Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-02-381/9 AI generated

2-02-381/9 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-02-381/9
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-02-381/9 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

     

      !" #  !



          $%&$'&'(()*+#     ',(',-%$                                  !      ",   '.&(/&'((0  #  &', 0/01(-           2222223 4       '%&$$&'(() "          3  56  222222 5" 777777777776 3  " #""# 8 !!&

 56 22222222  5" 77777777776 3 " #& #$ %&'

( )     ' !  "  *+,,*      ,*-.  /                   0 

1     +2          *     1                      )      1    !  " , "   1   *+,,*    , 3        ,               1     , $         3 

0         #   . 31

      1     /   

31    44      

     ,     

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

8 #"3 !!" &:!"## ?9( &$ ?$$. &- 4#  "#::+"&   # 33&/&':444;!+# "# :""'(&3:# !"3:#  !88 &3 3&/&-:4"!# "#: #!+ #"! & # " 8 " " 5I6 ?$-% &$ :4  +! :!  4!"& # # '.&(-&'((' #:3:#$$%$%(<<%009%/&22222222 #5 "&& & $0',$/$6 :4    # <   :" ! (%0/0/  (%0.'$  (%0.%95"#:6(%0%(9& : "4:" ! :8!   3$("#:!":&  "8+":" !!  "#4"#& 

   #"      3 #+ "  #  3"   !++"!" "&  #! +3! +3: :4#""+ ,!+ # 4: "!&   3       0  /

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

:4 :  &""#":#!" :"  & 3+"! #"3 4"+"&')&(%&'(('" 3     #:  4" +"  "   : " 3" #!  #: "&4+"#" 3 !::" '(&3,:""33  34 !" + " 8!&  #4  #  !   &-,',$,-%,9) !  3"#!:!  !#!+"&!"  #+! : ""! +"3"4# !    "  #   4    8 #" #   # 3 !!"        ;" !  !"  !    "  ! +& !  #" J $(-) +    " +""   &    "    ""  , )$(-)& 3 " 8 "   # 8  " &&8 "  +" "8 "&3"#": # +""# &  5#63+"!  # 4#  #!! "! &  .&  !   #  3 4 +  3  3 4 : 4 "!&

  "#:" "8+"     4"    .'$0-/ =&       3 3 &&8 #!+"3+"!& 3"#  ! +# " #  " !#""!" #!++""  :""& &&3 !##3:"# " 3!" ##"+ 3& A!   4!#!3+""# #"+"# #" "#:" #:4"    +"& #:" ! 4:3  !!   4 "! # "  # !& "#:"  !" 3""!&  !   3           %&  $/&(9&'((/8!:  "! "#&

 "  !   #     : ""    + #&3" "#::"3 !       # & !  :"   "!  # :"#"#+!  4!#: #! ""   !#  & ""!"" "  +""3  4!""!";":":& A+""   ##:"    ! 4!       #+! & ++"3&8 "+ &3"3 8   "&I  "   <<3"    ! 8 " 3 " "&   3: '.&(-&'((' !"! ;" < : %009%/ :" # !  < 4!

:"G(%0KH& !4  "  " +"&

  +$99%&&!:'(('&& 4"    /)09%0  (0 " !  "#::  +""& + " @?$($ &$3&$  # # !+"&  "($&(.&'((-"" 56 ?$) &) "   #+!  " !    #! "  43<<""#+ +"#"  "!  3""  #  # !     !+  3+!+ :#& #!! 43""::!  4+! "! 4+  "+#"&  9&  #  ! (%&('&'(()   "  4 $/&(9&'((/8! +!!+"  :4#!!  &  A  3"4#"  8 "# $'&(9&$99/+ !" # 34!3!#+! )- &A "#" #" 8  3" (-&(-&$99%($&(%&'((' # 3"  #:!         4& ! # "   8     + +3" #!&  #  ! + 4 #:     3+"!"! "?''. &$?--( &0&  #:    (-&(-&$99%  4#   !++! 3 ""  # 3:# 4! : (((((9  <   4! : (((((0& '.&(-&'(('  " #:"" ##  $$%$%(  %009%/  ($&(%&'((' $'-''%  %0%$((&  #:     '.&(-&'((' # : <   4!  (%009%& #  ! "  #"  "! 3"  3 #  3#"! #!# "#:""! 3::#" 4"     :  "!  #:"     # ;":"4! "  #+! & !#:" #!3 #+! ##:" &

  "    "!" ;" !     4!  #+!  " #!++ !"   +"&      !:"  "  +"" !  3+      : " "&     #+!   " !   3" ! 4!!3 #  #+! &     :4#!  34  #+! !   3  #"   #:"8 &A::"#!#+!  88"#:" 4"   !++ ! 4+ &   +4 : "    #:"":4"+34! " ## 3+"!& 

4 :4#"3 4  &  !  3  3 4"&   +   !

  "      4"    !+ !  #:  0.$''0& #  ! "" "!!+!  !"    !+  3+!+ #    #+  +   "&  ! +       #!!+#"& +""  4 #+ #    3    #+  4      #" " 4"#&  #   30    $(& #"! ": "3 " " ! '.&(0&'((0   # ##   !   "  ?''. &$?''%?'-$ &0+  43 43+" ! ?)/) &$3&/ &'  8"! !!+  "       3+""       #+!  3" +# ""8" :4#!!! &   ?0-% &$ 5 ($&($&'(() "  ?''%6 :   "4  +""4! "#"! + 4 ""  4 "! &"!+4++ &##!" + #& 

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

!   "!  335"6#+ 3""#+ "  #: "+4+ ! #:  !+: 0.$''0%%&!!!   "&    4?0-% &$5($&($&'(()"?''%6 34  ! 883! #+!  !  4   !",  # ## + !" 3"#"  "! & $'&(9&$99/  # 3 3&/&)& :   4 #+! :!

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

  + !        "  #  3"   !++"!" 5#"6  "&        #  ++"&  !  !++#"  #" !::!4!"!&   3   ($&($&'(() "  ?'-$ &/ +"" " !   8 "!:"! 222222#&   ! '.&(/&'((0     3   " #"  !  !!9-./9$)5/)09%0(0,0.$''0%%6: "!  !"  # ?)/$ &$5 ($&($&'(()"?-$9 &$6 & 

   :4#!   4 !  +3   !  5 ?-9'6 #:   "  +""  #  $'&(9&$99/  # 3 #:"# !  3  #"  !::   : # " :"! 3  5 " :"# # ! 4 " 4!3"  883! "!6 3 ! ":  5 ?-)- &$ 3&-6   ##:"  :""    :  ""  +   : !    !  + 3  "+"""!  3:1#++ 4 ""&   "  :4#! !!& 

"!  "?)/. &$3&-?))% &$ ?).( &$&      

  # !