Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-05-2441/8 AI generated

2-05-2441/8 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-05-2441/8
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

     

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-2441/8 · Viru Ringkonnakohus:      

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

     

     

                     !"#!"$##%&'( 

    $)#*)$++! 

   ,  ------    ,  ----  (.  $/+/%0% '1,----(.,------ (.#!"#!"$##+123....4 '1     

.!*"#*"$##0.          

 ,----322.5        !!"#!"$##%              322.6.  ,  ----  7"1  88888888 .  - . 8 (  2  1) 49  12 1  

..6,------7"188888888 .  : . 8 (  2  1) 49  12 1 ""2321";"    !           "#$%#$&%%'   

  $&%#&(("   )*      + ,,,, + ,,,,,,         *         &&#%-%% .         

! /  

0 *    $  +,,,,,,   +,,,,      +  ,,,,      +  ,,,,,,    0              "#$%#$&%%'        0            0   )*  $

 $  0 *   +,,,,+,,,,,,                 *          "(&(  .!           !   / 12  $  +,,,, )          $  +,,,,,, )         &#%-%%.   

! / 0       $          )   *            

  1%)0       0         -      )0 

  33      

        $   4'5"$#       0  -               $         -     *              $   6        0     .<.  ------  .  #0"#0"$##*  (  .2  (21 .<----(.$$%####3'('2$=* $*#((. .21'1" (212.'241321#!"#!"$##+1234222. 1.2124.<"32....1442 2.  1.  $#####      ((.  #*>  .4.  144.   ((..13?(." .  4  .    .?.1$##+@$##*..(1!$#####" #!"#*"$##*.('2$#%####24$##*1.$##### #!"#*"$##*((44$=* $##"  (  .  #"#="$##*  .2.  21.    .?  2.   .2.4'..(?2*$$ $*#('2(..++#### .21.."  ..#%"!!"$##*(.2(214.2..4".2 ...#/"!!"$##*"  .! "!$"$##*(.2(21(?1'. 32.2.(?24'.$/+/%0%3'('2.21" (212...(5..22.!#"!!"$##*((.$0=!!## 3'('2+/%=## !%=###" 



.4!!"#!"$##02(...121.#!"#!"$##+ 123  .25  21  .<  (21.  <21  1  A  /+  4'.." .<.4...21<.4224?.41.4 2(...4.<4'..2.1<414.<.24. <.(114"32..24.4.<1214..25 (121?.(." .21.!#"!$"!==/123222?(#!"#!"$##+123 '24.124'24.2(..4<212..", 3'42'.?..'244"  ..$ "#$"$##0 .2(.(21(.123 ....4" ..(.*$$ $*#(?24'.4#!"#!"$##+ 123?...4...?.4".123?42'24.1 24<.------.(2.124.<12:.8( 515.  3.4" 24<.  ------  52  21    .. 4...21<.  .  #!"#%"$##+  " .  .  21 .  3?. .<.  24.    .4.    #!"#!"$##+  123  .."  3'4?.1..<.4...21<" 1 '2'1A $=!2"!2".<121431.5'.4 24.(123(''241<212."1 .1"1'111..1...."  4 #"# "$##02(.(.232?..214."

.  2.    (.    (4  22  . .  3?.  .<. 24.    #!"#!"$##+  123  .. 2" .1 123    1 .4  '    .5  .4  (1"   <212.2 ..2.2.11..1..<. .21212212322.1(.2"  ..?3.$0"#+"$##0..2(.3.(.21.123 '244.25.<.1'24.144'27."2"! #9"     

.!*"#*"$##0.21.,------,----(. $/+/%0%'14..1444'...2.(?2B .(.(.#!"#!"$##+123....4'1 ?.214.B.2.4'..(?24.221..0##### 7$$*###'521 %*###2'(9B.4.221 ?..411" ..  2.    .(2  4.21  .(..1 .  #!"#!"$##+  2 24<.------71219.7.9(2'24.1123 422  ?  121  1    .  ('..  .  .4  .  . 1212  2(  (  23  ..?.1  .4.2" 3  4  2 4.<  12  : . 8  ( 4  2  24<.  ------  41" 3 ...  4.<  1214  44  !=####        2.25 .14.!####$#####422.31 121  3(2  14  242.  (    (4  3?("

 + ?.2..4.4.2.31..4((.#*>3?(((..1 3?(  ."  .    2  .?.1  4  232  ."   (.

