Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-06-30610/4 AI generated

2-06-30610/4 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-30610/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

              

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-30610/4 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja:               

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

     

                     !"##$%&'(      ")#*)+#*#    ,   &-. /!'&0- -'(                &- 1,   2314445%'1444 &- ! 1 214445&- --

6-3!1. 2314445%'14445

6-3! - !  ' -3   21 4445% 444 '!/!'- 24445   

      ##"##$      

6-- &-''!   '!/!'-                    !!"#$%&%'

   (((     !)* 

   +""%  !&*""*  ,          -  .((('((('. (((/(((*  0   1     2   !+*"+*+""%  !3*4"- 

,  

  

  !* +,   *  5             *          

    

 *  -  1                      -   !& #"" 6    

    7        

 $3""6      7  *  0 

      '- ! 63 ' /6 !' /--'!7  !3!!'- +# /0& - -' ' 0'''('('%  ('' - (  &  (88(- ( '(''&--'''&'3('    

&-!")#*)+#*#  "2$5  6--  ,    2/1 &- 5 ' '- /!'&- &6-3!   . 2/1 &6-3!5 /!' &0- -'( "9!'&--'6-(&6--  &6-3!:#$"##*&6-'!!' ! +;;$"%(--&6-3!'!!'(&6-3!&'&- ((+####!6 -7 /6&6-3  !' !!3 - (!' !6 -&'(3 .)-' ! !&' 9- -// % ' &6-3 '' (/(  &'&-' &6-'!!'- +#$"##* 6-3!'0'!&6-'!!''!6'-' 6-3! 0''&6-3!& '0-' '(' 6-'!!'' '-!& /6&6- 00  /!'&- '(3('7+####!

6-3! &- &-!:#$"##*6-('&6-'!!' 6-63 2/1 <5=+#(6''%!--3'!!'7&6-3!&6--(- '7-- '( 6-'!!'-(--/-& '&'%'%(---(- '!!''%-'3--'-( (--'!6!7

'&-'/-'&-6-('&6-'!!'-'&6-3!(( ('0'3'(''!!/(-&&#%>?'0'3-''('((-'/0&% ('-&6-'!!'(-&- -63!6-'3&6-(( '('!0-&- -!'3('/!'&-3/&- & - &&'!6'('/!'&- &- !'!&6-3!-&-'-  --'''/!&6-3!& '(% 6-3!---'-('(''0'!

'&-' <==$* :"'-7''0'!6'-&- !-(00' '0' -&'&-' -/!30''- !&6-3!--3/-' --!&6(-!'!&6-3!&''(% '-7&- &6-3!(&6(- &- !"/'(7-"##*&6-3! '-(- -- &'@-/!''

6-3!-'!(&6-3!&'!0-& ! &- -7%'!-'-%'&6-3!!0-!'3('/@&-'( 6' ''&6''3 '&-'9!'=#-3"/'&-  ,  &6-3!&'/!'&- /-7'-&0- -' . /!'     + -3'"#!&(7-"##*'-'(003. /!'(!'-% !('  ' /!'-  %   ' &0-  -3'( &6-3! &  '!!3'('---!      

 '/!'-!!&6-3! ./!'(!'-

6-3!/6-!'3&&-! !''(!%(@@ 9!' (!'-(03 .2/A 6-3!B%A.B&6AC@!3B5/!' !'&'' ''-- 03!&'1 $*!*                      $*!*!*8  -1   !6  '! /!'- 6-3!-' !( ( !'3& ' '- --  6!!'!0@!3 '-'6&'!( 6-3! '&0'--!

&-!")#*)+#*#  +2$5 &6(- ! 6 &' !D'% !  - !-' ' -(-' ! 6 ('/((!'2'(''-!7--'%'!! '-3!''-! -( (!' '0--' @- !('5 6-3! ' ! '!!'! &6-3! /@&' ( 6''

