Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-07-11683/2 AI generated

2-07-11683/2 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-07-11683/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-07-11683/2 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



 



         

  !!"#$ %   #$& '" (') !!%      + ,!'* + !  

     

    $!(' + + -!%& -.*(/- %/ +00 "##' 1! 1! -''-'%/ +00 "##' . )/%          !(/1!2  3 !% "#$& !*(/ & 3 !'3 -#*'&!& ) /%')!1! !')# /'%!* 3 ')#44 /%&' 3 #5 1!!,! 63 !'7 #%&1!2 + +

 

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

(') !!% #$& '"