Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-01-137/7 AI generated

2-01-137/7 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-01-137/7
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

              

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-01-137/7 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:               

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

                              !"   

   #$#$%   

     

           

    !"!##$%  &   '((%  )  )     &  ' $((      #)%       

 * ++ ,  

 -    

    ( , !"  '         , * ++.  

/////////// 0/ / #// &  1 ,   23            #23             -  .4  #   5    1        2 

 +, -,& ./0&'(( *    .

 "1!#2!##1   

 !3224#$

       +   #!#2!##5  *)  !   6 "  * ++ 23   -  .4  #   5    1        ,  

   +    %7 .    

 +  1 

        *   )                $# *0        0 

         *0 

  66            !  ', 7 85"   1         0        !    )       !

  &    0   (8$    -  &  '      ,      6  "  

   23  4  '    *  2     

  "  %$98 

     "   ( 

   " - $ 

 2

  "         ",,     $889   $888     4 

   .4 1 : %7$  $    -      97$88  66    $%   ;<,,            ",,      

      = . , 2 1 <,,     " 

   23    6         

    >  ,   ",, ,  9 %9 ', "   $         6       &  ,     4 :%7$(

  4  '    *  2          >  ,     " 6 ,   

 

       ",,        6   6    ,       6   

  "        '     6    "         ?    4 :%7$(2  , $723     "           "       "    ?     %$    (#%) $ 2

      "         

   +  6  + "      6 

 2

     6   6  " ,@@    $ $         6   ,

  

  2 - 

 

 65 >:$9$

," "

 - " 

       6       4    " 6 6           ",,         -   9 

 6  6              ",, 

 $(%  

6    

 8(%  

   4  :%7%     

66(A         9$#$8$

     

," "   8(%  

 

(8(%( 

  2

  *  ++ . 2    B  *  % %71    $$$            

  

  *  ++  6   7$$889     ",, ,  9 %9 6  "          6 ,  89# 

 

   6   $$$889 ",, ,  9 % 6 *  ++  6 6     23   ,  $% 

  2

 4 ' . *% 1           "   "   4 '  ($%. *$$(1  9$                  . *  $(1 "     "  8(%  

      9$ B 9$ 

 ( 

,6  $9 ,6  

($9 

.4 :%7 %1     "      9$ % $7  

      "      6  

 * ++. *$%(1 

      ,"   - 6        "     

  5 

 .5 21:$$",- 6  "        6    % 

     ,6    " 23     6             $8$

    %  ,6  *++   6     ",,  $$    

 23 ,       "  % $7  

   "  %( 

*  ++

-   6 "  " . *$(1  $($ . *  $(%#$(71 66   ,        8$%



 4 ' " 6      %$           

-  

  4 '       $(           "  

-  " 

  "  " 6    . *$(8$71  (( 66   ",            #()% 4  ' 

          . *$77#$7 1  &&   *)    &  ' $((        -  6    2   "    23    *  ++    6     -    " % $7  

 ," "

  -8(%  

 

($9 

2    "    23  * ++      -   6 $ ( 

2

   6      2      

  *  ++  6         23  "   6 ,6  " ,-  ,6 

 "       ,    *  ++      6 23 "   "    6    

  ,89#     2      " "   6   -4 :# %7$ %7  "          5 2 :#  $ %  $ $     $#% <,,  6 ,  89# , ($ 6  - 6          ",, ,       " '         , , (

       

  ,

     6   6  6  

          ,  "   26          6     6  6    ', , (%

   - 6    ,    "        

 2

  *  ++6         6   ",, ,  "      ,@@      % @@       5 2:$$,$ 

",- 6  6       ",,  "   % 

       6 ,6  -      6   2

 * ++$ $

    66  6   ",,    89$( 7 

    6    $9 $ 4        (8$  5 2: $$,6     6   ,  2    ,"  

 * ++6  , .,(91  6      +  ,     " 26 ,89#,7$6  6      "      

  2  6 6 ,  

 * ++   %%(    6 6 , , (9 +                  5  5  : $78  % 6 6       "  "     6    

      5  : $7 6 ,6       6 -       ,

62  6,

      

  

      6     2

  *  ++ " "   "  6    23  ,     

 

 "     2    5 2:-" 23  * ++

   6  "   "    % $7  

 6    "           

      &&&*     *)         ((  * ++&  ' $((   ,  ,  

 -    , - +        

 

  23   66 

   

    

               -   % $7  

"  

 23     6 "     

  "   6   -  * ++      , "      "  

,  - 5 2 :$$,# $  6 ",- 6       ",,  "   

 

      6 6 ,6  -      6    2       ,  %$$      

    " 

      $($   - "

