Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-14984/8 AI generated

2-05-14984/8 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-05-14984/8
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

              

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-14984/8 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:               

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

     

      !" #  !



          $%&$'&($$)*+#      (,$-,./'0/                       

$'&.$&($$1           2 3 4 5       ./&$0&($$)          4  67 2  3  6" .$'())(1 !!--,.1 ,*8# 7 " " "!#&

 67 *  9  6" ::::::::::: :::::;;;,;  4":::::::::;,;; ,*8#  ",

!"7 4 "&  ! "#!$

%        &'()&(*&&+     ,    ,-       .     /000000000001(  , -             &'()&(*&&+    (    , .            -       ) '23 45   5    5  6  (          -  .             7& -,

      ,     8     -,         

     ( 9      .    

  ! :*); (7       

      5

  (

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

(&  !   # 6& & /(,/%7   "  4  8   "! ""& 

    4  #    $.&$.&($$- + !" ==#+ 4 # +  4!== 4& + " 4  #  + !" == 4  ==#" !   "&  %&$'&.$&($$1 "   .74 # + !"== 4 +4!5" > (74 # + !"== 4 +44==   $%&$%&($$%> %7 !+#8 !88"4 -01$> /7+"== 4"!4 !!4"$%&$%&($$-, $)&$1&($$-8 "!> -7 !+#8 == 45"  +4!@#0$)$ ##4 !!##!.$0- +44#4"!( 1--&  +"  # " 8 +  #!" ==! +4 !  5!+&  +  # " == 4 4  #    $.&.(&($$/  $)&$1&($$- 8 85 #! # !  " 67 D/(% &(    4+"     4"5  "# ## == 4  !  A #!&# "+ "! 5!  == 4 ! #+4"!&      #" #" 4 " 4  ! @ &  #8    #+== 4  #8  4 # + !"==#+ 4& 

+ +" 6 G7 D1%- &.    ==#+ 4 " !88 #  !#! & GD1.'858" 4@68"7 ##  4  !     68""7 " 68! 8"7 8""!!   4"&8"5#  ==#+ 48"" ! !  !    !88 # !4& #+" 4  #   4" !@@ ==    " !88 #  ! #! #"5"#+! !@@+ !! " "       4  #    + !" # +  4    !!==#+ 4#"8" 4&   D0 85  #"    4  ! @    4 " + !" == 4#8"#=="+"#4"#+4  !4 "+ !"  4&  D. == 4===="#  4!  == 5 ! =="  " ==" !      =="  5 !! ==  ==    " !   4   44  # 4 "#+ "8"==!"& 4== 4# +  48! "4+ <  "55 4 ==4>!885==! #>!5==#">   5==!#>5 

#+ !>  ==" #   #"  ==      5  &

# &%,(,.,%,$-8"#  "! @  !  ==  5  "  + ==  ==" #  + # !  !88 ==#"   "==" +!  #" "#  == # !88& * ==  ==" + # ! !885== 4 +# +  4& 3 #  4&%4&. #+"4 "!6!@@ ==7&44&(  "!@@"#"5"!"&44&.  4"8!5"==A4&( 8!==! &""4"#" " 85 #+ #48 !@@ ==" !       !!  # !88&   "==4!88==!#!==#" "==!# #4 #  ! ! == 4 & 

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

!4 & 8"# +@4  (1'$!  4 #8 !+(1--&  == 45"  +4!!+!@##8  !! 4  !! 0$)$  ! #5 == 4  "   !  &  # "   ==#" !" ! 4"   "=="!&  <-       .8 ,      /&  4 5 4 5    8" 6& & .-1,.-' .))7 @" !$'&.$&($$1+ "!8!&      !  8 " +  !   +""  "& ## A " "!   & 3 " 44"5!@@"&!" 4 + !" 4 # "   #! 5+8! 6 GD0 &.(7& 3   + 44 + !"# + ==#+ 4! 6!@@ "7& "    +8   4  #   " + !" ==#+ 4      4  # " 4   " !+ ! 4   "    #!"A@@ #+#" !# " #" !# !"&+"+"" " 4 8"8 4&

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

+4+"!"" &==#" ! "4 #+  4+"!&  D1%. &. #+54 5"@#8 !!   4+5 +! !  #+  4 !  #!   #  "  +"   6 D1-(7   4 !   !!#&  -&4 5!#6& .01,.0)784 5 "!! $'&.$&($$1!!& 

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

4 5#8" !858!& 

  + 4 5 #8"     4 "   "  44"!== 4 !& 

D. == 4====" 4!  ==5 ! =="  " ==" !      =="  5 !! == ==" ! 4  44 # 4" #+ "8"==!"&  3  #     #"    @   " #    + !"  4  4  !@@ == !     #! 4  "" !" 5"" #!/I*+#&  3  #  $.&$.&($$- + !"   4 &%  "5 8!  D(1 &. 8" !"!"<.74 "!">(7== 4+ !! ==== !C$.&$.&($$->%78 == 4C%.&.(&($$->/7 !,#+!#+# A+""==@  "C!@@==>-7 == !  #+ 4" C # ! /I # 5"> 17 4 !"C.$$$6!!" !3 D( &)8"4   !!887!#! 48# >)7==!C8!5" ==A'&$$,.'&$$&.$"48#>07== 4 +4!!8"C 4 #+5 8  +4" 4   44  #+       5 44&.,'8""    ! ! @8" #+" +44! 5"&    4 &%   !" ==" !      == !  ==#+  !" 4      " 4 &% ==#+ 4&  ==! ==" 4"  4"!  #+"  !==&   + ""   4" !"   ! " == 4    ""#"  "! 8"&  ==  " " !88!  == # 4"!  #5 ==" 6==,4"D.(D./7&        " "!"  == # 4"!   4 5  "  " !@@"" # +  ##    ! @  !   6& & .($ .(( .(/,.(-7 !" @  48#    !  "  == #5"    " @ "     !"     ! == 8"     !@!& 4 5 #8"     !  8"   "  @ "" "!#""!5==A8 4@!5 @"  4&/$  4&/.  !  4+"" !     == #! "+"" "#88&  @! 4 5#8"   ==#" ! $)&$1&($$-    4+""    ==#" !   ==! #!!  ! +"& ==#" ! $)&$1&($$-     +"       8 #  !  ! #" "&  ==! #!!  ! +" 8 ! ! $'&.$&($$1  85 #!   5! +"&  !$'&.$&($$1!8"5+"

L%0)$1..((%)M !  5    "! 3KK  6& & ./. .'07&  + "  L/)($%%.()00M 6& & .'' ($1 -0 // 7& !" 584 5 !## D//)84""&  4 5 "!8! 5 #8 !+ # ! "8! ""!"D% $.&$.&($$1 "  D1$ &. D1$ &0  D1. &.    #   4+"" 4 !  +5 !!.'/)## ./&$0&($$) # &%00N$)& 

 "  !   "   DD1-.,1-/ D1-) &. 4&. D110 &.D1)$ &.&         # !