Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-02-297/17 AI generated

2-02-297/17 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-02-297/17
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

)'+  ! * !) * )*   * !) *  & *   &*+ ')!

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-02-297/17 · Viru Ringkonnakohus: )'+  ! * !) * )*   * !) *  & *   &*+ ')!

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text





        









 

 

 



 







 ! 

  

 

""#

   

 









 

  

  





 



 







$%

&''



(

 )*



!+&'& 



 





 

 





 

,

-! &''

+

''

+

 

,



-!

.  *

//#/01)( )  *











)



*

,

((

.(

 1

 

*/$0(

 )*

,*  )







)



*

,

((

.(

 0

(

  &*1 (

  &  & ) !



3



 



) &)

!"#$%&##'

( 

 



 









)*+,,+-)).

 

+



"  

 

 





  +







 



4

! 5  6 ! )

"7

)* ! ))*

2 )& ))!)   

 )) (

 !)**  )  !') ! )  



)

 2

* ,

((1 ))  )  )  ,

 -!1 (

  &''

 

(

 )*

,*  )

 6/ ! )



""/67/' ) 6&&.8*)66"61##"0



/% ,

-!

) &  

& )).888

*)%"$01& ))()2

 *.2

09%9%$)))!+*



)

 2

* ,

(( .(

 0 (

 )*

 ,*   )1     ' * &

(

 )*

  )

) )  

 )

 2

* ,

(( .(

 0 (

 &) /

! ))* * * *#6

 )

2

 )*

 (  :)*  !!) 2

 9;; )   ! ))* 

! )     !   * *) 1 

  &*) ) 

+

(

 &)

2

 )*

 ,*   ) & * '*   ' *   ) 

(

 &) ) .:) )& 0   ) (

 )*

 *

)** : 

! ))* 



2

 )*

 !1 *<

0 ; 8*"

 )   ,

 -!  ! 6 

 

(

 !

 ! & . ! ) 

"##7;0=

0 ;; 4

! 5 )   3) -!1 8

 -)!  )



-)!  ! 6 

  (

 !

  ! &  . ! )  

 "

%%7;"$/0=

/0 %; 4

! 5 )   3) -!1 ,

 -! 1 8



-)! 

)

 -)! 

! #6 

 

(

 !



 ! & . ! ) 

"%7;"$0=

60 %; 4

! 5 )   ,

 -! 1 3) -!  8



-)! ! /%% 

  (

 !

  ! &  . ! )  

 "

%7;"$0=

;0 ; 4

! 5 )   ,

 -! 1 3) -!  )



-)!  !  

   *  !

 +*)  !)*

(

 !

 ! &  *. ! ) 

"%;$7;"#0=

%0;4

!5 ) %

 1

 #6



  (

 !

  ! &   *1 &  :)+ 

 )

 2

* ,

((

.(

 0! ))* **.

 ! ) 

";"/60



  &* *:)  ) *1&*()!)&*)( *) 

 ** ) )&!)*.!

 ! &  **(

 &)0

(

 )*

)*! * *:&)1& :()1& 

+*)'+ !& 

* ) )

 *! *!&&

:)+& &

*)

)

2

*.(

 0! ))* **



2

 )*

   ) * * (

 !

 ' ) &  .2

 9;; )/ (0

2

 !

 )!* * 

::*1 *&*  '

 !

*  !

 

*&!''

2)   )(

 )*

!)*!

 *

&   (

 )*

 *&

*  !&))  & &::* 

 !))

' "5'

:)!) >

&  (

 !

&&   *1& ))

 &  ! ))*) ! ) )



2 *&  ! ))*)   (

 )*

  ))1  ( *&

(

 !)*  &  ,

 -!  ! &   

") )

 2

* ,

((

.(

 0 !') ) &&  $// 

  .8*"

  //; &''



 ! )

"#7;0



2

 )*

   ) &  ! ))* 

)*& 1! *! ) 

) &,

-!   1&

*1,

-! )(*+! &)

:)*! ) )!

**&  

,

-! ! ))! &   (

 )*

!& 

& ' ! ))* * *

)** (

 &)) (*

/ &  

& /%



"6"67;;.888*);%0 !

