Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-07-19985/9 AI generated

2-07-19985/9 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas

Case Number 2-07-19985/9
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

 <0 :$$5 0 $ .$  #  $@@0$ $ $

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-19985/9 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas:  <0 :$$5 0 $ .$  #  $@@0$ $ $

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



          

 

  















 

  

!"#$% &""'(#

()%







 

%* &*)!!+,









"-""". ""#//!+ (0

  

   





.1  " -"  20 333333333334  33333 33335

333333 33333 33333 333333365 0. " "  27

0#08""5333333333333336

.1 " "  201 333333333334 1 33333 33

3333365

0.



9"

"



2

3333333

333

33336

.1 " "  201 333333333335 1 33333 33

33333650.9""









  

)%"% &

  

)")00"

)"%

:. $( " "  . " "  0 " -"   ; % ,  2$0  

#8$$062;  <(#(.% , ##6"



%"=:>&?(.$00.0.;;?(.

$0.0"



;") :#.($$%+" ,"% &""$::<)")

8<50"-"$ "".""#

33333333333333333335$#0

33333335.0.$#.:.8<

$$; % , "-""

;"%%+" ,"% &""$::<)"%7"'"20333333334

33333333 3333 33333 3333 33333 33333336 " "  #  $#::  /   

$.:$"

;";$.:$:$"







 

 

%2+6

 < #( 0 < 

 ;  <:# .5 

 <0 :$$5 0 $ .$  #  $@@0$ $ $

  # #$   !"))"% &""   #(0 00

.$50$"



   !   



)"#0$88.)>") "% >""#.

%/  "0.0.<$:0:.%) 

 " '0# $$ ;    0 .0 . $ .$

),"))"% >"" .0  0 ),"))"% >""5  < 0 <0# $$

$.0.<0#(#$$

 <( $" <  ($ ),")%"% >""  .0 $

  $  0" >" ;"% &"" .0 0 0 #(

5 0 .  %;  " '(#( < .0 $ 0

:#."

.<.#:.$(##<$$$; 

 .  ## ),")%"% >"" . ($0 <" % >"" #$*5

0$*.% &"".%! 4% &""#*$:*.

<;+& 4$*5.*../&& 4*5<$*

.  2  ),") "% &""6  ,>&    *  ;;/ <:#   )&%+ 

" 0%; ..::0)/!+ 5$.<

. #:. $("  #0  0 (0 #:. $( .

>  (.<$.$:"



 "

 

%".0#0#0#".0#0<(#(#;  

50#0#0#(0"

.05#(0..0(05'(#

8<)>") "% >""(0$88<<

 ## $ $ $88$$ 2;  6 <0 :.

2),"))"% >""6$$.$0<A0 5 %,?:.

$$$##0<:#2<<%"/"65.<(.

(:0##(0$0$5$0A0.

#),")%"% >""0B<C".#.$<.

$.0050.0:0.<::$

000$::0"$0(0<

<05(#<<$.0$$#$#(.

#( $( $ 0 0 #$" #(0 $::0 A $0

(0<5(#

DE*));:5

$.5<($00#$5#$($0

<<0.(#50#(<

"0<0."

0 .  < ($0  #$ 0 #5  <

."(0#

DE);%5$#05

<<<<<2$0#6($00#$5

<0#$<$$.:$5<"

7E*&&:05<000#$505

#0#$0:0(00"$<#;:5

;2+6

 0 :0 #$ 0   $ 8 $ #$5 $

050:0"

7E+;):50:0#$.:$.:$

850#(#$(0$$:"

.0 #05   0 . 0 ($  ),")%"% >"" <

$::0$$8(55$.<

@ < 0 ::$ 0 $" .  <  <

:$.(#*.#(0$

5  #( $ :  $@@00 . #(0  5 $

 0 :# 0 <0"    . $(.   0

$  :# .5  .0  .:#  $.0 "

.505.<0$<00<8

##0 . :$0 $05 00 8  $$0 .

