Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-04-1504/4 AI generated

2-04-1504/4 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-04-1504/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-04-1504/4 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               

       

     !"#   $"              %&'(('%))*+,  

    %-).-(/). 

   -+0   112,2" 11 "" ,20 "     -+0    112 ,2" 3#"!4 ,#11  " 2 ! 0" "# 11  #"4  0",",'     

%/')('%))* '%-).-(/).          

 -+0 23        )5'(('%))*+,               2-+0 6#7/))()(7!8  (5 -+0 9 2 #  :   69    ! "            #$!% !#%%&  

   !#'%(' $%(  )       *    '+,     , 

,    "    #-%%   .. /     */     0 1 !#   "           /      (2-%% ! #!   "   )   ,   

  % %659

,      "      #-%%    '+,    

, *        ! 2! ,  *    '+,     3 '+, 

     4 .. /      */     0 1!#  "  5              /        (&%%3      4 ! (! 6 ,,   ,      #$!% !#%%&   ! $!          '+,     /    !     7/       , /   !         /   *             2% /,          ,         )      /, 

  ..               !     0 &1  !$             ,  )              !      )   *             !  ! 7        ,   #- "112+, 11 #"%;')5'%)).8 ('  -+0    2 )(');'%)). 112 ,2"  #    < ;* 2'&  3#' 11 #"   # '  "   < 75 '(  11   11 #"  "20 ' %' ", -+0    0  # '    < ((7 '% 4 "23""(.*))67&))=%9  # 0""#2,2)(');'%))()(');'%)).6&* 93""%;%))'  "0"2 !''3""(.*))'6"''(.-(/9' 

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

  . .659  '  2 "  0 -+0    #"'  11 -+0   #  )*')('(557'  #     112 "2  # ",# 2# ,  62-# &'&  *'&9'   ##112"242#"#' 3!112,2""3#0"2,8 11##112,2"2" ," 11#'112##" ?  '11#2#! ""# #!"#2#6!! 9'11#22# ,"# !0# #!211#'

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

' "##" 6"''/%-/*9'  -+0  #  6"''*&-75!;/-5*9'  !     /*   

  %/')('%))*  0 -+0    '   112 ,2"  11 "" ,20 " #"' '   -+0  #'112,2"'  )(');'%)).<;*2'&3#'",-+0  0 '   4    " 2  "" .&;))   0" "#2""%;%)) 0""##"4 ""%;)) '#0#' 2,#2#32  #!"  4"3#" 4 !  " #"'

  / /659  ,  !   "  # 3 "# 4  !  ,22 ,# #   11    "   0# ! " "# 0##4 "  "'  #!   2,"00 2'&'% 3 ,##",2-&'('$,"002'&'%#" #" 0'$,"002'&'( 0#"0"  #3!#"003" 22 2,"3#112'-+0 2,"00</.'(3 #! "#  #   ,"  "#  ! ""  "0  " 2  #  -! #-! -! 2#-  "# '  2,"00 < /. '& 03!   "  "" "2,'  #!  112 ,2"     0#  < 5; '%   ! ", 112 ,2"   # 112 ,2"2#' &(')/'%)).#""0#8@ "2#!   ,# -+0 #"'@ !  11# 2## # "#!  # ,'   03!    )!/  11 ! )!/  -#"     112 ,2"   %7')7'%)).  (     &)')7'%)).(  '" 0##,# 6"'&5-..7&-779'112,2"#" ,"#112#',##!2### #"#  11!  -#"!  ,  11"'#(555-+0 ##!%))% # # " 0 3 11  #- "  6"''.79!%))% #- " "0 #- ""  #"6''.;9!%))%-+0  0#" 116"''.59'    4#  4 4"3 112 ,2" 2# " ,# #,##' 112,""22#2#112"'&(!112,2 .5/)2,#"" ,""00,"  2#!0#' -+0    ()')&'(555 "00  //  # -+0   11 2"00#! "    )(')('(555     11 4 2" (-&( 2"!  2"   # 2"00#!   2"# 3 2     2  ,# 2"'"#"00 ( ('2"(555#2""00(%/) &('2"2"007&))'%-!#-!2#- "#  # 2"   %('2"  &('2" 6"''&(-&&9' -+0    )*')%'%))% "00 ';) # -+0    " 11 2"  2"00# "' $" "00 (%-  .)'2"!  .)'2"  2"00(.)))&('2"7&))'&0 #2"%&-.)6"''&.-&79'

