Legislator Case Law & Legislation
3-06-2021/7 AI generated

3-06-2021/7 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-06-2021/7
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

 !     "   ,   4 " &      '22     '  ,         ')         4    (    '22   /       "    ,     "  ' 4     &  ' '22    0! &    4    '22   !      4   '4     ')  #    ' ,   4       ) &         4     7  "    &     & ,  4       ) &     4       (   '22 ,     &  ')   44 4   '22     /&    " '4 ,  &    '   '22  & ,'44  9  '22   " ,  4 #  ' 4  #    4    & 4 ' ,  "  , #   "  &   '    '44   & ,   '    & 8)  4      '44   /&        ,    '22     4    & , (  '22   4  &   4  ' 4    ( '          4 " &   1 44  (   '22   '  4    '    '44   ' , 

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-06-2021/7 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja:  !     "   ,   4 " &      '22     '  ,         ')         4    (    '22   /       "    ,     "  ' 4     &  ' '22    0! &    4    '22   !      4   '4     ')  #    ' ,   4       ) &         4     7  "    &     & ,  4       ) &     4       (   '22 ,     &  ')   44 4   '22     /&    " '4 ,  &    '   '22  & ,'44  9  '22   " ,  4 #  ' 4  #    4    & 4 ' ,  "  , #   "  &   '    '44   & ,   '    & 8)  4      '44   /&        ,    '22     4    & , (  '22   4  &   4  ' 4    ( '          4 " &   1 44  (   '22   '  4    '    '44   ' , 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                  

      



         

   !"             !    "  "  !    "  #  $     % &         '       $    !% (    )  #!$%#$     &       " $ '  " %* +   " *    ,  " - .  

   )#             "    '  '     (    )   "   &      $ /01 & #%            !    "  ) &'    , 

&     "      

22' '  #  $ /0 &#%  34  ( "44      $ /0 &#%  !"

5 # ')   '   

- &    #4'  "  #

    '    '    '  &  5  '    '  & #4'      & '& (      - '

- (  ' 6  "  $    & # 

, % /

  '    

       1 4 " &  1   - '

 '6  "  6      4   &  4   '  ' '22 $ !%  !  &       "   " $'      % #  ' '     

"   224    '22   &)     '  

 "    22     &  /     " &       " ' &    4  "     0 &       

 "   22' '  #     4       $ 1%  7'  "      !    "  #       '      ! '  &  8"4 '     $  1%  !  &          "     "  $'       % )    4    '22      ' "          &  "  '  9      , 4    '22      ' "      )        4              $ %        



     $     %, 

 '       ! " !   " $ %  



  44& "4  '  "    "   4 & $ 1!%    '        '  "     "   & ,   '   

      &  &    #" ,    ') '     '     &'    '   ')  "  #    /   "     "  4 #  "   ,       22           #"  )          '  '      ,             '

      #    & ' " (  #" $ %  1            $     !%           "   '   # "   

 (     $ %  



 ! 44& ')   "  " !   "    (     "  (       $  1%   "   44 # '  ,

  4 '  "   !   " '     (    )  

  '   4 &     '   '  "   '  !    "  (    ) 4 &&  &    & ) &          "   ' $  %#   $ %  



    44&  "4  '  "   & ) &        $ 11%     " &  #   '   "  4#  ,   '  "    )   !   " ) &'   '    )# (   ')  ' " 

    '  (    ) 4 "     ')    "4   $ !%

   1       " ,     )      !    " '     # '   ) &'     &  ) # (   $ %  



  44& 44       &  &$  1%      &  4#  '  "   )  &        '    '     $    & # 

, 1%      &          1  4 " &   1    4   "  44   '22     "   '  6   "  "    7'  "      #)"     

  '22      '22  )    &       4       ,    +  '      0 !     '22  4          '  "   '  4       &   '  '22 ,      /     ')             4    (    '22  /&  4 " &    '22  '          4 "           #  1 '4 "          ,  1 "  1 :       &     '22   44   (   &     &  4    ( '  "   (   4  " #)        "4   

"22'44  &   "       #  &      -  (              4   ')   ,  #     0 ; &  #  "4&     ( #  &&  "22'44         "4&  44  '22 4   ,   "  (  4   " #)          "4    &       '22         9 &     ' # 4      '22     +  ' #)  0

