Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-04-738/21 AI generated

2-04-738/21 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-04-738/21
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-04-738/21 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



   

      

                     !"#$"%##&'() 

    %*#$*&!+ 

               !      """  #       $        $%                 $ 

   

, -" #"%##-,,)."%*#$* &!+          

 /    0          1..,2    

 321(.              1..,  /    0  4/ 55555555555 .,  5 55*5 '() .  /*

67 1..,  4/55555555555 .,555*5'(). /* 67

,,  ,,   8    4/ 55555555555 .,  5 55*5 '() .  /*

67 .6       '    4/ 55555555555 .,  5 55*5 '() .  /*

67  ! " &     '         ()*(+*,++)   

    *,+-./0              '

       *              ! %          *

 %          %   $           

  /+%'       '         1      %' 

  22      

        *   3,(0*/          

        1         1           & 

       *   3).(*4       '  1               *         1     $              *           '   /,),9,%%"#-"%##$ /* ,.)./,, ,  ,   .  ,  ), 6/( 6 .(1,6   /.,,6" )./  .,  6.//  ,/  ,  ,.  .)  , /.  5 55*5 '()  6/  .),  :,,:,6,    .6 6(.,;(/,/,/;//,/1, 1.,6,/6...<2.)(6$/)<6)(.//,/,/ .<2.)(6".),.6 6..),"!,/ 1,  ,/  1./6  ,(,,  1/<</    .  .)  , :.66" ),).,6,./,=$." =$-=-# (/= &$,6//=%"  ,/ , ,. ,6 >"#&"%##$.), ,,/1./<,,./6,"

,.,,.2,:.:,61(,/)6,,/," ,"$6,.)6./6,:,,/,/ 26,,,,,1<,,61.,/,,6./6, ,66    ,  :.:,6" :,  ,/  ),  ./  ,/  ,/ ,,6,,/,6/)/(6/ .),  1:,,  ),6,   1:,,  ,.  /   /  )"  .6.):,,:,6),<.)<.),6,<<.,6,,/ ,6/)//,)/,//,.)<</ :,,,6,(,,,,/6,..,:,6,,//"  /,),9,#&"#>"%##$ /* ,.)./6..1. ,1,.6/,,1.. 6)"

,).,)./../,6,,//,.2,1, 6/:.<</,6/)/..6,/,).1/,2 /)("3,.1.//6,.," 

 ! //,),9 6),/%!"#%"%##? /*

,.)./. , ,. ,),6/( 6.(1,6/.,,6")./.. /,),91.,%%"#-"%##$,,/)./.. )/,/,6//=%?"  ),#$" %"%##$)./..,,,6.. 555*5'(),:,,:,66,64:,,.,.,,):,,.76/ 1,"  //,),9 6,/#>"#?"%##? /* ,. )./,,@.)),6/(6.(1,6/ .,,6" )./../,),91.,%%"#-"%##$,,/ )./.".)./6<,/, -"#>"%##$6:: ,

,  6  ,  5 55*5 '()  ,,  @.).    )/,/

(.(/= #??"  ,,,@.)6 ?"#-"%##?.),)./. ,,/" ,.,,,,555*5'() , , <,  -"#>"%##$",  1/ :,,,A,1/4:,7 ,.  :,,)    ),)  /6,,." ,    .  ,.  ,/ ,,  ,  :,,:,6  ,6." ,  ,  1  1/)/   /  ),./    .,/ 6,(,,  ,.  1/2    )(6. ,,.):,,:,6.6"     

, -" #"%##-,./,..,,,,,,, @.),.(1,66/(6,,6:,,:,6).6 ,.()<66)","1./6.6.1611:,,. ,.,),./",../<,6,..,//",,, @.).,6(,,,./)<.1,,66 %&  >" ./,)./.2./6.).6,.()<6 6)" ,),,.655.,,6.)//,),9. 4," 7 6.4,"!7).4,"$7,, @.).4,"%., -"#>"%##$7" 6,.)6 ,