'2'1A%02"!A!#!2"!3"!A!#/2"!21. 3'1.1252142".2.1..?.14. '.2.(21(.('2.4.2.2(..2" .  7  (.9  .?3.  (42  ..2 .  #!"#!"$##+  '24.1 123...7.(.9(..22 ..12.14.<4"22.254.<..42" .  1  '1  2.    .  22.  ..  .1     ?.. 4.21 (.(2.  (?2...2  $="#0"$##*" 2.2  ..1   .  . .  .4  ('2        /$!###     '1 (?14  (21.  ?.5 .  .  .  !#"!!"$##*   (5..22.  44 !%=###"(.2(21.<211A/+A/*A /0)/=A=#)=%A=/2"!A!##2"!21..22..1.'11 22...3CC132(21..<.4" 21...4'..<.43?.(21 4.44 !%=###.4...."21. 2(.3'1.121422"4.'. 1   .  (.  '    1 (1.    (21. <21  1  A  ==  2"!  3"$    A  !+ " .(2.  (?2...2    . 4.21?..$="#0"$##*(.2..1$ "#$"$##0" 3CC...?2322.#!"#!"$##+123'244 224.<424<.------"D.14.2224<. ------#!"#%"$##+""32#!"#!"$##+123'244.<45(4..1 .<.------" 2112. '2'1A$=!2"!21 .3224<.------<45(4.4..<.------ 24<.2------2(4.<.4..422?1#!"#!"$##+ 123..2(1121'1.1<2412 4'.#!"#!"$##+123.(.".4(1 17.<.1A$2"!9('5231'241" .(?1.22..24<.------.242 "")221 '.123222.1'.1"&.. #"!$"$##  3.22.?.5.....11233.22222.4 ..<21.42 "")2" ..  4'..  .2.      (?2  (212.  ..1  2'( 44 %*###'52144$$*###"   6)     *  )*    .4 #"#0"$##0322.53254...<.1. .422?..214.211(." 322.52.1'4.4' 1((2142.42?.42" 322.21..<.------224<.------'?2" 2.(?1.24<.------2<45(4..1.<. ------" .<.  .4  .45  (.(2.  .<.1  '.2" 3'4?.1..<.4...21<4211 .4  32.  .41  4    2(.  : . 8  24    4.< 4'..2.1<41424.<.(114"

 * ..4322132.#!"#!"$##+123?222 22  ..  ..4.  2142" .  (?1  22  . .  322.   1(..4.?.#!"#!"$##+123....4 32'2"     22.  (?2  4'.1  .2.  '521" 1   ?..5  1 '14*>21.1.""44.$/+/%%0"         4!/"#="$##02(.322.52325?..5 214. 4  .4  ..  4.4.    .2.  (?2  4'. 322.4.221"

.2...24<.------24.<.------ .  2.  4  24.  (1" 12..(  123  '244   4.??1  1.  (?24'.4  2  1(2.    1.1   <212.2"

123'2442#!"#!"$##+214.<(2..1.4 42"3.2'3322#!"#%"$##+" 23221...<.224<.'?2" 1'.0)2.4.?.(.2" 4  .4    4'.  '.  .2.  (?2  '521 44  $$*### 4<2.1..?.1.E*$$ $*#74'98##* F 0!!0*"'1(?14.4.2.4?. 32.  (5..22.    ('2  .4" 22    (?  '  44 $/+/%0%"        32211..2241"!#"#!"$##%(21.. 322...15.32.1.41('.." 

..2?1(..1142(.1321 ?..322.5214.4..4.4." ..11 32132212.(?24'.322.4.22144!+#### 72321";"32.(..4*####..2 240*###121 "".312144$*### 9"      )*   

..(1?2(.(24.2121.322.5 22.3'1.14...2522..<.1.<..1 ('42.." 

12..(  ..    4  .2.      4'.1  (?2 $/+/%0%32.(2.123..2(('2.." 

 0

'.54..144(?24'.43'1..4.2 125.4(2..(.12.#!"#!"$##+123 '244224.<:.8(224<.2------"

.(2.(222.22 1) ...2   24<.  ------  <22  .  (42  # "#!"$###  .4(21 22.1!$"!!"$##!244:.8(2414..1     ...1  .  %*!  42  .41    #+"#%"$##  .4(21  22    .1  #="!$"$## "   4.  .   .(..1.#!"#!"$##+123'2442224<.4.<4.25 4..22.<.1" 322.5(?122'" 4    .  .1  3'1.    .<.4    .  .<.4.   214    .(  '  2.  ('5  <<21  7(.(2.