$.0  #0$5   $ $$ 0$5 $

#  0 7 " '"  . " "  #  $#:: /  "

.0  5  ),")%"% >""  B<C $ $$  

$$85#7E*!&"7E*0!+.!!)<)0

.08#050$0#8$#0"

7E+/)8<(.:".0

#05  <#0  $ )>") "% >"" < :0   5 %,?

<(#(<:#&,<:#"

.$.0(<#0.0E//,)0

$:::$5$8, "



     "







;" .  ( . #:  $.0".  .:#

5  . <  .:0 < < :$" .  

$.05#00#$.($".(5

.0#(0$#(0"

.  (   5  . < .0 <  . <

0"),")%"% >""0<($.#".00<

.0<0. >" ;"% &""800$$%; 



.:),")%"% >""($0<<(

DE;!>%5

$5#($$#(0#.$(5#(

#(0.<<05$$#(#("

#

 0   << 8$ .   8 <

<$"8"



!# !   



/" '  5 $0 (0 < : 2   ;+*/+65 ($0 . .

.0)>") "% >""$88<5$.$88.

 '(# :  ;5 $  0   '(# .

$   3333333 "

# $88< < %") 

$88$$ %/   5 $ %)     <00 .0 $ .

 $ <<:# . < $ #($  . $

$" < < %"/  <00 .0  8.::0 $88$$

;    $ . .$ ),"))"% >""   <  <0 

/2+6

<<05$##$$88.((0.## 5 %,?

:.$$$<:###0<:#"

'0.0%/  $88(50

;  <:0:.),"))"% >""0".#:5$0

.$#(5$0$$$:#."

.#:5$(#(0.0(0<:2/!65

<0),")%"% >""($0.<5$.005

.$.;  #(.0$)>"))"% >""

$$;5;?5$$$@@00#)?#("

.#:5$$#(0.0(0#:.#(2

,;65. "" >" ;"% &"".0%; "



,"

D E % +  )   . $88< $88. 0$ . 8

$#5 #$# #( $88. < # $0# .  $

#($ $0 8$ .5 .   $88. $ . 

#(#($.#"

DE&>):##<#(

0"

DE*+/):05:$:$::05

  : :0 :."

D E )     $

#( #  :$ .:$ #( $ :$5 

:$##$"

DE*) ))<)##(#(0.5.#(

  05 (0  :$"

D E ) +  #( #(0.5

.#($$5(0:$"

DE*>,/

:05$#0<:$8505

00#(0"

.;  :#..$5

.00)>") "% >""$88<2<%"/6#"$

;  

DE*0% +)5>,/5&>)5) +).) ))<)

.0.#:.$("



>"'#05:.),"))"% >""$.:$

#..0(#"0#05

$0.<..0<#0.(#:$$"'00

)>") "% >""(0$88<<<0##2 5 %,

?65 0 ),")%"% >"" ($0  0 . << .  

0."

0 0$ $  :0  ),")%"% >"" <  # (

#A"'),")%"% >""($0<#".5

),")%"% >""<<$

DE;!>%($0<.

.((0.".0#05),")%"% >""

($0 $ <5 #0  $0  ##  0  #$($0

<$"



&"    #. $ 880 05  . $ #(

),")%"% >""<00"

$%/" /"% >""#.;*%*

)*%)* > $:05  #( #(  #  26 #( 0#"

#



#($

#(





#

26

#(

DE*; "##(#

(#5$05"0.::#0(#$"

#(0$0#(0#0#(

##0#0##:0"#(<$(0

,2+6

 5     < # #(5 $  

(0 #( < 0 $"  #( < #$ $

#$(

DE; *%.;.:2##00<0);*)/6"

$   2 < ),6 $:

5   $  #(  

#5"

DE; (#($#($#$"

($

0##(5$$:5#08

$#$.:#($#($##:0

#(5 $ $  #( (0$"  #( :0

$::#(."