,.",/,/ /* ,,," (/  =  &$  .,  )(2  6/  .),    )((//  )( 6,6,)(..6/.,,),...,6,.,( 6.11." ,  ), ,  ),).,  6,,/  1)  ,/.    .  6/   )((/,/6/.,,),6/,/" (/  =  +>  .,    6.  (  (/    6 ()./6,6.,/)./," ./,.655,%....,6/,/,/:,,:,6" :,,:,6.6/,/,,,,"<,,,<.1,,)<, ,:,55.61./,/2/..,.61,,",..

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

 ? ,,/  ,  ,  ), /  ,  1  ,  6(,6 ,<..6/,/,(//,,/,,@.)),"  .<2),6.6,6,,.//<./.,, , ,6,,,,@.)/,1.,%>"#>"%##-,,/ ,,.//,,,@.), , ,<,, 1(/6,.,./6,"', , ,(),.,,,/ ),)., (.(/= #$!= #$?." 1"&,,/:),6 ,,6:,,:,6655/.." 6,  .//  / ,  ,      ,6.  6  ,6  , ).,6,.  /,  <,,/ ().//    ,6.,    / ,),9  .1.  /  ./6  B" ./6  B    ,<,/ ).,6,.  /,  =  % +  ."   1"%  .1..  /.  ,,<,/ (11166),)//6//,.,/"         ,,,@.)6#>"# "%##&.),1..,2. (,221..,2),,:,/,,@.) ,,,/,,.,,,,/ , ,"  

  %$   

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

 - 6<<)1,/1,.6/,1.. 4,"."%$&*%$+7" 

,).,# "# "%##-,/).,6,./,= -$." 1"$ 4.,# "# "%##-,)).,6,./,=!>%." 1"-7.,2 .6,.)<.6,../" 

,).,  ).,6,.  /,  =  %#+  ."   )(2      ,. ,6  .(116  6  ,6  ,    ,,..  6,.,  .(1,6, //,,," 

  .2 ,  <.).  .    .  6  .6,.  < .,/)<.,/6,../"/.,. ()./,)/.,,./,/6,.2 ,1/<.)..,,./,/6./6" 12./6,)...,,/)./"..   (,2      1..,2  )<," 6,    ) .6,.)<..,/(/,(//"6(.22, ,.2,..26)6,/),).,).,6,./,(,." 

,).,  ).,6,.  /, =  -?-  ."   1"?  ,:,2   6  ,6  ,  ,  1..,2  1(/,,    ..  ,,/ ./,.6,/2,66,6,. 6,6.,,/.,...,1(// 6<,,."%.,,.(1..,21(/,, .6,,:,/6,6,,,,66 ,6,.,,6,.(6/..6,(,," 

.2,,/..66,,..., 1(//6,,/6,.(66,.1..,,6 )(6.().//"  .,/...26,,),).,).,6,./,= -$-  ,:,6.      6,./  ,.2  ,  6,  ,   ,6"  .,/.12).6</<6,"  <.),). 6.,/1.,6,.24,"."%#+* %#>7" 

(2/= %<2,,(26,,),,. (//6/= !,,...,)//6//"  ,/,).1/2 6,,.1.6,.26 :./"6,1/)/6,./)./.,)//6//"  6/1.,6,.2.6..,,.,"  .,6.,.26.,)<..,/)21.,6,.2   <. ),)  ,,.    ./6,/  .6.  .  2  ,,/ ,,../6:."

 &  6,,,.2,:,/6,.(6/6,(,,1 ).)(,,,1..,2:.<</)</,"  1..,2  .2  ./6.  .., ""  6,  ,  ,:,6 " 

/,,6..,/,).,6,./,= -$-=-? =-?%=-?$=-?-." 1"?."%=-?&." 1"!=--+=-&#= -& "