'2'1A +!1219224(2 222.'2315"'4'..22.('5(2 ('..12<<23.(2(?2<<422 <<23.(" .(2. '2'1A!$2"!4'.23.(. 2.23'24422.?.4('4.('.<<21221 ?.4'."?2(2(12.22<2.4.<-. 8  (  2  .  .2  <2    .    1  .1" 4.  31(1   4.21  .'11  22  . .  .41  21  42  (2  4.< 1214  (." .31   4.21    24  24<.  . #"!$"$## 3.227."2"/%9422..42(2.11232 22.4"  4..4?.1214..(." 

.  (21  7."2"=0)=%9  2.  21  . .  1  '11  1 ..1..."4222(21(1.1<212 422(....31"$0"#+"$##0.41..27."2"!$=)! #9 .?3..1(.21..4.4" 

.(2.  (21.  <21  1  A  =$    4  5'  ... .2.21."2244'2..1..('5.<.1" .<.4    <32  1' 41  ...  ..(21  .2 3221..?.1.?.2".(212221(4'11 1  .25  .'11  22  .  32  '14"   .  .<.4  (' ..  ..4  4  .1    " 1  .5  '2'1 141A%2"!422?.45..<.43?.#!"#%"$##$ (11?...1"    ?2(      4  .(.1 .  .    2  2  .1 (.(2...(21...<.44'.?.1(. 214." '.54..13'1"  42'4..(1(.42(21. <211A==?...1.?.124.?.1"<.4'2 '42242"4.32.?.1'.2'3.(. (?2..?.1"   4    4  .  (11 (. 32   424..1.2'.25.3'1122 .<.1"4.2.4...<.4(.

 % 4.2.(.214(..25?..214. ..(214...4.2322" 

.(2.(21.<211A==2"!3"$('5.42 .<.12(.4..14." 4.212. .(214.21?..$="#0"$##*7."2"$$9"22 32.?.242.22.3?(." .(2.(21.<211A !##2"!2'35..<.4'..<.4'..1 ...5"..<.4'..1.<.42. .5..?152...." 4.212... 2  !#"!!"$##*    ('2. 44  !%=###    7."2"+/9" .  . 3'1  22   .      .  ..  .1   '   322.5(?1222."  ,22.122.254..22..<.13'1..22 .211(.?..214.4.. 4.4.?.1?2(...113'1.2" 

12..(  ..    4  .2.      4'.1  (?2 .21..'521$$*###" 

.(2.  #!"#!"$##0  '.1  (2.4.2  1.    ?.4.2 1.  14  1  A      4..1  1  '.4.  2..1 4.23221.4.221.421124??42 .1(2.4.21.?...." 

.(2.#!"#!"$##0.1(2.4.21.A0!2"!3"! 4'.5    322 22    .  .. .2.  322.  (?2  (21   3'1.121.4132...1'5.32 *>21.1.2"  ?2(    21.    44  $/+/%0%   * > 22.  44. 41.5!+$+ /"    .  (.  322.52 .  .1    .4  '1 (?14    .  32. 44(5..2.4.2(2. 22.4..(?24'..1'52144$$*### 3'1.12'" 

.(2.#!"#!"$##0.1(2.4.21.A0$2"$ 255.22..3?..4..?.1 '141(5..22.('5'124.22'3.44?? .2.(?24'..21" 

25.?2(222.4..254   315  32  1  7 #!"#!"$##0  .1 (2.4.2  1.  A  !/$9  .  729  254  (21 4. .4??.729254(.('.4." 25. .12.4.444.4" 

 / ,22.122.254...<.1.2.4.221.. (?24'..1'52144"22('42. .    .2.  25      (?24'.42 !+$+ / " 322.522252142"  322..21..2.322.4.2.12" 

..  1.  ..2  322.4.2  '521  (?24'.4 44!!*###.25(.(2.#!"#!"$##0.1(2.4.2 1.A0!2"!3"!?..214.4..1?.....1*>3 .5'..4.324..1*>3(.(44 '521  ..      5  (?2 4'..1" ..  1 '121  44  $*###    ?.5    (..  1  322.522.3'1.1252142"  322.5(?1.4?5.'25.11 (?1.2    (..1  22.  4.  .  3'1(   422   '.5   <2??1    ?2(  .  . 3'1(  "   315  (1  322.5  (?1.  21 (?2.414" 

1..422.1.(2.4.21. A0*!A0*$A0*+A0*%2"!3"!A00/A0%#"         

 =