'>(6'  A&' "!!"=,"AA% .-& .:& .:A  .:)!&/& ..> .)(!&'           #!   !$!