      4      /&         4   '22      1   (&     '  "    '4  #  '  ' "  #(         & )  - '

( #  &,   4         #  &  /' "  #(            & ,  ')   " '   &' ,   #( '           "   ,       &  )   #  &     ) &   &' )# ' /  , #( ' ' "  4'   '4 " &  '     ' #  

') 4   +  '     #       ' " " #)"      #     "    ' " &  #)"  "   )  '   

          "   &  ( ,   "  4   '  )           :      ' "        '    #  " ,      &   &  # ,  &  '4 "    '  4&  

'        '    $ %  !  " '    '  " #)" , 

     4  

4  )"    )    /&      "      $   ;% +  ' '  "4       #         4   4         '   ,         $ %  !   "    )  )     ' "         ,  ' "       ,   #  " ,

#)"       &  ')     '4 " 4&       : & 4         "  ,   #  '   "  ' "    '4 " 4&  "   '    &  &   #  

   

 '4   -   '  "  

    "  

 '4 " 4& & ,   ) & "  ' ' ( ,        &     '  '     7'  " # #(  ' "  4'  4& '4 " "  '    '4&  4         ')    &  ' '  ')  "       &  '  $ ;%  +  '       "    '  "   )    6   '22    '  22 5   '   "           '  #      ' "  )    , '      ' - (  "   "22  +  '      0 1 &             " 2  &  ,  & ' 4  4        "4&   6

       '  &'  

') 4   $  " "  %-  (  "   "22#  &  

')      "  #      '      "  ) &'   $    &  # 

, 1%  

 &        ,  '  & "        )  & ,  )      '4  &  &  ,         #)"   "        #     '')        4& , !   "     " # ' , 

          #  !  '       '  '  '   4  !  $  1;% 7  "             !   " #  #4  '   &          1  4 " &   1    4      "   '6  $& 1% &6  $& 1%/  4 " & 44    4    "     4 " &  4      & 4 "  4  4   (  '22 

 !     "   ,   4 " &      '22     '  ,         ')         4    (    '22   /       "    ,     "  ' 4     &  ' '22    0! &    4    '22   !      4   '4     ')  #    ' ,   4       ) &         4     7  "    &     & ,  4       ) &     4       (   '22 ,     &  ')   44 4   '22     /&    " '4 ,  &    '   '22  & ,'44  9  '22   " ,  4 #  ' 4  #    4    & 4 ' ,  "  , #   "  &   '    '44   & ,   '    & 8)  4      '44   /&        ,    '22     4    & , (  '22   4  &   4  ' 4    ( '          4 " &   1 44  (   '22   '  4    '    '44   ' , 

 4      4   4  )     '22 #    ,  & 4  4   '    /

    '      "      "  '4 ,   "   (   4               4   ')   ,  #     0 ; &  #  "4&      ( #  &&   "22'44           "  '4 ,   -  ( #  &   4        #  &  &  )       "  ) &   &' )#  ' ,   '44 +  '    4      "   4     )#   01 &       4         4 " &  "     &   

 4 "    #4'   '  /&   '   

 ')  "    

 ')   #4'   )      4   4     4 '        +  '    0! &#         4    '22    &   #(   &  22  "  #)" ,     #  #(  ' "          , '      #  " ,  ) &     4   '22    2           /       4   

,      "  '  4'  #( ' ' "   '4 "  &  '   

') 4       "  4        &  '22   44           #    1! 4 " &  7 "  

')  "  11!  4 " &   7   "   

 ')  -  "   (  #  &     0 &" +   & + 44 ; <  '44 &  "  "  

')  "   )#   <01      "  

 '  "     4  4    4 '  ) "       & "  

')  "   ')  '  "    4     ')  '  "  ) & "    /

    '        0 ! &    "   

  '     !     '22  11!11    '22   #(   " 

      &  )    ' " & "4   #       &'  #4   "   )##  " 4        '22    /   4&      ,       &  



   $    !%,

& "4          ) &'          &, 

& 

   ' "  #(  

      )    &     ('   $ 1!%  4 '         1 4 " &  144 4    (  '22 ) &#4  &

    '  ) &#4    4 "  &   0! &#       !    "     # "4      $ 111%   )*&''     "    &  '          !   " , !   "        "    '   '       $  ')  44, 1%        4#   

