Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-06-19418/14 AI generated

2-06-19418/14 · Viru Maakohus Rakvere kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-19418/14
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

&& '(& &!-&5-!&, &-3-(!2 (5 ( && '(& &!-&5-!&, &-3-(!2 (5 ( && '(& &!-&5-!&, &-3-(!2 (5 ( && '(& &!-&5-!&, &-3-(!2 (5 (  ! (&'    ! (&'    ! (&'    ! (&'   ' (5 (   ' (5 (   ' (5 (   ' (5 ( ! '(!&!%!(&  ! '(!&!%!(&  ! '(!&!%!(&  ! '(!&!%!(& !-&. !-&. !-&. !-&.5& ! (& -&% - '&(&- 5& ! (& -&% - '&(&- 5& ! (& -&% - '&(&- 5& ! (& -&% - '&(&-%!&(& %!&(& %!&(& %!&(& &!-&& 2! @* &!-&& 2! @* &!-&& 2! @* &!-&& 2! @* -' ; !-& &, -! -' ; !-& &, -! -' ; !-& &, -! -' ; !-& &, -! %  (!  %  (!  %  (!  %  (!   

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-19418/14 · Viru Maakohus Rakvere kohtumaja: && '(& &!-&5-!&, &-3-(!2 (5 ( && '(& &!-&5-!&, &-3-(!2 (5 ( && '(& &!-&5-!&, &-3-(!2 (5 ( && '(& &!-&5-!&, &-3-(!2 (5 (  ! (&'    ! (&'    ! (&'    ! (&'   ' (5 (   ' (5 (   ' (5 (   ' (5 ( ! '(!&!%!(&  ! '(!&!%!(&  ! '(!&!%!(&  ! '(!&!%!(& !-&. !-&. !-&. !-&.5& ! (& -&% - '&(&- 5& ! (& -&% - '&(&- 5& ! (& -&% - '&(&- 5& ! (& -&% - '&(&-%!&(& %!&(& %!&(& %!&(& &!-&& 2! @* &!-&& 2! @* &!-&& 2! @* &!-&& 2! @* -' ; !-& &, -! -' ; !-& &, -! -' ; !-& &, -! -' ; !-& &, -! %  (!  %  (!  %  (!  %  (!   

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                                                           















 ! ! ! !

   "#$$   %% &!&'&(& &'  !  %% &!&'&(& &'  !  %% &!&'&(& &'  !  %% &!&'&(& &'  !  ) *+ ,& & !(

+

 ,& & ,-   (. ,-   (. ,-   (. ,-   (.&   ,-  ,-  ,-  ,-     & &!-!( '  & &!-!( '  & &!-!( '  & &!-!( '   /  0$  / 1-23' % '- & 4 ' #   , !  

  32&  (5 (  ! ( & (& &!-&-35&! ( & (5 (  ! ( & (& &!-&-35&! ( & (5 (  ! ( & (& &!-&-35&! ( & (5 (  ! ( & (& &!-&-35&! ( &  & &!- -&2

 & 2&  & &!- -&2

 & 2&  & &!- -&2

 & 2&  & &!- -&2

 & 2& & 2

& 2

& 2

& 2

2   '& 6    /   0  2 77774 0$ /  5%

 !&(  1-23' % '- &4&- !677778,-! !2& 2

 !$ #

&691-- &/ ((+#

*+ ,& & ! 6#0  277774:&- !67777 

- (& &!-& 

- (& &!-& 

- (& &!-& 

- (& &!-&   &-! 6 &-! 6 &-! 6 &-! 6 

Taotlus rahuldada     !  !,-     !  !,-     !  !,-     !  !,-                 /  /  /  /  0$  0$  0$  0$  /  /  /  /  1-23' % '- & 4 '  1-23' % '- & 4 '  1-23' % '- & 4 '  1-23' % '- & 4 ' #         , ! , ! , ! , ! ,3-' &,& ,3-' &,& ,3-' &,& ,3-' &,&  ,,!&+ '((  

