Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-05-20657/9 AI generated

2-05-20657/9 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 2-05-20657/9
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

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

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-05-20657/9 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja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

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



                           



 



!"#$" 

  %& " "

   '"(")   " "*+&& "!"*& 

    ",-  '&."/.)#"*"'" 0+#1'#"*  

 !"#$ 

  %& " "!,'&#+    !         !! -"+2  34 -"+")+)")!*') "##  !'+2  34 !'+!''&)")++& ' )(3' 4  -"+")+)")!*') "## !'+")+ )(   " #$

    % &' '( )*$' '()**+' '3 4+  !,,--3** '&,' **)4 

       ,.'   ,--/''   +  0 ''0   &  

%% !  ' 

  &  ' 



 

      ! ,,'  ,--1''     ! 2' % &' ' $' '  231-)+! +!*

' ,' %  & ' '   ! &2,/-)+!+!* 

' -'&&)""0+#1'"'&) -1 

* !!'&"$'&),)&#'"" &#*!'!" 

567   "' 8,.- 1  59  .- '"    7

 57 !,'&*&& "-'&"*#0 *) '+&#$" + -1 !,'&*&&)"$','*&'&#" '0,'"- ! 5  .0" '" !'&" +1&'&#"'  $','*& '&#" '0,'+ #::)&#" .:: '*"!'& -'&&)""0+#1'"'&)*!,'&*&&!&)'0'#""    "! !

   &  

 ! .-  

 0     !   '  

  $     '  &! !!  0    ! ' 

     !!       

 +!!0  !!         '   

  ! &!! !$ 451..'    6%#7 " 8 #78 6"89" -)&"3'

5 64*!,"''&'&).!!")77  ),)*!!/,"." " "#*!'+  "&*!, !!"&+%".'"#$ *&&779  % "'&,-"+*!'+   '&*!'+."'',-"+''"'"-%'".!!'","&& '/%#'1* ,-"+,*&#"*!'++&& "'!#*!+&779  !"#$ *&& /),-"+'/'  

 !'+'&'"'#''"#"'*&''/' " *+).""*"$ "-& "'"'' 3) ,+!'"."" )")-#0-&+&%'&')&'*!#)'"*&'" ""4  !"#$ 

 "'  *!,'&",-%#"'!'"2 4 '&')%"'  /)&)'/'   34.1"$*!'+  '  4 0+#1'*!'+  '"''/' " /.)#"*,-"+*&* 

* !! -*&&"'% *&) #''" 0,"#% *& .!! $ - '&" .!!' *",'"''&) *&&.-##00 ; 54 ""'&*&&)+0''*!'+*)   !,'&*& #""'&" -&" )" *!'+    ,-" '" *& '&% *&) 1&'& .1"#" '&'#"* < "*." ' #00 #"-   < "*." ' 3*'     5



  4.1,+)"*." ' #&"%"'&& #'&"#&'"*!,"'!)&")"* 5 1"0!&%#"*!,"'  $!  "$!!!-"3)&"'1"0!&4! 77= 3' 6 674 (""<"*." '*'$&#'*!,'&"1''*!'+,-1-"* !%#.&&)&'$.1"#"'&'#' '#'*!,'&.!!'.!!'""*! )&''",'&) "''"."*&'"" ! #') )&  &,'" $','*&' ." "*!"&!*!% " 1&'&&) *!'+  ")  '"-"#% !!)"% "' *!,&   '&'* .1"#" !'&"-   !*'!!$ 

  !!'&"-'&'**!,&  "

 777  /)&)'/' "  "



  .1"#'*!'+  ' '&"*!,"''&"$  *)  "/*'3'75 764 

 

   "') .!!") *!,'&" * +*& *!&".."% #" ) '"') !!' /,"))."'!!'0,'"-  

  (!!")*')%"')"!!!!'&"" .1"#"'&'#"*"')."'!!*"$&'3' 74   '#'*!,'&*! )&'""*'"'""+.!!'"'&-0+")'&)!!"%"&'&) )."/.)#"*"'"#*#"!*!#. !#+!!)%"'*!,&'""* "'"0+#1'#"!!'&"   -"+ '!'"$ ." /.)#"* -*&' "'' &## 

 * !!  '" && &' .1,+")$,-"++0 -#"'2 4 ' '::'$   % *& *"*#" '::'& ! 

