Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-07-19564/1 AI generated

2-07-19564/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-07-19564/1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated



Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-19564/1 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval: 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text





            

     !" #$" "%%!

       &&&

 !  ''!%" !& !() ")%" (**!% *  

    

  + ,( "  "- $%- "*." !" *!* (!(" *      * $/" -* !*.*(" * !. !("* !"0"%*

 1"--* 23 +*- * 4*3".%" !*%* *!*%* %-!$ /". * $*! "" ( 5&& $*! " !&  3& * 6 27 8  %.&66 8  3& 66   8  %.& 6 8  %.& 6  %.& 9- ( * $/" -* !*.*("* !. " !"0"%*&

     

 *" %* *- "*$!$&     

 ! !"0"  ,%%" &&&& ( *. !" + ,( "  "- $%- "*." !" *!* (!(" * ( * $/" -* !*.*(" *   8  %.& 3& % *% '%* 3-*$%* !"%*&

 * (!""$"-*  *%! * "! + ,( "  "- *." !"3"-)%* $%- *- "*." !" *!* (!(" * & /%*( -*$%- * !!%*!" (%. -* !*.*(" ! 3/"") * *-! "" ""!(" * ! ) %" !" -*$%- *%* 3/"") *- *-! ""-&  8 5 %.& 3&  *%!  3/"") (!("*  "* 3-*$ * & 9 8  %.&  *%! )/ !0 3/"") (!(" * !  $ !$ -* !*.*(" *% "*." !" *& "*." !"%* * "!!$%* $%- *%* 3*0 %" (  "* !  * 3/"") (!(" * !6  "*  %* 3!%%" $/" %*! 3!%%" ) 3/"") * !* !"&

-*$%- *%* %" !-  "* !  * ! !$%!  3/"") (!(" * !  * $ ! $/!- :;! 9: *." !"- 556  ! <!%)*6 ! " "."" & *." !"3"-)%* %" !"

%"!")%"   $//-(" * %*3".6 ("%%* % *% :;! 9: (- + ,( "  "-  & <"(*!!-   $//-(" * %*3". %" /%("!- ! " ".""." ". (/%*(- %*3".3%*- %"- ! " ".""." *." !"!- "'".-&





"$/-  8   %.&  *%! 3*$-

$//-(" *  ! !*". )  ! !*". %*( !"% *%! !/* !!- ". * "!!- %*3". *- $("/*! )."!- *" %-6   !"0" %*3".3%!*  ! ) %*3". /%("(" * ! $* !-* 2 8

%.&6 ) 8  %.&6 !."*-* *" %*6 *! !*".%* !%*0 %-- !*" * ""." /". !&

 

 6 $-- %0" * "!!- (!*)%"-6  0 *" %*6 *! "'".  !* $//-(" * !*". !* !%*0 !-  )%-*% %-- 2* !" /". !&

23 +*- * 4*3".%" !*%* *!*%* %-!$ /". * $*! "" ( 5&& $*! " !&  3& *  *%! *" %"** $*! "" * "!!- %%" ""("- )""-"%" * " " !* %-!$ /". * !* 6 & )""-"%" * " "  !(" *6 /". $/"(* ) *." !"(" *. *-$ !* &

27 8  %.&  *%! %-! * )""-"%" *%* " "%* %-! * *%%* ""." /". !6 ("%%*  *%! !   !!-& " )""-"%" ! " "! )"! * !*.*%"%! 2* !" $/" !*( 3/"!*.*$ !"(0 2* !" 6 %-! * )""-"%" *%* " "%* 2* !" /". ! 27 8  %.& & 27 8 

 *%! (! * )""-"%" *%* " "%* %-!$ /". * % *% (%. )""-"%" * " " /". $/"(*! ) )""-"%" * " " .*"- 3-!$- ' "( *-& 2*%!- ! !%**$%! !%*0 2* !" *." !"!- )""-"%" * " " /". $/"(*! ) .*"- 3-!$!* ' "( !* %-- 2* !" /". !&

+ ,( "  "- $%-  !- (%. "'". 3/"") (!(" *%*6 *&  "* /". * !* !(" *%* ) *%%* /". * !$ (!(" *%* %(-!*%* " "!*%* "*." !" $*- *%&

