Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-07-40151/16 AI generated

2-07-40151/16 · Tartu Maakohus Jõgeva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-07-40151/16
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

 '7'8 !"04+"$$!"3$#-,"%"#!"0 !"0&"3$#'!"0 $  "!"#0 "! - % %$$&$&  ' !"( +$- ,2"$& $" &$ *"" & " ,*"%&" 29 $& ,2&- 0 ! &" $ "!$3 %"# & "0 "!#& " ! & $# &9 $&$ $%#"!" ( +$-!"%$#& $#9-&$!,$  %*" &"#-$"&$4&$9" #(  +$-&! & 0&"  9$+.......'((( 4!#"!#&9  ....... .....7& ''80.... .....$%&9 "9$&$..... ......$"&$7&'8( +$- " $&$  !,!$%4,""  %% !" (  -!$ "!#9&+*$!#"0%"&&" $ $& $%>> !$ %" $&655!"!$ ($&# "&%!$30$ -&!&$%  " $&$0%" ,*"%&#3$&"  #(   0&&$ "!#-"!!!#+#*$!#$"#&$"30$+"&$3&## &" $& ( %*"  ,2&- $&"  "+    : !"   ( &%%22  !"!+ +!-2$&$ !$&-  $$ (  .... .....! &$"#!#0 $  -&#0 $  $" &$ ..... ...... 3"&+"&"!$ "  !"!+ &9 $+ $# 9#,#0 ! $!#&"$   -&#$ 0 %"  ,*"%&#3 -2 $&" $ ,2&- %*" %(..... ....$%4 "&$%" $&"!!" 0$.... ......$" &$(9 $- " ,#%" "!!" "#%*&$%#9&$#(  -&0 $ .... .... $" &$ &9 $ ..... ...... 3"&+"&"!$ " 0 $"  && &  $&" $ ,2&-%*" % -2%" $ ( $ ,&#%" $+ $!!  " ! &9 $ 4!!"" !#0  !$3%"%$4&+!$,  2"$&",!$%&",  &9 $$$ 0 ,#,   9! #&9 $4&&9"#%" $ %$"& $&( 9 $$$ ! #&" $%%*&$%#,!$%#(9 $"&!#" !#$$+$%" $ -&,*"%$&"!$!#%% $"  $&&$ 0  ,"3..... .....%"  ,*"%"$0 $&&" $    $ $$  , ,# 2"$& %22& ,!$%#( 9 $ *"+ " " $ $&&$+0 "     0$4 ,!$%$ $"9$%  "2"%(  .... .... ! 9"#!# &&" $   -&0 $ &9 $& ..... ....... ! &$%  9"" , 4&&9"#%"!$!"!+ $$*&$ -2$&" ,2&-%*" %0..... ......."34&& 9"##$%3" ?.... .....(  &$"30$!#-&$"&$*$!##&9 $9"" , " $&$1;5&+59%*$ 0%" ,*"%&# -2$&" $,2&-%*" %,*" $&&$   ,2$!##( +$- ! &9 $&# 9 $& !"!+ $% " $&$  ! ,!$%4,""   !"  0 ,!$%4,""  $"  "!#& " 9"## 9"" ,  " $&$  ,!$%4,"" $ ,2&-% %" $+ %"$ $# &9 $ 4&&9"#%" $ ( ?.... ...... " $&$$"&$*$!#$"#$ "#0+$-!,2"!#0$?.... ...... 9& $" &$ 9"" , ..... ...... 4&&9"#%" $ (  %  $"   ?.... ...... " $&$ %# *"+ &" 2$!# 0 ! &9 $ ..... ........ 9#3 ?.... ....... $# $  &$!$, $ ( &"% $&&$ 0 $ ?.... ..... ! 3"$&  &9 $ $%+09#3&  ..... .......4&&9"##(  +$- ! &9 $ & $  !"%$# 4&$  !"  ( +$- " !+"& !#"  4& "0$&$ !* $&" $,2&-%*" %" $+ %% :!" (  %*" 3 $&" $ ,2&- %%  : !"   ( &%%22 0 ! +$- "!# 0 $  $&&" $  %22 $&" $ %" $&!&9 $4&&9"#%"!$,*"%&"(  &" %*" $ $,2&- *& 1;+'5&+&$ +"$ "%" $ :(6(((  +$- &$  $&" $ ,2&-%*" %"  + "&,& 4$   $$  &$  :(6(5( %% !"(1;&+!2$3$$0$ ,*"3+$-!*#$&%*" $&" $

