Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
3-02-12/10 AI generated

3-02-12/10 · Tallinna Halduskohus Tallinna kohtumaja

Case Number 3-02-12/10
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

                    

Legislator headnote

AI generated

3-02-12/10 · Tallinna Halduskohus Tallinna kohtumaja:                     

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                    

                !"# $%%&''(")    *+'&+&  

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

:"   '  * $  1 ) / 011#   ##    0  % 6   9+ '   # 6.7%    606 " 1   #    )   ##   6.7% )/ 011#1   9 ( .+ *) $%.   &4"'4"22 077% . %" 3  ?/.# #%.0 10  %0 #  0 17$#0 . 6   0  %%@ 8  #  0  %:  *3 . $%.   '5"'&"22* 077% . %" *3  ?/.#  #66% #% .0  %%@  &') 0    #    0 #% 0  00"

 3      #1  .  6 .  $)   ##    6.# " #0     8:00 1    0  % . % 9+  3!+('"   16 '"'"&''& .  ####&&""22214"'"&''')+  $  0  "  0 6.    606 .00 6. %$)0  #  6  "D     %$   6   9+ ' # 6.  606 ) 0    #  $ %.  0 0  . #  17%1   .   0   16.7%"  . /   01 1  # 1 B  # #  0  %% . /.#  #66% #% .0  %%)   0  #   .# 061 %    . %    01770  "  .  .0  0 '("&"&''   % *+*++5+'  !  C ?0% >%06.$1 0  .# 6.# #%.0 70#1)0# 11#%6.# #66%0"/ 01 $  . 0 %0110  "01#1 1 0   $ 0% >%00   17%. # 0 "@  0% >%06.$1 0 .#%.0   1) ##   )0EEB  "0% >%06. $1 0 .#%.0 %  1#) 0   00 1B0 %  %0#"   #% 0  #    B0)   %.  0  )      06 6.7%  )       #% 0    177#  0" 0     0     # >  1 #       1 0" D     1 0 # 1   /   01  #71  .0 .  0    7.) 0     %0 6 0  . 0 6  "    1) 0 6.$ #% 0  1  #    00)    1)00 $0  )001 # ##% 00    7. #71 60" #  0  %% + *!   #  01 7 #      6   #  #6 $# ) 0 7 #  6   .0 #1 B " #  0 %%*3 #6#  00  . 7% 01    . 0 0 #   1 8   #%) 0   .07%.)  6  10":)0# ##61 $ 0 0 %1 0  1     01 )   #$   7$ B   1# 0 7 #%# " 7 7#1$ 01  % . #60 0  1 .  #  0 ) 0  #     0 "  0  61      1     6.7%  .     01770   %0"  ''

 (  .B.&4"'"&''& .1%"*+!++5+'&8

&''&)&4) *'4: 9(6 *# #6  8:9*6 .&19+.!   0 "&"%&''(.B. .1%"*+*++3*+'5 8

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

 4   6   17%  ##  0   ..  7  )  #0  $ 7#  .  # 7% #   0 8#   9 &5 6 21':"  7  # $  0  $10.B.  9 ( 6  * 6  #  ) %#   B 1.)  )       6. %# )   0  0  1) 6.  .   #) #0#6%  "    #  )  ##/ 011#     . # 6  #   6.%0 )   6.#  . 7# $ ") ",A )"A)"A) "A)" A1 "A $ %"       #71060     )  . 177# 0      "