,

 -!  /% ))1   &  

& (+ 

+&

(

 )*

!:)'

)!)!& (

 &)!()

 &  

& ! &! & & )



6

  $% &''

 .888 * ) ;$";#0 '  ) (

 )*



!+& 

)*&



''

 )   ) ) ( **  ) (*!* )* (

 )*



,*   )  !+&   ) * 1  (

 )*

  

 2

 9;;

'* ) ! ))*)*

2

9%#))+'

)!)!(

 )*

!:)! +

)*

) ) )  * ! (

 &) '    )*

 !  

!*)*

 & 

  *& )   (

 )*

 ,*   ) % ) !

(

 &) '    )*

 ! 1 (

 )*

 !

* 

! ))*%:)*)(

)) 

3 *!

* &*

*( *1& (

 &) )

) () ! **1 &  *&* &::**  &::& !

  % :)*)

(

))  )  ,

 -!  /% ) ( *&1  (*!*

)* )*

 !+&  ?)*))   ! * )*

)  * )+*1 

 *

)*& ! &)*+! ))* 

)*& 

)  )1)*

' *+& 

) )))*

)&

) 

!+  ! ))*! ) !











;,

-!()+&/%&''

+.888*)0: *&

$% &''

    &''

1 & )) !+* 

 )

 2

* ,

((

.(

 0(

 )*

(

 )*





''

+ )   ) (

 )*

 & * '*   ' *

 (

 &) )   ) (

 )*

 *

)** :  ! ))*

 ! * *&  *  *

:** ! )*

: &) 

 ";"66  *  ) '    '(& 



&))   &  .) !  *& 0    ('

 )  ))

)&) * &      &''

*   )   &)) ) 

 * )&  *) *



2

 )*

 )*(

 &)' !

' ) & *

::*

*&*'

!

*)*

!)*))()   * )

& )*

*&

*!&)) &&::*

!)) ' "5'



:)!) >

&  (

 !

&&   *1& )) & 

 ! ))*) ! ) )



2

 )*





 *

! ))*)

1





( *&

(

 !)* & ,

-! !&  8*"

//;

&''

  ! ) 

 "#7; 

") )

 2

* ,

(( .(

 0 !') )

&&$//

 



2

 )*

   ) &  ! ))* 

)*& 1! *! ) 

) &,

-!   1&

*1,

-! )(*+! &)

* :) ! ) ) !

* *&   

 >   *&  

()) )*8*2)  (

>



& )&)

666/#



   )  &''

 !' *1  )*

 + )  

) ) )*

) &

)

!+! ))*! ) ! *

2

 )*

! ' *2

9'*&'

 



;;%&''

!  ,

-! &''

+&).888*

)"$0



% 2

 )*

 ,*   ) & ! .888 * ) $%"$$0 ! *)

&''

+)!) * 1(*!*)*(

 )*

!+& 



/%)/%&''

+ ) *! ) 

)

2

*

,

(( ()1 ! * 

   ,

 -!  () /; !')* !) 

 





)  !')* 

   ,

 -!  ()

   ) ) 

&''

+ *2

9%$) &*('*!  ()

,

 -!   )  

 )

 2

* ,

(( .(

 0 ! ))*1 



 %;% &''

 '  & 

 )

 2

* ,

(( .(

 0

! ))*))+ & ' & )

)*&



% )  

 )

 2

* .(

 0 (

 &) '

  # ! ))*

   && /### 

 

  ! ) 

 !'* #6 @

/###A$/;

 !

1& )*

!)&



!) ! ))* % ) (

)) )   ! * )*

) 

 *    )+*1   *

)*&  ! &)*+ ! ))*  

)*& 



2

 )*

 %)+(

 &)' )*

!

1 (

 )*

 !

*1 ! ))* % :)*) (

)) 

3 *!

* &*

*( *1& (

 &) 

)) ()! **1*&*&::**&::&(

 !



 * 

&   ,

 -! + 

"  )

 2

* ,

(( !

1 * 

&  

)*! ))* **



  * &''

+ & / 

 !!) 

 9%%/ );

)*& 

 )



$ 

 )

 2

* ,

(( .(

 0 (

  &* ) *  & ; !