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-40151/16 · Tartu Maakohus Jõgeva kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

       

            !" "#$"%%$&      '((()*+$,%-  

     

  .... .....+".... ...., $&" $!*#$           +$-/ .... .....0 " "#............0 $& ..........................  -/ ....

..... " "# ............ $& ............................. $ "!#-,!#$#,!12$&0#,#"34!)$0"" 3 &"!!   

    5(06((0((0(-(((         !  "# $  "%%%%%%%%%%%%   %%%%%%%%%%%   %%%% %%%%%%%%   %%%%%%%%%%%  &  %%%%% %%%%%%%   %%%%%%%%%%% '&    ()    +*!*,!-.! %%%%%%%%%%%%%#       /    #  &  & 

##/ #        $&    #   &$  / '    $   $&&      #$&   ! "# $  "%%%% %%%%%%%   %%%%%%%%%%%   %%%% %%%%%%%   %%%%%%%%%%%  &  %%%%% %%%%%%%%   %%%%%%%%%%% '&       -)!*0!-.! -)!*1!-.!  () !  

 7'8       #"%%%%%%%%! $!$&  &"!$ ,*"3 !*#  - &$!#!# $ "%$ $  %$ & %$!$& &#$ &"  "!#& %22%" &$!#"  " &#,&#$99 "!& $- $& $&'92$,- &0 &$ &#$- $$#&$!#"-* %" $ ( 4,", %% "!#& $+$%" $ ,&#  $ " $  - %$!$&$!# $ "%$ $  %$ &$( ,&# $&$&"  $%$!$& &#$!"%$""!"!+& "#*$!#,##%$!#"#         $&$ ,*"3 $ "# 9$&& "!$3 $  "!+!!&$ 7 &$," ! 0 8 ' 92$,- &&$   $2$"%$%" $ ( $3 ,*"# $&$!##"-&" %$!$& $ 0 "$3 $ $"&$ $&&$&$!#%" " !+"&(   ,  /  2   .... ..... $ "   $ +" .... .... ,  !*#$+ %*"  ,2&- ....

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

....&9 $..... ......" !! #$#4&&9"#%(1;5&+ $& " ,!$% $" 2"# &9 $ 4&&9"#%"    ,3&"&0 %*" 3   $" $ ,!$% !*#$&,2&-$&" $$" $,!$%  - %9+,"&*"$ $&%22 $$&"  &9 $&$ "!#&  "+" $ $& !0 &2#$  %%+" ,!$% ,&" $  $" !#"  - &9 $ ,-# $ ( &" $ &%%22 ! 1 ; 5 &+   $& < $",  %""!"%%9&+%22 0 ( : !"  ( +$- ! &$!# $&" $ ,2&-%*" %"  %% !" 0%"&&$   9$&$&% %,%" 2$%3$ 5 !"(   +$- ! !"%$!# 9- & $  "+    &&-2+!$,/ "  !"0 $$!"!+   !"0 "!$!$"  %" $   5 !"0 %3""&$&$=!" ,$ 

