Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-07-24316/8 AI generated

2-07-24316/8 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-07-24316/8
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

#"!, ()  %"#+++&1+2"&  "+"%""+ 2"'%"#"#'""'" "'#+ >7##+!%2"& "+">#&  ! 2"&%#"#"%#,"2"&# ' *!"#" "' 2#+ "" "' 1"++  2#+. %1# '1" # "#"'"'1"> "+ "#"'" + 1+  "#" ""#  % %+ + """ ' " # """ %11!  "  +  > 7 #& 4 #, " 2"&  % "& % " #  %+#" # #'# %", ! % '""'", "+ " "#% "  1' ::+"#%"#","#2"& "'#+  5%" "#+" + 1'# "+" ( )    % 2"' #& # %!  # , "+ "'#+ "" ## 0%"# / +#"  "+"+""'"#++1 '1"2"&% ""%% % &""%"&,"+'#&"" '"+#+,11" () 1"+'#"#&7", "+ %+ +  " %+ $#&" '#+ '"+ "& 1'& '#&+# '' '""'" ', " 2"& % 2'  !%" "#+"&,%""'#!"+ () +" % #"" % #"'"+"% )  3  +#" &' 1"2"&  "+" #+"#% 2"'%"#"# "'#+""","++ %""'+"# %#"'#&"%""&   "#&"&!%" "#+"#"'"+" ( )    %""+"#" "" 9 >  #  %"# #+"# "& +  2# 1""  , "##  11! , " +  2# 1"" + '%#" # 2'"" 5%" "#+  "+  % #+ ', "## #  %" "#+"  4 " % 2'"' #+ 7 , 4 " *# 0.  #"!,  '+ %" #+"::,::%,#!11%"# "#+"# 2#1""4"%#2'""7 , 4"  9>4#&%1&"! "#&"# "# #+%&"%#+#9"%%#"+1'# ()  +'+ "&&+#"+'+"+%"#+"'1#%"%#2'"" "' '#   >  ! 2"& #"'"+"%"+ " # "'#+ %# " #"'"+"' 2"& ' " %1 '##+% "&"  #+"/ '#&"#  "'#+ "# " # # '"#'#&"#' +"#%1 "##&/9>#&  #   + "# #&"# "  %" "#+"   "#"",  #&" '1#% '#&" ' % '#+, '" "& % ###"" %+/ "+>!%"##+"# "& +  ?""""" 7 11   >  #& 7 # '#&" '#+ ## #&+ "# # "# &"& " '1#% # '"!  %" #+"  % 2'"'+ #+ '1#% " ""&" '+"%1&"#@%"#+"%2'"'+#+'""#%"#+"  '" "# 2'"'+ #+, "+ "  " 2#  " *##& +1++.>#& #'"!2'"'+#+ 11 !2#, "## + #+ &! # # " # %" #+

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-24316/8 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus: #"!, ()  %"#+++&1+2"&  "+"%""+ 2"'%"#"#'""'" "'#+ >7##+!%2"& "+">#&  ! 2"&%#"#"%#,"2"&# ' *!"#" "' 2#+ "" "' 1"++  2#+. %1# '1" # "#"'"'1"> "+ "#"'" + 1+  "#" ""#  % %+ + """ ' " # """ %11!  "  +  > 7 #& 4 #, " 2"&  % "& % " #  %+#" # #'# %", ! % '""'", "+ " "#% "  1' ::+"#%"#","#2"& "'#+  5%" "#+" + 1'# "+" ( )    % 2"' #& # %!  # , "+ "'#+ "" ## 0%"# / +#"  "+"+""'"#++1 '1"2"&% ""%% % &""%"&,"+'#&"" '"+#+,11" () 1"+'#"#&7", "+ %+ +  " %+ $#&" '#+ '"+ "& 1'& '#&+# '' '""'" ', " 2"& % 2'  !%" "#+"&,%""'#!"+ () +" % #"" % #"'"+"% )  3  +#" &' 1"2"&  "+" #+"#% 2"'%"#"# "'#+""","++ %""'+"# %#"'#&"%""&   "#&"&!%" "#+"#"'"+" ( )    %""+"#" "" 9 >  #  %"# #+"# "& +  2# 1""  , "##  11! , " +  2# 1"" + '%#" # 2'"" 5%" "#+  "+  % #+ ', "## #  %" "#+"  4 " % 2'"' #+ 7 , 4 " *# 0.  #"!,  '+ %" #+"::,::%,#!11%"# "#+"# 2#1""4"%#2'""7 , 4"  9>4#&%1&"! "#&"# "# #+%&"%#+#9"%%#"+1'# ()  +'+ "&&+#"+'+"+%"#+"'1#%"%#2'"" "' '#   >  ! 2"& #"'"+"%"+ " # "'#+ %# " #"'"+"' 2"& ' " %1 '##+% "&"  #+"/ '#&"#  "'#+ "# " # # '"#'#&"#' +"#%1 "##&/9>#&  #   + "# #&"# "  %" "#+"   "#"",  #&" '1#% '#&" ' % '#+, '" "& % ###"" %+/ "+>!%"##+"# "& +  ?""""" 7 11   >  #& 7 # '#&" '#+ ## #&+ "# # "# &"& " '1#% # '"!  %" #+"  % 2'"'+ #+ '1#% " ""&" '+"%1&"#@%"#+"%2'"'+#+'""#%"#+"  '" "# 2'"'+ #+, "+ "  " 2#  " *##& +1++.>#& #'"!2'"'+#+ 11 !2#, "## + #+ &! # # " # %" #+

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

     

         

   

       !"#$%                 

         "## "&"     '#&" ()

#".      0&"#  !" #$   # + "# ( ) 

&" 

 %"# "#+"#      #"'"+"+ ( )      %# "# # " 11 %" $!+     1  ( )   &"""%" "#+"  11 ( )    +"+ "+% 1 1"2"& #"'"+"" )  3  *""+

 $1#%"%"#+"4*""+"2+'""." *"#+!+1+.