 ,,!&+ '((  

 ,,!&+ '((  

 ,,!&+ '((  ;  ;  ;  ;   32&  32&  32&  32& 5-!& , &- 

,! !2  5-!& , &- 

,! !2  5-!& , &- 

,! !2  5-!& , &- 

,! !2 (5 (-&5 ' % ' &, 6 (5 (-&5 ' % ' &, 6 (5 (-&5 ' % ' &, 6 (5 (-&5 ' % ' &, 6      ! # ! # ! # ! #          !.! (  !.! (  !.! (  !.! ( / / / /) ) ) )0,!&!! !4 0,!&!! !4 0,!&!! !4 0,!&!! !4  ,3-' &,& !!&    ,3-' &,& !!&    ,3-' &,& !!&    ,3-' &,& !!& 

;)

;)

;)

;)0 -(! !,  &- 1((& 24

0 -(! !,  &- 1((& 24

0 -(! !,  &- 1((& 24

0 -(! !,  &- 1((& 24           3' . -2& !!&  3' . -2& !!&  3' . -2& !!&  3' . -2& !!&       #           

 !<<5   !!%!     

 !<<5   !!%!     

 !<<5   !!%!     

 !<<5   !!%!    =  =  =  = 5-!   5&&!2  !!%! 5-!   5&&!2  !!%! 5-!   5&&!2  !!%! 5-!   5&&!2  !!%! 







,&

,&

,&

,&-2 2 2 2  !-& !2 ((  ;  !-& !2 ((  ;  !-& !2 ((  ;  !-& !2 ((  ; ) 0  ) 0  ) 0  ) 0 -( 1((& 2 1 -( 1((& 2 1 -( 1((& 2 1 -( 1((& 2 1  ! ! &     ! ! &     ! ! &     ! ! &    1&  1((& 2 4   )& !0!%!&  )>>)4 =-&25 -, 2 1&  1((& 2 4   )& !0!%!&  )>>)4 =-&25 -, 2 1&  1((& 2 4   )& !0!%!&  )>>)4 =-&25 -, 2 1&  1((& 2 4   )& !0!%!&  )>>)4 =-&25 -, 2 (5 (!%!(&  !!%!  (5 (!%!(&  !!%!  (5 (!%!(&  !!%!  (5 (!%!(&  !!%! =1-& !%!

,&-! 1-& !%!

,&-! 1-& !%!

,&-! 1-& !%!

,&-!/ / / /

,&-2

,&-2

,&-2

,&-2

,&-&

,&-&

,&-&

,&-&

 ;   ' 

 ;   ' 

 ;   ' 

 ;   '   -&55& 5 !  (&! !2 (( +     -&55& 5 !  (&! !2 (( +     -&55& 5 !  (&! !2 (( +     -&55& 5 !  (&! !2 (( +    :    ) 0 &  !&! ! ! ,  &- 1((& 24    1-& %% 2 ((  ) 0 &  !&! ! ! ,  &- 1((& 24    1-& %% 2 ((  ) 0 &  !&! ! ! ,  &- 1((& 24    1-& %% 2 ((  ) 0 &  !&! ! ! ,  &- 1((& 24    1-& %% 2 ((  ! ' ! # ! ' ! # ! ' ! # ! ' ! #   

,&-2

,&-2

,&-2

,&-2

,&-&   '  

,&-&   '  

,&-&   '  

,&-&   '   ; ; ; ; =-!&- 52, 2 5% ! %&-&, =-!&- 52, 2 5% ! %&-&, =-!&- 52, 2 5% ! %&-&, =-!&- 52, 2 5% ! %&-&,  (5 (  ! (!

 %&-&, 

 (5 (  ! (!

 %&-&, 

 (5 (  ! (!

 %&-&, 

 (5 (  ! (!

