Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-23377/2 AI generated

2-05-23377/2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja

Case Number 2-05-23377/2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-23377/2 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

    

           ! ""#!$        %&!'#"(#)&*'* '$"+                                               ,#+-& &.  $+-& &/.&      $"#!#$0       !                               "           "# "$$%            &       $$  #0#'1(# $2!,!!$0#3#00$ !#( #34#'+ 00$#  $  #4$$#$"#$" # $*2"$$#0+#"'#"552" #0# "# # $"#$$  # '00$$#$' $#,#" # $& #( '12 #0#!22+0 "#!#$0 # *#( # # $$0#$ #00#0#!2" $ $!,0&    

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

  

& &"&&)&$0## $$2' $ # ,#$!! $& $'42#$# #0$!2(

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