"+2+."% 4"*"#+!+1+. (8

 * . '+"  $1#%"%"#+"7 *+2+2." % 4" #"+# () *#"'"+""#."&+"#%#""#%

 9"## "'#+++#"'1#%+5#"+ +++ 

11 &""#%  "+"#      

11 #  "&"+11! "## " 1' %# # 11 1""  "&#   $ %+5%"#+"%#2'""'"!"+11! 1' %# # 11 1""  "&#   $ %+  %&$#&'&!("  # "  9"'#+#" () 1"&""# 2"& " &'#+ "+% "+::#+#&"22 () % %  '#&'  % ##""#, " ",  )    ( ::%   5 &#;"""''&""5#+1;"," "+ #!+ #+ & +   &", #  +   5 2#+704 &"'""#%0<4"+# + () %11"#"'"+"%)33"'"+""#1"&#&, ()

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

  % 2"' "+" # #& %! "#%#   #  ( )   %"#+"#1"+"> 1+

 * .  2# 5#   " 1"+" > 7 #& 4, "  % #""& " '""'"## "'#+ () %#""&% #"'"+"%)3"# 2"'%"#"#"+'""'"#1"2"& "'#+ *'#+ "" # ## #. " 0 "+

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

# "+ +" 1!,  '#&"# " %1 ' "# #+ / '#&" %+&'    &" # +/ ' &"'"" % %2'""#"+#"#&/"#! ()

*#"'"+""#. "## + "'1#%#&"  9 > 7 #&  #, " "# "#!,  '#&" % %%""'"&,1&"!+#+"%""'# ;22"#" "" '#&" '" %""+"#" "" '#&" %&" #"" #  ""#"#'"#  

 4* .

#"!, ()  %"#+++&1+2"&  "+"%""+ 2"'%"#"#'""'" "'#+ >7##+!%2"& "+">#&  ! 2"&%#"#"%#,"2"&# ' *!"#" "' 2#+ "" "' 1"++  2#+. %1# '1" # "#"'"'1"> "+ "#"'" + 1+  "#" ""#  % %+ + """ ' " # """ %11!  "  +  > 7 #& 4 #, " 2"&  % "& % " #  %+#" # #'# %", ! % '""'", "+ " "#% "  1' ::+"#%"#","#2"& "'#+  5%" "#+" + 1'# "+" ( )    % 2"' #& # %!  # , "+ "'#+ "" ## 0%"# / +#"  "+"+""'"#++1 '1"2"&% ""%% % &""%"&,"+'#&"" '"+#+,11" () 1"+'#"#&7", "+ %+ +  " %+ $#&" '#+ '"+ "& 1'& '#&+# '' '""'" ', " 2"& % 2'  !%" "#+"&,%""'#!"+ () +" % #"" % #"'"+"% )  3  +#" &' 1"2"&  "+" #+"#% 2"'%"#"# "'#+""","++ %""'+"# %#"'#&"%""&   "#&"&!%" "#+"#"'"+" ( )    %""+"#" "" 9 >  #  %"# #+"# "& +  2# 1""  , "##  11! , " +  2# 1"" + '%#" # 2'"" 5%" "#+  "+  % #+ ', "## #  %" "#+"  4 " % 2'"' #+ 7 , 4 " *# 0.  #"!,  '+ %" #+"::,::%,#!11%"# "#+"# 2#1""4"%#2'""7 , 4"  9>4#&%1&"! "#&"# "# #+%&"%#+#9"%%#"+1'# ()  +'+ "&&+#"+'+"+%"#+"'1#%"%#2'"" "' '#   >  ! 2"& #"'"+"%"+ " # "'#+ %# " #"'"+"' 2"& ' " %1 '##+% "&"  #+"/ '#&"#  "'#+ "# " # # '"#'#&"#' +"#%1 "##&/9>#&  #   + "# #&"# "  %" "#+"   "#"",  #&" '1#% '#&" ' % '#+, '" "& % ###"" %+/ "+>!%"##+"# "& +  ?""""" 7 11   >  #& 7 # '#&" '#+ ## #&+ "# # "# &"& " '1#% # '"!  %" #+"  % 2'"'+ #+ '1#% " ""&" '+"%1&"#@%"#+"%2'"'+#+'""#%"#+"  '" "# 2'"'+ #+, "+ "  " 2#  " *##& +1++.>#& #'"!2'"'+#+ 11 !2#, "## + #+ &! # # " # %" #+

 * . ;22"#" "" '% & 1"!# ="# %#+# #! " %" #+"  % 2'"" #+  '1#% %1&"#@ #+ & 7 , 4 " *##&+1++." (8%%"#+" 0,4"*##&+1++." '1#%""&" '+" 9"#  '+,  % #""& " # "+ "&&# "'#+ #"!,2#%11+%"#+"7 , 4"#! '1#%"#"+#'#&"# () %#"'"+"%#)3 /)3" ####''"#+*#.  911"2"&#"'"+""#!11 () +"+"+%)3, ++##"%#"#*#. 

"@