(#0<(

#5  #(   26"   8 5 $

 <(5  8  0# #("  #(

0$ #($ 0 $.

D E;!> (% :0 #(#

$"

$:05

#$<5$#0

.   (0 < # #( $ $ #$5 

#((0

.:

.

8

.5



$



#

#("'.##(00

<(0$#(0."

.:05$0#

#("

$2<)>6

$:05<$0<<0

#(#0 <($(  :#0  #$ < $$ #( 

:$<<<(<$".<

$ 7 E&& ; .:5 $ .:  0 :0 #$(0 

$$#.$#$.:$"

DE%!).::<(0$<<8"

<(0$:0<5#0(

0.0050<<0($0<$(0"<

(0$.5<805##(

DE%!/.:050<0<$<<$(

"

DE%!(/::0<.#(0$$(

<5:$($<<$0"



+" .5  ),")%"% >"" < ($$  <  0 0

# #( $5  .0:  0" . $

D E* ;!>  % # 5  .  <   ),")%"% >"" <  :

0##(".<(#((00.)>") "% >""

$88<5$#$.5),")%"% >""00##$

$88<($"<00

5),")%"% >""<<$##("



!" .   ),")%"% >"" < < $ )>") "% >"" <

$$$<"(."),")%"% >""

<#00:;##(;  5$

.0   )>"))"% >"" 0  .0 $ # <0

2$0<<06"8<(

  0 5 $<.<0<<0

 $"  #(    $  "  #(

(#0:$##$"##"=0

0$ $$#0 0  0 (   # $ #

 . ##  " '0 0 #$   $

>2+6

.:$.<<0(#00$##

2##6$"5.0.:0.<<0:.

 $5  $(# . # $0 <$5 0$

.0 $  :$" .  5    $ :.

$@@0$ <@@0  . <  #   < . # $::0

(  <0 $::0" . .$ ),")%"% >"" <

.5.00$::0$$("

) "  2 :<$ ##6  :  $ )>") "% >"" < #

(#"

DE*));:05<($00#$5

  #$ ($0  <<0  .  (# 5 

0#(<"'#$88< DE*

))!)((0" DE))!).$0$

#(#((0$0<#0$(0"0<

.0:.$.:$##"7E*&&

;:050:0#$0$8$

#$5$050:0"7E*+;)

:050:0#$.:$.:$85

0 #( #$ (0$ $:   " ' << 

 $ .:$  . $( (#    0$  

(0 DE*))!)5

DE*));.7E*&&;#<<

 ($"  <  ),")%"% >"" <  ($0

.#$57E+;)8"

))".5),")%"% >""<7EF+;)#

8#07E*!&008$5<

#.$:0.:$"

DE!&#(0A8880

$ < ::$ 0 $ 0 5 $ $  <

 : $  #.05 (#5 $ #( $0 0

.0"  $@@5  ),")%"% >"" < <0 ##$::0 

. #(0 #$ <0 ## 00" 0

D E !&

0$   #0  <  0 < ($$ . 

:$"

 #  < . $ (00 . #:0  ),")%"% >"" <

($$ . <  .0 :$ ("   .

<  00 . 2. (# .   .  #( 0

$5#($:$@@00.#(05

$  0 :# 0 <06   8 05 $  

0.0:$(".#($

8 :# . 0

D E* !& $ <0 (#"  ' #0

(0008<#*$885

$0.0(:0"0#(02$.#(.0

$(.06 < #  " 0 ##0 .05 $ ( .0 .

(# 0 05 .0  0  " . 0. 

0 #:0 .  $0 #  $(. '(# .  .

0#(##.:05::$80(.

$::".0<$05$.$0.

0#(#0.0.:.0#(0":<.(.

#:00$.0"7'(#"2$..

