Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-04-742/14 AI generated

2-04-742/14 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-04-742/14
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-04-742/14 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

     

        !"    !# !   

            $%&$'&'(()*+# 

    ',(-,)-' 

   !   "! ! # " +  +#!"  "! !  !  # "! " !.#      ", (/&()&'((0#!',$$($1(-          

 !2!!3        ')&$$&'(()              2!!14 !  5" 66666666666  !  666666666 77  !, *8#! ", "9:

14 "! ! 5" 66666666666  !  666666666 77,7  !, *8# ! ",  "9  !2! " #""# #: ! 4 * ! 5" 66666666666  ! 666666666 77,7  !, *8#! ", "9: !4!!5"66666666666  ! 666666666 77,7  !,*8# ! ",  "9    !"       #$%#&%'##(            )        %    $& !  !" ! 8 !"& '& "! ! !" ! !"" !!  ! ! + #8! "!

 ' !  2!!! " !" 5+3!"9 .# -$;( 5!."!."9& ;& *&&&&!"8"""&         2! #+3 " 3

! ;( 28# !  ! 8 !  "  28 #  <<"   #!! #& #!!"59='$>!;! #+3 !! !   !"  " #!"  ! . #""#"#"!&

#!  = /)$ ! 0 !3 3 8"    #3   !&

! ! !     +  !" !!&       * + "   *    $& '0&(/&'((-  !  5"2"  9 ",  ! #!"5 "&!'9"!!5"2"9# !!2!" .##8#"#!""# &  #!" !  2!"   66666666 77 !,*8#! "& (/&($&'((- !   ?  " !# # # "#!&  2"  # 3"!&  #  @ =,"! )0 !&0  >%  A##8  ! " = $$ ! ' !2!&  '&#"!!#5 "&!$),$>9!#& 

 ! !!  '((-&   ,   ! 2 &  2!  ! !  "  " #2!#!!!2.!& , 

 <<" 2" !#  " # "#  " !"" 2 "2#"#!""&!2 !!<<!"2! "!"!!&+!"#288 !&!!!#!&." "      2!"" .#++& !   !!2!&!2#8!#" " !"& "8! ;"#!" 8#"& <<"# !!#""$%%),$%%>&&!!! 88"!.!!<<##&2!"8 #" "#!"&#2+"! !2"3# ""+!"&".##"  +3!& 

 ; ;&$$&(;&'((0! ", !#!"5 "&!&;',;;9 # !!2!!#8!+!"'-/> 00&  #!"!6666666677!,*8#!#-,!!  & !"  5  79   &   " . "  .##8 " !"& !  "  %>)- '(   !!'-/> 00 &B 23"&  -& ",  $$&(;&'((0 88 5  " &!& --9 !"  !" " . !&  0&#"!!#5 "&!/)9!#&

!!!"+""&     /& ",   (/&()&'((0  5  " &!& %0,%>9 8    # ##   #  " !"   #!"!!!+#8!;$$ $(&  )&  "  "" 59 = $$ !&$ 2&$  !&;  = $ !&$  '  +" 5 @9 = )'  )0  #+!+" 5 @9 = $;% 8!&   ! !   !   && .! +"   !"#!+""##!&+"

&&#8" '>2!"""!#"&!  &&  && .! +"   " !" +!3"  #" #8!####3 #!+!&!"  !"28!+ 3###! 8+!! #8!!" " !+""#+"&2!#!..! #&  +  #8"   ! 2"3  ."  "&  !"     ! " + "     +   #   # # !8 !83  & !! !#!8!"&  >& @ = )' !#! #!"#"  #" "  #,  !. .!  ##" .!  " ! & ! " +" 8#! ! ! !,  # "  +!3& !!! ! !3 !  !"  +!3!!&!" +"!""2!! " .  >%- -(  ! 2   !!   ""B''; /(&A!88"!!" +""   " !" "    2! "  8!!!38!"&  %&!"!.#&!" !+"#" !!!" !,*8##!!;0(&2!!"+"5 "&!&>), >>9 2+! 8!"      " "  #"    "  ! 52!"9  "  !&     #!

 - !!88"!!3#8!+!>) 0(5$1-;0( 9&  ,)   * + "    $(&2!32!!35 "&!>,%9."  !!8!"!"&  3!##8" .##8!#!"   !"  ! . +"   " "& "  3 .     .!!" 3 .!!    3"!  33#&  8 8!2  !"   ##  !2+!#2! !""" +  3" !83   !#" "  !! "   # # !<<& +" !!!!!" !8" !!"<"!! #"!&      "  +    $$&#"!!#5 "&!$$93!#& 

! &&!#!"  "    !"  #8!#& "   ! '(($, '((' 83!"""&C3!"##"!! '((-&!& #  ! 8"" " <<"     #+ 3 ! !2<"&     

    $'&  $-&(0&'((/5 "&!&'/,;$9. ",  (/&()&'((0    !! 8   !"    !"  6666666677!,*8#!#!.##8 ! !#  666666666 77,7 !,*8# ##  " .##8 !# #  & A!88"  8    &  $;&  #!!! $/&$$&'((/  5  " &! 0(,009 . 

$)&(0&'((/!"!" "  ." ! !!83#& 8 $-&(0&'((/ !!8 #"!"!!.#&                 )        $-&   '(&(%&'(() 88 5  " &!& %$,%;9   ! !!!#+"!"2!!*&&5"2" !$#+!"""9&&5"2"!'#+!"" "9&

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

 / #8 #"# "! "!#!"& !32!+2""#3"#5=$$!& ;  @=)'!&09&  '-&   + !8"  = $$ 8&  = $$ !&$ 2&$ 8 2++!"3 @=)'!&;&.!!""!!  @ = $;%  " " !"!! "!#" 3+!!"!&  '0&3!#! ##!2! ""& !"!"5 "&!&'/9 #"!"<<" " !"+!! #! !83&  '/& 3!!8!2!!8#!"#!" !!"#!2++!& @ = )' !& ; 83   !  + . " #+"     & @=)'!&-!!+8!#!" +! "#+3!!+"8! #!!.##+"!!""&

#! @=)'!&0!++"!! " !#  #!"    ##! +  #"!& "2#".82++ !+" +&  "##! @=)'!&-+& !++!!""## +"!!!!"!"&  

')&#!!"8!"""=; ! !"  8!# " + 5&&  ($&($&'((/9 !" ! 2! !!" !  " "!88!  " #!!"5,$%%>98&  '>&2!!8!""&!" " !+#       +3!"  )$(  5 "&!&/%9&';&(;&'(()#!"5 "&!&)% >> $$/92! #8!+!!"+30(((&    2!!3 883 !"  88#"  !" !" ,$%%>=/(!&$ >!!""&  '%&2!!8!#8!++3!"# ;((5 "&!&$% /%9+3!" -$;(5 "&!&/% )-9&

 )  !!"#8!+!3!"!!!&

!"!  !  !    " +3! #8!+& ", 8(/&()&'((02!!",$%%> = /( !&$ !! 2! " "&   ! !!    2!! #"!"      +"  2!!  "!"#8!+#2!!& 2!!! " +3!" #8!+ + !3 !"! 2+""#!+3!"!3!#8!+! ,$%%>=/(!&$ > =/$!&$2&'!!-$;(&  ;(& !"" " 2!"  # 5  " &!& $((,$($9 8 !!" 2!!""&

!5 "&!&$$/9!$! !!!"  "& !  '  !  !"  !"   !""& 8"!"88#"!"!""""&  ;$& "!!"=,"--' /;$ /0$ /0-  /0)!$2$ //> /)(!$&             !#!