Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-06-34802/3 AI generated

2-06-34802/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-34802/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

, ,,,  >#, , >, "#! . "  )"*#$  #&*# # 1#($+, D&' .)$ # #$ 8 $+

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-34802/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja: , ,,,  >#, , >, "#! . "  )"*#$  #&*# # 1#($+, D&' .)$ # #$ 8 $+

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text















  

    



 !"#$







%&'($)"*$







((+'#

 

  





,!($'-,, $''

   



   

*.

/0"1 %'"!)#1#$12 (1$-3,3

)'""(.!1..1.-3-4,3)'""(.(2$+



      

 

!  

  $)"*#     .(( 5 *!

6.($ .( .(+! 1" .).'!  $   ( %$'

.(+"'77

#.5"8$!9 .(( 5)"#!

/0"1 %'"!)#



$)"*# .* )"(( 9(# 3 $''5 +$ .)$+

.(+!+!$*#$ ..)9+ 

 

   



.'! .)9(# $



  

 !

 



"  #$ % 

 &' ( )

 * 



 %

  

+,-. /,

    +,+0 /,

 1



,/. 2.

 





  

 

  3$

  





 

"  4 

 



  

   

$     

 





   



"#!12.8.#+# !"#$6 )!5)$.#9#1$#$59." .# !"#$

#9. $)5" .#.(.#$+92!$1#62*!$#, !12.8.#+2 #$9#92!$162*!$

" 9" $#5)$.*.1#9#!&#9.6$*$ " .)"#! 12.#9.(+! #".9##$+)&##

9$$ 1... )$...) .)$ # ).'!1#$: (+9.,

! 12.8 .#+ # !"#$ )&###".9#9.#  #  6&1 !"")$  "#$ #.($+

)"*#$ ,2$++)! "(&###$+#.1.. )"*#$9(# $; ,





!*53*61)6!37









.##$+ *. 6 $8 *! 92.# )"#! # *! )$) 1& ! 62*.(2$ $99 -3,3

)'""(.!1..1.+-3-4,3)'""(.(.(.#+9(# $)$ $+!"#$9(# $" .#1* ,

.1 +$ )"* # *! (.( )"#! 2 9..+ 5 5 ..#$9. 6.($

6.( 5

9.   $  "$# *! )"#!  # #($#

. ,#1 # 6.($  .# *!

)"#! '1+(',)"))$$99-- 5

.##$*#)$$+.#):99(+:))'""(.

! )$$):99(+  (#.  )'""(.

.  , .1 +$ .#9. .$ "( )"#! 12 

-353

.##$*#1..+)*)):99(+)'""(.!)$$):99(+1..(#. )'""(.5

9. "( )&" 1 *#)(. #$9#,! "( )"*#$1& . 9(# $ #($+ )"#! 

12 (2$+5 9.  #1.# 1..9# #$9# '1## ! (+. #&.(+1 #&*#! 12 (1$

.)1.+'.9.)

. ,!"('1#($+1..1.# #1..9'19)#&*#6&1 

!&'(1#6&1#)$(.*.)""#9.)$$6&1(., ,, "#!"(" ($+1..1.#$

 46&1, "#!1..1.12 *!"( 5

)*)#.##$*#( .+)*)

)'""(.!)" 9(#. )'""(.,..1.'1#9. "( $)12#$+)$$6.))$6&1

! # 6.))$  6&1, ..1. '1#$< 5 3=>6&1 ? -353 )'""(. @ 5-

)'""(.>6&15 5- )'""(. ?  4 6&1 @ 5 )'""(., $ (1 #  #5# 1..1.

: #862*.12 (.( &*#$1 #*$$!92.# .))$62*.92###56.++:*# .. 9

#. 8'... )"*#$6')#.)#

...)"*#$ #.1.. )" .$9. *(+ #.1.. ! (',  

3 (.(#.1.. )"*#$9(# $+$#.)$

 ;   $&###$#"(*!

*$1.##$+1..1.#62*.12 #1&.)9$ #$5,",$99-3-453

.##$*#1..+

.#):99(+:*))'""(.!)$$):99(+1..(#. )'""(.,

2$+2.$ .)62*!(+$

A ;    ((8 12 $ +!  2.$ (2$+ '* . )"*$#$ #&.#9.#  

'.))$9. , #1 # 12 2.$+$

A  ;     "( 6.( 6.($6"" # 

#&.#9.))"*$#$ .),A;-  )"* ##$ 8)"*$#$#&.#1#1 # 6.($ 12.

