Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-21397/14 AI generated

2-05-21397/14 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-05-21397/14
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-21397/14 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

    

        !"  #!  !$ !   

            %&'((')%%&*+$ 

    ),%-,)(./& 

   # $    $ "+  0 +!! !    " 1"  22" "!.%%%%!!22")-%%%% +"     

%)'(%')%%3          

 #$1!!4        (3'(%')%%&              1!!56 # $ 7" 88888888888  !8888899,998888:!88888$!" ",  "; !1!"$""$"<

56   7" 88888888888 !88888888899,9 88888 !; !1!"$""$ 1    !" #

   $            %&'(%'&%%)  '    *2 # $ 1!!! !" ! !"' #! 1!!! " !" 2 1!""'         1! $+4 " 4

! .% 12$ !  ! 2 !  "  12 $  =="   $!! $' $!!"7;>)(?!.! $+4 !! !  

 ) !"  " $!"  ! : $""$"$"!'

$!  > 3&( ! - !4 4 2"    $4   !'

! ! !     +  !" !!'       * + "   *    (')?'%)')%%-#$7"1"; !$!"7 " '!.,-; 7"1";$ !!1!""+0 +!!!&-&5(%.(.+!!888899!!2   9 !  "         7 (?3/?;  "   ! 0+!0+! ! $2!+.%%%%22""!'  $!"!!$!+!"":!1$"!: !1:"'#!""")%%('&-&5(%.(. +!!!!2!888899!9:!"1&- & )'!.-%%% !!'   ! !  $2 !$   1+"" !"   2""  "1"" "!!"! !!" !! !$"2!$2!$'!! !! !"@A$'

!12!"$!4" !   1!" $"   2!! $"' #2 $  )4==!4@A$4:' )%%('14,4!!=="'$+ !! 1"1!="'$ 4  1!     ' $4  "  &     !!,'!$"!!::!  ::1!"$! 1!"$!'11"! $! !"   " 2 $ : !$ B    C :"  $!"  !'  :,  $: 1!"  $!:!1!" 4!    :"'  !! ! $   !! 1!"!' 1!" 4 1!  $"   !" !+11$!!  "11+"1!"!' !+!4!)%%)'12$'  $" !1B!==!1!3%%% + -%%% '   "  !  (% &C3   "  C/&&  "?%& $.%%% 1+":$ &3- C% ))C ?% $$!-%( (- ! 1!"  (&%? 3?   :: !"  (%-? )C   $(%.( %-$ !1! /-3.    .C .&. ' !! "     

 . 7!"  ==; ?%%%% !    )%%)' $! " $2! -%D  '"$22.%%%%%'     ! !+11 )%%.' $!'   $+!   "' !$+!!"$2!::"::.%%%,-%%%'!! 22""!)%%.'!)%%-'$4.%%%%7)%"9 (-%%;'  )'%&'%-')%%-$7 "'!&-,&/;"1!2 !" !"1!$2!+!' 

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

!!"+"" "!!$" !"'   $!" (.'()')%%( $!  " " 

 C 12$ !"":' ! $!" :!1!' !1! $!!"!$"+!"2"4$"2"!1 2$!! $!!'  -' %?'%/')%%3 !   ! $!" 7  " '!' ))&; "+    "  +" !4 ' $!" !2241++"0$22)-%%%%$2!++'     3'   %)'(%')%%3  7  " '!' ).3,)./; !+1 !  "+  0 +!! ! !   " 1"!4'22""!.%%%% !!22")-%%%%+"2!"' !!" 2 2 !  "  ! +   !!"$2!(CCC?'  &'   !!  !4 $!"   !!  $$2"  "'  !"    ! !4  ! " $!   $!$'!+1!!4"!>C.)2'  ?'$ )('%(')%%)!&-&5(%.(.+!!!!2 ! 8888 99 7!   9;  ",      (?3/? " '  .('%?')%%-  " ::!1   ::"!!2!888899$" -%%%%% 'A',!