 * !!  !'+     *0 ,- "'#"+'::",'++'"# )&*"&)!'&)&'. "# 1 ")",-"+- !'+"!" !,*"#/.""')  4 &&'&").""/,"*&&!'"#"&*! )&"''-'&'+0 -")2  "& &&#"> "#!)*

* !!%""*'" 9

* !!%" *'!!  * !!%*/'" * !!;  '"'&

* !!;  ::*

* !!;  "'&

* !!;  ''& -"# 

* !!  ,/-""' $")%#0-&+) * !!;   &'+0 "#*9

* !!;  '" "' * !!  ""-*!&*&&$-*&"'*"*#"'.""6 * !!%#"'*&#$*"#'"' ."* *)# .!!"  &)  "')" *!'+ . "#'  ' !&*! ) ."$ ,-"+ .1,+")'&* *!'+' 0+ #1' "'" - *&& 

 * !!  ."" '",''" *&&'&'" '1")#"* "' ,-"+ )!*&#"'") '1")) >  "'" *!!.) 3' 7  4% '1") ") '::'& && &" *!,'  '   3' 4% #*"*'&-'" *!!.) 3'   9  !,'&'&-*',-"+")+%"',-"++00$!#1&)"+&& )"- "')"." *#' + *!! 1.-&'" &'#' ! && ""&) * *&&'&") ." /.)#"*  -"+'!'"$."/.)#"*"'"0+#1'#''",-"'#"' !'+" !""." !!).""$','*&'/.)#')&)  

$8 "  7 !'+ '&0'") "'" 0+#1'#"" .&&)&)% *&) *!'+ ! 1& '&# "'' ###00 %! 

* !!*&& !'+'&0'")!+0 -#")2  " !" .1,+")'&)% "' *!'+ ."* ." /.)#"* "'' '&# && "# &##%*&,-"+;  ,-"+.!!'"''&)'1"))"'1")")%"'*1**&&'&")%#!,-)&" !"'"'&)%  !"* '",'&) +&' ." ,&)"'0,'&'  0'"* #"''*" '" "''%  &''3' 954;  *!'+!'"&)'" ". !$""#)%#"1#)',"'*"'::)'", ::'&! '+&$

  ".'"#$ *&&'  !'+"$%"'"'."/.)#"*'&"*0+#1'!'&"*&&&'#"+"&-  !'+ !) -&" .1,+")'&) *,'&'&")  ." '"#' .1"#" &,'"  -"+ ' '$*!'+0)"'"*!,!+*&''#'&$)&""*!,!' '#"1."') ")"'"&)%")&)*!'+,-"+"* ,,")")  '#'#""'&"*"'"*! )&''&)&$)&'"""')'1")")!#'&0)"'" '1")#"*"'"&& &""+0+#1'#"+"%*!'+""'&) 



  

$ $  "9 8"7  !,& "$% "'  ,- *!'+' "'" 0+#1'#"* *&&&$ ,&)#""% "'" && &"*%# "'$.",&)+*!'+ '"&."$*!,&.1,+")'&*#00 '

* !!*&& (!!'",""!")&'""/"%"''/'   "$,-"+  "-+ ! '"# /.)#"   !'+ )&  &,'" ! '1")'&) (0 & *!,'& !'&"-  !*'!!$ '

  %*!'+")/'&'"- (!!'",""!")&'*""%"'*!'+   ."$'/' "*'#"*"''#*# "!"*!#. !#&'#'+00#"- .").!!").1,+")'&*"'"0+#1'#"*!'+'*!,'&!'&"- (!!'","! )&"'"&& &"/"+""/"%#,"'*"''&"*"'0+#1'  !'+     *' *!,'&'&- 

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

  #00 &  5 9*",'"'*&&.-##00 *'"  +& '

