Legislator Swiss Legal AI Agent Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Court Decisions Legislation Analyze in Legislator
2-05-595/23 AI generated

2-05-595/23 · 2-05-595/23 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-05-595/23
Court / Authority
Decision Date
Jurisdiction Estonia · Case Law (EE)
Open official source ↗ Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Summary

AI generated

                                 !"#$" ##!%&'      (#)()*)            ...

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full Text of the Judgment · 2-05-595/23

    

      

                     !"#$" ##!%&' 

    (#)()*) 

            !        "#           !    $%  &%      ! # #  #

+ )"#)" ##,'++'-" ( #)()*)          

   %        .--+/        0 "#$" ##! '     #  #   #  # .--+ %-  +1+2 0#,3,))4+%&4--5-.-2 -' 

++ 1+20#,,,)*0 +  6    44  +5 -.-  2 '22'+7      !   '   ()*+)*(++,     

   *(+))-).   *          %    .  #   * #      #   %   "    #       

  /+%.       .         0  #    %. 

  11#      

        * !  '2(34*/          

        #0   #      0 #           5 



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

 4 ( >(-+  %&'  '--'  82+2  &2  --  .&88  0,!!34#)*  ( (-+++82+2&2--.&88! * $#''2 1.+'6--+850!*4#0*#3)$0 (

&--82-2(/29+-+82+2&2-- .&88 4##3#))''21.+'6--+85 *!4,0) 4*30,!# ( (-+  +-+  82+2  &2  --  .&88  0$4,!$$$     ''21.+'6--+850# $40$0)4*0!)3  ( >(-+/&82+2&2--.&880000#,$" '-2  -+    6-'-  -  8-  8+  +&++  +2 -2   2+  +-'  &2  +  +    +8  +6+   8@@22"-2++2+82-&++8-- 8--2+'-2+2-+++6+2+&++8-+2 +   8+  &2  '2-+8  -2-    .&2+2    +8 +6++8+6+8@@2-+28&'.&+&++"  '

--'1.+5.+8+-'2-++2+&22- 6-'8+-'&+8.+8+--8'++8+   +6+ 9-+8  -9-    ++2  + 8-+  8++ 8++ -+'&++8++"&82+  ' --'1.+5 '+  ++2  &++  7  ; 2  --    &-8+2  9-  0#  '6:8   .&--82++  &22 ---  &2  +6  -+  -28+  6+8  '&/ 82+.9'8&+" .-+2+.@@28+6+"  66( +00"#4" ##)866++-+8+6+ '&+    '-2    +  '+  &2  ++8    '

--'.+8+-8+-" 

  +  "0 " ##)  866  9--8++2  66(   + 00"#4" ##)866+8+6++8+9++'-2   +8  +6+  +8  6+  -28+"   2+  2 8+-8+66( +-"  +804"# " ##,-'+'-2-'2-++6-+ -2+&2.--228+" 8'+'2-+'-2-'+--+= (&8+-/ +( +'&-'-+++++88$3$,4 " &2  -    22-.    +( +   .-+  ++2  &2+2 -2+-+2'2 +( +&2-'+8-.-2 -+&22+-2+-+++2"++2'+-A'&B +  +9 '-  .2'2  +2  '&-  .-+  +@@2  '+'&+8+" &28+8--+-6+'-++-.2288804)3,!* '&-'&-' ( &  8  +-/  >  -  " "    '&-  '-++  +++  88 )) ,4!"&2-+@@-.-+2'&2-'+8-. 28+'&-.-++@@-.&-82"&28+ +@@2'+'&+2++2'+'&-+2-

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

--''+'&+2 (&8+-/>(-+/&82+2&2+880000#,$" &2  -     8624#"#*" ##4'"!* ##4880300#,$  4#"#*" ##4  +-  "     &2  -'+8   -. 2  +- 2++2 '-2  .-    -  -+2  -8++2  &2  - -'2 28+" >--+2--.-+6++&22'+'-+882$3$,4 )) ,4!   ,*4) 0   , !0$*$#   ,*,$*3$   0,!!34#)* *#3)$00)4*0!)30000#,$-28+" +-2.-+6++2" 

+03"#)" ##,+--/2&+''+&++ 1+"-" !05"    

 ) '  

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

+'-+++-- + --' 04"#)" ##,&-82 &2&-'+8-." .-+-'&++  +28+- + --'&-8-"  8#)"#4" ##!-'+8++2++--'+'-2" 

 +#,"#4" ##!866-/+8+-+2+ +

--'&6-- (-"  + 8-'+.--+/-.-/6++ -28++'+8+8++-26++.--22"

+-+.--2+--++ -'+8+ -22  6+2  .&28+-+  +6-.+  .--2   8--  -+ '&--2.-+'+'6++8+'&--2&2-'+ .&8&++-'+&'++9'66" + --'#*"# " ##, '+'-2-.&--+-+2+'2-+.--2&2--+ +22'+'6+&++8--"8'+  + --'++2'+'62+8+'2+2.--2-2' &2.&22"8'+8-+'+28-- .--2&2-'+'62++2+26.&22"8+ 8'+--+'6-+2.+8+-'+'62++8 &-2-2  ' --'1.+5.+8+- &++8--0$"#0" ##)+8:+-2-2"

 !     -    6+2  .--2  '6+2  +6-.+      +  62 '-+8+-2+D$$ -"36++2" 8-28+.'-+.&--+.&22+6 +'+8+-22-26-228--2-&2"  

    

++-628.--+/--'62+ 2.-/-22++8+8+-"  +2.-++-6++.--+/-28+ 8+'+8+8+"  

  %" # # 

 ++'2  6-'  +'-  8+-2    6  -2 8+--2 -2 +  8+  '+    2-    .&2+2   .--+/'6+2-+--+9+8"  +2+2+'+ 33!0#3*)&2 ++8    '  --'  1.+5  .+8+-   &+ +8--2&++++2" 

2-++'8+'+6+2-28+8" 

+'-++2  D  0#, -"0&++8--&+-- -286  '&  &+  +'+  .2&+    +++2 ++/  &2  '& .2&++8'&--2--"'&/+29 -'+.6'+8--6++&2'&.2&++8+" 

+'-++'-8+-2-&++8-+820$"#0" ##)1  2"+"-"4,(435"++2'-2 )"# " ##)1 2"+"-" (4#5 9-+6+8" 

  &+/  8+  '+  .&2+    8 -28.'+'-+'-+8+-2+D,)$-",-- '-  2  8  +  +"  +2  -    -  +8+  +8+ '&8-2'.++6+" 

+.--+/'62+-86/68+"  .--+/  '62  +  .-+  '-2+  9-2  2  D  043 ++6+2    .&8&++  8  +      -+  8+  + +9+8" 8++2'6+&+" 8+-2+6+/+ +&+-'+'-2--+" 

&+.--+/'6+8.2+/8+.-+ '-+8+-  2+  D  $$   -"3  8+"   -/ +

 3 8+'+8++26++-'+/--'+8 .'-+.&22-28+6+8+8+&++"-2/ 8++.+8+--+'6+2--+28"  >--+2  --  +-/  .--+/  6++  -28+    8+  '+ 8+8+"  +-2&22+++2" 

2++8--+2+'-+8+-2+D ,)0D,) D,)$D,)!-"0."0D,,3D,!#"