Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-04-1369/6 AI generated

2-04-1369/6 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 2-04-1369/6
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-04-1369/6 · Viru Ringkonnakohus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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

              

     

      !" #  !



          $%&''&($$)*+#      (,$-,'.)/                  

  !  " 

 #    $    

(.&$(&($$)           00012 3       (-&'$&($$) %         2  45 000 1 4" 66666666  0  0  5 2  " 

#&

" 00000 4" 66666666666   7 # " 88,  !"5  0000 4" 66666666666   0  0,0 7 # " 88,  !"5" 2 "& &'( )*(+

, -   $  %  ./0.0.      1              .2 2".   #    

 # 

          0 &           #       33333333333 

    33333333   .2 2". -   -          -        2       0  %    $  %  ./0.0.    0     $ #    

   4       "5       -  0 '        4  #          &   / 4

 

         1     4    66     

     0      #          1                 0   %     0 1 4  $%&$9&($$9  8! 000 15  '9&'$&($$- ",   4 $'&$'&($$) 54& &.,-5000004'5 0000004(5# " '-$)/--:"+"&  # " + !"1000$:&''&($$(2" 2&'-;$( !   210002 "2"2"!##  1000"  ! &1, 0002" ($$(&&2!3, "!3 " #""  #" &($($'/ ($($9- ($($)9 ($($/' ($($//  ($(''%&(%&$(&($$(42&($$.5!"1000#+ #'--$-$ ! '$.%$$2+#+ #-$(-$###+ #&   .$&$-&($$.   #  &(;(::,')/:;$.!+ 1,  000 #8 '--$-$#+ #/$$$ "& 8! 8 8# '(/'%--! '(.$99. "8 &1, 000#2""!< 88" #+ #8&

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

 ? >'-9 &'   ##"1000( "  # 

?>)9 &'# 3  ! !  "#38! +"& .& !883!8 "#" "!         +  8"!"    #+ # +"!!  3"& 2+#+ 8"8"#"!## " 4 ?>'-: &'(5  #+! #+ #!! " &*8    8 "2+"!&#""< ""    3  8"  "!& ?>'-(>'-9 8" "2#" "!+ #+!" "& -&  #8 !+"!!"#8 +"!8! <!& 9& ?>'9. &'2&'8 +238"8"" +22!&   +22"  +22"8"& )&8 #  3!! ! 3#+  "  #+ #8!8" ! 3!2+"!"#&   " 2 #"   # 8 2 3  "!  !!!  ""&

 !+ "" "!  "   +8"!"  #+ #+"&?  8 #2+#+ !8#3#+ # 8!8"& +  "2" 8! #+" 3&  "     # "     3 ()&$(&($$.& 8" 2    # 2   8" 2  + !"   (:&$.&($$.  !  8!&!"8" "#" #8! #+ #!#+!  22"&   + !8"     " 1 000 #"!!     #+!  #"!8" # +"!+""& "  "  #"!!  + "   &   #! """ ?>::-  & !+" +    !  #"& !" 8  3 3# 2" 2  #   2+ !" & 

   2   "  "" 2 3  <" !   (      !  #8  !+   (   8" 2    '(%%:(     "  +#&  " 82  (:&$.&($$.   2   8" 2 !8" #+ !!'(%%:( "##"!!-$(-$!  #"    .$&$-&($$.   8! 8 1,  000 "" !! '(.$9 &    '   2   #" "#&  ("2 "82 3 "!! !!&  &   4#

 "  ! (.&$(&($$)     "   !  8  "!(# 3<"+!!+

    !   ""    ( # '(%%:(  #8 !+!&  >-.) &' 23 !" 2+""!" >-.% &' 8   "3  +"" 3 !  "  #" ! + 3 "" 3 "! & 

+32 3#8" ! 2 (#"(:&$.&($$.8" 2 #+" "! 8!  !! '(%%:(     2+""  +  "&       +"  8! 8"     +  + ! "& 

?>:) &'8 38##  2 #+" &

?>'-( &' 8" 238" !"42+#+ 5 #+  "  #! 2+#+   8! & ? >'-9 &' 8 ! ##"2+#+ 8"#+  " "  8" 2 8"8"#3< #+  "  + 2+#+  #  ""& ! 2# &(   8" #3 8"#8 &  B #  #"  (:&$.&($$.8" 24& &%5( 8"!+""2+#+ 1000##+"  #+ !!'(%%:(## (:&$.&($$. 2  4#+ ! 25& (:&$.&($$.   2  4& & /5 8  2+#+  1 000 #"! ! #+ # !! '$.%$$  4#" &($($'/ ($($9- ($($)9 ($($/'($($//($(''%5 22#!!(9$:(4#&.$('$/5#+  " 0 1 45  !@    "  " !! ')'$/  #!''&$-&($$..$&$9&($$.& 

"         2+#+  1 000  !  "     #+ # !! '(%%:(    (:&$.&($$.   2  4#+ ! 25  2" !@    8 .$&$9&($$.   !!8!"& 

? >'$' &' 2&'    #+    " #+3 #+  " +" 8!&  8" 2 2&(&(    #+  41 0005  8" #+ ! 2  #"  #3 8"4 (5  #+  " 45   " &

#  ? >'-9 &' 3 8" # !   2+#+  3 8"# &  " #   3 8" #  " 2+#+ #+# & "# #+3#+  "##  ? >)9 &' " +"  8"  #+  # <    8" #+   #+ #  #+8 &8 #"(:&$.&($$.  2 4#+ ! 25 #+"!!'(%%:( ! ((:&$.&($$.8" 28 8"C(#& 

 "  #  3      ( #  2+""   ( 3#8 !+!  ?>:) &'(:&$.&($$.8" 2 2&(&'2&(&(  #8 !+'(%%:(&   "!8! #8" 8"#1 000 #+  8! 8!     ! +" 3 " ()&$(&($$.      8" ! ! +" 1 000 #"!! !8"8 #+   ?>::-&      ()&$(&($$. "  1 000 # '--$-$  42+#+  '$.%$$###+ #-$(-$5+" 1000#  $:&''&($$(+ !"2" 2!"(8" "& 8 #(### '9&'$&($$-# " " #  (:&$.&($$.8" 2! 1000#+ !!'(%%:( 42+#+  '$.%$$   22# (9$:( 5    #  (:&$.&($$.   2  4#+ ! 25 ! !  !   2  "  "  +"   #+ & +  4 25    #  " !!&

+   ? >, .$ 3" 435 2 !  #  +    #8 "!  #& +  #8!  8"     4 ? >%/ &(5&   4#+  "5 #+3 # 2+#+  '$.%$$  !  8!  #  (:&$.&($$.   2   8" 2   (   3 " 8"     !! '$.%$$  !   $:&''&($$( 2" 2 , #" &($($'/ ($($9-($($)9($($/'($($//($(''%&  1 000 ## !!  !! -$(-$  (:&$.&($$.   2  4#+ ! 25 !8"    8   " 1 000  (8" 2" &  "+"'(%%:(! ?>)9 &'  ( 8" "#+ #  "  "! +1000 #"!! "2#"!#+"& 

# -.% &'3! + 3 ""& !# " +2  ""+!!  ?>::->:) &'&

!+!8" 2 #+"! &   !    <!  2 3  "!  3 ! "#8 !+ ($'&$'&($$)" >)$ &'%''  !! '(%%:(! "  +#  %$$$   2 3 !  "  +#  ):9$&

"!  ">)9',)9->)9: &'2&(>))% &'>):$ &'&   

  # !