 '7'8 !"04+"$$!"3$#-,"%"#!"0 !"0&"3$#'!"0 $  "!"#0 "! - % %$$&$&  ' !"( +$- ,2"$& $" &$ *"" & " ,*"%&" 29 $& ,2&- 0 ! &" $ "!$3 %"# & "0 "!#& " ! & $# &9 $&$ $%#"!" ( +$-!"%$#& $#9-&$!,$  %*" &"#-$"&$4&$9" #(  +$-&! & 0&"  9$+.......'((( 4!#"!#&9  ....... .....7& ''80.... .....$%&9 "9$&$..... ......$"&$7&'8( +$- " $&$  !,!$%4,""  %% !" (  -!$ "!#9&+*$!#"0%"&&" $ $& $%>> !$ %" $&655!"!$ ($&# "&%!$30$ -&!&$%  " $&$0%" ,*"%&#3$&"  #(   0&&$ "!#-"!!!#+#*$!#$"#&$"30$+"&$3&## &" $& ( %*"  ,2&- $&"  "+    : !"   ( &%%22  !"!+ +!-2$&$ !$&-  $$ (  .... .....! &$"#!#0 $  -&#0 $  $" &$ ..... ...... 3"&+"&"!$ "  !"!+ &9 $+ $# 9#,#0 ! $!#&"$   -&#$ 0 %"  ,*"%&#3 -2 $&" $ ,2&- %*" %(..... ....$%4 "&$%" $&"!!" 0$.... ......$" &$(9 $- " ,#%" "!!" "#%*&$%#9&$#(  -&0 $ .... .... $" &$ &9 $ ..... ...... 3"&+"&"!$ " 0 $"  && &  $&" $ ,2&-%*" % -2%" $ ( $ ,&#%" $+ $!!  " ! &9 $ 4!!"" !#0  !$3%"%$4&+!$,  2"$&",!$%&",  &9 $$$ 0 ,#,   9! #&9 $4&&9"#%" $ %$"& $&( 9 $$$ ! #&" $%%*&$%#,!$%#(9 $"&!#" !#$$+$%" $ -&,*"%$&"!$!#%% $"  $&&$ 0  ,"3..... .....%"  ,*"%"$0 $&&" $    $ $$  , ,# 2"$& %22& ,!$%#( 9 $ *"+ " " $ $&&$+0 "     0$4 ,!$%$ $"9$%  "2"%(  .... .... ! 9"#!# &&" $   -&0 $ &9 $& ..... ....... ! &$%  9"" , 4&&9"#%"!$!"!+ $$*&$ -2$&" ,2&-%*" %0..... ......."34&& 9"##$%3" ?.... .....(  &$"30$!#-&$"&$*$!##&9 $9"" , " $&$1;5&+59%*$ 0%" ,*"%&# -2$&" $,2&-%*" %,*" $&&$   ,2$!##( +$- ! &9 $&# 9 $& !"!+ $% " $&$  ! ,!$%4,""   !"  0 ,!$%4,""  $"  "!#& " 9"## 9"" ,  " $&$  ,!$%4,"" $ ,2&-% %" $+ %"$ $# &9 $ 4&&9"#%" $ ( ?.... ...... " $&$$"&$*$!#$"#$ "#0+$-!,2"!#0$?.... ...... 9& $" &$ 9"" , ..... ...... 4&&9"#%" $ (  %  $"   ?.... ...... " $&$ %# *"+ &" 2$!# 0 ! &9 $ ..... ........ 9#3 ?.... ....... $# $  &$!$, $ ( &"% $&&$ 0 $ ?.... ..... ! 3"$&  &9 $ $%+09#3&  ..... .......4&&9"##(  +$- ! &9 $ & $  !"%$# 4&$  !"  ( +$- " !+"& !#"  4& "0$&$ !* $&" $,2&-%*" %" $+ %% :!" (  %*" 3 $&" $ ,2&- %%  : !"   ( &%%22 0 ! +$- "!# 0 $  $&&" $  %22 $&" $ %" $&!&9 $4&&9"#%"!$,*"%&"(  &" %*" $ $,2&- *& 1;+'5&+&$ +"$ "%" $ :(6(((  +$- &$  $&" $ ,2&-%*" %"  + "&,& 4$   $$  &$  :(6(5( %% !"(1;&+!2$3$$0$ ,*"3+$-!*#$&%*" $&" $

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