Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-04-569/15 AI generated

2-04-569/15 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-04-569/15
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia · Case Law (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

                            !"! ""#$%&      '"(')*+                        !"#$%&"'        ( (    (         )"***&**   (  + ((...

Legislator headnote

AI generated
2-04-569/15 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:                             !"! ""#$%&      '"(')*+                        !"#$%&"'        ( (    (         )"***&**   (  + ((... «                     !"#$%&"'        ( (    (         )"&   (  + (( (»

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

          

     

  

        !"! ""#$%&   

  '"(')*+  

                     !"#$%&"'        ( (    (         )"&   (  + (( (

 , +!"-! ""# .//  .,0 ,,., /,.        

 ,1.// 2 0 .,0    ( (   (( // 2 ,3,4&, 56, 1 4  7 88888888888 0, 8888888898888888&077' .5 ,,3 4, &, 56  , : , &  4  , 7 ;""* -( ,  <,!#'+

00./50< 0  7 => $ ,-./0.// +

  %'1*21$)                  (&  

     (                   (       1    ((1     3       

 (      1   ?&  , ;!")! ""( & ,0 &07,,1,  &, -;;"#"#       ,  7&%% 7.  %7!  .,,7 &%0& 0  , 7 ,0  , ., ,., /,. ,       <% &%0,  .. "+(-        & & ,  ..  ## +(    ! .,   ,,0  



,07&/0.% ,. ,,0,,< &, , . ,..(""""""   !  ,. )!"*! ""( 0 &,  , ,7!   7. +!! "")&07 %,<0,0,&/0.% , <% &%0&..- *))-)  & & .. #))-+*   *" ";+*  !  ,   ,  ,0 -!"! ""* &, &07 , ,,7   :& ,.  %7..#("""""  ,07%7! , &070, ..,70

0 , <,. !   7. (!"(! ""*&07 %,<0,0,&/0.% , <% &%0&..-+)*""  & & ..-+*""   #"-) ""  !    .  "+!")! ""*   0   &,  &, &070  <0  -!"! ""* &07,.,0. ,,&%,,!  ., .(!"*! ""*&07 %,0 ,, "!")! ""* 0 ,<% &%0&..("( (;(  & & ..-+;(""  ! .  ""*,,#)""""  <0,0,&/0.% ,  "!"*! ""*  <% &%0&  ..  --#)-"*        & &   ..  - ;- +)   );*""  ! ., <0,0,&/0.% ,.,007 ,,7:0.,7  0% &4,,7..( )"""  0/,7  , *)"""""  ,0   7<% %7/  --#)-""  5! 

  ,  )!"+! ""*  0 , 0  ,     0.7 ,,07  , ,  7 0:. , ,%,,! 

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

 -  "!"! ""*, 7 & 0,.,07, @*"0!00.% ,  ,0,&/0,,7  0% &,,( )"""  % 707 *""        % 2 07  :& ,.   )B     07,7  ,  .. - ("#  4*(; (+  9)B5!   .,,7,0,<0 ,,)! ! ""*. 00<0.,.//  ,: ,7.,0,,7& 2 , , </&0 )!"+! ""* , &,&%,0 , %77! & 00 , !"+! ""*C-"!"+! ""*!  ,  ,  %7. 0  ,,    , 7    .  <  ,  ,  & ,  ,  0   &,&%,0  )!"+! ""*    < A:0, 0 0  ./  0  0/2  D , <  &  ! 

,+!"-! ""#.// /, , 07.,.,0,,.,! 7 & 0,.,07, @()@(*0!-@( 0!-@( 0!'-! 0 7 ,.,0,,. ,,0 ,,7,/,0,  <72& 7000:0,,,0 ,07,,7,0 , ,  , .. , . ,, 0.. ,/ 7,,70 !: . 00, <0, , 0/,. 0 .%&<%&% . ,,, 700,% 0, ,0,,7! 0 7 ,/0&00 0,. ,.%&<%!,.  <% ,.   ,7 .   , 7  ,%7  . 00, /,2 , , 0  )!"+! ""*  , ,  & &,&%,0 . 7 &% 2 / ,07 . ,%7   & 0,.,07, @( 0-.%,, 7. 00, /,, , 07 , , , , 0 0..,!  <  ,  "!" ! ""# &/0,7 <  ,   ,   /, , ,   0 , ,7 ,. , , 0 0.., &%  00, ,0 % 0, ,,., .  , .7 .%&, <%,   ,  0   ,7!  0 7  , ,. ,   0 0 , 0 . ,, 0..  .%& <%   ,02/,, 07.,.,0,,.,! 

 , +!"-! ""# .//  <0  , , .// 2 . 00 0 2 , < 20.  2  ,  &/0,,7 ,%7  & .  0 7 .   , ,%7    <02 .,.// ,: ,7.,0,,7! 

 , ;!")! ""# .//  &%,  .// 2 .,0  7,  0 7,/,.// 2, &07. !  ."*!"*! ""#&,<02/,,.// 2 07.,,<0,  ,,7  , ,%7 ,,   /, , ,.  , & 0   7 0  , , , , 0 0..,! , 0, , 2 , <%,  & ,.  ,,7  , : , :0700&0 0,,,200%  &% .0 ! 

, *!"+! ""#.// /, .// 2 07., ,, 

 ,00/2 &,. 07. !   ,,&7  /0&.// 2., 0 70 7 ,., +!"-! ""#.//  070 ,02,: ,7.,0%  . 700 

. ,%,,! 

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

  ,,2 , 0.  , .// !/0&00, 2, 0.  ,  !"*! ""(.//   !;)  ,0, . 0  &/0,,7     7   ,.   &%   0/7    ,.,  ,& . ,,&,%7 & .&/07.  747< 7  ,,  75!  /0&, & 0 !"+! ""* ,,7<  , ,%7 .,,7

0 &,! ,&0,

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

 )   770,7, & 0,.,07, @(#0!(@ 0! @#!