Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-03-29/20 AI generated

2-03-29/20 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-03-29/20
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-03-29/20 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:  )$()5..($# 5       )) (  $)   $  (4   (  )2.   $)5)   $($/ ( 5     (53. (#(($#(( )2. $(4)#0(( $ )4.() )$)(    **-  ( 5   $ )(.() 5(  ; - ) 5$ (#)5. 0# .#(((( . $ )(.()5( ;-&)&3 8 ) 5 $#) #). 2$#))54.0 .  4$ .)22(#(( (3     )( ( ) ) 5 $#) )  $ )(.() 5(  ; - )* (  )  . )( ( $  )) #5 ()5 $/)4.# (. (  5   ( )5 )  &%%*%6%6 4/ )5 3 (    1 )..   )5 .0 .   #).(53 ) ) 5 $(( ). $() 1 ).. ()5 $/)4.# (. 4)( 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

       

     

        !"#$   

  %&% '( $ )  %* !+,  

           ! "##  $%  & %% %

(-!.// .())#0(.        

 1)...// 23 4) .() '()*+, &

 -!.#-.-## / %     %  $    . &   $            %#!#1"'      2 0   %# 33"           2     %   0$  %2     45!!# 0  / %%/ %2   .     %%.    $6       

 %      .   4 ()%"/ $ 4 (*&5% () $)5(4 ()%"/ $ )  $( *!!6-*63     #5 7 .((5 $#)$ )  ( 5 ) ))$(8 ).('5  5))$ &&3#4)) 3"/ $8)(*!4 "/ $8)(6*,4  $ (. ((.(4/(. (  (4  ()%"/ $ )  $( )(     .((5 ).5 (5 1 () ). )5. )   4 4 (4 (()( )) (  5%  ( --&.// 4)/2 $(. )).5  (40))1()).  5%  ( * & .//  5(    4  (())  ( $ )4 (4 ()%"/ $ )  (4 1 () ).   (  ( $ )4 )/2 $(. ) ).5  (40))()%"/ $) 





 ( *! .//  4/(  1 () ).  2 5%  (* &.// 0) )5.(4(.// .(.(  (*! ( )( ()%"/ $) 4(()).() (4 40)(4()(1()).4()%"/ $) $/)4 .# () 5 )(*!!66!93*6     ()%"/ $ 4 (**-.()$)5 ()2. (3 44()%"/ $) #).  5**-.0 . )0 3. )))(0)5 )00  5  )55 (% 4 ($/) 5 $ 5)5 4$#)$  .0 .  4)2. (/)$( $ )4()%"/ $) 4 1()).$(40) ()2. .()$($#((  (4()%"/ $) .*! 4) $(#(.())#0(.   (41)..'1()).# 4/ ):5()*-6%*-9,,.9*-  4)  (() $($/ ( 5 .() )#0(.   ()    (53  5 0) $/)4 .# ( .())5 .. &--3   3  (4) 05$5 (5 4 

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

7 .((5.(-!.// 0) (.// 2(41).. 2  (4 ) 23 ( .//   0#45.( 4 25) 3  .())5 $/)4.# (.( 4/(. )  2# (  )5(5 .()#   . 2  (4 ./  23((54))2)5. ) **-( 5 $ )(.() 5(   ; - )*   #(23 (  $# 2 (4 #5) .() )#0(.  .//  4)( $/)4 .# ( (4 ()53 $/)4  $(5  3   4 )22  ((#((3((4#5 )55 /)$) 4)   ) .// 2  (4  4 #( )55 // 2  (4$ (2( $) $ )(.()5( ;-&)* ) 23((54)  )5(4 ) )( (.//  )55$# .) ) 5 $(( 8 .(4)3(40)5$#)$$/)4#5. ((4()() 5 )(3  .5 .// 2  (4( ) 5 $#)  1 )..   ) 5  )$

 & (.() $/)() $#)  ( (5   ) 23 (   2# (  )/(5  ()5 ( &%%*%6%6 // 2  (4 0)2 (8 (5 .( .//  ) )(3  .())5 $/)4.# (.(4/(.  (.// 3. )).# (4)(1).. .())5..&--3   

 ( &&! .//  $#(  .// 2 .() 4 5(  .()) ()35(/(4.// 2( $)5.   4 . ! $( 02 .// 2( 0#45.( 4 0)2  4/((

)5.(3    )3 (  4 4 ()%"/ $ )  $) #). (5 .0 . )0   / ()($ ((5 .# ( (/ (. 3 . )) (4/ 4) )2 4  ( ()%"/ $ )  4 1 ).. $( 1 ).. (   .((5 (/ (. / ()($(/ (. ).5  0)(  (4  ()%"/ $  )  . *-! $( #(2 .// 2 (55 $/ 5( 4 ) 23 ( .// 2 () )55 4 0 5  ()%"/ $ )  .0 . )0  #). . ) 4  ( )2. )  $(. $# .)  1 ).. #(.())5  .( 0)51)...0 . )0 0)3 .  (4/(( )( (.)554   ()%"/ $) ) 23((5 4 . )1).. ) 5 $#) ($((5  // 2  5(   *!!  .(  )((% (  (/   )) 4 ( 4.().   () 

  (  -!   4  (((   ( $ )   .()  $ )(.()5( ;-&&)$# )6(((.  

