Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-4/4 AI generated

2-05-4/4 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-05-4/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-4/4 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

       

          !"#  

!"$% &% %''!$# #( ($% ''      )**)**  

     

  + ,%'%'% &%-((%,%#(' ".% &#$'#($'$ !,-$-/01* !!%2-(#          .(3 + , %'% '% &%-((%,%#(' 4  # !"$5 2%, 6'4 -&'-4,4'% &%-((%3

!#$3    

    )**)**     7"%--(# #+8'.*9 %/*1* ("$%- #+8 / '.*9 : 8 0 '.*9  #  8 11 '.*9 % /** ("$%- #+8)'.*3 #8//)48/;4848)) '.* "'-- + ,%'%'% &%-((%,%#(' ".%* %##(2- <'$'#($'$!,-$-/01* !!%6 ##- !', 6,,(-6"( #$"$ #(%$#(#-&%%# 6,,(- !!%3#($%  + ,%'%'% &%-((%,%#('  # #*    7$$ !"$ '-  -* '3,2%#$ <'$ + ,%'%'% &%-((%,%#('  # #%%.%'2%&#,,#; !!% "( # $"$ !!% *     

!"$!$##( =('(&2%>(#%$- =(''$#%!! (>#( ''%%. ! !"$'(/=(&3!! #' '$(#!$##(=(''-%'( $$($!%,($,%#(#$4 %-,%$$("%'3(, %&%%( ,??-,%#(' !"$!$##( &'% '$$($& #$(.(,%#(#$* (>#&2%- #('"(-- %3'% #,(($'#(#4 % (>#(#(% $!$'($#(''('"(-,%#$ !"$%#$.%'*         

   .%&'-#( !"#('$  + , %'% '% &%-((%,%#('  '% &%-((%,%#,(($'#( %.# ! %',(-4($ + ,%'%3"$#('%%.( !/**000**&2$- + ,%'% ###$ #'"#&'311*0 !!%*'" !#$3'(&'3, #,%#( !"$! !!#$$- ## &'3,%( !-(*/@/**000**%.#(''('!#'"&#$&2$3'' %3$-

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

!#$3 (#%'.#(# %3'% # &#$#(#  ".% (% $%#$* !#$3 #(%# !"'$  D 8 ;1 '.* !"#('$  &#$$$&- 3"$#( '%% ,(- #(-#( &* =2"% %3 2($( % ,%#( 3 !, !"#$#$( $%$,$ 3E$,%#(.  !#6"%.'( &* !#% ('( #66'%#('$ $( %$$-  "3 ((#$ #!'%-#('$*D%,($$-(- $#%!!% !"#('$!3"$#('%% ,(&#$(#%$$&2-( (.,%#$"$(.#$$% ,%#($!%,,%#(#$*((. !#$3'(%>4($".%!(.-3 ='>3$$".%"'-,$*

!#$3$%(-&# %3'% #&#$#(#".%(%$%#$*%# ##(''('(4($".%!(.-4! ".(3 !"$ ( #%$(('( &%%-* !#$3 (#%$> !"$'( &2' %3 ****4 ,%''(' ! + , %'% !#%  7  '' %%4 ,%''(.  '' %3$  %%$> &2' %3 =*#  #$(#$$- )0;1 !!%$.#%, #($%.&2' %3****4,%''('! + ,%'%!#%   '' %%4,%''(.$ %%$>&2' %3=*#/#$(#$$-)0;1* !!%$.#%, #($*     ! 

!"$%#$.%'".(3='#".%"'--3 !#$3'$&'3,2%#$ !"$ '-* 

!"$%#$.%' !#$3='#3$$".%"'-,$3 !"$ '-".(3'$&'3,2%#$*           !  "   "      !    " 

!"# '-=!$#(##%!#'%#(-4$%#$36$'#(-3$$&-#3# !.$- %3'% ( ,$(3'%-(.'(%-%#4($".%!=2"3(-$-3 '>"'-,%#('(*   !'% + ,%'%3"$#('%%.(*#$&'$ ##&'3,%( !-(%'(*/@/**000** !%& !! &(%#- + ,%'% ###$"#,,#11*0 !!%4,%''( !"$ $!--'' %3 ##&'3,%( !-(%'(*

!#$3 $!$'#(' $(.% !"# ( %3 ( #=($%%#% $- -! ,(-%'( 3 ( #=($%-( &,#( !"#('$ ! + , %'% /**000** ## &'3,%(   !-(%' */ " &#$&2$3$ 3#$&'(' %3(A'' %%A3.%!'(&'' %% %3$$- =!!'$* 