 + 8  %.&  *%! !*"0 */". %" )""-"%" * " " /". $/"(* *- *. *!!*!- *." !" * -(" * !&  8  %.& 3&  *%! * "!! * "'".  !(" *% *." !"3"-)%*  "* $*%"*  !(" %*3".&  "%" *(%* $//-(" *% !-  ! !*". )  ! !*". 3*$- %*(  8   %.&  *%! !"% *%! !/* !!-&

 8 5 %.& )   *%!   "- "'". /.*( )!"(" ." &  8 5 %.& 3&  *%!  3/"") (!("*  "* 3-*$ * & . $- 3/"") (!(" * /". !  !- " "-6 *  "(*!!- /". * !* !(" * )% *%%* "'".  "- !"% *%! !/* !!-  !(" %*3". $/"

$//-(" %*3". % *%&  8  %.&  *%! )/ !0 3/"") (!(" * !  $ !$ -* !*.*(" *% "*." !" *&

2*%!- ! !%**$%! !%*0 2* !" *." !"!- "'".  "/". * !* !(" *6 & 3/"") (!(" *6 !* %-- 2* !" /". !6 "$/- *%%"*  "/". * !* !("*  ! * *%! *!- "'". ."!* ) /". $/"(*. = (-*!- 3/""" ""!! *  "*  %*6 " "'". /.*"( )!"(" ." !  *. ) * "!! * *%%*%* /". %" !*- * -(" * )/ !(" * *." !"3"-)%*&

(!" !"(0 * "!!- (!*)%"-*  *%! + ,( "  "- 3/"!*.*$ 2* !" ,0""." 6 4*(%6 ,( " $%% &

 8   *%!  *!!*$/!)  !!- *." !"3"-)%* * "!( -* % * %*$- ) *- * !* !!- (- -(*-"-6 (!" %%")"-" *-& 9%%")"-" *- 3*$- %*( !"% *%! ""!!-& *." !"3"-) $/"0 *!!*$/!)%! /-

!"*-$"- -(*!*6 " -  $)%"- -* % * %*$!*  )%-* $%) *%."!(" * &

<"(*!!- !!* ! !%**$%! %" *." !"3"-)



/". !!- ' "( + ,( "  "- -*$%- !* %*-(" * "'".%! -(*!*6 (" !/*- "- :;! 9: /". ! + ,( "  "- " " !  !* !*.*(" * &

2 "!!- (!*)%"-* ! !06 *! :;! 9: *" * "!- 2* !" /". *%*  8   %.& !* !!- $("/*!*%* $ !$! %*3".!6 ("%%* % *% ! + ,( "  "-

(- &

"$/-    %!-. *" %*6 *! 2* !" *." !"!- ) 3' "$! !*.*$ ! ($ "'".

(-(" * ". *%%* % *%  "/". !* !* !(" * !* !%*0 %-- 2* !" /". !6 !%*0 2* !" /". ! %--

:;! 9: 3%! + ,( "  "-

(-(" * ) " " /". !*6 & 3/"") (!("*6 !* !(" * !* 6 $!(!  )%%*6 *! "" :;! 9: "

$//-) %"- (/%*(- ! " ".""." *." !"!- "'".- ". !*". $(" !!" (!" ! " ".""." &

2* !" /". * %-("* 2* !" *." !"!- "'".!*. ) "*." !" *!*. *-$!* !"(".!* !*  (%. %%"* "'". ."!* $/"(%" ! "$""%$ !! * ) "*." !" $%-!- !*0*  %- $  * !.(" * 6 * ! $/"(%-0 /""-*% /". * 0)*!"-*% - 2* !" )" -"! ""%* %%!!- "'".!*. *-$ /". * ! !*$*! '* ! %%" !6  !(! *"- $* !( $/"(%"* !*" !* """-* /". * ! !%**$!* *"  !*.& <"(*!! !"0

! "$""%"0* !0""%  * !.(" * (" "'".!*. *-$   &

"$/-  ) *" % %-(" *%* !*" * ""." /". 6 3-0

% ( * $/" -* !*.*(" * '%*-(" * 3-*$%* !"%*& 2*%!- % *% ) )"--*   8  %.& !%*0 ( * $/" -* !*.*("* - !. " !"0"%*&

 /%   8  %.& )/ !0 * %*$ ( *%%* !!*!"(*!(" * ! $/" !*!$ !*.*(" * ! *. %*   8  %.&  *%! *- "*$!$&

#$" "%%! !"