'A',!'  /'  2      " 22" " .%%%%   !!22")-%%%%+""1+"! 1!"""" !"":!1!! !4! $ !4!"+"+ "    1! $!  :  !1   +  1! "$"!!!!'  (%'$!"7;>C.?:!1!!$ 2"  $+" 1!" +!" !1 :!"!  $'  14  "  $++"  +" 7 E; >((/ ! ( 2 ! !! +"' + !"    "  "  +!":!11"!!!+"'!!!1 !   "  !2"  !!   1! : 2 ! " " '   "  !  >CC% !) 2 "+ "!'$"":"1!"  +   22"  !!! " :  !1'  $  )%'()')%%-!.,),(,(C),%-)3'%('(///!.,),(,?, //'  (('   ! +""    ! $2!"" +!! "$  +!" !1:"!2$!!! !$ $4"''*''':!24 

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

!"!1+""'4$2" 1 +"! 1+"'""+>,! ).%!('+""+2" "'*'''! "":!!! !!+!":!1 !!! $"" 1!$!!+!" :!1' "==+"+":+" +"" +!""'+"" !!!== :!!1"!  "== "!"' +2" ?%%%%!:$+""1!' !"!$!+2!"" "!"" $"$!!+"!""'        ).'    " 2" 1!!4 "'  !   1!!4"?%%%%!"4" )-%%%%+"'!1!!$2!+1!!4 !"!+$'

 &  )C'"$"!4$'!"!"'     $*    )-'    !" 2 !!"  $" $! !" !" !42'  )3'>3-(!'(!!!41!! "!1+": !!1!"$"'    ! " $" ! !+1  " $2!+ 2' $"!")-%%%%$2!+2 1!" !!:!!?%%%%$2!+'!"+" !!4"!1!!4!!'  )&'  !4   1!!4 $2"   !   :$1!!4$2"!242'  )?' 4  " $2"     1+""    !""  +""?%%%%!1+" ==+ $2"4 1!"+""$2"$ =='

!4 "4$2"!$$"' !"1"4  $!"  !!   !"  " " ! ?%%%% $2!+ 1!$!==!1!$!==$2!+' +"" ""!?%%%% !+"'!1":!!!!$"+" +" "   ! $"4+!!! :'  )/' $!" 7  " '!' C; "" !" !   1+"" :  !1 !! $2"  !!! 1+"  +"" 7!!  !!""+""; !241!1"!"!" !=="! !!7==H!";"?%%%% 0)%%)'$22' !!!$!+)-%%%%$2!++":!! !"" !4" 1!$!!:!1'

 !4    2!" :  !1 1"  +!  " +"!   "    ! !! !!4"+"! 1!" !!!$!:!11"' +"!"!+ $">,! ).%!('  .%' 24 :!!7> .&3;'!!!' "!"!" +'

!! 1!!4""+?%%%%      " +" )-%%%% '   

 ? 1!!4$2""+ "!7>.&3 !'-1');'"!"$7 "'!'C%;  +!4$!"7 "'!'))&;""! !'" $!"!"""!1$"!"'  %('%.')%%3 "!$+"$!"7 "'!'(.%; :!!""!!!  E >,! (%.&' !! $!"  2  " !"  !!! "   "" !! !  +!! $!B!'  4 2!""    + ! !"! 7 !!;   !" "" )?'%)')%%- " $!" 7  " '!' .,-;' #! " !" !$! +$!B!!"1!"$!!:'  .('4$2"" +$"">,!C&& "2"!! !!!"'

 $    4+ +"  "  >, C&& 2!'    2!""    ! !!! 2! "" 1"" ! !! !" " $"!'  !$!   2"  +!"" $"!!"!4" 1!$!! +!":!17>C.?;'  .)'   1 $+! $ 4 $2!    $ $$ !    4 " "  "" " "$"!"'     ..'$!!"2!""">. ! !"  2!$ " + 7''  %('%(')%%3; !" ! 1! !!" !  " "!22!  " $!!"7,(//?;2'  .C'1!!$2!+1!!4!"!+$ -%%%7 "'!'C; 1!!4!" 22$"!",(//?>3%!'(!! ""'  .-'!"!!" 22$"!" ""7,(//?>3%!'(;'  .3' "!!">,"CC) 3.( 3-( 3-C  3-&!'(1( 33? 3&%!'('         #!   !$!