Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-07-41691/1 AI generated

2-07-41691/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-07-41691/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-41691/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



 



                !  " #  $

 %&'($ )"*$   "*#$(+) ,+) + "#      - (",./' -  %&'($0 )+'! +) .(# $  

     

   + #+  *+  ,#$ ,1   -23 )'""(+0 ,++,+ 3 324- )'""(+ ! 5+ ,++,+ (1$5-          !6  + #+ 0 $)"*# + .+ #( 0  +((0 *! ," +##$5 +(5! '+) ' 7*0 +(5"'88 #+ 9 "#!6 



  :$*+(5$5 ; <  -0 < 2 -0 < - =-00  <  -0 <  -0 < 40 < 0 < 2 - =-   !   "  #$ %   &      '(   )% %  

 *+,- ./0   1   ./  2

   ,/ , ",,- 

*//.3 +0        1

 

    +         ,4 , ",,-    %  

  ,23 5 )% %  

  )$   /  

  $        - :&## .(# $)$ $5 #&+ $ #$  )(5- - & ! .1+#  > #  + #+ + )$) .(# $)$ $( '+++ 1+, $.. 4- ?) #$*# ))5 ,++)?..(5 )'""(+- 3- (# $)$ $5 # #$ / #$5 .(# $)$ $5 $$'$# )+(5 )#, *(5+ !1$#$.+#  # )$(+ #&+#.+(+ ,++,+#0 .+  +(#'+.&&') "( ="" # )$= $'""= )=( =1*+'8+((#'+.+"='#+""(+5  )"* 5#, ,++.( +(#'+.&&' (( + # - !($'+ ! - !$$ +#0 .+   +(5$/ +# ='"#(#+ #-      "#! ,1+/ +#5 # !"#$ =  )! .(# $ ##.+) %&'($ )"*#$   =&, !"")$  # # !"#$ )&###"+.#.+#0 )$+ #. #,$#$0 .+ " +



  # !"#$ #.+  $)0 " + #+(+#$5 .1!$,# =1*!$#- ! # #$ / #$5 )$#!"(0 .+ ,#/ '+++ 1+,$  =""  # *+*+(( #0 )$+5 .+## ,&*. )$+  )'""(+ ! .+## '"*). )$+  )'""(+- !  #$ / +5 )1+) ! ##, .+#.+ 1=$  ,++.+) ,! +)0 -*- )+'! +) ,#$ *+ - 

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

,+) + "# "*#$(+)