 %&-&,  (5 ( ? && !2 !!& !%!(!  !-&,  ' '&2 ,

-&2  (5 ( ? && !2 !!& !%!(!  !-&,  ' '&2 ,

-&2  (5 ( ? && !2 !!& !%!(!  !-&,  ' '&2 ,

-&2  (5 ( ? && !2 !!& !%!(!  !-&,  ' '&2 ,

-&2  (!!&,

-&2 32&2 !& &!&& !&+ ( 52! , 2

3 & -& (!!&,

-&2 32&2 !& &!&& !&+ ( 52! , 2

3 & -& (!!&,

-&2 32&2 !& &!&& !&+ ( 52! , 2

3 & -& (!!&,

-&2 32&2 !& &!&& !&+ ( 52! , 2

3 & -&

!,- !(& &!-&, 2-&&!  !,- !(& &!-&, 2-&&!  !,- !(& &!-&, 2-&&!  !,- !(& &!-&, 2-&&!      =-&2 !& 2- 2 @; =-&2 !& 2- 2 @; =-&2 !& 2- 2 @; =-&2 !& 2- 2 @;%!&! !2(& &!-&-35&! (&! ' % '&2&!  ' %!&! !2(& &!-&-35&! (&! ' % '&2&!  ' %!&! !2(& &!-&-35&! (&! ' % '&2&!  ' %!&! !2(& &!-&-35&! (&! ' % '&2&!  ' !5-!  ! !2 (5 ( &!(&!!%!&2 (& 2

!5-!  ! !2 (5 ( &!(&!!%!&2 (& 2

!5-!  ! !2 (5 ( &!(&!!%!&2 (& 2

!5-!  ! !2 (5 ( &!(&!!%!&2 (& 2  ) ) ) ) =-&2     -&55 2 =-&2     -&55 2 =-&2     -&55 2 =-&2     -&55 2 (5 (  ! (&  ! 5-!

-  (5 (  ! (&  ! 5-!

-  (5 (  ! (&  ! 5-!

-  (5 (  ! (&  ! 5-!

-  (& &!-&  ' (& &!-&  ' (& &!-&  ' (& &!-&  ' ( ( ( ( 5 (  ! ,  !(%% & 5& -& (%%  &.

(  ! ,  !(%% & 5& -& (%%  &.

(  ! ,  !(%% & 5& -& (%%  &.

(  ! ,  !(%% & 5& -& (%%  &.& & & & &! (& !%!

 -1& 2 (&! &-& 5%&, -& (%% & %!!&

(& &! (& !%!

 -1& 2 (&! &-& 5%&, -& (%% & %!!&

(& &! (& !%!

 -1& 2 (&! &-& 5%&, -& (%% & %!!&

(& &! (& !%!

 -1& 2 (&! &-& 5%&, -& (%% & %!!&

(& 5%&, -&  5%&, -&  5%&, -&  5%&, -& % ' &, !5%&,  % ' &, !5%&,  % ' &, !5%&,  % ' &, !5%&, !

, !&  !

, !&  !

, !&  !

, !& 

&&5-!&, &-

,! !2 (5 (  ! (&' (& &!-!,-  -35& &&5-!&, &-

,! !2 (5 (  ! (&' (& &!-!,-  -35& &&5-!&, &-

,! !2 (5 (  ! (&' (& &!-!,-  -35& &&5-!&, &-

,! !2 (5 (  ! (&' (& &!-!,-  -35&!

!

!

! 

&& '(& &!-&5-!&, &-3-(!2 (5 ( && '(& &!-&5-!&, &-3-(!2 (5 ( && '(& &!-&5-!&, &-3-(!2 (5 ( && '(& &!-&5-!&, &-3-(!2 (5 (  ! (&'    ! (&'    ! (&'    ! (&'   ' (5 (   ' (5 (   ' (5 (   ' (5 ( ! '(!&!%!(&  ! '(!&!%!(&  ! '(!&!%!(&  ! '(!&!%!(& !-&. !-&. !-&. !-&.5& ! (& -&% - '&(&- 5& ! (& -&% - '&(&- 5& ! (& -&% - '&(&- 5& ! (& -&% - '&(&-%!&(& %!&(& %!&(& %!&(& &!-&& 2! @* &!-&& 2! @* &!-&& 2! @* &!-&& 2! @* -' ; !-& &, -! -' ; !-& &, -! -' ; !-& &, -! -' ; !-& &, -! %  (!  %  (!  %  (!  %  (!   

