Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-06-836/9 AI generated

3-06-836/9 · Tallinna Halduskohus Tallinna kohtumaja

Case Number 3-06-836/9
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-06-836/9 · Tallinna Halduskohus Tallinna kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

       

    

     !"#$%&        '(')*'       ' # +#, "-  .""!/" /"% 0'1')'"%%"!2% %""!((       1'(')*'      "-""%2'#3"24"4%!/  %%2  .""!/" /"%3 "2 5 !    ! " #$%          %%" .""  67 "% ."%"-

 7 %"  .8"4 23  %%" 4%%"%4%"7"/"%!4%"  # &#" '!  ($  .""!/" /"% 0'1')' "%%"!2% %"7 ! (( %" % ' #" " %"" + , 9 ( 6" ) 7 9 1 6" 1 .% : 2 6" ( " "%%"!2% //% " %% .;%%%   7  -" .% ( 2 /88!% %8 %21'(')'7 %%3"%"%%"!2%"/%%"%8%/"!"%"%"/ %"  916""! (!'  )$ ' # "%  .""!/" /"% 0'1')' "%%"!2% %"" ! (( 4"3/28"% 4%")0'')'!!"7< .""!/" /"%0'2!)'"%%"!2%""!(("%%4"8-4%/"=! /%'  *$ ' # "% )':')'   %" "-"3 / 28"% 10':')' 2 '')'  %/88!%"7 87%' "-" %8.%" )('*')' %%" "-2

.""!/"/"%0'1')'"%%"!2% %"!((%; %/%'

 ) "- 46"% 1('')'  % /""%" 2 4%%2 %%%

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

 9 ) 6" 1  "%  " % ."7  %% ; "% 2 /%"7"4"

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

 ( .$, "%.6 2%"- " "3"%"4%4 %67.8!"2"" %; %/".-'  /$""%"482/6%/%%%"%""'      !"#$%&  %