Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-07-151/5 AI generated

3-07-151/5 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-07-151/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

            

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-07-151/5 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja:             

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

            

        !   "                       ! "      #$%&#$$'()$') *+* ,"-. ""-!"-/ 0)! "" )!"" ##%*#%#$$1 *#)+2#34. "5"-!   64++34. 77 "##$13.5 &" "*(43+% ($% #$$' "-!,"!8 " " !)!  "" )!"""! "" 9":#15*&1.:3#5*/ 9 ,"- )! "" )!""##%*#%#$$1 *#)+2#34"0 ";"% 9 ,"08 "% 9":(*56/ ""8;-"&""-"

5"($&"8!8"""8"5" " #$%&#$$'% "" 5. ""5" """"5."-" !" !8 "&"8

9 < ##%*#%#$$1)! "" )!"" "5*#)+2#34,  -" +#6'$.& ""8 (+4$$6. 64+16* .77 "##$'$.5 &" "*6$#6=#+>% #4%*#%#$$1 "-! ""=(>% $+%$*%#$$1 "51)#2 ""88! " ""8 !"-!  64++34.77 "##$13. 5 &" "*(43+=*#4>%*4%$*%#$$'","-"" "*#) +2#340 "=(>%     < "-!"5"""&77   """""&"-!""" &;"5"8". "%"-!"""& "5 "& &"5" .77"&5"! ""5"" . 5"";" 77"&5" "!&"8"  "8 &""%?)* " "-!77!""577&.&"".77!77"."-!  77!""&;&%"-!77!"5; 77"&5.  77!&;&. "" ""5"&"8%!77"&5;  !56%"-!."-"8""""." 77"&5" 577&,".77!2!"" 5 "!" 77!&"5"";"-5"77!"77% "-!"5""77! " ""5!77!"" &"8  ""5&"8"""% 0"&50"""5."5" 5 @ ""5 A% ""5&"8""-!77!"77"&5"& &;&550""""5" 5@&A%"-!5"-""8! ;5"""""5"%"-!8"""  ""5" "5" !.""-!5  """;"."77"&5;  B8""8;"5."77"&5""77!77" "77""% "-!"5""8  """55 "" "" ""."""8 77!""" "!. " "-!88%"-!"";"." "5"8  "" "-! "" "". -"-!77!&. " 8""8 "5"! " "%"-!8"""" "".""" "!"8 ;5"!% "-!"."77!"""! ";5"5&"""8;"  & )8; 8"""8;"." !"  "% "-!"5""#$$6% ;&&50""577!""&"8"" &"8""""5"5 ""5 %77"&5"&&577!  "77""!% "77""!."""77! &588 ""5";"""!%" ""77! . 77)!

5 &" "" ""%"8. "0"""" & . 5" %"-!& "0"& ."" "-!&"8" ! %"-!5  """5 ;"""8; 8."77!"" 77"&"8 ""5  "". "  ""%C5""5"8  !"8"" " !."""-! "" "%&"8"  " "77!.""" 8%

!""-"%8.""-!""77!;""" ,D. ;" ;58", "8 8""""-" !"5 E00""""8! ". "-"77""."-!!8" ! 0"  ""8 %8"" ""-!& ""8 "8"%"-!""" ""5"88""5 "5"",%

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

 & "-05&""&;"5"";"; & " ""05 8.8""5&"%!."-! 

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

#$$$%.""-!55"""8!5"" """5" ;  "! &  "" "%  "":6$56.5+"8." &!  &"" 0")! "&5"!" 8! ""5" " "!5"8*$%&"8. &!" ;"6  "&"8)! "&" """ "% ""5!.&58! " !#$$6.&"" 0"5 " "*$%!#$$6% "-!8"""&77 ""&,"""&;"5"8"%"-!" " 5 ""5.8""""8 8"5.!- 8"""&% "!5;""5 !8""""."   """8!"5;"! " "5" "% ""8""&8!""-&;!" !"-! % "-!"""08""&!% ":3#5*-&.""!"%""5 "-"-!"08 ";"! %   "