(--!.// 4/( 1)...// 2 )5.( 45( )5.   () (.// )( #(.// 20#45(  3 (($5  /)$  .// 2  .( 4) 53 ) 23 (  .( .//  )) )(5) 3()2) )((8 (54))$# .)  (.//   ($)(   $ )(.()  5(   ;  -6   )5(  ( .// 2.(). )0))(  .()(/((((3 (50(8 ( 4.// 2).( ()(  (   ($)(   $ )(.()  5(   ;  -6*  )*  ( )) 2  0))(  

 .(.((5) (40#45((8 3. ))0)5 $(5  /)$( $ )4(41)..$ 5)(5.(-! .// 8) )(:.())5$/)4.# (.(4/(.    $ )4  .()  )#0(.        )  .()) 5  .(  .// ( $ 5)(53. (#(())()2.(.// 4/((.(.( 



 5)(($    (.// (    4/(5  0)(  .())5  (/   )( 55 5$ (  ()5 )( $ )4 &%%*%6%63. )))(3    8  ) 5 $#) (  (/ 52  $#))54)  (3        ( () ) 5 $#) ))(#5()5$/)4.# (. (   #(.(.// (550#45(1).. .())5$/)4.# (.(4/(.   /)$( $ )4.( 4) 5$44()%"/ $) $)#). (5 .0 .  )0 '5()*66%*6!,0&-)(4//$5 .((5( $ )$ 5) (5# ()555 5  )(5))4//$544()%"/ $) ()555 5  ) .((5.0 .  )0  )#).(5(5( $ )4( (4:1 )..  ($)( **-( 5 $ )(.()5( ;-)*$# 2   (4  #5)  .()  )#0(.   .//   4)(  $/)4  .# (  (4 ()53$/)4 $(5 3 4)22 ((#((3((4#5

)55  /)$)4) )(41)..4#( )55       #(  .(  .//   0#45(  1  ).. .())5$/)4.# (.(4/(. (3. 05(2) 5 $((( 4)3(40)5 ..$/)4.# (. () 5 )(3 )( ) 5 $((  )5.  ))    #(2    .// 2  (4 ) 5 $((( )$# .) ($(5(.// 3. )))#0(( ( $ )4.() ()) 5 $((40)($ 5(5()0 ( %*&* )0 ( *&-'5()*9!%* ,3. ))0!40 )(2 )..45  '1 ()  ).# )),$((((.4 8)(5  $( (3( )).##( (54(.( 5.(/ ) $(3 ( 25  .)  (<<3   ((5  (.  4#).53 4$# 5  4  (  8(. 5  $4)   .5   $#   (  .      (.( 5.(3  $( (4( )).##( (5 .5 4

(. 30*)( $)52 )..45  (  0 $(  ) . 5  0)(  ((5  4    ( ()%"/ $)( 4.' ()%"/ $ 4# )),$()(5 . 5  =4*** 6)0 ( * '5()*%*!,3. ))0!40* )5)0)$ 5(5)0 0( 530 )( ) %)).'  ()).# )),.(( .5 $#  (  . ((. 3 (. (8$ ( ($)(40)( ((5&*&# 5 )' 5()*9-,  )5/)$( $ )4 $((5$#)$..*!!6-*63   8 ).(5 5 0 55 $((54(

2 . ( 5 0 55 ( . )5  $(  $5 5 0 554(

2 .  (( 1%) ()).3 $)5 5 0 55( ( 4 %()%"/ $ 4 $($)(#). (5)0  * 0*$ .)))  ($)(  **-  4#(5   $ )(.()  5(   4  / (.() 5(  5. 5;&)5( .((554#(. (

 )((5.()0).())54(. )45 5).// . )  ( 5 $ )(.()5( /((((  ($)( **-( 5 $ )(.()5( ;-)*$# 2   (4  #5)  .()  )#0(.   .//   4)(  .# (  $/)4  (4 ()53$/)4 $(5 3 4)22 ((#((3((4#5

)55  /)$( $ )4 )(41)..4#( )55  (41)...() (5(()()5'# 2 )5, $/)4.# (. 4)( $%()(5'5()*-3*- %*!,.. &--3    02 .((5..(0#45(4$4) ()5  1))(5  ))  ) 2  3 (  .// 2    0#45(5  4  )2

)5. )(.// ()2) )((8 (5 4)(.# ($/)41 )..0)(/)$( $ )4(50#45(54$4) 5()5 # 2 (..&--3  '5()*- %*!,  4 55)(5(4 $ )(.()5( ;&&)3; ---)4;--!        (