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

  7659 11#   # 11 #' 2 3!   < 5; '%   0##!-+0 # ,"' 3 11#2#'   3, ,## $ < %  &  4 112 ,"" 2' 2,""22#2#"2!"!2,3 4,""2,"! #2' $#0","2' 23!-+0  "#2  #1122' 2,#" ##69' 2"113!!  -+0   "# # "  ,##! 2  4  "00"2,#""00'2,##!"311# 0","24 ' 

 '  # 3   2 0 23 #"  """'  !    /*      

! # "#!#!"3 4# ", " 3, #" ,  2, "# ",'  <((7'(%1123#,2"11#211 , ,# # 11 "! 112 ,2" ?" ""  # 11 2#"   " 2 ""'  11 33 11 "!  11# #  "" 11 4   11   "2'  '   # 11 #"      3 11 " ,#'<((7'(%  ,1123#,2" ,#112,2"?"""4 11 " 2 ' $ < &.   '  #  , 0 0"  #2 0""'  #   " ##  '  ,# 0" "# #"4  0","'' #!"#"<;*2'&03#!     #" 11  < 5) '( 2'(  #"4  0"" '   '  , 0""# #"4  0""2,#"' 

!"34#<5)'(2'(  3, #" ! " " #  0" "# #"4 ""%;))-+0  0","''  0" "# #"4  "" %;))  0","  3 0 #"'  $,##23 0#!"!#<-#%%7'(%&( '.2,##!"",-+0 '  0 4  112 3# ,2"   *  " 2 '

3!"#2,"#",3"

  ; ;659 4#4# ,""" "03 ""' '    # 11 #" 112 ,2" 3# "! 4   0" "# 2 0"," , &(');'%)).' 11 #"A'"11##112,2"6)(');'%)).9 ' %;')5'%)).! "  112 ,2" '  3#! ", 11# '   0  < ((7 '%  4  112 3# ,2""2!"  " 0"0#"' ,## 0""#2-#"4  0","'  # #  112 ,2" #  " "!232,##4 4 " 2''3""(.*))6%=7&))9'  B00#,3"2,#" ""0"!2<*/.'/"  2,#" -+0     #  # "  ,"#"' 3 0"##"4 ' 

23 0#"030"8  <5;'% 11##112,2"#", 2"11 ,"11#' 

#!' #"<;*2'&)(');'%)).#11# 0"# 3#11#8)!/ 11!)!/  -#"!  11#'   !  11#  2 2" 11#! # 3!"#11! #"#"!! "   #!  ," "'  11  2 "  ?  ! # 2# 3  11#! "   "  ,' '    11 #"""#! 110"! #2"# 3112#11#"! 3#11#2# #'-+0 2,##"0 #! ' 3 , ,""11#2"# 3#11#' 00#  23 0#!  '    #  !  2 "# 11#3#' '  0#! ,4 3# 11# #11#' "#036"''%)-%(! 7;! 5/-5*9!  ' 4A    # 11"!    # ",# 3# 11#2#'    23 0#!    3, ,## $ < %  &' 0!""#0##,##'

00  2# !  112  22# 2#  "2 62"9' $  )*')('(557 ,"# 112 2- .'( 03!  2#   22# 11 11" &(' 2" 0' -+0     ## 0#!3112,""" 2 #"112"#'  <&#)(')('%))*,## " 2 "# "  # #"00"  #  "#0' 

  5659 <-#*)'(((*('(322"# 023#"2##' 

#"<-#*/(-*/%!*/.-*//!*/7'(2'% *7)'         $"