3-06-1854/6 AI generated

3-06-1854/6 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Case Number 3-06-1854/6

Court / Authority Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja

Jurisdiction

Estonia (EE)

Decision Date 2007-03-16

Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

(& &)3& & &'& (&)

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-06-1854/6 · Tallinna Halduskohus Pärnu kohtumaja: (& &)3& & &'& (&)

Full text

! " # $ % &'

#

(& "# (( $ %

&)$ &

) (*

(

&

+ # $ ( $&( (

# $

&(

&,&

-(

(+

- &'&&

( $ !& $+&&

$ .#

( (

&

$

.( ,( $ / 0

# (( $

#

( #

( ( &

$ /

! "

1(( ! &' ( "-/ 2 +3%

4(&3& &#,

'&

( 3& (

&'&# &( (

+ ( & 3&# $ # (& (& #

(

(& ( # (&+&

&( 4(& #

( (& ( # (&+&

& 3&#

" #!$$ %

#,((

#

+# ((&"

#

+

(& 6

# #,,

&7 (

&%

&+ (

& (

&& &# ( ((

&

& ( &( *& &+& ( +

&3

+ ,

&+ ( & #

(

(# &+

#

(& (

(

"( ( %

(# &(

+

&"( %

#

(& &+ ) (

, &

( (&

&3

+ ( & (&+&

& $+&# (8

( +

&+

(

"

# &+

(

% ))) !

9 $

#

(& (& &

# & ,

(&

&3

+: ( "( %

#

( &)"#

( ( (%

&+

(( (

&

( & + 3

((( $ ($ ( ( (#

3 ( ! 9 $

# & ))) ,

( &

&3

+

,33&

( -

(

(# & &

& (

+

&

+ (# $ $

(

,

+&

$ *

(& &# (&

&(&"( )%

#

( &)"#

( ( (%

&+

&(

&& &# (

&( ( ()

+(3( (

(# $

(&

+ (# $ $

(

*

(&$#

&"( %

) &

( # $

#

(& & ) 3& &

&'&"

% (&"( %

( &+ $&(

&'

+( "( )%- &'&&

( $

(& &3 $

(

$ &&(#

( ( # (

+ &(# & &

)3(&$

+&&3( '

(&$ *

(&$#

&$

&& (

&&+

# $ & +

( (3& (

# $ # (&' #(

(*

(

,&

& #,

(&

& )

& && &

( (

& &)3(&$ +&

&

&(

# ( "( % # $ &'&

+( $(

& & & $ #

(

&'& *(

&# (

#

(& &+ )

"

%

( &+ #,&(

$ $

&&( &$

&(

*(&

&( $ &*

&'

&(

"( %

&!$

!# $ ( ( &'

#

(& & ) $

& ) (*

(

(

+

#

(& (

( # $ (

(

# $

&

&+ ( & (# &

& $ ( &'&

&

( $ ( # $ & ( & (# !

/, & & (

&

(*

(

( ( ( &' # $

((& & &3 ( &( ( &

+

(# &

$ ,

+& # (

( #

&&(,(( &( # (( $

(# & (

+

( 4

& &(

#

+ &+

#

(&

&# $& #

&

( & (# (&

&

&

3

&& &

( # $ &"( %

!# $ &

( &'&# (( $ (&3& &&(#

' #( &&

&(# (( $ & (# && && &'&&

( $ - &'&

( (

$

(

/+

(

(&(

(

#&&

( & & (&

# $ #

(

(

&&( &

( &

(&

4

& +&&(

&

#

(

$ &+ #

(# ( &'&&

( $ & !# $ ( &'*+ # (

#

& & ( (# (3 (

&

&&

-

((

&

+ ( (&(

3 &&

+ & ( ' & &#& (

& &

$ && &3& &

( (

$ & &"( %

- )

' # $ ,

+3 ((( (

((#& (

+3 &+ 3 () (+

&&! 9$

#

(&# &

)) ,

( &3

+3(

&

& & (3

&&' &3

+ (

! 9

$( '&

(# (

($

#

(&

&

( 3&# $ # (#

(&

. (( $ &

& (& ( &( #

' &

(& ,33&

( (& )

3 &&

$ (&(

#&(&&

+

&' $ #

& $&

3 &&

(

#&(&&

+(&( #&& &

&&

( 5&(

& "! 9% &+ &(

&

" # $ %&

&

&

(

+&

3&(&

& &&+

#

&

( $

, &

(&+& ' &( #,

' # $ $( ( 3 &+(&

& (

( ,

(

& (

+

(& #& ( &

# (( $ &

& # $

3 #&

&(&

& . (( $ &

& #

#,

(&( $

# (

& & #, # '

