Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-07-30008/6 AI generated

2-07-30008/6 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-07-30008/6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-30008/6 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

  

     

          !"#$     %&'($)"*$ %&'($ "*#$+!    "*#$(,), ,'#$       -(".+/'--0%&'($   

      

   #,(.#',($#'$1,%()*,2--.#$3-)'""(, (4$5-             #, (.#',($# '$1, %() 0 ',#',)""5 30$)"*#66# ,037'#$0,(5!,,(/(-   2--      

     ! "   *$ 55*,-  & ! +4,# 2- - 3 )'""(,0 +, # 3-8 )'""(, "( ##+# )'5,,5,$++0 - )'""(, ,(4$#.) +$$#$($5,(#'07-7)'""(,.,,.,08-7)'""(, 11#'*. (,(  )'""(, .4  ,(4$5+, "#$5 )$ $50  #, (.#',($#'$1,%())$)-  $((,#5# !"#$"#$##,#.,,.,#+##&,5#.)-

  

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

6 6# +,. 5$ )""1, ,#$5  1,($ 6 0 (4$5 )"#! # 38- )' #$+,#0 +, # 3-8 )' +""5$# ##+# )'5,,5,$++0 - )' ,(4$#.)

  

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

6 6# +, *#)) ,(4$#.) +$$#$($5 ,(#',0 .,,.,0 11#'*., ! +$$5 .4,+ ,)$5)"*$#$5-(4$/*!)"#! #6 5#,(,+$#15-0 -03-03-! -(,(:909 150!709 09 093 09 ! 9   0 0  (,( 9 3    $  1,($ ,# )"*$#$# #&,#+,#0 )$!$$' )"#! 1,($ ,# )"*$#$#( )&,# / *! )"#! )"*$#$# #$5 *!  ##+# )'5,,5,$++0 ,(4$#.) +$$#$($5 #$+# ,(#'0 .,,.,0 11#'*. (,( .4  ,(4$5+,"#$5)$ $5- $()"#!," 1&'# 1,($6 6# +,#*! +,##6*#,+)##$($50,,"( )"#!1"" # 1,($!&',##+#)'5,,5,$++) 308)'0+,#$ /6 5#,(,+$#1 5-! -(,(:909 1!9  $ )"#! #.& !+4,#-

 



1,($ 14*,#,(,+$#  $  "( )"#! )"*$##$5 +)+ *!  ,(#', -= )'5,,5,$++# 6* # )"*#0 )"))$ 383-8  )'- $( )"#! , "  1&'# 1,($

6 6# +,#*! ,(#',5)##)+,##6*#,+)##$($50#$ /6 5#,(,+$#15 -! -(,(:909 1!9  $ )"#! #.& !+4,# 1,($

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

  3

  !&##)"#!+(# $)$ $5#+(5)(5-   "  "#! "(*,. 5$! ,5&'),'!57-8---)&###",+##$50)$,5)"#! , "  )"*#$  #&*# #   1&. !"")$  .#($5- "#!# "( *",##$50 # )"*#$  #&*# #+,##.#+, .4,/)"*$*,# !"#$'*$ 55- "*$ "/9

  $ *!,##$5>)#, ,5.&,#5)"#!1"" #"+).4#$)- "*$'*$ 5/ *,# !"#$*,. 5$+&',#$5!!" $54,$ ,)$ #14*!(5#$5$ #$ #,.,, )"*#$+(# $5$#,)$  9   $ -       #   $  #  #%!##  #    " +(# $)$ $5#$ /!&##)"#!)(5-  9 7    $  #$ / )"#! # .& ! +4,# *! )$) *,. 5$ # #$#$5 ',,, 4,.3-)'""(,-      , ,'#$ "*#$(,)