Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-07-34756/1 AI generated

2-07-34756/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-07-34756/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-34756/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text







                 ! "  # $  %

 &'()% *#+%  

#+$%),* -,* ,!!#$     

. / $ 01 ( .  &'()%2 *,("!,* 0 ) $!%  

     

    +,  3 -$% -4! .5 *(##), " -,,-,

.5 *(##), )4%/ .           "6  2 %*#+$ !  !!,))2 + " -#!,$$%/ ,)/"  (,* (!7+2 ,)/#(88  $, 9

#$"6  3 

  :%+,)/%/  ; <  !.

2 < 5 !.

2 <  !. =. 22  <  !.

2 <  !.

2 <  2 < 2 < 5 !. =.   !   "  #$ %   &' ()    %   

  

 *"+", -./     0

  -. 

1  

  $       

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

' #! - *#+$%#$% $ = ! "4%$%0,$ )00*$%/ (,,,!4,-% $$0, # $',$0, *

#+$%$ 0$%=,/0,* *% ! 2 ! -, $)

2 ($%.     



 

#$" -4,1 ,$/ $ !"#$% = ! *" 0 ) $!% $$0, * &'()% *#+$%!  =' - "##*%! !$  $ !"#$% *'$$ $#,0 $0, $2 *%, $ 0 $  -% $%2 0, #!, $ !"#$% $  0, !% *2 #!, $,),$%/ 04"%-$ =4+"% $. "!$ $%! 1 $%/ *%$"#)2 0, -$1 (,,,!4,-%! =##! !$ +,+,))!$2 *%,/ 0,$$ -'+ 0 *%,  *(##), " 0,$$ (#+* 0 *%,

 *(##),. "! $%! 1 !,/ *4,* " $$ -!0,$0, !4=%! -,,0, * -"!,*2 .+. *,("!,* -$% +,! . 

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

#+% /$ +,-!/% "  !! ! !,$%/ 0$ ("!,/ *#$"! ),) )/, +,! -$0, * $'+$"  =' - +, *'$$ 0, ! "'() -$ =' -$ !$ . ,0$ ("!,/ #) *#$"! /$0, * !!*,(" -$% *'$$ )$%/ ?.?... #$" $'+$=' -* *#+$%! -$%$ +,! , ,$)%/  #! $ $)%/ * 04"%-$ =4+"% $ +,! -$0$ "'$0, *.

#$"! #)  !,$$%/2 $ +,! -$0$ "'$0, *#((! -4,1 *#+%  <  !. !% ! +, $ !"#$%  (+%!// +,-!/%  0'(,$%/ " "#!%/  4,%!,*%!$ =4+" )/$%/ %!$% 2 *%, *#$"2 * !! ! *#+% #) 0''()%/ -$0, $'+$"2 , #! $'+$  !$ -$)%/.  ! "%+%! !# $* + " ,$$%/ 8*$,!, / -',$ / *#$" =##!$ #0*-4 $%*.

#+%2 -/)%/ !'1, ,$$%/ +,-!/% "  !! ! !,$%/ 0$ ("!,/2 ! ,12 $ +, $%! 1 *##*4!  < 2 <  !. " <   (+%!// $ !"#$% .  " )4% #) 4,%!,*%!$ =4+" )/$%/ + " =##!$ +,-!/%  0'(,$%/ "#!%/ !2  $ *#$" , #! $',$)%/ #0 ! =,)%!,$ (+!,$ *#+%$%$ ),) + "! #) 4,% -4!4,% /% ; 

! = " < 5 ! !% ! )4%/ (+!, *#+%$% $',$0,$. 0%$, #) + "! 4,% )4%/ ; <  ! =  *#+ !$ -,,-,$2 0, #) (-%$$%/ ; <

 ! !% !.     $-!$  <  !.

2 <  !. $%! 1 0 ) $!%*%!%/ "'$$ *#$"  3 *)/ " -'!" 04,$ $ 0!$ *#+$%*%!%) (,,,!4,- %00 . *(##),.  <  !. !% ! $%! 1 =4+" )/$%/ " -"!,*% *#+$%*%!%) *#$"!$ -'!" 04,$ + " *%* + " =##!$ " *)$%/ 4,%1,*%!%/ %00 . *(##),. %%/ 0 ) $!%*%!%/ *#+$ -4,-/ 0 ) $!%#!, / )4%/ &'()% *#+$%!$

0 ) $!%*%!%/ (+!,$ *,)/!*0''(0,$ !+ )/, ,!/%- *%!%/ "#$% !% !  =' - "##*%! !$  *%!%/ "#$% *#+$ $ +$%/ !+ )/, "4%$%0, $ A  <  !. .

&'()% *#+$% -,,$ )%01(,! +)/%0,),$ (,%0, (,,,!4,-%/ *#)$#! #) .5.. "

.5.. ! *%)%/ ,)/#(88  $, ,!$  B  *( (,,,!4,-%  !,$% 6  - 3 .



 

#+$%! #) ,$$%/ -,/ @* +,. *!,*%!$ )0$%$%/ (,,,!4,- $$$* (,,,!4,-% $%)%/ ,,*% )4%/ ! *#+$%0''(% !% !  <  !. =. " !..

-,* ,!!#$

#+$%),*