'('  --% ' &6-3!-'  -  6 &' !(%  '! - /7 ''7 ' '-  ' - !! -(-&' !(' 7-  !  &6-3!&%!&0-'&6-3!&!(' ''!'(-!'3!'-(!'-''-'3'!D-  $*!*+*-1     1        99        !&'3''!!3( ('!'''! !D('!/6 --3%' &6-3!(7/!3&E(/9!2 00#)5% )!/!2 00"$#*45 "'/!-/& " (' !6 6-3! &' """##* 3 !    2(--- -!& !'5%!6''''0'-!!6( + 3'' !('- '  !!  /&% 6'' 3'' 6' %---/7--!-'2 '&0'-&-!%(!'5 ; 9! -!3D( !('- '& -/!3 /& 2-/!3 (/ !3  -6//!5 >00!) ' 3'!!!('-(('/!/& *''0''-'0'(-) --('!6 $''!('(3) (!'-!6  $*+*  -1   

3'!!- !('-1 6-3! 3'!! 03' '' :"##;  '3'!!3'':#"##* 6-3!-''3&' !"##> /'-;#### ' )!1   -'#>#*"##* !! -' #>#"##* !!   ,' -(' - ! >#*"##*     % ! #"##*   -' #>#"##*  !!  ' -3   63 0@!3- /7C@!3( !'-3!# !- -6//!+'(7-

6-3!-/7( !'3&%'&'88'/&

6-3! /6'3& /'! ''(! '(! '( !/!- ( &- 7!( .@-/!3 -6/'' @@-!  /-' '( --' )-' (/ !3((@@ '!--'!'&'@'3'&'-/!3'  $*4*-1       '- --  6!!'! ''& 63 &' 0@!3 ('/( !('3

6-3! ' ' 7-! /!'(!'- -3'( 3 2"#"##*5 ' &- ! !-'3(-  '! - '3! &- 3'' !('-% -(!'-''-'3'!D('!- &6-3!''!('-  -   -3' ''!('-'0@!3-/!-&!((") 

E; 6E+>*"#$

3''-&&E62-&'%3''(&6'('5 &2&--& !!&5!(/-  '!-!!6! &6(-!&6-3! '-'6!(&'

6-3! ' &0'- ! !6 !&' -/!3/'!' &'%  &7''--'  - &!'&6-3C@!3&6-3!/-'''&'&0'!6('-,'

&-!")#*)+#*#  ;2$5 !!!3-&67!6'(''!6'&'2!--''&-'( -//'&!6'35-''6'' '!-!77''!6'&00'#  :   1            '  ;-1     !$400*   '---'-&'&6-3/6 -!(&6-- ) --(' 2F + '5 6-3! /-' !  -! %++; (- ! 6-' ! '- "%$>(- ! 6-3!-!/- ''%-'!''('--' !'%( 0 6-3!/-''!(' ('' ((- -!& !-' !')-//'&% (-- ((  - '

6-''/&-'!7&''&'!')-//'&3   ;-1   '          '3"&4))4  *        

  !   -1   1 2    2       * '! - ! &0-  -3'! &6-3 -(- -3'! &0- % ' /& - &!  ( &% ' /7 (- '3&% ' &0-  -3'' !(' -' ! &6-3!(/'--3-'!3'&! '!-!-%'/7-!&  '' &6-3! /!'! '&'( '0!&' D!!'!-@@% ! &6-3! ! 3'!('-'-3-'( 6'  $*$*:  -1   1     

6-3!-/7--3)&00'&%(--3-&6(-'!('&6 -% '' &6-3!&('- 6-3!( !'3&!-6//! !!3 6-3! D!!'- ! /&-' -&!! ! 6-3! ( !'3& ! -!%-&6(-&6-3!( !-- 0/!(! 9!' (6'' -'  '7 ( 6' !' -%  6-3!   '0'3-'(''0'9!'=-3" 03 6-3!!( 6'%' -&6-- !6 '('-&6-3!( !-'-' '-!&-' '! !!'-''! '!/!'--%' 6-3!!/3-'--% '('633-''0'!!3 6-3!-/&-&6(- ('''0'(%'-& 3! 6-3! '-!('-'( 6'  $*3*   1        1          1   

   1 

  '! - ! &6-3! ' '! &0-  -3'% ' &6-3! '3- /'! ''(33&'(@@/!- (&-- ''('' )-'(/!3 -' ( 6-3!- -3  --' 7 '3& -3' 2'!3 -- ) 7/& -3/'-  /-!' ( 0&'-5 &- !(' 03 &6-3!- '''0'(-'&&'-'3'"##>)''(&-% (- )-' (/ !3 ' !6 -!3-/!3 -6/'( .@-!  /-' 8- (3-'@-@@-/!3'''0'(' 0'(32.@('' /!--/!3-6/'(3@@-! '-5 6-3! -!3! /-' &66!'-'(%!'3& 0'(!-!!(&6(- 3& -6/'(3  '(! '!3'   '! - /7 &6(- & '3&6'( '3!6(-'-(-0-&/!'(!'-!&6(-%' ! '(! @' &6-- ' -'(! ''- ('' 7 '0/(  -  '6!&0- -3'/!'(!'-03

