Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-03-118/6 AI generated

2-03-118/6 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-03-118/6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

              

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-03-118/6 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:               

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

     

        !"  #!  !$ !   

            %&'()'*((+,-$ 

    *.(/.%%& 

   " 0  1 !" ! $  22!3 !-3 44"3!)56) 37$%*+*6-"     

%*'()'*(()          

 1 !"!3!!8        *9'(6'*((+              3!!:; 1 !" ! <" %(99+   #= %/ $ ! ".  "> 3!!"!3!" !?$@

:; " 0 <" AAAAAAAAAAA !AA.AA !!4! ".  ">    !" #     !$"%&"$%%&" $" '( ) *       "    #!"!"!"'         3! $-8 " 8

! /( 34$ !  ! 4 !  "  34 $  22"   $!! $'  B *%& ! / ! $-8 !! !   !"  " $!"  ! 7 $""$" $"!'

$!  B )+% ! 6 !8 8

 * 4"    $8   !'

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

 !  ! 3! $!  22!3 -!"'   "  22"!(%'(9'%99+ 4"!1 !"! !!(+'%('%99+'"22!!!!!' 3"22!3 $-22!'  !$-!1 !"!! - 7$!"$-!"7!"4" "!!',!7$"4487!"!' 447$' ""224" 22D'  #3"-!$" $-  !!!38'   $4"    22 3 4  !  3! -""'  3-2222!3!!!1.#" 223 !(%'(/'%99&422'22!3!!-3"!!*&'()'*((*'   

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

!-$"3!$!22'$4" ! !"-*( $44 $4!"E'  " 22!3! -! '  4 - 4!3 22  !"! !8'$4" 3!$!! !!33!!! $!3!-!'

 6        %)'43!!8"'$""'     -+    %+'    !" 4 !!"  $" $! !" !" !87!$-! !48$!'  %&' "$"!!!7! 3!$!!22!3!'  %9' 3!!8$4"3!"-"4!34 " -"8-" !!"8-4!"3!$!22 !!3-""'!!"B55*!'&4" !- $$!87"$-! !48$!'  *('3-"$!!"-""<'!%*).%*+> !!!!8!" -"3!$!22' $!" "" !" ! 22  ! %('(9'%99+   7!34!<'!'%>' !"  "" !! !"8   -""   4!$"   "3"H'!'/5./& /9 5% 9*<#'7!"> 96.9+ %%(' "-""-""3!$!$4"$22!%('(9'%99+'  *%'!22!3 3!$!22!!34 !7!4!%('(9'%99+ !"!' 22!3!" "34! 7!3'  '!!<'!'%+)>434!"!"E <!3 -!  22" $!  3! ! >' , !7!""!""E"!"'

"!3!$!!! !(9'(5'%99&!' IB%&(!'%!7 "887' 1 !" ! 3- <   '!' *&.*9> 43!   !! ! 7!""  !  3- 3' 5'% 8 7    8 7  $! 3'5'*874$!!'

 !8    3! !"" !" 3!    !$4"$!344""7!""$"! E" 4  !! 4 22!3 !! !  ! !  ! $-!'  3E! 7! 4 3 4   $4!"!E"3" !!!"' ! (&'()'%99) -"  B + 3'%( 4  !   "!   !!' !!22!3!347!4 34%('(9'%99+!!(9'(5'%99& !!-3"  $-"!$!$-!'

 )

38$!!4" -"" !!!!4!""3! $! 22 !! 3 4 7! 4  ! "  !' !! 7! 3 4 22" 22!3 !! -"$  " '!/.) /%.// 5($"-"" 4223 4' "-"!'!'9&'" < '!'*).*+>!"34:"4'  */'$4!22!!' "!!!22"4722!3!!  $22"!4' $4"-"322<'!5*.5*3> !!"  *( !   !" ! 22! %('(9'%99+ .! ! 34$!-!"22!3')(!!'22!3')(!"!' $"!""22"- $4 !! ""!!"!"!!4"!  -"8!!8-'

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

 + *)' !  "  -""  !!  4" ! $4!" " $!!.22 3"$-"" 3!<'!'/ /%.//   '!').+>'  *+'  !"" -""  !8     3! -" !"" 3! $! $ 22!3 !!  B% -  " " !-3$$!-"!$4!-44"3! 7$44"3'     *&'$!!"4!"""B/ ! !"  4!$ " - <''  (%'(%'*(()> !" ! 3! !!" !  " "!44!  " $!!"<.%99&>4'  *9' #!"   ! !"   !"  ! !" !  "' !! !$! 44$" 3! !""""<.%99&B)(!'% />'  /(' "!!"B."55* )/% )6% )65  )6+!'%3* ))& )+(!'%'          #!   !$!