 *  ++  

         6     - "      "   "- "     5 : $ 6   '  66 ,   6 ,89#, (9    5 2:7 

"- 6        "26 , 89# ,   6       "    "     5     +

   .5 >1:98$+ '  6   6 6 ,   5  : $78  %

            6

   ,  , -   5  :# $78  %    6       6  "       !6      " 6 ,         5  :    $ 2       

   

   23      6        "        ,

         6 ,  89#6 ,9 % " ,6  $$$889          -      ,   6  ,  

 -                  ,        "   ,  6  " - 

  $ 

   

  ,  "  5 2 : $$ ,  6 - "         -     $ %%    %## $#$#%   5 2 : $$ ,     6",,- 6      6   

   6   ,  6 ",,6      @@    , 6    6   ,  "66 6       "            , , 6  ",,6    

    $#$$ !6         6   ,   6      ,  6   +      , -      6  6 ,    5 2:# %

  6 , ,  

"    +      "     5 2 : 7     "

  ,        6 ,  89#     - 5 2 :    $ 6 6    "       5 2  6  ,

 "         

,

  ,       6 ,          ',  >  ,   ,6 ,$$$889  -      ,    " , - ,    , -   ,6    ,"      *+         6 ,  -  

    2 ,  23           #23    

   23 

"        ,

,   ?          -               ,   6-     -    

" 23     "    6       % %$ 

  +   *)          6  ,  *  ++                 ,  

 -  6           +       2

 23               .$(1       

 * ++ 23 ,

  $889 $888 "",,  6      ,-        -  5 2#  4 #  6      -  .4  #     1 4 :%7$ %7$   ",, ,            6     4  : %7   ""         5 2 : 7 $

  - 6   6 , 6                  6 -      6 "

   5 2 :   $     $$$889 6 , ,#  (   "  *  ++        " ,

   6       

 "   2 

 23    "6      ,-      +4  

"-4 :# %7%  2

  *  ++  -           5 2 : $$ ,  6  ",,        6   % 

      ,6              

           6          ",, 

        $ %%    %##$#$#%6 5 2: $$ , - "     6      ",- 6       6   ,  6 ",,6      @@   ,     

,  7$$889 >  ,   

 23   "",, , 9 %9 ,$    $     $$888 " '  $     

    -  ",,   4  : %7$ "   ",,      .    6  ",,6  1    "

     ", 

   "    6  ", ",,         ,6          6  ",,6        6    , 

     ?   .",, ,,71<,,       ",",     , ,$ .  $ ,$1 4  : %7$ % 6            6  ",,6   -    6  4 :# %7           23   6   $$ #    ", "

 ;'/=", ",,  6  6  6 ",  >  ,      $8$       23  "   

          23        6 " 

  $$$$", - >  ,   ,6     - "   ,     6 ,6  -  . * $(1 2   23    6   4  '    *  2    .++1 "   66 6 ,6    ,

      -     # >  ,  23 "    8(%  

 . * $91 4  : %7          -        ""  2  ,

           4 :%7$

   -            $  ,6       

  ",,   6   6     " ,6  ", ",   

 ",,  6  6     4 :%7%6    "",",  - 4  : %7 $   ,"   , -                       ,6       " ", ",         

  6  ",       



 -     ",,   ",   "   

           23     ", $889  ,-   ",,  "

  '/   - $888

 $7  5  4  :#  %7 % , 23                 ,6 ", ",  

   $       

 

        $7 



  $$$$  4 :%7$      -     6  ",,6    $$$$ 2   ,   

  6 6   - * ++$($ 66    "     4 :%7$    ",,6         

 4 :%7%64   23  * ++ (8$  

   6     6    

  

        -    23    *  ++   ,"    &   '     - 6            

,"        "     ,  

 -  6  6 , 89# ,(9      5 2 : 7    6 ,  ,  6         "         

   6 , +       -    6   "    6 ,          "  ,

    6           "    6   6   , 

    "           23                    6   *  ++     5 2 :   $     - 6      6       "  4     "  *  ++    

-                   ,

 (  6     

 23   "  % $7  

   6     6  % %$ 

&           6   5  5 :%

   $$7" 5       ,            66      5         6    

 * ++ ,  

 -     6  -5 :# 7$  9  7$   ,  *  ++   ,   23  6  "           -  ,  

          

        6  "   ,       ,  

    $ 

 . $8#1    -       +    -    

           

  6  "    " -  +   $ 

 5 :7$$,$ "  -  ,

        ,

 6     ,"       ,



 " -      ,   ,     

  4   % $7  

           ,   % $7  

   $ %7 

 '6     

      $ 

" -   - 6 "  -      ,  

 " -  +          %7 

  ,  *  ++   ,   23  ,  

   - 6               5 :# 7(7( $,7 $ 7 $