&

& &

&(&

+ 3& '

' (&(

3

&& &

$ ( (&& ( &

&3

+ #,

( ("( %

!# $ ( ( &'

#

(& & ) $

&)(*

(

($

#

(&(

(# $ ( (

# $

&

&+ ( & (# &

& $ ( &'& &

( $ (

# $ & ( & (# -

&( ( ,& $'

(

(& (

#&(&,&(& ( ( &' &'&&

( $ 8% (&)$

) ,

+# ( &

(&+&

(0 %

#

(& (

( (

# $

&

&+ &( + ( !(&+&#&$(

&&

& $ +(

#((&

&

"(

(+

3( ( %

' $!

#

( # (( $ 3 ' ,3&(

& ( $ &&( &'

&

( ( (( &+

& $ (( $ &

(

& 3 & ( ( ( &

( ! (& (

#&

( ( & 3 '# (( $ $(( &

( ( &'& ( . (( $ 3,$& '

&

(

$+

& (

! &( &'&&

( $ #

&&&& &+ &(# (( $ &

& # $ ( (&(

(& #

( ;

& (

#

(&

$ + # $ & , &

&& ( (;

&( (

$ ($ (&( # $

(

+

( (&

&( &&

& ( & &

( (

& #

$

& +

(& $

&

+&,

+

(&( ( &+ $ !#&( & $ &(

&( (

$ "%

# $ &

$

(,& (&(#

& + &

#

( ( &( (& & )

#

(&

&&* $& ( &

# $ 3

(

&

& +& ( # &&+ (&

& &' &

( (

&'&(( &+

&

+( &'$(( '

# ( (

!#&( & $ &( &

&( ( #

( ( (( &+

&

+ (&

&

3,

&'&

&& & ( &'$(( &

&& &' '

# ( (

&&

& +& (3&3&(

#

(&( &'&&

( $ 3 (( ( &(&&

" (# &

&

( # $ %&

&#,

#( (&

& &#

(

&+

&& &# & &'

& +& ( &($+

(& 3,$(& !# $ #

'&(

(&

&

'(& ,

+3 ((( (

((#& (

+3 &+ 3 () (+

&&! 9$

#

(&# &

&))

&3

+3(

&

&$+

3

&&' &3

+ (

! 9$( '&

(#

(

( $

#

( &

&

( 3&# $ # (#

(&

&

& #

&

(+

&' &(

&$ (

+

& & &$ &' & &&& & &

#

(&

,

+ (( $ (& ( &3

+ $(

&( #,

,33&

&(

)

& &# $ &(& $( ' &3

+

((&3

&&

&((& (

&&

(

&

& # $ &

(

((&*(&+

(,&

(&+ + (

3& &(,& ( #

&(&& &(

&($

&3

+3

&&3

&&

(

&& &

&3

+.

& +

(( $

& &3

+

##,

&3

+3

&&

&3( &(

&,

+3 &

(& 3 ( &3

+ (( $ <<

( $ ( 3,

&' #+ 3 &

& ( # (

(( $

(& &3

+(&&&+

$

$ (

& &3

+(&( (

(( $ $

((& (( $ ( ( &&+ # $ #

(& && ,

+3 & (&+

&( (

&(

+ (

+

#

(& (

( +

3 &&

( $

&

&&

( #,

& (&

&&

(

#&(&&

+(& &(+

&# ,

+3 &(&

& &

((&*(&+

,

+ (

(

#

(&*(&

& && (# & & ,

+

3& ' (

&& ,

+&

& ,

+&

& (&( ((&(

(

#((&

$

&

3&(

& ,$& ( & *& & ,

+

( (& &&

(

&

&& #&

(& *(& #& ( &

& #

( ( &(

(#

& (&(

' # $

+

$ (

& & #

&( # $ 3,$& ( ,

+3 & (&

& &

& # $ &

(

*(&+

#

&(&+ (,&

((&

&,

+(&

&(

#

(3& '

&

&( ! #

&

& #

#

&+

#

#

(&

(&(*

(

& &&

#

# $ ( && (

! $()$"%%

- &

'&( &'3,$& ($ ( &'$(( ( - & '& (

&&(

(&( ( &

3( # &'&(( &+($

(

&&$& 3,$& ' &

(

&'& ( $(

&

. (( $ 3 $(( &'& "

& (% '

