Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-281/9 AI generated

2-05-281/9 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-05-281/9
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-281/9 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

     

      !" #  !



          $%&'$&$(()*+#      $,(-,$.'                             

$'&(/&$(()           0000001 2       (-&'$&$(()          1  34 000000 3" 555555555554&

 34 000  3" 555555554 1 " #& ! "#$

% &          '()*+)',   -               (. +',    - +* / 

                   0              ( /                   &             )         '()*+)',    )  0         )                    ) !        0              +* 0

           -     0         

     )                -                 )

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

    #;;  #;"     " ($&(-&$(($ + !! ! !  11  !" -((( & ! !    :  66  #"#1"1# &66" "#"   +"

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

1+"  "66" #+! 1"" +11# !!:  $((7&&#!2"!2& (-&('&$((- # &$$'--7.' 3! ; '8&('&$((-4 $%&('&$((- # &$$77/()7 3! ;'(&($&$((-4')&($&$((-#&$$%.($$'3!;($&(/&$((-4&  ! 1    ;"  ;   +      " #" !&  -&! #3& &'$(4#""  #  "#"  66#"  "! " 3  4 9)  9<  9/% &$  1 ;# "!!+&  )&  $'&(/&$(()  ;  "!  +"" 1" 66 '%/$)   ## /(-((  ! ($&(-&$(($ 66 1  + !" !! 11  :!!"  "1 1"!+#!$$&'$&$((766 1&-88 +1!  11    : !    !+ #;   "'-(( +#&# "   !+ #;    #+ # !! / )-/  8(    "  $-( & > ;;"  & ## +" !! /($  '(  ; #  "!& 

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

1;# ! 8?  '$&('&$(() # !;"&  " ;" "  1+"" #;###+"!!/($'( "!& 

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

#  ! !  11   !  # "   66:  ;!&  66"    +1" "  1 ! 22 ! +   1+"!        " # "!" +""  !  !   66 ;! &&  "  11 !&  ; #!     66"     :    #;   "  3& & $$,$. -%,%-4& ""  !"+ " "##+#&  97/) &';#  ! 1 1#   1+""&  ; "!    ! : #  !  1"!    "  1  !+ 66  #  !  #+! !66;!":  #; "& 

 "#;; ! +!&"< 9/)#"  !;! 66+!1 #"     + "!#; 266;!" " 1"!+#& "" ;#!+;!  + "!&  " !  > 98%  98. &' ;   #"  " "! 66" #" #    66; 66+!1 66"+ #&  .&  !   # 1 2 +  1  1 2 ; 2  "!&

 !"++""!1 ;"#!  1   " " !"  !2 +"& A! "   #+    " #; 1" #   12    "! " +"" #+""  # "! ##&!!" "   ;"+"!! 66" ""!66 ##+!</(%66#"21#  !"&-((( & 66"       "!  66  !+" 000 , : "#+"&  ""1 ""!!   66 #+!  " ! #; 1  66  66 ;! &   2& !  66"  2!;& #+ !  !;; !! #" "!! ;#+"#+"  !1""#+"1;# !+"& !!#+! "!66"1 66   " !" &   ! +""!#;"  1"  !   !"  1" ! 66 ;!     " +""# 1 ;1 : #+  " ; !" 1"#; #+""& 

;;#;"!! 11;"#+! ""   2&    !   66  "  + 66:  ;!  ;"  "   "    2  #; 1  66&

1""+"# "66 $7  "1;# 3& 11;#"4"661"!000 ," "!" #+! +!   ##  ! ;;! & 66"   !1; ! !" #" ;;!  #  ;  #+"+"!   ! #+ !&+ #;"!   " ! #" 66 ;!      " +" +""&($&(-&$(($+ !"!! 1#2+ +" "+ &     #;;  "" ! + !&      #   #"       :  "     #;"  +"!+ "!1"2+  & 

  0  8&  2! ##"  2 9)-) &'1&) &$  1 21+" !:" :" ;2#!!! & 

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

   !    #;"  66 !" # 3  !4 66"1  !" "!    "&   2+ "     +"!!  ""   1" +"!      !   2 "& #  +""&     ;2#!   2 !  +1   !   " 1   +"!  +" !  ##   9$/(  "   #+!  ;"# +"    ($&(-&$(($  11 1&/&/ !" !1"! , ! ;  !  #;   " 1  :  ($&(-&$(($  11+ !! 3 ! !! 4 "#"!  "! #"1"! 66++""!  " + ##&

2!; 1  ($&(-&$(($ 1 + !" 66 1 ! 66 1!2!;!& ! " 3& & '7,'. /'4 + !" 1 " (.&(-&$(($ 66 1 &)%'  " "     ;    66 1    ;;" ($&(-&$(($  1& $$&'$&$((7 +1" 1 " '7&(%&'88% + !" 66 1 &-88 !    ! " 1"2&   "  ;2#! !!& " " !  2! #"9'/7 &/!   #+     " #  +"   : # +""& 

 "  "  9)-' &' 9)-% &' 1&/ 9)). &' 9)%( &'&      

  # !