Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-06-27834/3 AI generated

2-06-27834/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-06-27834/3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated



Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-06-27834/3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja: 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text







             !"#$%

 &'()% *#+%    ) ),( $        -., $ /0 ( .. %( (            +1  1 2$% 34+1)4%, 56 *(##)1 " 21121 65 *(##)1 2'!"/41$/1 *           "   %*#+$ !  !!1)) 5 + " ! 31)%!1) 1)," 2#!1*1(" !% !  ! ) &%( 1),#(77  $1 5 #0%"/  !!1)) 5 *#$"         

1("!1* / ) $!%    !  

" #$%   &'(  $% ")+, ** $%+$ *+ *, *%%*8// ), *%% *(##)1 " 211*8// ), 8*  )$1          " ,))+*- ** $%+$ 211, *+ **8// ), *+ * *(##)1 " *%%*8// ),  )$1'  + 

 , .,,+ 211 $%+$ ) !1, 211*8// ), 211 *(##)1 " 8*$ 1$  )$1         

. 9'$$ + "   / ) $!%*%!%, *#$" *),. . #$" 3 0 $%/ (111! *#+$%*%!%, # / ) $!%,#*%/ )$1, *'$$ $#1/ $/1 *%!%,.       

#$" 2410 1$, $ !"#$% 3 ! *"5 *%1 $ / $  2% $%5 /1 #!1 $ !"#$% $  /1 !% *5 #!1 $1)1$%, /4"%2$ 34+"% $. " 2410 1$, 4!$%/$ /4"%2 34+"% #! /#!%$5 *%1 +1 2$/$ "'$/1 3%+%! #!1 *#$"! 241 $ / 1),"! $#1/ $$%, *'$$ /%%! 2111! *%1 11*!1*%!$ !!*1(" 2$% 8! ),/1 .

" 2410 1$, $ !"#$% *'$$ $#1/ $/1 $ !$  3' 2 "##*%! #$% $ 1)%, *#+$%! . 4%, , *"! #) '$ $$%, $1211!*#+$%/ ) $!% :  .



 

!(/0(1+21!03 1$$%, +1 3!%0 + " /41$ *#$"!$ + " *%* 2'!" 34+1)4%  56 *(##)1 " 21121 ,  65 *(##)15 *#% 6665

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

. 1 20$)%, 11*1 *#$"$ $%/1 *#+%$% $. @ :  ! 3  *#+ !$ 2410 24!%!,"5 *%1 24!)1* #) *#+%$%$ (1%)%,5 )4%, (+!1 *#+%$% $'1$/1  21121$/1 *#((! 21121$. $2!$ @ :

 !! 2410 24!%!," )4%, 24!)1*%!$ (+!1 *#+%$% $'1$/1  21121$/1 *#((! 21121$5 (2$  *#+%$% 1 )4%$2* /%%$%/1 $ *%)1 *#+ $'1$/1 )1. 1121 /''(* !# $* @ : - '$ $$%, 1)$( 1/''(5 /1!! ! !1),%0  < $. '+$%,  @ :  6 '$ $$%, ,13#1$112% 34+1/4$$ $ ! 3311, + " )1) *#$" 1)1/%$ 3%)*$1 6. . *#% 21121  /''( 5 6 < 3' 2 $'+$  !$ $%/$ %//$. 1)1/%$ 3%)*$1 6.-. *#+ !$ !# $* /* $%$%* %// ! *%/1 ! + "! .



   !) 2$ !'+$%,  24!) 0 *#$" + "! 6 665

211 $%+$ ) !1, 211*8// ), 211 *(##)1 " 8*$ 1$  )$1 *(##)15 /1!! $ 34+1)4% +1+1), /##,%$0  56 ** $%+$ *+ *, *%%*8// ), *%% *(##)1 " 211*8// ), 8*  )$1 *(##)1 )1) 21121  65 ** $%+$ 211, *+ **8// ), *+ * *(##)1 " *%%*8// ),  )$1 *(##)1. 1211!*#+$%/ ) $!%  ,%$1*%  :  ! *#+ !$ 1$0 " / ) $! )%, *#+% / ) $!%*%!%, "#$% / ) $!%#!1$ 2+ ! *#+$%#$% 241 / ) $!%$ !43 $2 /''(% . $2!$  :  ! *#+ !$ *))0 +1/ ) $!% *%!%, 3##!5 * !! *+"%* #$% $ +$1. /%$1 $%! 0 +821$, 2"!1*%, *#+$%2'!1 , *%!%,5 /1!! * #) * / ) $!%#!1$ 1),"$ " )4%$"$ *%!%, )1) / ) $!%#!1$ 41,%*%!%,.  ) $!%*%!%, (+!1$ *1),!*/''(/1$ 2410 )4%, " !+ ),)%, 1/  $/ *#+$%!$ !+ ),1 1!,%2 *%!%, 3(#3#($1#)! "#$% !% !  3' 2 "##*%! !$  *%!%, "#$% *#+$ $ +$%, !+ ),1 "4%$%/1 $  :  ! . 111*#+$% $1211!*#!! 1%/1  . . .. !+ ),1 *#+ !$ $1211!" )(  



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

 ! 5  :, 5  ! 5 - ! 5

! 5 - ! 5  ! 5  ! " 5  ! " 5

 ! " 5  ! " 5  ! " 5 5  ! 5 5 (111!412% ,% :, $  !