+$ , A ;  &##85 # )"*$#$ '.))$9.( "( 12 $*## #$ (1 )"*$#$

#&.#9# !&#9.( 12. 9.##)"*( #&.#9.( * #&.#9. 1..1.#9.(, A ;     6 

((812 $ +! 2.$)"*$#$'.))$9.)"'' (2$+)"*$#$#&.#9.#,

6.($12##.)"#!)"*$#$9)#*! 1#1 #.##$+'1# '*,6.($

*$#9#$) .) "(  #($# )$#9. : +#.(.9$+

.(.9$+B .  ,

.(.9$#6$()#.3, , ,)"* #)"*$#$)"#!#&.#96.($#5#1#1 #6$()#. 3, ,,

#$92. ##($#'1.+1#1 ##.(.9$#7.)'.#$+'1 +$#)"'' ,

! .# )"#!  '1+ +'.   CCC , +'. 9$$#$9.# . "  )"#! *!#

#1.#($+, #1 # .(.9$# 6$()#.  3, ,3,  # )"*$#$ )"#! .9  12.9 $ 

#1.#9*!#"9(.95+'.5)"(#)## 7"(.12.#.#')1...#.+9$$#$9.#)""

$$# (+9# .#9.,  (1# #$ (1 # #$ 8 $+ )"#! 1#1 # .(.9$#

6$()#.  3,, '1+ ($), '1# 9.##9.( 1#1 # .(.9$# 6$()#.  ,4, .

18#($+..).)"#!##$9.)"*$#$#,

A;    6)"* #12.812 $ +!5)$.12 (.)"()"*$#$#'.))$($+5(2$+

'* . )"*$#$ #&.#9. 1..1.#9. )"''  1..1.#, #1 # A ;     12.8

12 $ +!(2$+12 (.)$ #'* .)"*$#$#&.#9.1..1.#9.)"'' 1..1.#5'1#

)"*$#$.(2$#1)9$$#$9.#)$(.)"*#&.#9.(.,..1.9&&') "#)A

;4&###$+.(#'.9&&'59.   .(+$8-=#,&*#$+A;3&###$+

+.6".#..1$ 62*.92### 66..+ *! (.( )"#! .(.9$# 6$()#. , , )"))$

1..1. 9&&' 5 3 = 6&1 #&*# # #$9# $99#, .(.9$# 6$()#. ,-,

)"* # "#) 9) #$#$) '1  .##$+ $99 )$9.  *! ,  (1#

&*#$+12 (8)"#!*!  3 5

1..#.##$*#:)+)$$):99(+)'""(.!

)" 9):99(+(#. )'""(.59. #62*.(2$

*.*.(+ 9""+$#8-353

.##$*#

1..+)*)):99(+)'""(.!)$$):99(+1..(#. )'""(.(.(1..1.-3-453

.##$*#1..+.#):99(+:*))'""(.!)$$):99(+1..(#. )'""(.,









.1.. )"*#$9(# $+$#.)$

 ; -  )"* #.#8!9(# ($+)"*$

9(# $)$ $+!"#$9(# $" .#1* )"*#$"#$12.9(# $# 26#19&&'$,

#1 #;   )"* #)((8*.9(# $)$ $+6"" 5) )*!$)"#$

#*#., 9$#. #$ 8 *:1.#+ 1! .)$+ )"*#$1& .+ )$ $+5 9. ) "( ) 9(# $" .#

.(+!# ! (2$#!# )$ $+ (.( 9(# $" .# 2.+$)$ $+,(# $)$ $+ '* .#

).(+ )9&&'9.# 12.8 (2$+ ! *(+($+ .9 #9 )"*#$ # *(+. . +$1

)$ $+ 6'"6"'#."(  !"#$  $   6&1 !"")$   # )$ $+!"#$ )"*# #*#$+

*(+. !2$#$9.#

 ; -  , ...)"*#$ #.1.. )" .$9.  , ,  #

*(+. )"* # #.1.. ! ('     12.8 )$ $+")$9(+.) "  9$$*$ 

+")$9(#59. #(&*#$8.(+!"$##$+2.$8.##$9.)"*$#$,

!)"*$#$#$+.(+!6"" #"$##$+2.$8.# -6'"#(#.*.'*$ +#$+

" ##$ (8!!!.(+!1* 2 9.#$+ 6.($#59.+#2(+8*!

).((.#$).'.

.3 ,

.1.. )"*#$9(# $+$#.)$

 ;  6# &*#$+##8*!5#"((2$

!).'! .)$9(# 9.(.(.61! .)$)! &8.1#9.#)"*#$.#$(. ,.(+"'77

#.  "( )"(#" # ('<  #$($+ ,4, '... 2.1$ $99 335 )'""(.

*(+$9.(.#'.$9. '1 +$'1   -- 9&').+ 1..#($98'.) 4-4

(.( .#$)

/0"1 %'"!)#,... 2.1$ )$9.#)"(#'" .8'... 2.1$12#!

