Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-528/4 AI generated

2-05-528/4 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval

Case Number 2-05-528/4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

                 

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-528/4 · Pärnu Maakohus Pärnu kohtumaja Rüütli tänaval:                  

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                 

                             !"#$%%&%'(()##*% !)#((  ++ % % 

   ',(-,-'" 

  .%$%/.% %01))!!#!) 2$%#               .%$%**0%!(*# /% %3/ %%$ ###  .% %**  %2+ *

%20 $*  $$#  %3/ %%$0$%$0  

                     '"#0%&%'(()##*#   4$$%5616*561-*561) /!*'*1*6*7*561"*5618* 566'*5)1' /!#  4 $.%$%/.% %01) )!!#!)2$%#

  '9":       .%$%3 $ 9/ 20:% %$$# 

 2.%$% !"1(#--. % %#         3% %&%02&%$1(3%0 * %%3% $ %%%%* $% %0%;;$% %%%%%0   %0%/%%# 3% %& %&%$  / %#%&02$% %$$ %% %*%&%% %% % %$/ #         

!   " /%%'!#('#'((-##/;;02 %3/ %2$%117((*"( 00%2$%'!'88#'(*2%--(((#,# /%%(8#(8#'((-##/0 $%3%%2$%;;02 %3/ %11 7((*"(00%'8!(#1)2$%#2%1))!!#!)# !#< %$ $ !#!#/%   2 $ 0%  3  '((6 = %3%&% '((6  % 0 ;;02 %3/$*  % %   /% %  % %  %0%, 

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

  69": * C 5 !(!  / ! 3 )  %  2$  % % %/ 00%   00# C5!!1 /!586 /!% 00%%7@'D8A* %3//% % %3$%# 1#'#'!#('#'((-%$/0 $%31#1#/%/%00%0% 0%% % /$(*-A, %00%#4$$%0%% %$$ &&/% 0%% %/$(*-A, %00%2$%/%&00%0% +%%$% %$% %=8A*%(*('67A3%0# 1#6#(8#(8#'((-%/0%!!!!7*--"#6(%/00$1)63%0#

0%0%!!!%/00%%%>!7--"#6(E(*('67AE1)6 3%0D!-7"*)6 1#-#(8#(8#'((-%/0%!!7!)!6'#6(%/00$1163%0#

0%0%!!7%/00%%%>!)!6'#6(E(*('67AE116 3%0D!11!#7'

0%$(8#(8#'((-%/>!-7"*)6@!11!#7'D'8!(#1) 4$$% C51 /!*" /'*'- /!*'" /!'*'8 /-*!(! /!3!*!(! /!3)*!!1 /!*)1- /!*)17 /!1*)66 /!1/%3 &> !# /% 0 202 /%0%32117((*"(B '# /% 0 200%$'8!(#1)      ! " ##$%  !      

 & ! %&"   %%0 3$%+ $322% 

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

   #  $  $    " %"

  -9": %/% %0%$%/ + % # /%$%F%G*$% /%% 2/% FG# %$ 3$$+%/++% %*2 &%FG*%/%02% %%$# 0%$%/ 0 %$%%$%02/*0%%,% %$*  %  0 $%%$%$$# %0% % %0$ % %*%% % 3 %$2 $ %0'((6##3  %3/;;$%%%%/*  %% /%% % '((6##3  % %  + %/% $,%0/%0%;$93 %%;;$%  20$3 %$3%/$%:%/%%/ %3 '((6##  9##:'((6##%0%;$#/%3$/ 23 %%$;;0%# $  3$&#%%/3 %$2 $'((63 %0%;;$%;;02 %3/ %0%;;$%%/%%%  + #     

         ! " "  " "     "    " "   # " !$    !  ""  

% ;;02 %3/  %/%3 %$ %33$# &    

    "       "" $  '  

    #    "       

  $ "   

     $      #        % (     #     # "  ")) #  $    

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

  "9":