&''

+)1&''

+( *&)+'

)*&



2

  &  ) (*!* )* (

 )*

 !+&  )*

 

)'+  ! * !) * )*   * !) *  & *   &*+ ')!

 (

 !

)1)*

() * ))&&)1

   ) )*

 !+&  ( * )  *+ * )1  )*

 :

+



!    &  (

 !

 

** )*

    )  ! )

)'+ !& '

2

  & 

!  + (  )1  )*

   * & BB* 

 * *&  ! ) ,

-! 

''

+  ) *:  * !' *!)*

()

& 



! 

/



#  ) +1  &''

+ !' *  ( **    ) &

$%&''

: & 





9/)&)+ ! )1   (BB

*+'*

&

)*!* * ! !  



2

 9% ) ! !* )*

 ! () ! ! ))*  ! ) 

(

  &)1! ))*:)*))1)!  &  

& )

&*9%$)'

  )*

'*&:)**' &!  ' * *

 )1!++)*

&)))! (

  &1! ) 

!   &  

&  )) !  ! ))* :)*)  )) 

!++ )*

   1   )*

)   )  *   *)  + )*



)&''

*'!

*



!*))*

!()!! ))*! )  +

)*

 !+*  &) )) !  2

 9%$ ) ))*   )) ! 

! ))*:)*)))



,

 -!  &'

 * /% )  /% &''

+

)7+   C! )  ,

 -!D ')! (

 &) 

. ! ) 

""#0! ) 

)

2

*,

((1& >:: )   ,



-! )  

 )

 2

* ,

(( .(

 0  &) ,

 -! * 

) &)(  *)&''

+*!)(

 )*



!7! * )

 $% 

) )) 1 & ))  * 

 .! ) 0 ,



-!   * !  ! (

 )*

 ,*   ) 

 )

 2

* ,

((

.(

 0 (

 &) !' *!)

+1 ,

 -!   * &''

*

'

)!  *

2

 )*

!.888*)$%1$#0&''

+)'+1,

-! 

))%;%

)

2

*,

((.(

 0! ))*&

) *

 '1 *! ))**) *!) *,

-! * *&

(

 )*

!+& )&

2

9/))(

  &* +(

 &)  ! ))*

!1 !)!+ )*

 ! :)  ' *+ & * * )! * :)* *

2

  &*

)) +1)*

+

+) )*1') *

))! ) &*!' 1

&( *&  > )

*



)

2

*,

((.(

 0(

  &*) * &!&''

+)1

(

 )*

!) * & *(

 &) *(*!*)*&

!+& 



 ) +1  ,

 -!   ) ) (  *   ** &

  * ! * 

&  (

 )*

 () 

 )

 2

* ,

((

.(

 0 (

 &)1 &   &    '*

)*& &

)(

 )*

!+& 



!)2

9$)(

 !

!

1& ) ! ) )(

 !'))& 

)1 &  !

1 &    !  ! *   !  & )) ! )  &*+

(

 &)) ! & & '*2

9#



  + 

 )

 2

* ,

(( .(

 0 (

  &

 1(

 )*

() &&)!

 ! & 7

:! &     &     )  ,

 -!  !    )

(

 )*

!+& 2

9%$)))

)

2

*,

((.(

 0

(

 &)

&

) *'!),

-!  * */%)

.888 * ) /$"/#0 !&  ;   ; &)  *

) &* ) & : &)

;%&''



 ! ) 

 ";"66  & ) *   1  .0  ,



-!1:&).888*)#%"#0? *(

 )*

();

 *  )) &&)&)+) 1

!' *&''

+



&'

 +1! ) 

)

2

*,

((.(

 0) &

 ,

 -! ) &) + &   .  !* )*

  &  

(

  & 1(

 )*

!

0!!)2

9#

)*

!:! &  * &  !!)2

9%/ 2

9$;

9$'*+*& (

 &)! 

  ! )   ) &)  * 

 * > 

 )

 2

* ,

((

.(

 0(

 !



::& ! !

& ! (

 !

!)*& 

)&*   ()1   )+ )) ! * 1 (

  &* ! 

(

 )*





 *&''

& ))*2

9;)1

9%%%)

9%%