! (%% 

 

! (%% 

 

! (%% 

 

! (%% &' &' &' &'  ;     @  -' ) -&- ;     @  -' ) -&- ;     @  -' ) -&- ;     @  -' ) -&-  -2 !2  -2 !2  -2 !2  -2 !2 !%!&(& &!-& 5& ! ( & !%!&(& &!-& 5& ! ( & !%!&(& &!-& 5& ! ( & !%!&(& &!-& 5& ! ( &  !%!&  !%!&  !%!&  !%!&  





 )>>)  )>>)  )>>)  )>>) 0  0  0  0 -! !2 

  -! !2 

  -! !2 

  -! !2 

 

! (%% &  )  

! (%% &  )  

! (%% &  )  

! (%% &  )  -&-

-&-

-&-

-&- ( & % (& &!-& !   ( & % (& &!-& !   ( & % (& &!-& !   ( & % (& &!-& !            *;) *;) *;) *;)  --  !!%!    --  !!%!    --  !!%!    --  !!%!    =  =  =  =  5-!  5-!  5-!  5-!4  %!&(& &!- -. & 2 (&-&  ' & 32   %!&(& &!- -. & 2 (&-&  ' & 32   %!&(& &!- -. & 2 (&-&  ' & 32   %!&(& &!- -. & 2 (&-&  ' & 32 

, -2 -.- & 2 (&-&, ! , -!

,!

, -2 -.- & 2 (&-&, ! , -!

,!

, -2 -.- & 2 (&-&, ! , -!

,!

, -2 -.- & 2 (&-&, ! , -!

,! !2 (5 (-&

!2 (5 (-&

!2 (5 (-&

!2 (5 (-& 

  @  -'   -2 (&-  5-!&  -&55&! !-& &, -!   @  -'   -2 (&-  5-!&  -&55&! !-& &, -!   @  -'   -2 (&-  5-!&  -&55&! !-& &, -!   @  -'   -2 (&-  5-!&  -&55&! !-& &, -!             !(%% &-& !(%% &-& !(%% &-& !(%% &-& 3' 3' 3' 3' &!  (%%  &!  (%%  &!  (%%  &!  (%%  &.

&.

&.

&.   '  !-&  (  (

   '  !-&  (  (

   '  !-&  (  (

   '  !-&  (  (

! 2 ! 2 ! 2 ! 2  5%&,   -  5%&,   -  5%&,   -  5%&,   - (%% & %!!& (%% & %!!& (%% & %!!& (%% & %!!&!(&! (&! - !& !(&! (&! - !& !(&! (&! - !& !(&! (&! - !&   %% &%



! 5-!&-&  %% &%



! 5-!&-&  %% &%



! 5-!&-&  %% &%



! 5-!&-&  '(%% & 3!(&-  --  !!%!   '(%% & 3!(&-  --  !!%!   '(%% & 3!(&-  --  !!%!   '(%% & 3!(&-  --  !!%!  = = = =:7777 7777 7777 7777    -2  -2  -2  -2  !(%% &53 & 2&2   !(%% &53 & 2&2   !(%% &53 & 2&2   !(%% &53 & 2&2    ; &! A$$/



!-&( & % (& &!-& , -2&#, ! )  ,3-' &,& 32&     !&! ( (

!(%% &' #( &&!!&5 &  , -2&&! !2 32& ! (&    )    

 

 (  (%% &'  ,3-'  -! ( &&!!&5 &  (&! !2,3-' &,&& 32 2 (& &!- -2&'    - & ,3-'  -!



!-&

- , !,%2&   *  

! 

 

 !(%% &'  A$ $  /  ( & % (& &!-& &! !2 32& &2 &  (& &!-&(&  '(& &!-& ! --,& 

  

!-&  %%  3! *    !&

-

. ,& &!(

 *  * *   

( (%%  &'    @ * -'  !-& &, -! ! 2 , -2

! ,,! ( !  &! (  (  3&  53 & 2 ( &2  ' , -2&-&&!!& %!2, (- &( -!5%&,   -   %% 

2&!!& 2(& ,3-'  -&#  ; * 5& ! %&-&, !,-   (& &!-&& '& $/ ( '



!(%% &' ;   -2 !,3-'  #! !-!&( !& -! !2 !%!&(& &!-&5& ! (&  !!%! =

,&-2  !-& !2((  0; )

 4  ) ; * !(%% &' -. !/$/5%

!&( ! !-&- !2 5 !& '& 

&(&-  '(& &!-!,-   %!   ! 