  / .(3!".%(#%$-'#($% #$,%#(#$($( !"#('$&#$&'$/**000** ("$%-

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

#  8 11 '.* !"#('$ %#% 4 (# %', #(-#(. &* $("%.. %-' #,$- '#($ !,-#&$(%#(&('4! !"#$$-&%%,#('('#($'$!,-$-&$.#$,*

!#$3=!!'$(('%#$.%')**)**$-#('($#( !"#('$=!'($(,#(-"#-4 $(, &2$$%# '=#(-  ==% $??'(4 ($ %&%- # # !3$- 3 #%%# =%-% $ '#$('( " , #,4 ,$=%-3#%,#$=' *,,#%&'3&2($-(%(&$(' =(&-('3 #$$- (%(&$( # &3-#$( #4 #,$%  , #%# $ $((#$(  !#$,%#( ((#$ =2'',3-#$("%  !#"!% #4!#% -!'%-#(''(#$$(-'% -*"! '$$- + ,%'%$>( #$'* ) * !#$3=!!'$ !"$%#$.%')**1**$-#('($#( !"#('$" #$$% + , %'% '-( $,%#( #4 %- '-! ,($((%!'(*((#,,!0;**'.#(#$ %000** '2=% $( %- ##3 * '-! ,($( (% !'( 4 #(#$ ,$=%-3  #% ,#$ ='  3 '=#(- !3#%- =2''' %&( $'*); * ((. !#$3 &%$(- " #$,%#(# + , %'% '-( $$( #(%!'(,%''(..%$2(-$-*

%#$3 !"$%#$.%'$-6$'#$(3.%$??$#$(, + ,%'%,$=%-34 =.#'' %32%.#$$'(%!'-3"#%=.#$&'3&2$$%'$ *,$%(%!'- $(, (# .%#'"4 #* ""!%-%#4$(,(%$(*. '2=# %3$#$ ## &'3,%(  !-(% !.  3!! #'    =!!'$ '$$- " !"$ 3   $2% '-! ,(-%-" #$,%#( !"$* ##&'3,%( !-(*/ '-! ,(-% #$2%   '-! ,(-%-00;**&((>%#$4,%#!'%-3>00;#$''>% $-3$(,$(.% =-# -($'*/ *

&%%$./100;@**00;**/G !"$$'*)) (%$2(--($#(,>%#000**" '$,%#$4 -! ,($!#$3 -&#(,#$3#$* ,$% ! !"$'( (#%$$- &2' !"#$#(- ****4 ,%''('( ! '' %3$- &2' -3$( 37%.&%%-$-$.#%, #'((('=!!'%,($$- &%%$.%/100;3.%4 ,%# > =(&**00;**$'*))/ *%,($$--! ,(-%-(%$2(-('#($" $#,%#$   <'( 3 7 <'( !  #,,# /0 1* !!% -($#(,>%# 000** ,$% %,($$-  &2' !"#$#$(  **** #,,- '%%$(# 3 $.#%, # ,"&(#$-(#4 (% #(($'(,#( #&2' !"#$#(#,.%$-&2'.(&#(#,,$*

%#$3   !"$%#$.%' $- 6$'#$( !"#('$ $(, (% $(4 # #!!,'#(- #(''( " ('#('$#%-$'*/ * %#( !"$%#$.%')**1** %%$#4($#!!,'#(-(%!'(#(-

   " #-4 &%- " ' # + , %'% '-( $$( # 4 ,%''( !"$ '-! ,(-%- =-&-$'*); * 

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

 !"#"'->".%#%%#$'(>32##(3$$".%$.,%#(,#****4,%''(. !"#(#$%# J'( '&-&('-# !$!-(#$%>%%.%= -(#".%"%'$#(# ".(3 # #*      #$&'$ #%&%%' !$",(($'#( #(-#$%  3 %$(,(($'#( #(-#$%   (-,%#( #(-#( 8 /  (( #(''( #(-#( 32#$,%#$ '#$$- ,(($'#( ="' !"'-$ #( ,(($'# '-( 3!$,%#('( 3 (-( %-' #,,%#('(  #(% ("$%- $#%&%%' !"$,(($'#( #(-#$% #  #$(#$$$* $- !"$,(($'# ! '#$$- (( **)**3#('3' ("$%- #8)'.*3.% ".%"'-$ #( '> !#$3'$ ".(3 # #&'3,2%#$,%#('( !"$ '#*!*%%.%'2%&#,,#; !!%*   &% %''!$#

!"$%