"  3 5 65  3!%0 + " *#+$%!$; +12!,% (+%!,, "  /41$ *#$"!$ + " *%* 2'!" 34+1)4% +1+1), %//  56 ** $%+$ *+ *, *%%*8// ), *%% *(##)1 " 211*8// ), 8*  )$1 *(##)15 21121 , %//  65 ** $%+$ 211, *+ **8// ), *+ * *(##)1 " *%%*8// ),  )$1 *(##)15 *#% 6 665

211 $%+$ ) !1, 211*8// ), 211 *(##)1 " 8*$ 1$  )$1 *(##)1A  1$, / ) $!%*%!%, "#$% / ) $!%#!1$ 2+ !.  " / ) $!%*%!%, +12!,% 1$/1  1% #); (111!412 6 **, 211*8// ), *(##)1 *(##)1 " 41%01*%!%, -5 8+ *, ***8// ),  1$ *(##)1 " *#!/*8// ),  1$  )$1 *(##)1. 

 0( !

#$" 1 #! *#+$%! 2$)%, =$.! - 5 =.

 ! !

#+% #!!  $%$2%)%, $1211!" /$ ("!1,  ! 105 $ *' #! 2 " 2410 $ !"#$%  +1 (+%!,,.

 :  ! '$ $05 $ *#+% 2410 + " $#$!% ! 241 #/! !$% ! +1 $ !"#$%  (+%!,, +12!,%  /'(1$%, " "#!%,  41%!1*%!$ 34+" ),$%, %!$% 5 *%1 *#$"5 * !! ! *#+% #) /''()%, 2$/1 $'+$"5 1 #! $'+$  !$ 2$)%,5 1 1 *%1 +1 $#1/ $$1 *#$"! *'$$ 2'!1(111 241 *%1  $#1/ $$1 *'$$ 2!1*%!$.  ! "%+%! !# $* + " 1$$%, 7*$1!1 , 2'1$ , *#$" 3##!$ #/*24 $%*.



   " 2410 )1/ $$%, $#$!% 1$, * +12!,%   :  !  .  !"#$% 2410  :  !41* )1/ $$%, "%+%! $ + *#+$%1$%)1$ 31,/$  :  !  .

#$"! 2'!"$ *#+% +12!,% "  !! ! !1$%, /$ ("!1, . ...5 *#+%$,  *#$"$ +1! *1("!1*%!$ 2$/  3' 2 "##*%! +1 *'$$ /1 $ !$  =$.! - =. #$"! #) / ) $!%,#*%/ )$ 3#$1%$% 3##!$ *'$$ $#1/ $$%, 11*!1*%!$

. . =$.!. =. #$" 1 #! *#+$%! $'+$  !$ 2$)%,. 9'( !1*%!$ $%! 0 !% , + " +1 1$$%, 7*$1!1 , 2'1$ , *#$" 3##!$ #/*24 $%*. #$"! #) $ $$%, +1! 2$/$ "'$/1 $"'( , $.

#+% %0  1%*#+! 5 $ + " #) 41%!1*%!$ 34+" ),)%, #/ +12!,%  /'(1$%, )4%,/1$ "  :  ! !% ! *%%!%0 +1 $ !"#$%  (+%!,/1 ! .

 " 3!%0 1$, / ) $!%*%!%, "#$% / ) $!%#!1$ 2+ !.  :  !$ 5 "  *#+ !$ +1/ ) $!% *%!%, *))0 3##!5 * !! *+"%* #$% $ +$1. &##!5 * !! *+"%* #$% $ +$15 +821$0 $ 1 ! 3##! ! /%% +%! *#+$%/ ) $!% $4$$% $ 1)%, 2"!1*%, *#+$%2'!1 , *%!%,. #+$%2'!1 , *%!%,5 /1 +821$$* $%))1$"! 5 * (2$%, +821$1 /$ "'')%, $CC$% 241 /%% 3812 1 $%! *% $5 +821$$* 3##! ! /, ! !%$ ! " / %!$% 5 )% +821$$* $%))1$"*%!%,. #+% 2410 "'$$ *%!%, $'1 !1*%!$ 241 #!1 !$ 3##!$ ),1 *),5 *%1 2$3##! *%!%, 2'!"/41$/1) 3##! !$5 * !! *+"%* #$% $ +$15 #! * $ / %+$  ''(/1 !$ 041!) 241 0/41$!1*.

$2!$  :  !! "  1$0 " / ) $! )%, *#+% / ) $!%*%!%, "#$% / ) $!%#!1$ 2+ ! *#+$%#$%  241 / ) $!%$ !43 $2 /''(% . " "'(/1 ) / ) $! 2 *#+$% !+ ),1 1$$* *#%  )1 *)$%, / ) $!%*%!%, "#$%.  ) $!% *%!%, "#$%  )' 0 *#+% $$ 5 /1!!1 , / ) $!%*%!%, * 1 / ) $!%#!1$ $ 3 0 *),/. ",% *#((! /''(0 *#+% *1),!* / ) $!%*%!%, 3(#3#($1#)! "#$% / ) $!%#!1$ 2+ !.  !$##,%! $%1) ,  %0 /*#+%  1%*#+! 5 $ *#$" 3 0 *),/ + " / ) $!% *%!%, " $%/ (111! / ) $!%,#*%/ )$1, *'$$ $#1/ $/1 *%!%,.

.),( $ *#+$%)1*