# ( (

+ ,3&( & &

&&( && &

( ( (( &+

& "# (( $ & &( ( $

(

(+

3( ( % - &'& &

( $ &

' &( &' &

( ( (( &+

$+

&"( %-,(' # $ + &( &'&&

(

& &

&& &(&( (

(( &+

(

-/ 2 ) + (&( ( &( &'& (

(*

(

& #,

' ( &

&

( * $ 3&# $ (

(& ( # (&+&

&( # (&-/ 2) +

& (# ( ' $ '

&'&&

( ( (&

&

&&( &'&

, (&+ 5

+

# ( #

"

(& (&

% &(

3

(

'

( ( &&# ( & +

(

( , ' ((

$(

&'& &

( $ (& &3 &'& &&+

#(

& (, ( ( &

&

(

&#,

& &

-( $ (&$

&( (' &(

#

( & ) $ )

&'& &

( $ & & (

$ + "( % $ &'& &

( $ & &

((& "( % & &( &( # $ &#

( ( (

&(

+ (& #&& +

# & (& (,&&

&

( (&

&!# $ &

(

#

(& &)3& & &'& (&)

-$((

&'& &+

+( #

(&+ -/ 2 +3 &

&( &'&+ &# &

& +& $ *&& ( ,

(&( # & 3&# & (( $

3(& ,#

& - &'& 3& ,# (

(( &+& ( "( % !# $

#

( & ) 3& & &

&'&

&&( & #,(

&

&(

$ *(&&&( &&( (# (

(&(&&

&((&+&

(*&$

#

&+ !#&( & $ &( &

+& &' $,

(& )

+

# (( $ (

, & & # $ & & "( %

3&# &(( &+ &'&&

(

& $ #&& << &

&&+ &'(( &+&$

# (( $ & & &( ( ( &'$(( (

!# $ ( ( & &'& &

(

& $+& ( 4=

&&( &

("( %-(

(+

# $

&( (( ( &(&

'"(

(+

3( ( %

(

,

+3 ( (

( & * $ & &

& $ &(& &

+

+

#

( ( (& # (#,(

& &(& 4= &&+ 3(( &

. (( $ &

$ & +

((& & ( ,

(

( (+

&3

+ 4=+

$ # ( # (

&& &# ( # ( #,&( ) "(

(+

3( ( % &&+ 3

#,

($ #&( &(# (( $

&

( &

(# &3 (

$ ! 9

# &

&&

&3

+ ,33&

()

(# ( &&

&( (( &

&

& ( $ + (&( $

(

&(

#&( $ &(&

#,((

# ( (# & &

&

3,

,((&

& &

&&+ $' # $ 3 ( &

( (

&

( ( (

'

*

+

!#&( & $ &((*

(

,&(

(( &+&(&( &'$+

&

(

#

( ( (

# ( # ,

+3 (& & (

& &&

( ( # (& &,&(& &$

&& ( $ * & &'& &

( $ ,

+

# /

3( ' ,&(

& +

(

# $ (

(+

&( ( ( &

&'& &&( & #,(

& &

3,

,((&

& ( ,

+&(

>

&&

( "(

(+

3( ( %

3

( (# $

&

(

(

& # (& (

#&( ( &$

&'

$'& &3,

,&(& (

(&&( && (

2 + & (#,

' (&3<<

&

&

'&( (

+

((& ,

+

#,

3

((& # '

&&+ (

'

,

+&3& ( &'&&

( $ ,

+

(

-& &# $ #

( (

#

(& ()

$ ()

( # *(&(&#

!# $ &

'&(

&

# (& ,

+3 ((( (

(( 3 ()

"#& (%

3 &+ - &'& &

( $ & & & &

+ &

,(

(

(*

(

&&

( ( &'& '

# (

& ( &'

(( # (&,

+(& ,

(

'$&(

#&

#

&,

+

(3

'

'$&(

#&(,

+(

(

&& ' #,

#

( '

& ( #,

(

&

( ,

+& (

& & ' ,

+& (

& &

(

& #

(

+

#,

& '

& (,

+& (

("5

+

((

()% (

&$ '$&(

#&,

+&3

&# & 3& ' &

3,$

& ,$

& 3'