&-!")#*)+#*#  >2$5 

6-3! !!!3- ( 6' /( /6  - &-&' 0/-! - /-!''(0&'-%-7/&-3/'-6&6(-!'3' 8!(-' (--'''(- 03!/7-('88 63 '! '!(- '! - !6'7 &6-3! 3 ( 6' /6 ' ' ! &6-3! (/'--&0%'!&6(-'''!/-!&0--'            ""                           

 

       # $      

%&       

   $          %    $                                                      "     

        

  $    

            !    $           $        

            '          (  )* $   +  -'&0-  .G3'444G/!' " 00' /!'- '! /!'- !!' ( !6-'  '0'( /!'-@-! +6'&0-  '-' @&'-''''2''---'5 ;'&6-- '(!@-- > &-/!'' (!@--3&0- ! ('-!!!3 (--@'-'&'%'1

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

6-3!-&6-3!&''''0'('&67&'&6''@!-       ''!3- - &6--  !    '! /!'- 6-3! - '! '- -''-/!'&--07&'-(&6-3!! &6'' 

&-!")#*)+#*#  *2$5 ''!3- 0  '! /!'- ! ''  % ' &6-3!- !  '(6-7- 6% 6- ! &0- '' '- --!-'/-% (--' &67 0-%'6'444!66-7- ''6'0/''  '!/!'-!('!%''-7'&'

6-3!'' ( (- !%/- '--(!/--'&(''% -''&6-- '3!'''&- 6-3!!! '-3 ! -!   /! '- /!'-- /- 6!!'! 0''  6 ('/((!'!'-' '-('-'''&6-- '-('7 &6-3(7"(- !'!%!&6-3!&6-363-&6-- '-(7>%(- !' ! '!/!'--%'''&6'!/@&-'( 6' /-&0- -'''&6'' /!'%   '' '- !6-' 0'' /!'-!% !!'  ' /!'-' @&'!!3(00'&6-- '(@--3 

6-- !  0&-'' !!3!6' '/!'- !''3!!3/-&0- -'&6-3!/!'  -   

'&-'9!=-3"!&6-3!( 6'%'-&6-- '!6   '('  - &6-3! ( !-' -' '-!&-'  '! 9! =  -3 + -' ! -' ' &6-3! ( 6'  %  &6-3! &  ' '( ' --!!-&6-3!( !-'-''-!&-' '!9!= +-3;-'%/!'&-!'!&6-3!%-'&6-3!( 6''  ' ! -! '&'('% ' &6-3!   - &6-- ' !6% &6-3! &  ' '( '   '('  --! !  - &6-3! ( !-' -' '-!&-'  '!  -7% ' /!' &0- -'(! ! /6 !'  '6!'&6-3!&-3 ----' -'6!'3%(' '/!'- &( @'-'3  9!'=+-3---'7&0- /!'%&6-3!!( 6'  9! = + -3 > -' /!' &0- -'(- ''7  &6-- ' ( @-- '((    % /!'- 2-5 !('( !!3 3 '3( 7!6 -( 6- 0'( /!'-! ! !!  .   /!'(!'- !  ' -! '3'!    -7% '   ! 7&  /!'--!' &6-- '-  9!="+-3--! '---63(@-!!''0'(''%(--  (007 % (' !6 ( @-!!' '0'( '' & - -'' @&'('(00(-&'7 '-@-!!'('%'   '-' '!-!'!&'%(--/-7&0- (6' ' /!'- ' " '!! ' * :## ! G&'3  '! H :## !G  & - -''G'!/'%%/0!3G'';>##!-7%'&'&-' '- /-' '' '88 -  (-% '-7  ' - ' (00' * :## !  & --'''';>##!%"+##!  ''!''-0'-''!!3 !9!'=-3"%-3+%"+%+-3 %-3>%=;+*%;;"%;>"-3%*+"-3%*++-3   

&-!")#*)+#*#  $2$5  G--G  '!