Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-06-14313/24 AI generated

2-06-14313/24 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-06-14313/24
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-14313/24 · Viru Ringkonnakohus: +& -+& &-4 -+& +0*  /((' +& ' +&8.,  ++,+ &+& &0& + & + - 4&0+&,++ +' +&++'+0+&&+' 4 '. &+ +00.+' '   & 4&&,-(+,'(( *'& /+ -/( +- '&++ -4+ - 4&'&'((  +-+ 0./-&-4&+*&1 &-   &+*&& '&+ &'   &,+& , +&'&+-& ;!!+$,. * &&++  '+&-4 +& ,&4&&'&/(&' ,. * --&& &( &' &,. ++,. '&&  (+,& , +/' +--) &' &&+) '&&- &&+*$$  #0(,=&+%!"%<>&&++'&0(,

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



               

     

        !  

  "#"$%$  

                            

  &  %$  #  '((      &'  &       

 )'(( *  !"#   

 $%&''$$(       )                                    *        

          ) &## # &+,+-),&,'. &'(( '  +&&/+&+'(( '  ,+-+&0+&++& $# $1- -&1&  )/ $    022)(+,+/+* ++&&- ,+-/0+'(( &+&+,+-/+&3&33,+- '& 0+ ,+-/ +.  & ''(( &,+-'&+' /+0-+' &'/ -4+&,&&/++&',+ + -&5+& &' ', '   &&/'$6# # /+ ,&0+/(&&,+- +-'& 

 

& ## #'(( /(& )&&+ &'  +-'&  ) &$$$ # &+&&+ &' +-' 4 0+0/2 ),(+/-' &,+-/+ ,+-/'(( ' &+0,&/  &'&++.00'   &++&,&&/++0/+-- ',+-/+ - 4& +0& ,+ 4& , / , - +,. '+ 0/(&&- *  /&'++/ - 

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

--   /  '(/-           -  &  &  +  '(( ' +  &+*  ,&-+. +&,  -0-,-/( ,-+& 4  - & +&- )0+'(( &+&+&'+&3'&33"38.,  

&%$  #'((  +-& )'&+* &&+/,*&& & &( + +&'&++--' & 

  &  %$  #  '((   +-&      &'   &&+: '(( &  &'&+/0+&++ &+&++&'+&3'&33"3 8., /+&&'&+/)"++&',+ + -/ -, '   ',+ + +& &( ,.&'  &'(( +&& ' *,&,+& &' &&+++&',+ +  ( , ' '+&-'&&+0  &-/+  && , +/

+   +-' 4 ' ++  &+'  ,. *  &&  &( &'   &-

-& , +&'&+-& ;!<+$0+& &'  * .-9&/+&&-& &/& ' &&' +' 4'+ +(' ++-' .+ , +&'&+-& ;!<+0! * +/4 1++0 -' /  /  '  0 /  ,. *    '&+  /

 

+ -    ' -  * +  /  0   -, -  1 ' 4 ' ++    +-' /+-&&+,+&,/+   -  '.&&&  &+,+&  &+*  +0  0&,  , -+  +-' + +(&-+. +0, -&4 ,&-4&0+&&-*.* + -4 '.+'-,'-, ,-4&+&++-+&4+ - 4&+& & ,+ /0 &-, -/(&&+0- , -++- &'   +''/ - '& +&, -&+(&-0./-&-+&)"++& ',+ +  +'& ,'&-'&+& &( ,.&'  -/ -, '   ) &$$  #1++ '&&-'&'(( +'(( *4' ++0+ &'(( &1 &-4&'(( //(&& &' &&+ +-'& (( *  +&     +  ' ++   0./-&-  &   &4 &  )  +0-)&-'& ',+ + +&+& &( ,.&- -/ -, -

++& +) &-1& &.- &&'((  &&-&  '+& &'&+/)"++&',+ + -/ -, '  ',+ +  +& &( ,.&'  &0./-&-4 -+*+

4'(( *  &/+ +,. '+ -+&+-./-&-4&,'&,+0* +&  &+'   +'    +0 &-  '     /   -4 ' - '(( * &/  & /(  -      +  '((   0./--4 '   &+*  &'&+  /  0+& ++ &+&+'(( &/&)+&'(( * &/+*  '/4 ++&+0 '/& ,+ '+-&'/ &+ /   +'. ,/+ -&  '- - -' +** ++ )'&+ -+'(( ' +0*+(&'+. +&, -& (( * &/+&-+,+& +8.,  ++,+ &+& &0& + &  &-&+&+").''+& &0& + & -1+&&4' ++&.&& +--&&+11+&+&.- &+& - (( * &/+ - *4&' -'&+.   ' &,+& , +&'&+-& ;+$0 +-&,' . &  '(( '   &&+  +0  &  / +0  &+'   

+-'    & '&+ &,+& , +&'&+-& ;+ ,. *,' . &  '(( '   +0  &  /  +0  &+'   

+-'   +--    '&+4 -.&* ++&' * ++&' .& &-& , +/ &&- +)/+-' &-0-&&-  

 + , +&'&+-& ;+$0 /;+ &+,+& 0./-&-  ) 0+& ,&    &'   /  ++  '&+'   +0  +  -+'(( '  .-     ++     &'   &&+   &'  -&&-  *),+-- &+0+&  )' 6$  # /+ ,&'(( *++ - 4&'&'((   &' -+ /0./-&- '(( *,( &- +& &'(( &1 &'  

& !  !'(( /(& '(( * +-'&/-&&  +-'  &+  & & +/( '(( * &/'*/ -/0+

+-- '& + &..+' ')"+0&+&&+' / &+ '&+/ 

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

 &  '   0 &&  0-*4 &+*  &-  /+  +(&-   '&&-  0(,&4 & $$  #  ) '&&-0(, + )(+,& , +/0-&&-  )0+& ## # &&-,+-$$  #  +-'& ,+-&4 ) + +- / ) ,& ,+-    '&  ,&,+&  '& 0(,  &  &-0 && + &&-%$  #    &'  * . * '(( & +& +4' ++

+&&-  ,+-'&+,.&&=,&  &$#$$ %'(( &&/ " " $"$ %"%>  $$  #  +-'& ,+-&4)+ /:)  &' &&+ +- &&- , +&'&+-& ;< /(    -

     & ,   , +&'&+  -&      (  &&     &'  &&+1 '+-' &4'  &&-&/=0-&&-  >0+&4 + '&-/+& ' - , +&'&+-& (&&+&4' &.&& '& &' '(( &+*&1 &- &  0,. '+  '(( &' &0++&  &'++/( ,&+0./&+  )   '&+  ## #   &-  ,+-4 ' ++  0+*  '(( &  0+& ++ &+&++& +& 

 

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

+ '   '.&    &-  .       , -+  +.0+   +-'   / '& /+ -&  (&*4 &  '    +  

+  /(&-  ,+-/     &'  &&+- +-'&=&+$<4> '+ --4&'&+/+ .  ,/+ +'(( +&&-/++(* ,&' +&+*&-/+ &&++-' + ,&-/0./--  ?++&-++&+*'&'(( &1 &-/ &'+'&+ +(* ,&'   (( *+* +-' ++ +&4'&'(( &1 &'   &   / -  '((   &' +  +&-&  /   , +&'&+ -& ;64;#64;##4;##4;###+$/;##!        &