,

+& &

+

(&+&#&( #& ( (&3

(

(&# & &

&#

(& &&(&

&3

+

& (

&,

(

#

(&$ ! 9

# & ( &(

#&+

) "( %

+&( &'&&

( $

& &(

"( % $ (&$

&(&

&

&

(& + (

& &

&( #,

$& &(

$( ' &3

+ (( $

,33&&&

&3

+(! + 9#,

&( (

& (9$( '&

&3

+&

&

&

&3

+(

( (&+ - &'&&

( $

(&

$ 3

#&( $ + &(

(& ,

+

(( ( #,

' ,33& #,

( 3 ( &

&3

+ $

&

&3

+ (( $ ,33&

( &

&+

# ( (

3 ( $' (&( #,

3 &&

( # (& &

#&(&&

+(& &"( % #,

# (#,&( ? &+ # &"( ))%

-,('# (( $ + &(#

( ( & # $ ,

+3 (((&

- &'&(&+ &( $ (&$

&(&

& +&(,&,

+

&& &

(( &'&&

( $ &&(&(#

& & 3& (# && # $

!# $ ,

+& ( ( &&'&&3 #

( &

&3

+(

4 && ( & &(&( # $ ,

+

&

&#

( ( (

&+ &

(@&

(

$ (&$

( & &(# (( $ &

#

( ( (&

&

3&#&(( &&#

#,

(

& &&

( ( #

3,

,&

(,

+3 &

( (3&# +

3 (&(& &(

# ,

+&

& $ & &+ , 33(

& ( #

+ &(

+# ( '#

,&(& &

" &&( & & & 2 % -

#

(& & & & 2 +

& (&(&( '

# #

(&

& #

+

#

+

#

#

(&

& (

& $ (

& &(&( &+

;

&( (&2 +3 & ( '

# #,,

&(( $ (

$

#

+ + +

(

+

& /& 2 + 3

3(

' & ( (( '

#

& (# &+

#

(

& (( (# ( #,((

#

+ # ( (&

"

#

+ (&6

# #,,

&7(

&%

&+

(

& (

&& &# (((&

& (&(*& &+& (+

&3

+,

&+ ( &

#

( (# &+

#

(& (

(

"( ( % (# &(

+

&"( %

#

(& &+

) & (

(#

3 (

$ ! 9

# & )))

,

( &

&3

+ ,33&

(

+ 3(

(&( ( (

+

(& &&+

(# & (

+

(& &

& $ (

& ((

&

&

# $

$(( (# $

(&

#

(&"# (( $ %3&#&

.

( ( & ) 3(

& ( (# & ( #

(( '& ( (# $ (' ( (&

(& $#

&

& #,

(&

(&

& $

(&

&+ &(

(&&

# (&+&#& (

(& (

$

&(&(& *

((&

((& $

&"( %

&',( # (( $ + &(

#

(&3,

,((&

#&( &"-4- 2%&

,$# (&3,$(&( (

*&& ,

+

( (& " &'& &

( $ % &&

(

& ,

+

& (&

(& &

(& & &

&

,$#

3,$

&

& &'&&

( $ # $ (/,$# 3,$&&

+& $ &(

&'&&

( $ ( '&3 &+ &(

&((&+&

((( $

& &3

++

& ,33&

&( &'&&

( $ (&

-+

'

&($

(( ' ( &#

& ) 3 & (&

(&

(&$ &'&&

( $ &

'&(

(& (&+&#&

'

# # $

#,

(,

+& & 3&(&&&

#,& ( (&

(& #,

& #

$ (&+

#

#

(&

& (

&$ (

& &((&((

+

(&

-#,((& ( &' &

& &( #

( ( (

# ( # ,

+3 &

(

&&

& & ((& & $ &&+ $ &' (

&'&

&

( $ '$&(

#&(&,

+(&

& & && &# (

+

+& (# ( (

*

- &'& &

( $ ( ( & (& ) $ ) ,

+# ( &

(&+&

(

(*

(

&' $' ( ;

&( ( (& (

#& ( ( $' ( &(

&& &# ($' (# ( (&(#

( ( (

# ( # &&( && &

2 (&( ( ,

+3 & & (

& &

( ( # (& & ,&(& & 5 ( $'

(&

& (& (

#& ,&

&+ ( ( &(

#

(& (

( # $

(

&+ &( + (

( (&(&+&#& (& ($(

&&

& $

+(#((&

&"(

(+

3( ( %. (( $ + ( &',( &(

&

(& & ,

+

& & &

& #

(

&( ( &(

3& ( + (&

&

"& ,

+

%

(&+&#& (& ($(

&"(

(+

3( ( %

-/ 2) +(&( '&(&&( '3 & & $((&(

&&+

3& &&( &'& &

( $

# (( $ &

& &&( &

# $ ,

(

(( ( &"(

(+

3( ( %

-(