-2 , (%% &' ) ; * ! ! '& ! @*-' -&-&! (  (  3& 53 & 2 ( &2  ' , -2&-&&!!& %!2, (5%&,   -   =3 & 2 !2 32&'  ' , -2- &  !-& ; *  ',%- ! !&& % &- ! -& !!,(&  

- , !&&! (&  

! ( 

- , !& '-&  *,%!-

,3- ! (!$ /((  ;)  + 2 !3& 2!& 52(&- 52  !  ,3( -     - & 2 (! (5 ('   32&1,! (!((       ) *&! 25-&2, 2-&- & 2 (&  !-& (5 (-&5 '+(--&  &-!

'&  32&  %%. 53,3-' &,&  ,,!&+   ((  )   1,! ( & ! 5-!+ (! '& 3' . -2&1,! ( &(( ;)    !  !. '&  3!2((   )  1,! (  '& -& !!%!  =

,&-2  !--&, !&  '!%!&   )>>) ! -!  5&&!2(( 2& ; )  

,&-!    -&55& (% '!2 ((  )   -. 2(&-& '&  %2 !2

,&-2  !-&  '1-& %% 2(( ! ' ! (&-& ! -&!&( 

,&-2  !-&   =-&2 5 -, 2 &! !2 (5 (-&5 ' ! 5-! , ! ,3!!   &&  !  (%% &' +-35&! 2&1!-   (& &!-&   '&  &! 2 ! !-& @)-'5 -&- '&! (&-! !2 '-3,! B ! ' ! (&    !(%% &53!6 !(%% &53!6 !(%% &53!6 !(%% &53!6  +,

2-%. '( !&

-2 &! !2 (5 (-&5 '+-& .+&!! !- (5

(  ! (&  53 & 2 !2  -. -2 (&-&    @;-'  &-!,3, 25-&2   ' ! !&!2- & 2 3!(& -35&!  (& &!-& (5 ('    ! . (5 ( (%% &' + (--&'  1!-  -35&! .

 (& &!-&0 @-'54     @ ; -' ; %!&! !2 (5 (  ! (! ! ! , 2  -2 !2 - & & &  '5-!&&! !2! '(!&-  (5 ( !%2&! ,    @;%!&! .+&! (& &!- -35&! !2+&

 '& &!5<< 22  !&

''  (  ! , !, 2-& ( - -&- (  '&&(&1-&    (& &!-   -35&! !2 (5 (' +   -35&! (&-  ( 2 ( !&

-3'- 2  !&

-&2! ' % &2 '(& &!-&-35&! (&- !!&' + & 2&!&!-& & !&!   -&55&  (& 

-  '& -3', ! , -!!%!&(& &!-&& 2! @-'5 5<< !  '(  3& ! , !!%!(&-& 

! , 23'- 2! ' % &2 5-!&-&!&     @ ; -'  %!&! .+ &! (5 ( 

. !1!   &--& !1&-& 

. !' &2  !,-& 2!  1-2  & 2& (&! !2 -!&-  ' (5 (! 

. ! ' &2  ,3 &--&1-&<&-2 ,3- 3'& 2& (&! !2 -!&-  %!&(& &!-&& 2! @*-';  &-!,3. !%!&(& &!-&5& ! (&!1!  ,3 (!    !%!&(& &!-& 5& ! (& -   '(& &!-&  -&55& 

,!  (&'  %  - '& 2+  &&- &, ! !-& &, -!   ,

-   ! 5-! '(& &!-&  ! !2 (5 ( !%!(&   

! (%% &'  ;     @  -' )

-&-  -2 !2 !%!&(& &!-& 5& ! ( & 0!%!&  )>>)4  %  (!   ' !%!&(& &!- -. & 2 (&-&  %!&(& &!-   -! !2 

 

! (%% &  )  -&-( & % (& &!-&!   *;) --  !!%! = 5-! 

 '&  ! !-   @ ) -'  5 -&- ' &! (&- ! !2 '-3,! B   ! ' ! (&  -.- & 2 (&-&& -2 !(%% &'    2 (5 (  ! (&- (& &!-&-35&! (&- @-'5+; ; -'%!&! !! 

! , -!    -'  ,3. 5-!&  -&55&- (%%  &.& &! (& !%! &' 

'(& &!-&-1& 2   !     > -- > ( 1- ,&&  

3'&6 / &( &?& & ! ' 25(   !(%%  3!6 ( -*

6 ( -*

6 ( -*

6 ( -*  / &( &?& & ! ' 25(