""  6  % >"" $.0 0 2  ,,*>&6 :#  $ #

&2+6

:85 $ $.0 (<< $" . ""   8 :# .

<0<50<00#0<($$."

(5),")%"% >""<8$

DE!&.0

<0#0"



)%" '  5  .0<.:08$0.:"

#7E*!+)$8$#0$<

7 E* !! :0 :. ." .0    0 .  #:

#0"  .0 8 <0 0 $ #  7 E* !+ :0

#050.00%!" >"% &"""7E!!)<)

#(80.0:$.5#.5

$ ## . $(. "  ),")%"% >"" < ($$ .  

$0.0:$5<.$(005

.0$   .:0  # < < ($$"  ( 5 

.0   ),")%"% >"" < 8$7E*!!)<):0:.

$@@00"



);"

DE ) ) ) < > .E )); :#05:$##$

 #( #(0. (0 #( ## 2##6"   < 

#05<),")%"% >""<7E+;)8"7E+/)

   8   < ( .:"   ##

#$:0)>") "% >""$88<<%"/$:0##$:: 5 %,

? :. $ $$  ##0 <:# " .  (00 ##

.#$)>"))"% >""),") "% &"";;/<:#"

#$::<:#

;  3 5 %,&,";;/<:#0##;;/3&,%, , 

". >" ;"% &""%; ##:05.::#

0% , 5$

DE>,/5E) ))<>.E));).

0#:.$("



)/".0.<(#(.###:.$(

% , G;  ; % , "



),"  E //,  )   #(  <  0 $:: 

:$#.:$:<:#..5:0##$#(

:$$($(".0:#.0

$:::$5$#$$8, 

"      $ (  E*  //,  ) #

."E//,:05$$#(:$

(  "  #    00  2 :$

0 6 E* /, :5 $   #( #( #0 

:$ <0 #( :$ <00 #( .05  $ .:$ 

#(  (" .  #0 (0. #0  $0

.05$#(<0.$.00"

.0<(0:$$$.0.<0

"  5   .   .: 0$"

#

0$#:.82,/6(05 ""F33"33"3333""800"".

33"33"3333"" 800 " "  " " 

$ # # #( 005    ""

:#.#<0<.$00"$

..""$7*'(#"..".

< #5  7'(# "  #:85$% >""$.0(<<

+2+6

$"  ""   # #( $0 $(.# <(. 0  

@@05  .0  0  "   . #:0 0 

$.0(00"

.5.<#:<5$.5$

$:::#:$"'.0#<$

$ 80$"  " "  "  8.  .:005  .0 <0 <

.0#.23333"3"333333365$<..($$#(($0

<#.0"

.  A88 5    *$88 .   0# #(0

(0$0#<<(#":$#::<00.#

0 $    0:.0#($"5

.:<:.($5:E/>))"



)>":###E*)&;)$0.

$#"*)>;):050$

#0 <0 $0 #(0 05    . $0

#(0  0$  #(  .: $0 : #( 

< 0 0"   0$   00  #(0 0#

$5<<(.0$0.0#(00$"

 .:   00   # >& ? ( .

$0.00$.::0#;;?

( . $0 . 0"  0 0$::$ #(

$(0E*)&/:0"



)&"  %+" ,"% &""$::"-"$00

$(0.)60 "".""#33333333333

333333335$#033333335

.0.$#.:.8<$$/  

"-"4%607"'"2033333333433333333

33333333333333333333333336""#$#::/  "

05$:$.:$"

    00 #:$   0  8<5  

$ $:: 8< 0$  $ . # 8<  (

00  (0 "  E ;&+  /  <  # ( #

#$50#($.8#(05#(00#(<00

. (0 #0 . .0 #0 <(.0" #0 .

#$.:.#8<..00

(05#(005.8<0$80$::

.("(:5$.:.#8<(<

$880#.(00$"(.:#5

<(.00:0#$(0$7"'".""

#$500%+" ,"% &""$::<

)"%"