; 5,*,)"*$

;3 ,&*#$+:  #""+$#(.(!$*.(+$+A;;#35 5

-  5 5    6+ !5   5;;5  54  5   5-4  5   5

  !5   !5   !5   !5 -  !5 -5  55

;;  !6 5356 $8*!< *.1 +$'*$ ++B 92.#)"#! #*!

)$) 1& ! 62*.(2$

*.*.(+  $99 -353

.# #$*# 1..+ )*)):99(+

)'""(.!)$$):99(+1..(#. )'""(.!1..1..+$99-3-453

.##$*#1..+

.#):99(+:*))'""(.!)$$):99(+1..(#. )'""(.5)"))$ 3 5

1..#.#

#$*#  :)+ )$$):99(+  )'""(. ! )" 9):99(+  (#.  )'""(.B   .#+

9(# $)$ $+!"#$9(# $" .#1* ,!9(# $)$ $+*.1 +$.#9.

.$ "(< '... 2.1 335

1..+ 1..):99(+  )'""(. !  (#.  )'""(. !

2.$8.)$ $+ 3--53

)) #$*# 1..+ .#):99(+ .# )'""(. ! ))):99(+

1..(#. )'""(.,

 3* !

"#!." )"*#$ 1#($+>#, 35>,



 ! !

"*$" #$#1$($+#.1.. !9#'! .+ .85#)&" 1!12.8# !"#$

*.'*$ ++,

 ; -   &##85 # )"*$ 12.8 *! #"# $  12. "9   #$  *.

# !"#$ '*$ ++ *.1 +$ 9&'.#$+ ! !" $+ 2.$ .)$ # 62*!(+#$+

$ #$5)$.)"#!5)  )"*$"(9&&'($+1#9.#&*#!5." #&*# #1#($+5

..)$.*.#".9##.)"#! )&##1& .'...12.)$.#".9##.)&##1 .)$ #, !$*$ 

"#)*!.##$+7)#. .+1&.#+)"#!6"" #"9)12#$),



!12.8(.9##$+#"# $.#+)*.1 +$

;-  , !"#$

12.8;- 2.) (.9##$+!$*$ #*)"*#$.#$(.#6.+9#

;-  ,

"#! 1& !#)"*$*.1 +$!   .#$+9#'! .+4, ,,,5)"*$#+

)"#!# *.  ).'! .)$ # 1#9  6&1 !"")$  *. )&##9.#  # >#,  3>,

"#! "(9(# $+")$9(#6"#.$#$6"" #)&###".9##$+'.#'.!&'$)"*#

, ,,,  >#, , >, "#! . "  )"*#$  #&*# # 1#($+, D&' .)$ # #$ 8 $+









*!*..##$+7)#. .+1&.#+)"#!6"" #"9)12#$), "#! "(###$+*. 

1#9#!&#9.#!&'+#,

"*$$8.$)"* 5#*!"(2.$ .)$ #62*!(+($+"9*.1 +$9&'.#$+

(2$+9.#!;-   $ )$$ $8*.# !"#$'*$ +9. ,



!6 $8.#+9(# $)$ $+!"#$9(# $" .#1* ,

;  # 5!)"* #*.9(# $)$ $+)((86"" 5) )*!$)"#$

#*#.,%"" 5) )*!$)"#$#*#.5*:1.#8#. 6""  9$$*$ )"*#$9(# $#2##$

#)).($+1! .)$+)"*#$1& .+)$ $+, "*#$1& .+)$ $+59.*:1.##)#$((.#! 5)

'1#$+*:1.#.9#!&&($+#EE#$12.9$$6:.1.#$ )$#5*:1.##)6""  

9+  $# !9$ #$5($*:1.##)#$((.#!)$ $+, "*$12.8!&##)$ $+

#&. .)$ #12." . #6"" #(+.)(+5)$.1#6"" )$ $+1& !92.#9.(6""  #5) 

)*!$)"#$#*#.5" )#9$*#&&'9. #82. (12.892.# .),

#1 #  ; -    !  .#8 ! 9(# ($+ )"*$ 9(# $)$ $+ !"#$

9(# $" .# 1*  )"*#$"#$ 12. 9(# $# 26#1 9&&'$, ! !&'9.(

9(# 1)"*#$ *(+..##))"$(.)(#$+9(# $)$ $+!"#$,(# $)$ $+

!"#$ (&8 )"*$ ##5 9. .+ 9(# $)$ $+ ). 9(# $" .## 68 )(+9,

!+$ )"''  9&&'8 )"*$ ).(+ ) 9(# $)$ $+ 6'"6"'#."(  !"#$

9(# $" .#1* ,

 #""+$  #$.(+ $8 9)"*$ .$)"* 5 # )"#! 68 )(+9 *! 9(# $

)$ $+!#$9'... 9(# $+")$9(#.+)&###".9#9.)$ $+,







,(+'#

)"*#$(.)