  5

* !! ""-! #'+'"'"###00 *

* !!  ? 7-*!,"'!'+'1")*-&-&"'""%#!")&"0'"''&) . !'"! #+#"&"*!,&")&"0'"''&)*! '""$*)*.!!'"1&)") + '&0'") .1,+")) +!&) 1 ")" .&&)&#"% #&' #&&) + 1-"* ,")#"* '0,') +!&)  -"+ ! )!*&#"'"'" '1")'"- '1")&) ,-)&" !"'"'&) -*&") ,  0+#"*&)  '/' "  /.)#"*  -"+ .!!'"''&)'1")'"+'!'&"*!,"'!*&&'&").""*"*#"'6

* !! *&&   ""' &##'  ."*) ,-"++ *!'+ *)#*&#$* .!!"% !  &#$"   * !! !'+'&0'")"'"&& &""!!&).+1") '#'#""'&" '&)1#&'"""!"*!'+!#'&0)"'"'1")#"*'1")")"'&)%! '" !"+0 -&)?  5 -#"''&)'1")#*!,&'&' !'+!#,-"'#" +'::*!,% #""'&"+!*!'+'::&,'"1."'&) ''*!'+/'&'""!' *0"!" + '::'& '"

  ".'"#$ *&&'  & *!+ " !" *!,'&" ""' "-'&)+'1")&)!#'::'&*+00#".1,+&")%!*!,'&'"&)*,'&'&%"' *!'+ ! ','*&' &&) !# #'" "' !&*! ) ,")# ""#0 - 0,")) 0+#1'"''"'"&& &' !'+"!"'"/.""') "'!!)&''&""'" !" *!'+  .!!" 0'") *!'+      ,'" ,")'" .&&)&#" *!,' "'" #*#"**!,'&+!*"")   (" "*? -&"%*&*"'0)/.)#*!,&'&'%#1'$*!,&"'"0+ '" "',- "'#"'   -"+ ! "'&) '!'&" "'" 0+#1'#"* '" "',- "'#"'% !  5 !"#$ '

   ''&) '1")'"' 0,'&$% "' *!+ " !" '0'&) ." /.)#" *!,&&' +&$ #'& ''  - *!,'&*& #""'&" " !"



   #"&)"")+!&)%#*)*!,'&"'"0+#1',-"+.!!''!'"'&) +' '"'  !'+ + ,-"+ !"'&-*'&)%"'*!'+).""."/) ,-"+" , ,")")% *&) +&$ #'& '' '- 1."' ""% *& '"#  '" ,-"+"'0'&)&$'&)'-#&   *!,'&#""'&" ")&'*& + '0'"#""'&" ")&'*& *")#" ")&" ? 5 *!,"' "" 



   *",'# ,*&)  +1&'&#' &''&) #""'&" .&,& *!,)'*"#""'&*&&)"+!'#""+")"*)*#00 #"""*",'&) 0'"''&' "*",'&)? &"#1'$*!,&.!!"'!'&"%*""*&*! !'& '",'&)% '""' .!!"' "" .!!" *&* 0+ +*&) + .1,+")'&) *!,'&*&&) *&&)!*&#"')" + *!,'&*&&)" #"* + &"  -"+ ! '!'"&) #""'&*&&)" *)#" +0'#' *!'+ *)  -"+ #""'&*&&* '' "''&) #*"*! )&" *!!."! * !! -1&.1"#"'&'#"1&)"""'+9

* !!'&'&) <"*." '""'3' 7%54 !,'&*&&)"#"* +,-"+"!""'&) "'!!)&&" ."$ *!,& .1,+")'&* #1' *!'+' ,-"+ *&* 0+  #""'&*&& 9  * !!  ?6&" -1&%#"'&#"',-"+!$''&)#1'$*!,&*!'+' 0+ -'&&)"" 1 )"' ,- ,&)'&) !-   -"+ ! $''&) -1& '&#"'"'"1&)" -,)"'"1&)" "')",-1&)" ,&)'&)!!"* ? 7- &"79

* !!%#"',-"'#"'&"*'&) -1&   * !! #"''&)&##*&&&$*!'+'0+#1'#"" -'&&)""   '&"'"-"#"+&,)&$*!,&""? )"'656 66 %6 6%5 55      (")  *!,'&*