   )  &    "   "  ')  '              '               $ /0 &%    " 22 , !  "           ,  "   '   7'  " '     " ) &'     &  ,        " ) &'       "  ')     "    4    &  ) ,'4      "('   )$    &  # 

,  % /     '  "  !   "  ) &'      &    "  &     & ,      "   4  "   )         

 (    ,' ) &'     &       '   ')   '    (    

,   '  "   '    (

     & '  '  22,  #   "     ) & &  ,   '        #  =    4    )     "        '4     ' #4  $    & # 

, , %/&      "  )   "     #)"   '      ) &'      &  &'   "   

 '  ' $    & # 

,  , %       "   '    (    )     "      &  4 '        &  , 

           )    ,

&   )     ,' 

& "  '  "  4 #  #            $    &  # 

,  %       $  %      '  "    !  "  4   $    & # 

, %+   "  & ,      "    " &  4 #  

,      )        ,   4      ,   ' "    ) ')  (    &    

 '  '#"    "     '     

    # '   " ,

     '   /"4  &     ' "  '    &  4#   ')    ')  '       $ ' %     )    ')  )    "4     $    &  # 

,  % /   4#  &      "  '      (    )  &  & ,    '   "    #     '  '   & 

         4 '  "       $    &  # 

, %+   "  )   &    & '  '4     /&          "   '  '     (    )$        !% )#     "   &      $ /01 &#%      !  "   +     

,   "    ' 6  "         4  "   

 '22      14 " &   1 $  !% &   4 "     "  '        $    &  # 

, %/ )   

 4 "  1) &#4  +   #    

,   4 "   1                 "  4  " !$ %    #  !   " ,        &    '  "  ' '    #     

 "    22 4     '22   "  )      22    & $ 1%  "   ,   "  &  " 4     "   22, '4  , 

22   "  &  " 

)# $    & # 

, %+   "    ,   "  & 

   -  +

'  =   , 

       "4  ,   '   

   22 & $    & # 

, %    "  =    "     '  ,     (    '22   #    #     2 , 

 &     "    #   '    #  

,      "        "     "    "  

2      &  )   &                 #" ,   ')         "    

 4   '  

, ) 

22  )# ,    "  

4 (

   &  '    ,      "    !   "   '    "  '  '  '    & , 

22   "  &  " "  )# $ % /        "        &  $    &  # 

,  % +   "  22     & ,      #4' ,



2   ,   , -  '

 

  " /     ) , 

   "       "  +   " '   "   ,  "      "      

2    /   4&  ,   

22 &  &      '        '       " 

22&   ' '4  &  4 # #22 ,' "4 '  4       $ %

 "  "    4   ,   " '4    &   '   

     !  "  

 &  "     $

22%    "  '  "  #    4         ')  ,   4  "4      4       ,     "     ) &'       4   ')      )   

22&  (

44    ',          "   22 #  ,     "  )#          "   

 ;      ) & '   " '     "  4#       "  ) &#4    '      0  &  # , 

       "4&         '    " 0! &#, 

    '22          22       !  "        !   " &    '  "  )    4    '22      ' "          &   "   $  %   "  "         '22   #(      #   ,

  22  )#   " '    "  $  ,    & # 

, %,    )    &     /

  4 '  '   "   "  & ,   ' "   $  ,    & # 

, %/           # ,

    '    ' "    (    '     ) &  )

, )   (   #"  '      &  :      "   !  "      4  " '  '        #

    "      ,          "    ) &'  #)" ,  '22  #( ' " #  =      '   

 #" ,' ( #  "  && #     &    & )   $ %    ,   "    &#4  4# ,

   )        "  )  /     ')     #       4 & )'    "       )   '      '  & 

     "   ) &'      "    "   ')     "4   , #) )     "   '  "    '          "  4#   & , 

           4& ,          '     #  &      '  '  &   "         '    4                 &  ')   '   ')       

  , 

   #   '  ' "     ) &  )

 '  , &       "      &        4 &  22   +      "       ,   ' "     ')   & "4 '   ,'   "     (  )        "     +   "   &      & ,      "       "  4   4 &7'  "      4# '  (     &         "4    )   "    "  ' "    #    &   '    &  )   '  ,  ##   "  '   " ) &    ' "  44